7 ms·
It's called lockdown for a reason. Apple was just the very first to implement centralized binary blacklisting, revocation. They call it notarization. Problem i
by rurban 6y ago
It's called lockdown for a reason. Apple was just the very first to implement centralized binary blacklisting, revocation. They call it notarization.
Problem is, that they did it unannounced. There must be really some weird stuff going on in those managers heads. How can they possibly think to go away with that?
- m463 6y agoOnce you start something, it's hard to stop it. Every software place I've worked gives a special urgency to security stuff. And even if features don't come out regularly, security updates do. This is more of that.
- dagmx 6y agoThere were announcements about notarization around WWDC last year. They didn't seem to get a lot of media traction however, but there were specific pages detailing what's required from a developer and some basic details on how it would work From April 10, 2019: https://developer.apple.com/news/?id=04102019a https://developer.apple.com/news/?id=04102019a https://developer.apple.com/documentation/xcode/notarizing_macos_software_before_distribution https://developer.apple.com/documentation/xcode/notarizing_m...
- rurban 6y agoFor each and every shell or perl script that I create and use privately? No, certainly not.
- kevinh456 6y agoThere was nothing "unannounced" about it. Notarization was introduced at WWDC 2018 and announced as required at WWDC 2019. Every macOS developer should have been aware of this requirement. It was a special project for my apps.
- ghayes 6y agoI believe the concern here is that this is affecting not just macOS developers, but all developers who use macOS. That's an important distinction.
- pjmlp 6y agoDevelopers who use macOS as shiny GNU/Linux replacement are only getting what they deserve, they should have supported Linux OEMs to start with. Those that show up at FOSDEM, carrying their beloved macBooks and iPads while pretending to be into FOSS. I use Apple devices knowingly what they are for, not as replacement for something else.
- saagarjha 6y agoWhat if using macOS enables me to be a more effective FOSS contributor? What if I think that FOSDEM is actually has many participants who aren't really into free software?
- pjmlp 6y agoThen they are on the wrong spot to start with, and really didn't got the message what FOSDEM is all about. It is a bit hard to be an aspiring FOSS contributor given the foundations those contributions are built upon. Those same Apple loving users would be laugh upon at FOSDEM if they demoed any of their stuff on Windows instead. Yet, there is hardly any difference between those corporations going all the way back to their origins. Somehow after NeXTSTEP's adoption as OS X, NeXT and Apple's proprietary behaviour was forgotten and everything excused, because "hey they are shipping an UNIX clone"!
- Yetanfou 6y ago> What if using macOS enables me to be a more effective FOSS contributor? How would that work? When you build a house on rented ground the house may seem to be yours but it can always be taken away from you.
- 6y ago
- make3 6y agodeveloper who uses MacOS != MacOS developer. I couldn't care less about what is announced at WWDC
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- john_alan 6y agoCommand line apps aren't affected by Notarization. If you're compiling something yourself, the compiler won't put a quarantine bit on it and it will execute fine. Same with homebrew/friends. Scripts don't need to be signed. There is something else going on here.
- john_alan 6y agoSeems that in fact even though scripts aren't signed, IF YOU DONT have devTooling enabled for a given terminal, scripts are hashed and checked against bad known digests. not a big deal, assuming no data is kept. Also I wonder what it looks like if a script is deemed bad...
- ComodoHacker 6y ago>Apple was just the very first to implement centralized binary blacklisting No, AV vendors did it for decades. In a more efficient way though.
- andy_ppp 6y agoNot sure it’s more efficient given how sluggish most AV software used to make my machine...
- happymellon 6y agoNot as bad as Catalina
- jules 6y agoIsn't this what bloom filters are for?
- la_oveja 6y agoFirst? Windows SmartScreen has checked for malicious binaries since Windows 8.
- yariik 6y ago> Problem is, that they did it unannounced. No, the entire thing is the problem. Windows 10 can still open applications that were compiled in 1994, and it doesn't make it less secure.