10 ms·
Self-driving cars. Now that the hype is over and the fake-it-til-you-make-it crowd has tanked, there's progress. Slowly, the LIDARs get cheaper, the radars get
by Animats 7y ago
Self-driving cars. Now that the hype is over and the fake-it-til-you-make-it crowd has tanked, there's progress. Slowly, the LIDARs get cheaper, the radars get more resolution, and the software improves.
UE5's rendering approach. They finally figured out how to use the GPU to do level of detail. Games can now climb out of the Uncanny Valley.
The Playstation 5. 8 CPUs at 3.2GHz each, 24GB of RAM, 14 teraflops of GPU, and a big solid state disk. That's a lot of compute engine for $400. Somebody will probably make supercomputers out of rooms full of those.
C++ getting serious about safety. Buffer overflows and bad pointers should have been eliminated decades ago. We've known how for a long time.
Electric cars taking over. The Ford F-150 and the Jeep Wrangler are coming out in all-electric forms. That covers much of the macho market. And the electrics will out-accelerate the gas cars without even trying hard.
Utility scale battery storage. It works and is getting cheaper. Wind plus storage plus megavolt DC transmission, and you can generate power in the US's wind belt (the Texas panhandle north to Canada) and transmit it to the entire US west of the Mississippi.
- zhenchaoli 7y ago> C++ getting serious about safety. Buffer overflows and bad pointers should have been eliminated decades ago. We've known how for a long time. Would love some links to read over weekend. Thanks!
- Teknoman117 7y agoThings like: - std::string_view - std::span - std::unique_ptr - std::shared_ptr - std::weak_ptr (non owning reference to shared_ptr, knows when the parent is free'd) - ranges - move semantics - move capture in lambdas - std::variant - std::optional To be honest, learning rust has made me a better c++ programmer as well. Having to really think about lifetimes and ownership from an API perspective has been really neat. It's not so much that I wasn't concerned about it before, more that I strive to be more expressive of these conditions in code.
- jfkebwjsbx 7y agostring_view, span and ranges are not conductive to safety, quite the opposite.
- dnpp123 7y agoYeah, if anything, C++ is getting less serious about safety by piling features over features. Just write Rust instead.
- typon 7y agocan you explain why you think that?
- Animats 7y agoThings like "It is the programmer's responsibility to ensure that std::string_view does not outlive the pointed-to character array." "string_view" is a borrow of a slice of a string. Since C++ doesn't have a borrow checker, it's possible to have a dangling string_view if the string_view outlives the underlying string. This is a memory safety error. Rust has educated people to recognize this situation. Now it's standard terminology to refer to this as a borrow, which helps. Attempting to retrofit Rust concepts to C++ is helping, but often they're cosmetic, because they say the right thing, but aren't checked. However, saying the right thing makes it possible to do more and more static checking.
- typon 7y agoBut surely it's a step towards more safety. Compare to passing char * around or ref/ptr to string. Sure C++ doesnt have a borrow checker but these types encourage the idea of "reifying" lack of ownership rather than keeping it ad hoc
- temac 7y agoYou don't infer potential ownership from a C++ ref. Likewise for char* strings unless it is to interface with a C api, in which case you will keep it anyway.
- phaedrus 7y agoStatic analysis tools like PVS Studio are amazing. Software verification like CompCert where the compilation includes a certificate of correctness are farther away for C++ but will someday be usable for it.
- IC4RUS 7y agoMaybe it was a purposeful reference, but PlayStations have indeed been linked to create a supercomputer: https://phys.org/news/2010-12-air-playstation-3s-supercomputer.html https://phys.org/news/2010-12-air-playstation-3s-supercomput...
- jonathankoren 7y agoEven before that link. The PS2 Linux kit was used back in 2003. https://web.archive.org/web/20041120084657/http://arrakis.ncsa.uiuc.edu/ps2/ https://web.archive.org/web/20041120084657/http://arrakis.nc...
- samstave 7y agoWRT F150; I am so upset with the state of the auto market when it comes to pricing. Manufacturing margins are enormous when it comes to cars. The F150 is no different. A two seater (effectively) vehicle stamped out of metal and plastic should never cost as much as those things do. I hate car companies and their pricing models.
- dlbucci 7y agoLook up the chicken tax bill that passed a few decades ago that basically stopped any foreign car manufacturers from selling pickups in the US. That's why trucks are so much more expensive than other types of cars.
- gonzo41 7y agoAlso why you have hugh f-serious cars and not more reasonable sized cars like Hilux's
- ethbro 7y agoBecause small trucks require more fuel- and emissions-efficient engines than larger ones.
- Cactus2018 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicken_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicken_tax
- sanat 7y agohttps://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/06/12/414029929/episode-632-the-chicken-tax https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/06/12/414029929/epis...
- ponker 7y agoFord's operating margin is ~8 percent it's not like they're making triple digit profit margins here. You are overreacting.
- aj-4 7y agoTesla covering 3/6... stock price is definitely still low
- threeseed 7y agoI would never trust any self driving car that didn't use LiDAR. It's an essential sensor for helping to fix issues like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1cSw4fXYqWI&feature=emb_logo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1cSw4fXYqWI&feature=emb_logo And it's not contrived since we've seen situations of Telsa Autopilot behaving weirdly when it sees people on the side of billboards, trucks etc.
- sedgjh23 7y agoHumans don’t need LiDAR to recognize billboards
- reitzensteinm 7y agoHumans are underrated.
- jhallenworld 7y agoYou are right, for example, humans don't need anywhere near the amount of training data that AIs need.
- CreepGin 7y agoDepends on how you quantify data a human processes from birth to adulthood.
- erik_seaberg 7y agoSelf-driving cars could work more like a hive mind. Humans can share ideas, but not reflexes and motor memory. So we practice individually, and we're great at recognizing moving stuff, but we never get very good at avoiding problems that rarely happen to us. And we know we shouldn't drive tired or angry or intoxicated but obviously it still happens.
- zamalek 7y ago> That's a lot of compute engine for $400. So excited for this as a PC gamer, hardware prices are going to have to plummet. I don't think supercomputers a likely, the PS2 was a candidate because there was [initially] official support for installing Linux on the thing. Sony terminated that support and I really can't imagine them reintroducing it for the PS5.
- ethbro 7y agoSony's only interest is to do a single deployment, using a customized OS and firmware, and then get as many articles out of the project as possible. They have zero incentive to subsidize supercomputers. They're in the business of trading hardware for royalty, store, and subscription payments.
- jjoonathan 7y agoAnd if they do it would be wise not to trust them, because dropping support for advertised features with hardware-fused irreversible software updates is SOP at this point. FFS, they even dropped support for my 4K screen in an update and I wound up playing the back half of Horizon Zero Dawn in 1080p as a result.
- sandov 7y agoWhat? How and why did they drop support for your screen?
- jjoonathan 7y agoYes, really. They up and dropped an entire HDMI mode used by "older" 4K displays. A cynic would say they wanted to boost sales on newer displays, but it seems more likely that a bug of some kind came up in a driver (I was unaware of any problems, but that's hardly proof of anything) and they just decided it was easier to cut support of those displays than to fix the problem. Support forums filled with complaints by the dozens of pages, but Sony didn't care, because why should they? I'm sure somebody did the calculation that said we weren't a big enough demographic to matter.
- ekianjo 7y ago> The Playstation 5. 8 CPUs at 3.2GHz each, 24GB of RAM, 14 teraflops of GPU, and a big solid state disk. That's a lot of compute engine for $400. Somebody will probably make supercomputers out of rooms full of those. Mmm, this sounds like exactly what people said at the time the PS3 was going to be released, and I can only recall of one example where the PS3 was ever used in a cluster and that probably was not that very useful in the end.
- devbug 7y agoThe key differentiator is x86 vs PPC and 1 TB/s bus.
- jjoonathan 7y ago> 1 TB/s bus Is that the new marketing term for shared VRAM?
- midnightclubbed 7y agoPPC was ok, the killer was that you had to write code specifically for the Cell (co)processors and their limited memory addressing if you wanted the promised compute performance.
- marcelluspye 7y agoAre you referring to the time the US air force built a cluster out of 2000 PS3s? Seems good.
- dangus 7y agoThis exactly. The PS5 and Xbox One X are commodity PC hardware, optimized for gaming, packaged with a curated App Store. Sony also won’t just sell you hundreds or thousands of them for some kind of groundbreakingly cheap cluster. They will say no, unless you’re GameStop or Walmart. Everyone with a high-mid-range PC already has more horsepower than a PS5 and it’s not doing anything particularly innovative or groundbreaking. The PS5 is going to equivalent to a mid-range $100 AMD CPU, something not as good as an RTX 2080 or maybe even an RTX 2070, and a commodity NVME SSD (Probably cheap stuff like QLC) that would retail for about the same price as a 1TB 2.5” mechanical hard drive. It is not unique. Data center servers optimize for entirely different criteria and game consoles do not make sense for anything coming close to that sort of thing. For example, servers optimize for 24/7 use and high density. The PS4 doesn’t fit in a 1U rack. It doesn’t have redundant power. Any cost savings on purchase price is wasted on paying your data center for the real estate, no joke. Then when the console breaks you have to pay your technician $100/hour in compensation, benefits, and taxes to remove and replace it.
- friendlybus 7y agoGpu solved LOD won't save video games from the uncanny valley. In some cases it will make it worse. It makes for nice statues and static landscapes though.
- axegon_ 7y agoI never really paid attention to consoles (not a gamer in any way) but the ps5 sounds impressive. Shame Sony have a very Apple-like approach to their products and lock everything up. If they bundled up that hardware with linux support, sales would go through the roof and into orbit. I'd personally get a bunch of these and build myself a cluster.
- codeisawesome 7y agoMaybe they sell the H/W at a loss (especially considering R&D + Marketing spend) - and the real strategy is to turn a profit on PSPlus, licensing and taking a cut out of game distribution. If that's the case... you or me building a linux cluster will actually hurt them =)
- mcdevilkiller 7y agoNot maybe, that's exactly what they do.
- cmckn 7y agoThe PS3 had dual-boot support for Linux early on, for a couple years after launch. It was removed in a software update a week or two after I decided to try it. I don't see Sony doubling back on that one, but you never know.
- stiray 7y agoSony is selling them with little to no profit as they expect to earn on games. Guess why their capabale and cheap hardware is locked down to avoid using it for anything except playing bought games ;) Anyway you can jailbreak ps4 to 5.0.5 firmware and there are unpublished exploits in existence that are waiting for ps5 to be released.
- battery_cowboy 7y agoLooks like I found that "home server" to replace my over-use of cloud resources that I've been looking for!
- fergie 7y ago> Self-driving cars. Now that the hype is over and the fake-it-til-you-make-it crowd has tanked, there's progress. Slowly, the LIDARs get cheaper, the radars get more resolution, and the software improves. Still don't see fully (fully automated) self driving cars happening any time soon: 1) Heavy steel boxes running at high speed in built up areas will be the very last thing that we trust to robots. There are so many other things that will be automated first. Its reasonable to assume that we will see fully automated trains before fully automated cars. 2) Although a lot is being made of the incremental improvements to self-driving software, there is a lot of research about the danger of part-time autopilot. Autopilot in aircraft generally works well until it encounters an emergency, in which case a pilot has to go from daydreaming/eating/doing-something-else to dealing with catastrophy in a matter of microseconds. Full automation or no automation is often safer. 3) The unresolved/unresolvable issue of liability in an accident: is it the owner or the AI who is at fault. 4) The various "easy" problems that remain somewhat hard for driving AI to solve in a consistent way. Large stationary objects on motorways, small kids running into the road, cyclists, etc. 5) The legislative issues: at some point legislators have to say "self driving cars are now allowed", and create good governance around this. The general non-car-buying public has to get on board. These are non-trivial issues.
- mrweasel 7y agoThe hype around self driving cars is still very much around. I tend to view any debate about full autonomous cars (level 5) as unserious if they work with less than a 15 - 20 year time horizon.
- roenxi 7y agoIn 2014 top humans could give a good Go playing AI 4 stones (a handicap that pushes games outside of being between comparable players). In 2017 AlphaGo could probably give a world champion somewhere between 1 and 3 stones. From an algorithmic perspective the range between "unacceptably bad" and superhuman doesn't have to be all that wide and it isn't exactly possible to judge until the benefit of hindsight is available and it is clear who had what technology available. 15-20 years is realistic because of the embarrassingly slow rate of progress by regulators, but we should all feel bad about that. We should be swapping blobs of meat designed for a world of <10kmph for systems that are actually designed to move quickly safely. I've lost more friends to car accidents than any other cause - there needs to be some acknowledgment that humans are statistically unsafe drivers.
- beyondcompute 7y ago“Fake it till you make it” is precisely how it will be solved
- abhinai 7y ago“Fake it till you make it” strategy works when you know how to make something but haven't made it yet. The strategy falls apart when people try to fake having solved hard open research problems.
- FridgeSeal 7y ago> Somebody will probably make supercomputers out of rooms full of those. So I learnt very recently that the PS5 has a cool approach where all memory is shared directly between the CPU and the GPU (if this is wrong someone please correct me). I would be really interesting to see how well the GPU in this could handle DL specific workloads, and if necessary, could it be tweaked to do so? Because if so, that could be an absolute weapon or a DL workstation. If it does turn out to be feasible, I think it could be very easily justifiable to buy a few of those (for less than it would cost you to buy a major cloud provider GPU equipped instance for a couple of months) and have a pretty capable cluster. Machines get outdated or cloud provider cost comes down? Take them home and use them as actual gaming consoles. Win win.
- CraftThatBlock 7y agoThis is how APUs (which is what the PS4/PS5/Xbox) use memory, the RAM is shared between the graphics and compute units. This can be an advantage since memory is quickly shared between the two (for example loading textures, etc). This is also useful in computers since adding more RAM also adds more VRAM
- masklinn 7y ago> The Playstation 5. 8 CPUs at 3.2GHz each, 24GB of RAM, 14 teraflops of GPU, and a big solid state disk. That's a lot of compute engine for $400. Somebody will probably make supercomputers out of rooms full of those. That seems like a straight waste of time for lightly customised hardware you'll be able to get off the shelf. And unless they've changed since, the specs you quote don't match the official reveal of 16GB and 10 teraflop. Not to mention the price hasn't been announced, the $400 pricepoint is a complete guess (and pretty weird given the XbX is guessed for 50% more… for a very similar machine).
- GuB-42 7y ago> C++ getting serious about safety. Buffer overflows and bad pointers should have been eliminated decades ago. We've known how for a long time. The crowd that use C++ needs raw pointers sometimes, and you can't really prevent bad pointers and buffer overflows when they are used. There is a reason why Rust, which goal is to be a safer C/C++, supports unsafe code. Smart pointers is a very good thing to have in the C++ toolbox, but they are not for every programmer. Game programmers, if I am not mistaken, tend to avoid them, as well as other features that make things happen between the lines, like RAII and exceptions. The good thing about that messiness that is modern C++ is that everything is here, but you can pick what you want. If you write C++ code that looks like C, it will run like C, but if you don't want to see a single pointer, you have that option too.
- trebligdivad 7y agoSelf driving cars: Yes, but only if they really work - now is the perfect time to sell them if they did; for those of us who normally use public transport but don't currently like the thought of sitting in a petri dish for 2 hours. Utility scale battery storage: Yes but it needs tech improvements to store LOTS of energy; the flow batteries might do it if the hype is true - but currently the UK wholesale electricity price is £-28/MWh due to a wind/solar glut and a quiet weekend, so if anyone wants to get paid to store that energy the opportunity is there. As for C++ safety; I find modern C++ hard to read - are they going to be able to do safety but end up with something that's actually harder to use/read than Rust?
- kabacha 7y agoCan't help but laugh whenever I read about self driving cars predictions like this sorry. My GPS can hardly navigate most of the world I'm not really excited and if the only criteria of self driving car is self driving on a high way then color me uninterested. I don't think self driving cars will be able to traverse majority of the world's traffic anytime soon. The road is just too difficult to maintain for human free driving with the exception of few major block cities on America which makes the whole ordeal pretty boring.
- virgilp 7y agoSelf driving cars don’t need to be 100% autonomous in all possible scenarios in order to be useful. Self-driving reliably on the highway? Hell yes I’d take that (just think of trucks - having a driver to the highway is so much cheaper than having someone drive it cross-country). Self driving reliably in a few major cities? Oh, you mean cheap robotic taxi?
- kabacha 7y agoI agree with you it's just as I said - it's not what we've been sold and autopilot on highway is kinda boring.
- frellus 7y agoSpot on. This is our approach at Ghost Locomotion - L3 is pretty darn good, and highways are actually pretty standards driven, unlike local roads or cities. https://medium.com/ghost-blog/the-long-ignored-most-obvious-path-to-autonomy-2b4412626a6d https://medium.com/ghost-blog/the-long-ignored-most-obvious-... https://medium.com/ghost-blog/the-future-of-transportation-is-the-car-8eac64b6cee https://medium.com/ghost-blog/the-future-of-transportation-i...
- reanimated 7y agoI think its incorrect way to view it like its either full self driving or none at all. We are getting incremental benefits from this already: cars are correcting and preventing driver errors. They make instant trajectory corrections or complete stop and prevents a huge crashes. With time they will be better and better at recognising traffic lights, road signs, sudden unforeseen situations and so on and that way driving safety will improve exponentially even before self driving capabilities.
- tangjurine 7y ago> 8 CPUs at 3.2GHz each 8 CPU cores at 3.2GHz each?
- woah 7y agoWhy do they need lidar in the first place? Humans do fine with stereoscopic vision
- Havoc 7y agoNice post. I think the PS5 read might be a little off though. The pro edition is likely to be 600ish USD and come in a little lower than 14 of the tflops.