4 ms·
https://thespacewriter.com/wp/2019/11/16/scientists-are-not-baffled/ https://thespacewriter.com/wp/2019/11/16/scientists-are-not-... Start: "Every week, I see
by bryanrasmussen 7y ago
https://thespacewriter.com/wp/2019/11/16/scientists-are-not-baffled/ https://thespacewriter.com/wp/2019/11/16/scientists-are-not-...
Start: "Every week, I see headlines in the mainstream media (as well as the “social” and online media outlets) that say something like “NASA Scientists Baffled at….” or “Scientists Bewildered by…”. It’s annoying and tells me that the writer and/or the headline writer is a) lazy and b) doesn’t have a clue about science or scientists. "
- giraffe333 6y agoI agree with your general thought about this, but in this specific article one of the scientists was quoted saying he was "baffled", but only "kind of". Maybe the title should be "Herd of Fuzzy Green 'Glacier Mice' Kind of Baffles Scientists". I would be more likely to read that!
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoIt's not my general thoughts, it's a quote from the post which I thought was a funny enough insight on a frequent pattern in science journalism for the masses.
- klyrs 6y agoOr, c) they interviewed a scientist doing the research and literally reported the fact: > "We still don't know," he says. "I'm still kind of baffled."' Scientists are baffled. It's what gets us out of bed. If we knew everything, we'd be called oracles or something. If we stuck to the comforts of the known, applicable facts, we'd be called engineers. Humans are curious beings. We enjoy the trivia at the forefront of science, even if we won't read the boring details of the precise scientific answer. Mulling the questions that scientists are investigating is a delight. And yeah, sometimes it's a lazy editor who exploits that curiosity, editorializing without verification, but that doesn't seem to be the case here.
- fsckboy 6y ago> if we stuck to the comforts of the known, applicable facts, we'd be called engineers. seriously? you are showing off your knowledge of science by displaying an ignorance of engineering... engineers don't live in emotional comfort, and the best experimental scientists are engineers or they'd never create novel equipment to test ideas.
- dekhn 6y agoI don't like it when headlines say scientists are "shocked" or "amazed" (those are very rare in science proper, although you do see it when your paper is rejected/accepted by a major journal. In this specific case, it is an example of baffling.
- Ericson2314 6y agoBut the first quote acts like its a new discovery, but then they go on to say it's been known, just under-researched, for 50+ years.
- BurningFrog 6y agoYou're halfway there. What's really happening is that the headline writer knows what wording gets clicks. They're not fools. Their job is just different from what you think it is.
- zamfi 6y agoEpidemiologists are battled today too! https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/22/us/politics/coronavirus-tests-cdc.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/22/us/politics/coronavirus-t...
- zamfi 6y ago*baffled
- plasticchris 6y agoBut the scientist is quoted saying he is baffled, if that's accurate I'd say the headline is fair.
- DrScump 6y agoIn their general "journalism" pool (i.e. aside from Nova and Science Friday), NPR/PBS journalism has a really low bar for science knowledge. There's a new PBS science show hosted by a "journalist" (rather than a scientist) called "H2O: the molecule that made us". When talking about the atmosphere of the early Earth, she referred to it as "mostly CO2". That's so egregious an error, I rewound and rechecked it five times. The highest CO2 content we know of was 0.04%. "Mostly"?! This means that nobody with fairly basic science knowledge (I don't even have a degree in hard sciences, and this hit me like fingernails on a chalkboard) reviewed the script, or caught it in production, or caught it in previews.
- 8bitsrule 6y agoOne of the scientists was quoted as saying,"I'm still kind of baffled." Guess that seemed like adequate verisimilitude. After all, scientists like to be baffled ... if you're not, you're probably not looking hard enough. (Ask any cosmologist ;-)
- craftinator 6y agoOkay, let's play with the word baffle here to make the headline more fun [1]. I like "baffle: auxiliary devices employed in tank which suppress the effects of slosh dynamics." So scientists employed a device to prevent the slosh dynamics caused by fuzzy green mice from affecting glaciers! Now THAT is an article I'd like to read! [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baffle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baffle