6 ms·
People were saying that in New York in February and going to street parties. A month later the hospitals were overwhelmed. I think it is reasonable to ease res
by simonh 6y ago
People were saying that in New York in February and going to street parties. A month later the hospitals were overwhelmed.
I think it is reasonable to ease restrictions when case numbers fall. Hopefully enough people will maintain distance and minimise unnecessary contact to slow it spreading and keep the pressure off the hospitals. However free riders recklessly endangering themselves, others and health care staff should be ashamed of themselves.
- xkapastel 6y agoI live in New York and I'm under the impression the hospitals were never overwhelmed. That was the fear, but it didn't actually happen. They also thought they would run out of ventilators, but never came close to using all of them, started giving them away to other states, and then discovered that ventilators were not actually a good treatment anyway.
- Retric 6y agoNYC hospitals increased capacity dramatically, with people treated huge wards and some sent to temporary facilities. That’s what being overwhelmed looks like, it’s not a binary condition just a decrease in the average quality of care. In terms of ventilators many people where kept off of ventilators who would have been given them in normal conditions. That was likely a good thing as ventilators have huge risks associated with their use, but things where a long way from ok. That said, the lockdown likely prevented a much worse situation at local hospitals.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> In terms of ventilators many people where kept off of ventilators who would have been given them in normal conditions. Sadly, that wasn't the case in NY. Even though Chinese doctors warned of the risks of ventilators in Jan/Feb, the US ignored that. There were 2 reasons: 1) intubating patients protected staff from aerosolization after the intubation 2) old understanding of oxygen levels led doctors to intubate way too early for corona.
- nostrademons 6y agoI have a friend who works in a NYC hospital and they absolutely were overwhelmed. Every available space (including supply closets, ERs, staff briefing rooms) converted into a coronavirus ward. A few staff members (including their ER director) died from coronavirus. They never ran out of ventilators, but they did run out of beds.
- losvedir 6y agoWho is the ER director you're talking about? I tried looking it up but couldn't find any articles.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- simonh 6y agoThat’s hardly surprising, there’s no reliable record of health care worker deaths. “...US officials say they have no comprehensive way to count those who lose their lives trying to save others.” Also: “In some facilities, the person who is supposed to do the reporting is caring for patients and is overwhelmed,” Schuchat said. [1]https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/apr/15/coronavirus-us-health-care-worker-death-toll-higher-official-data-suggests https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/apr/15/coronavirus-...
- 650REDHAIR 6y agoMy friend is an ICU nurse in Manhattan and they were(are) absolutely overwhelmed. PPE shortages, mandatory overtime, staff shortages due to infection, and almost every department became a covid department.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> A month later the hospitals were overwhelmed. Really? There are well-regarded articles stating that most hospitals were well below normal capacities. The emergency hospitals setup across NY state were barely used, some are closing have not treated even a single patient. No doubt some parts of some hospitals were hit hard, but I see no evidence of the city/state as a whole being anywhere near capacity.
- sndean 6y agoI'm not sure about the articles, but my SO had worked nights in the ICU just outside of NYC for the past two months. Notes from her: - They quadrupled ICU capacity, taking over empty hospital beds from elsewhere in the hospital. At one point the only patients were COVID. No other admissions. - Out-of-work doctors like cardiologists, soldiers, out-of-state nurses came in to help. They didn't know what to do in the ICU, so they mostly got in the way. - At the peak they needed about double the normal number of beds. - Most 12-hours shifts were done without sitting or having time to go to the bathroom. So they overestimated the flood of COVID patients and were able to deal with it, possibly because they over-prepared, and there were essentially no non-COVID patients. At least that's n=1 ICU physician's perspective. Her friends in difference cities seem to have had similar experience (all east coast doctors, though), but the only overwhelmed ones are in NYC metro.
- fooker 6y agoSo, they were not overwhelmed?
- sndean 6y agoThat specific hospital wasn't. But, again: > At the peak they needed about double the normal number of beds. If they had not been able to annex a portion of the hospital for more beds, they probably would've been overwhelmed. Most of the people with normal things (heart attacks, severe diabetes-related issues, alcohol withdraw, etc.) stayed home, so they were able to create more capacity. I think every hospital did the same, so there's no good control group.
- fooker 6y ago>A month later the hospitals were overwhelmed. Please try to understand that the reason you have this piece of information is because someone purposefully decided to broadcast misinformation with an agenda. Maybe diversify the sources you get your information from.