7 ms·
I heard one supposed expert on CNN basically state that a nuclear meltdown is no big deal. He's right, in a sense. Modern nuclear reactors are designed so tha
by cperciva 16y ago
I heard one supposed expert on CNN basically state that a nuclear meltdown is no big deal.
He's right, in a sense. Modern nuclear reactors are designed so that if the fuel melts it will end up in a wide concrete tray which sits under the reactor, where -- thanks to the fact that the tray is very wide and not at all deep -- it will cool down to a safe temperature.
All good engineering works on the principle of defence in depth. This is the last step to safely contain the hot fuel, after the many redundant cooling systems fail, and it's certainly not ideal -- but it's nothing like the mythical "China syndrome". (Or like Chernobyl, which involved a graphite fire causing fuel to go up rather than down.)
- sliverstorm 16y agoI suspect your parent did not realize a nuclear meltdown simply means the melting of the fuel, and instead (like most people) simply directly associates the words with "huge disaster". (From that frame of reference of course- "a huge disaster would not be a big deal!"- it DOES sound ridiculous)
- Duff 16y agoA few short days ago, we were told that everything was a-ok, no worries. Then the buildings started exploding -- still, everything is under control. On Monday we hear that fuel rods are fully exposed, but that is ok too. Now we're talking about the staff evacuating the site to avoid acute radiation poisoning and dropping seawater from helicopters. At what point do you stop accepting the best-case scenario as the most likely one?
- sliverstorm 16y agoWell, I imagine when people are dying. The quake and resulting waves killed a lot of people. This hasn't, yet. Excuse me for thinking the most about those.
- timr 16y ago"All good engineering works on the principle of defence in depth." That line is as much a sound-bite at this point as anything you'll hear on cable television. Yes, good engineering has many levels of fall-backs and redundancies. But when you've reached the point that you've evacuated the last fifty people from your site because it's no longer safe for them to be there, then you've exhausted your defenses. There's no more depth. Let's stop whistling past the graveyard: a meltdown is, in fact, a really big deal. Maybe the "wide concrete tray" will capture the waste. Maybe it won't. But in the meantime, you're hoping that there's not a secondary fire from the heat, or a steam explosion, or some other kind of explosion that flings radioactive particulate for miles around. You're hoping that the fuel won't melt, form a critical mass in the bottom of the reactor, and re-initiate a reaction that's hard to stop. You're hoping that the containment doesn't breach, and that vast quantities of radioactive waste aren't exposed to the elements before the whole system calms down again. You're hoping that the whole system calms down again. The point is: they've lost control. The 'engineering' that they're doing right now is desperate and hacky, and they're very nearly out of options. It might be comforting to pretend that this whole thing is scripted out on some intricate Japanese checklist somewhere, but that's really nothing more than a fantasy. I certainly hope that things aren't as bad as they sound, but this isn't just a matter of bad PR by some pessimistic, nuclear-energy skeptics. These guys are actually in trouble.
- cperciva 16y agoMaybe the "wide concrete tray" will capture the waste. Maybe it won't. Maybe the laws of physics will change, but I'd be willing to bet that they won't. But in the meantime, you're hoping that there's not a secondary fire from the heat Concrete doesn't burn. or a steam explosion At the point when the nuclear fuel melts, all the water has boiled off 1000 degrees ago. or some other kind of explosion that flings radioactive particulate for miles around. Explosions don't just happen for no reason. You're hoping that the fuel won't melt, form a critical mass in the bottom of the reactor, and re-initiate a reaction that's hard to stop. Nuclear reactors don't hold enough fuel to form a critical mass. In order to become critical, they need a moderator (usually water) which thermalizes neutrons.
- 16y ago
- dexen 16y agoEDIT: nvm, found the answer by re-reading the article. In short, even without chain reaction, substantial (7% of normal output early after shutdown) heat is produced, so some cooling is needed. -- The original post: Why are (or were) they pumping water in anyway? Wasn't the whole point of reactors moderated by water that once the moderating water escapes (evaporates or flows out), the unmoderated neutrons don't sustain chain reaction anymore and it basically ceases to produce heat?
- bdonlan 16y agoThere's already no chain reaction - the control rods, plus the boron in the water they're pumping in absorb too many neutrons to sustain a reaction. The heat is not from uranium fission, but rather from the fission products made while the reactor was running undergoing spontaneous decay. This process cannot be stopped; you can only wait for it to slow down and cool to a reasonable level. The reason they want to keep it cool is to prevent the fuel rods from melting. While melting won't immediately mean a release, it would mean the loss of two of the five barriers to a radioactive release, as well as quite a lot of heat for the remaining barriers. It would also significantly complicate later cleanup. As such, it is preferable that the fuel rods remain intact if at all possible, and this means attempting to cool them.
- Duff 16y agoI respect your faith in good engineering, but I haven't seen alot of evidence of good engineering here. There is no evidence to support your assertion that this is nothing like a "China syndrome" type issue. This facility is located a few miles from the eqicenter of the 4th largest earthquake in recorded history. None of the safety systems worked, and the power company and Japanese government has no clue about what to do. So the future of (at a minimum) an entire region of Japan is dependent on a slab of concrete after a massive earthquake. It is a facility built in a known earthquake and flood hazard zone that requires continuous access to the utility grid. Doesn't sound like good engineering by any standard to me.