5 ms·
Intelligent Disobedience has also found its place in Children's Rights Education offering instruments that help to keep children safe from the rare, but traumat
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
Intelligent Disobedience has also found its place in Children's Rights Education offering instruments that help to keep children safe from the rare, but traumatic instances when authority figures abuse their power.
I really don't think this is rare. People do crappy things all the time, especially when they imagine they know what is best for someone else. This is the default assumption of most adults in how they relate to any children in their lives.
- Nursie 6y agoIsn't that literally the job of a parent? Knowing better than the child what is best for them? Obviously that should include letting the young person stretch, learn and exercise their own judgement, but within bounds set by the parent and with the parent there to help with any consequences.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI was a full-time parent (homemaker) for a lot of years. I always operated as much as possible on the assumption that my kids had a great deal of local knowledge about their life that I would never know and when they were little they were incapable of articulating it but still knew it. An event that helped cement my commitment to respecting their boundaries as much as possible is where I made my son eat lunch because he wasn't eating and he tended to be skinny and I worried that I would end up charged with neglect for not feeding him enough. About thirty minutes later, he threw up all over my jacket which I actively encouraged to keep it off the cloth truck seat. After that, I doubled down on trying to make sure there was food available that he liked and that I felt was sufficiently healthy, but I left it up to him to decide to eat. He likely has two conditions that can each lead to requiring hospitalization to treat aversion to eating by mouth. He's never developed any such issues. So, unbeknownst to me, I had some serious challenges to deal with. Respecting his boundaries paid off. Kids like mine frequently end up seriously abused because the parents just keep increasing their attempts to control the kid and force the kid to do as they are told rather than coming at the issue from another angle as I chose to do. I am on my third parenting blog, still trying to figure out how to talk at folks about such things in a way that is helpful and doesn't sound too accusatory. The intent is to offer options, not criticism per se, for people dealing with challenging children.
- Nursie 6y agoYou can respect their boundaries while still knowing better than them. You would stop them running into the road, as an extreme example. Good parents know well enough to communicate with their child, and provide an environment in which they can learn and grow, and also when to intervene because there is danger. It's overly simplistic to say that parents don't have "know better" as part of the job description.
- deathgrips 6y agoNo. The job of a parent is to raise a child so they can know what's best for themselves and be able to handle problems without you. Most adults think with little evidence that they know what's best for their child. I've talked to many adults who think that their child should go to Harvard, or should go into a trade school, or shouldn't hang out with risk-taking friends, or shouldn't be gay, or should go to church. Outside of the very obvious situations where immediate safety is at risk, I don't see the evidence that most parents know what's best for their child. It's just arrogance. You should be trying to raise a capable adult rather than be protecting a foolish child for 18 years.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI remember reading somewhere that job of a parent is to teach the kid how to swim. It is a terrifying proposition since I am not always sure I know how to. I mostly agree with you. But I also know there is a blurry line there. For example, I did some stupid stuff as a kid and it is a good things parents were there to intervene. I would not call their concern for my risk taking in that instance to be arrogant today. But that is my perception of my individual upbringing. I have no real knowledge how parenting looks 'on average'. I know I was lucky in some ways; unlucky in others. This is where it gets complicated, because the advice we get for parenting is a generic advice for a typically specific issue. I am writing this as an expecting parent so take my musings as just that.
- Nursie 6y ago> The job of a parent is to raise a child so they can know what's best for themselves and be able to handle problems without you. Yes, it is part of it, absolutely. But in the early years there's more to it that that. When a four year old wants to eat ice cream all day and nothing else, are you asserting that they know better? > I don't see the evidence that most parents know what's best for their child That's not my assertion, my assertion is that it's their job, not that they're always good at it.
- ars 6y agoEspecially young children aren't always able to explain. Like a kid will come and say "I need a stick", and the parent is "what, you'll just hit someone", and refuse it. And the kid will cry. Later you discover the kid needs to make a school project, with a stick, and without the stick they simply did not do the project, and failed. And they were just not able to explain this to you. (This isn't a real story, but it's similar to the kind of thing that happens.) You also get "I need a dollar", and you give it to them, and later discover they had some kind of bet going with another kid (which you would have never approved of), and needed the dollar to pay the other kid. Upshot: You have to ask the kid what's up, there is a lot of knowledge they have that you don't.
- thrwaway69 6y agoHeck, I saw this happen. The default assumption was that they wanted to beat each other or do something shady.
- a1369209993 6y agoThis. Just, so fucking much this. Child abuse is so common and so accepted that most people justifiably can't even recognize it anymore.
- joe_the_user 6y agoIn sense, the parent-child relationship is kind of weird to have compared to the flight-crew/pilot or the guide-dog/disable-person relationship. The later relationships are between trained individuals (or animals) acting in fairly specific circumstances. The parent-child relationship is something everyone winds-up with, with large portion also doing the parent part. And so whatever training a parent has is minimal yet the circumstance that they deal with their children in are very general. So a lot of problem parent behavior is ... a problem. The main way something like this "Children's Rights Education" tries to resemble the other situation is teaching kids that there are few circumstances of abuse where they legally refuse/resist. Of course, there are lot of abusive situations that the child can't legally resist and of course being a child navigating such an overall situation presents many minefields. Which is to say this approach has to subscribe to the fiction (derived from the law) that there is a fixed line between abuse and non-abuse where in fact the line is fuzzy indeed.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoFor the most part, the real solution to child abuse or mistreatment is to deal with the parents. America does a poor job of providing adequate support to parents. We have a lot of family unfriendly policies.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoCan you elaborate? Provide some examples of other communities that do better? (Honest question.)
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThe US is stingier with child care and maternity leave than the rest of the world https://theconversation.com/the-us-is-stingier-with-child-care-and-maternity-leave-than-the-rest-of-the-world-94770 https://theconversation.com/the-us-is-stingier-with-child-ca... The US is on a short list of countries that don't provide maternity leave. All the others are dirt poor. We have no such excuses. We have terrible healthcare policies. At one time, it was somewhat common for dad to be the primary breadwinner and have a decent job with benefits, including healthcare for the wife and kids. Mom worked part time or was a homemaker. Now, even if both parents work, the kids may not be automatically covered on either parent's healthcare policy from work. They may have to pay extra for that. (Though I'm not clear how much Obamacere changed that.) In much of Europe, it is still somewhat common for the extended family to help raise the kids, daycare is generally more readily available, maternity leave is the norm, etc. You don't have to try hard at all to find countries with better family-friendly policies than the US, even without having sophisticated, well-thought-out ideas about what that should mean.
- Reedx 6y agoAnother way to look at this may be something like: Odds of an adult knowing what's best for another adult: Low to Medium Odds of an adult knowing what's best for a child: Medium to High
- DoreenMichele 6y agoOdds of an adult being able to talk with the child in an informative way in a non-emergency situation and help them make a better decision for themselves: Extremely high. You don't have to boss the kid around and treat them like a puppet you control to help them make better decisions. Obviously (and it should go without saying, but I will say it anyway): Emergency situations are an exception. You can and should stop a child from sticking their hand in the fire without trying to nicely and at length talk them out of it while they are in the midst of doing so anyway. You will also de facto be making a fair number of decisions on their behalf when they are below a certain age. Infants can cry to let you know something is wrong, but they can't tell you they need to be fed, etc. Adults have to do their best to figure out what the issue is and address it. Good parents typically don't have a policy of "Oh, just let them cry it out." They typically feel that a crying child requires parental intervention to solve whatever their problem is. (Exception: It's okay for them to just cry for emotional reasons. I never tried to convince my kids to stop crying about being told "no" or whatever. If you know they are crying because small kids have big feels, let them cry. No big deal. But babies don't typically cry for emotional reasons. They cry because they have a problem that needs to be addressed.)
- deathgrips 6y agoWhy do you think that?
- gpm 6y agoOdds of knowing what's best. Approximately 0 in both cases. Odds of knowing better than the adult/child in question though, sure, those ranges sound right.
- fouc 6y agoOdds of an adult knowing what's best for another adult: Low Odds of an adult knowing what's best for a child: Medium
- deathgrips 6y agoThis is also the primary motivation in censorship, from social media companies to authoritarian regimes. You believe that you know better and must censor wrong information so that stupid people don't consume it and get hurt because of it.
- EmilioMartinez 6y agoThere's a deep line between "crappy things" and "traumatic abuse" though. It's up to you how rare it is though.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoMany years ago, I read an article about childcare practices in some country that valued boy children over girl children. First born boys routinely got little "extras." They got their favorite food just because it was their favorite. The got taken to the doctor a bit quicker, like tonight instead waiting until morning to see how they felt. That sort of thing. This was not article document horrifying abuse of little girls. It just documented boys, especially first-born boys, getting a little extra care and attention. The difference could be measured in mortality. Boys, especially first-born boys, had lower death rates than girls. I don't think there is a deep line at all between the two things. I think if there is a line between them at all, it's pretty darn fuzzy.
- EmilioMartinez 6y agoYou are right, I should have said "big difference" instead of "deep line". I tried to focus on how meaning is conveyed while neglecting my own language. And there's a big difference between "big difference" and "deep line". Back to the original topic, yours also serves as an example of how easily damage can be delivered through being systemic. I'm confident it's not hard to produce many cases that qualify as systemic traumatic abuse, but it's an exercise I'd rather not do today.