4 ms·
> The email client is specifically designed to be able to display untrusted mail. Email clients often do things like load images, which can tell the sender you
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> The email client is specifically designed to be able to display untrusted mail.
Email clients often do things like load images, which can tell the sender you've read the email, which is an information leak.
Some email clients try not to do this, but that's actually somewhat recent, and I wouldn't say they're 'specifically designed to be able to display untrusted mail', rather 'they try to avoid common exploits when they become known'.
- capableweb 6y agoEmail clients started out without embedded images. Images came after the initial email implementation. So one could say that displaying images in email clients is rather new. Also, most if not all email clients have the option of disabling Inline images. Email clients, just like browsers, are made specifically to handle untrusted user content. That then some people/clients allow information leak, is another thing. Just like websockets in modern browsers.
- brmgb 6y agoSure, let's pretend images in email are a new development and should be stopped. Meanwhile in the real world some of us have actual users. Pretending we should stop using widely used and useful technology while flailing your arms and shooting "but security!" is not going to help anyone.
- capableweb 6y ago> Sure, let's pretend images in email are a new development and should be stopped. What? No. No one is arguing that... The only thing I'm refuting in my previous comment is "Some email clients try not to do this, but that's actually somewhat recent" which seems to indicate chrisseaton thinks that email clients that don't load images is a new thing. So the idea is that first we had email clients, then the email clients added the option to hide images. When in reality, email clients started out without images, then they added images. Way to reply to a comment without reading the context and subsequently completely miss the point.
- wolco 6y agoThunderbird has always done this. Loading images prompting before send receipt notifications you name it.
- Aeolun 6y ago> Email clients often do things like load images, which can tell the sender you've read the email, which is an information leak. That makes it less than ideal, but describing it as a ‘failure’ isn’t going to help any users pay more attention to phishing mails, because they get tons of legitimate emails with images in.
- mewpmewp2 6y agoWhat can be done with this information? Most companies have e-mail addresses that are completely predictable, so you can pretty much assume that this e-mail address exists. If this really was a security risk shouldn't you have UUID emails for everyone? Also how do you as an attacker know that it was user not a e-mail server checking those images?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> What can be done with this information? It will reveal if they're working right now, what time they work otherwise, their IP address, their approximate physical location, their internet provider. A lot you can do with that. > Most companies have e-mail addresses that are completely predictable That's the point. Predict an email address, send it, find out if such a person works there. If I email unusual.name@sis.gov.uk and they open it then guess what I've worked out? > Also how do you as an attacker know that it was user not a e-mail server checking those images? Agent signatures.
- pbowyer 6y ago>> Also how do you as an attacker know that it was user not a e-mail server checking those images? > Agent signatures. Can you Expand? Googling isn't helping me understand what this means/how it works.
- eganist 6y agoThe "user agent string" of the email client is different from that of the user's browser.
- chrisseaton 6y agoAlso called agent fingerprinting. You can look at exactly how the agent is responding and make educated guesses at what agent it is. You think one HTTP request looks like any other, but there's enough little bits of information here and there to leak info. The user agent is the simplest example. That can be spoofed, but there's more subtle traces as well, all the way down the stack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TCP/IP_stack_fingerprinting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TCP/IP_stack_fingerprinting.
- jandrese 6y agoThis is one thing I like about Outlook. It doesn't load embedded images unless you click on a button at the top. All email clients should do this. Not only is it safer, but it discourages people from putting a ton of images in emails which is just annoying in general anyway.
- ttsda 6y agoGmail used to do this, but it seems they've phased it out.