21 ms·
The funny thing is that the MPAA are so clueless, they don’t even know popcorntime are their own worst enemies. They kept splitting out, rewriting from scratch,
by toyg 6y ago
The funny thing is that the MPAA are so clueless, they don’t even know popcorntime are their own worst enemies. They kept splitting out, rewriting from scratch, failing to establish a trusted way of distributing the app, then the latest releases have been so bad that people are abandoning it in droves - you can see the fallout on reddit. The ban was meant to DOS them for a few weeks, now that cinemas are shut and all eyes are on digital, but ended up being a big advertising campaign for PT. Good on the lawyers for getting paid to fail!
PT itself is a relatively banal app anyway, even if it gets nuked someone else will rewrite it. Napster begat Gnutella begat BitTorrent begat Popcorn, it will not end until the movie business gives consumers what they want: a cheap global service to watch anything anytime.
- mindfulhack 6y agoI also have another reason why I feel like download and off-line-only video is important: Privacy. Streaming services have increasingly terrifying and inescapable telemetry. Spotify, Netflix, Amazon, Google - all of them collect extremely telling things about us due to when we pause video, for how long, which bits we rewind back to, when we consume the content during the time, where (GPS-wise), how often we play them, the collective profiling of us based on what we download in general...and many other things we don't even know about. After listening to Shoshana Zuboff's audiobook 'The Age of Surveillance Capitalism' - the most important book I have ever read on technology - I am very aware of this. The data companies don't want us to be aware of what they're doing to us. I'm not condoning piracy, and I believe content creators should be fairly compensated for their hard work - but unless there's a convenient way to be able to consume content in my own open-source local software such as MPV, all offline, and in full privacy without being spied on, I refuse to legitimise the alternative. I realise there's still blu-ray and DVD, but not always - many releases are web only, now. I'd even pay a premium more for such non-DRM content...your move, Hollywood. It was never natural to have people watch and profile us when we're already paying money to watch personal entertainment, on this massive global scale.
- legulere 6y agoWith peer to peer file sharing you tell the whole world what you are watching.
- Sevaris 6y agoHe didn't mention p2p, did he? I can go years without touching p2p, while still pirating everything I want to watch.
- thejynxed 6y agoYou're still advertising to anyone and everyone with admin access who cares to parse their log files every server hop you make to get it.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoOn the other hand, all of > when we pause video, for how long, which bits we rewind back to, when we consume the content during the time, where (GPS-wise), how often we play them is entirely hidden. What model gives that up, but keeps the identity of the video you're watching private?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- taneq 6y agoNot at all. You share with an assortment of randoms that you're downloading a particular file (that they're also downloading) at a particular time. That's all. You don't tell them when you watched it, how many times, whether and when you paused it, or whether you fast forwarded the naughty bits or went back to re-watch them. It's far less intrusive. And most importantly, those few randoms don't have a flood of other data being scraped from your phone, social media, credit card transactions etc. to cross-correlate your viewing with. They don't see that you paused the movie when the main character put on some Nikes and went online shopping for a pair of Nikes for yourself. They don't see that you have friends over. They don't see what brand of microwave popcorn you watch with your movies. They don't care.
- js2 6y agoTonight I wanted to watch Spider-Man: Far From Home with my kids. I have subscriptions to Netflix, Disney+, Amazon Prime, Criterion, Apple TV+ and PBS. Yet, my only option was to purchase it digitally via iTunes for $15. There was no rental option. It wasn’t available in Disney+ because I assume Sony holds the rights despite the rest of Marvel belonging to Disney. It’s only available for purchase and not rental because I assume: greed. So I downloaded it off Usenet instead. Edit: Starz apparently has distribution rights at the moment. 7 days free then $8.99/month. So I could’ve legally watched it for free by signing up via Apple and canceling. Sigh. This is exhausting Hollywood. Get your shit together.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- toyg 6y agoDafuq is Starz, even? These days there is a new service every month, it’s hard to keep up. Absolute shambles.
- bitbckt 6y agoStarz is a 20+ year old premium cable channel.
- 1123581321 6y agoStarz is an add-on paid cable channel, like HBO. It’s been around for awhile. About ten years ago, Starz had a deal with Netflix to stream their content next day. I remember watching some of Party Down that way as it aired.
- flanbiscuit 6y agoStarz has been around since the mid-90s. It has some pretty good programming but it just doesn't get the attention that maybe HBO or Showtime does. They had a really good short lived comedy series called "Party Down" that I loved. Had a great cast! https://m.imdb.com/title/tt1073507/ https://m.imdb.com/title/tt1073507/ I think Outlander might be one of its more popular series now. Based on a book series and brought to TV by Ronald D Moore who did Battlestar Galactica (which personally I am cautious about because the last season or 2 of BSG was not my favorite)
- bananamerica 6y agoTakedowns often aim at more than the case in question. By going after Popcorn Time, MPAA also sends clear message to other projects.
- numlock86 6y ago> [...] it will not end until the movie business gives consumers what they want: a cheap global service to watch anything anytime. I would happily pay something like $30 or even $50 per month if I would get access to everything anytime. But then again that's probably because right now I pay around $15 per service that only give me ~5% of the total content each.
- dannyw 6y agoMovies and TV shows cost more to make than songs. $39 a month, sure.
- abdullahkhalids 6y agoLet me do a back of envelope calculation. This source [1] claims that the average production cost of a Hollywood movie has risen to $40 million. This is based on 5713 movies produced between 1999-2020, which is about 285 movies/year. Let's double that for fun and figure out what happens if you hit 500 million subscribers worldwide. 600 movies *40m/movie /500m subscribers = $48 /subscriber every year. So presumably, only $4 dollars a month is more than enough to cover the cost of producing all Hollywood movies - ignore of course, all other sources of revenue such as cinema tickets and product placement etc. Is marketing and distribution online really 9x the cost of producing the movie itself? [1] https://stephenfollows.com/how-has-the-cost-of-making-a-movie-changed-over-the-past-twenty-years/ https://stephenfollows.com/how-has-the-cost-of-making-a-movi...
- lukeramsden 6y agoBut how else are movie executives supposed to afford cocaine? Jokes aside, this is a very interesting calculation - it seems the issue with a system like this would be the monopoly and centralization, as the numbers themselves stack up quite ok.
- nkozyra 6y agoBut that would just be (not quite) breaking even. Major Hollywood films often make 3x or more their budget in profit. And marketing costs are huge and for some reason not included in the film budget. In 2020, people are consuming "movies" and "television" like they're the same thing. You have to include those in the cost. Finally, if you're including worldwide subscribers, you have to include worldwide producers, not just Hollywood.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoI can imagine that software like Popcorn changes hands every once in a while to a grey-area investor who thinks they can make money off of it.
- onion2k 6y agoa cheap global service to watch anything anytime I don't know about Hollywood movies, but for TV shows that would require the makers buying a perpetual license for anything they use in the show. That would probably make it too expensive to make something anyone would actually want to watch. Shows would have to have no cultural references (eg a pop song) in them at all.
- toyg 6y agoMore likely, they would do what Netflix is doing when faced with the same problem (time-limited licenses): they would commission more original music from cheaper, less-known (and likely younger) artists. Honestly, I can survive the thought of not having a Bowie song in every other production.