32 ms·
Google is now applying its coronavirus misinformation policies to personal files
- LeoPanthera 7y agoThis headline is very misleading. They didn't delete the file from the user's Google Drive - they disabled public sharing for the file.
- ycombonator 7y agoTo quote a popular politician “what difference does it make ?”
- LeoPanthera 7y agoAn enormous difference. When you share a file publicly, it's Google doing the sharing. When a file is privately stored and accessible only to you, Google doesn't have to know or care what's inside it.
- drummer 7y agoIt is still censorship.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dang 7y agoOk, we've swapped out the article title for its subtitle.
- muststopmyths 7y agowhat does "take down" mean ? did they turn off public sharing or delete the file ? Why anyone would trust a corporation with their only copy of anything is mystifying to me anyway.
- grawprog 7y agoIt's somewhat unclear, though further down it says this >Google blocked access to the document. It's still somewhat unclear to me though.
- tssva 7y agoSince they didn't say delete I'm guessing they stopped the public sharing but that isn't as rage inducing so the article stuck to using "take down" hoping people would interpret it as delete.
- arkitaip 7y agoThis is gross and unethical but we should let them continue digging their own grave.
- nafix 7y agoI don't think they are digging their own grave unfortunately. The majority of people seem to be Ok with this, and the majority will continue to use these platforms. I still use these platforms even though I hate what they are doing. We really do need some alternatives...
- adrianN 7y agoThere are alternatives, but they don't have a free tier.
- blisterpeanuts 7y agoRegarding the sharing of controversial video content, isn't Bitchute pretty much a free alternative?
- anewdirection 7y agoHow much further do we let them dig? What line do we point to that they don't erode like the rest?
- deepl_derber 7y agoWhat about them restricting the visibility of a video in response to a violation of their policies is 'unethical' and 'gross'? They also don't allow sharing porn, or for people to use the service as a CDN, is that 'unethical'?
- fredsanford 7y agoIt's 1984 in 2020 all over again. Paging Mr. Orwell...
- thephyber 7y agoYour take is an overreaction. All of the big file hosting platforms have long had copyright and child porn content filters. The fact that they are policing ToS violations (presumably only after they are reported or scripting re-violations) doesn't seem anywhere near 1984-style censorship. I do fear that this will give the tin foil hats more conviction that "there's something to it since they are hiding it!" and not more motivation to be skeptical of this particular thread of inquiry about the pandemic.
- pnako 7y ago"Oh, it's just a ToS violation" Let's make promoting LGBT values (for argument's sake) a ToS violation and see if it's still just a "ToS violation".
- fredsanford 7y agoOK... How would I find out from Google why they deleted original content written by me and stored in my account? How do I effectively appeal the action?
- 013a 7y agoThis is crossing a very bad line, and is absolutely unacceptable. My company of about 50 people on G-Suite will be canceling our subscription and moving to Office 365 within the next three months. We had discussed it in the past due to their history of flagrant disregard for the security and privacy standards we require, but this has galvanized the conversation and we're prioritizing it on the near-term now. I'm sure we'll eventually discover that Microsoft has similar policies, and that there isn't any good option when it comes to putting sensitive data on another company's servers. Maybe we'll eventually need to self-host more system capabilities. But, we'll cross that bridge when we get to it.
- bebna 7y agoDepending on the functionality you want, perhaps a synology (commercial solution) or nextcloud or even a samba box will be a better solution for privacy than Microsoft.
- drummer 7y agoThe future is all about self hosting and/or peer to peer technology not controlled by a central authority.
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoNetwork topological discovery is the hard pill to swallow with p2p based tech. You're paying for it in much higher network bandwidth, cpu, battery, and more. Eventually the tradeoffs will be so minuscule that they will be a rounding error. But right now, that's not true.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoPirate Bay is all magnet links now. Internet Archive serves most items as torrents while acting as a store of last resort. SciHub and LibGen are functional and available. There are tradeoffs, but it will happen, even if it's TXT records for a domain that point to IPFS links (namecoin aside). The future will make it easier, but it works today.
- cgb223 7y agoFurther proof that when you upload a file to Google Drive, you don’t own that file, they do
- thephyber 7y agoYou use the platform, you abide by the contract. My only concern is that contract violations (or even gray area violations) are not always predictable by the customer because the legalese in the ToS is so vague. You are overloading the term "own" and your use of "that file" is ambiguous. You "own" (in many senses) the local copy of the uploaded file. You only lease the space and hosting for the remote copy, assuming you pay your bill and abide by the contract. My coworker overflowed his Google Drive quota and learned that lesson the hard way.
- deepl_derber 7y ago> My coworker overflowed his Google Drive quota and learned that lesson the hard way. This sounds a lot more sinister than "my coworker had to delete some files to go back under his quota".
- thephyber 6y agoHe lost many MBs of files. He had a local filesystem directory synced with GDrive. He moved (didn't copy) lots of files into the directory and ended up losing all copies of some of the files (we still aren't sure how it picks which subset to keep). It was basically a few weeks of work because he didn't understand the implications of the change (and because he didn't have drive backups).
- jimmaswell 7y agoWouldn't be surprised if this results in a Streissand effect.
- harrylepotter 7y agototally agree. This is like fuel for an alt-right fire.
- nafix 7y agoI did not expect to see platform censorship accelerate at this rate. It always seems to be government and media dictating the terms of the censorship as well, which should be very concerning.
- csharptwdec19 7y ago> It always seems to be government and media dictating the terms of the censorship as well, which should be very concerning. I'm not incredibly shocked. This is on some levels history repeating itself. Media has historically been 'self-regulating', if only because they want to avoid having regulations imposed on them. However, this also has the not-unintentional side effect of those self regulating bodies also acting as gatekeepers. Another parallel to draw: When the Hays code was challenged due to 1FA, the MPAA created the 'rating' system, in which movies have their content rated on by an unknown group of people impose their moral code, and remember before the age of the internet, you -had- to hit certain ratings to have any hope of a decent number of people seeing your movie. Any Adults-only rating would result in the overwhelming majority of theaters refusing to show the film. Sure, you could still release it somewhere else. Sound familiar?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chockablocker 7y agoNote that the article doesn't say explicitly whether Google deleted the video from drive, or simply disabled the public sharing of the video. If they only disabled sharing (like they would for spam, pirated materials etc.) this may be understandable.
- darkerside 7y agoThis is a hugely important distinction. Can we please figure this out before we pick up the pitchforks?
- jfoster 7y agoThe headline ("Google Drive takes down user’s personal copy...") is suggestive of the file being entirely gone. There's a couple of paragraphs in the article that would seem to support this, but agree that it would be good to have it made very explicit.
- NeutronStar 7y agoAnd headlines are known to be facts now?
- deepl_derber 7y agoSince Drive doesn't generally delete users' files for policy violations maybe the safer assumption is to assume that it wasn't deleted unless there's evidence that strongly suggests otherwise.
- neuronexmachina 7y agoFrom the article, it seems like they stopped public sharing of the video via Google Drive: > In an article reporting on the takedown, The Washington Post’s Silicon Valley Correspondent Elizabeth Dwoskin complains that after the coronavirus documentary Plandemic was censored on social media, some YouTube clips were telling users how to access “banned footage” from the documentary via Google Drive. > She then notes that after The Washington Post contacted Google, Google Drive took down a file featuring the trailer for the Plandemic documentary.
- pnako 7y agoSo "journalists" are now colluding with platforms to censor information. Brave new world.
- AaronFriel 7y agoNot collusion, not "journalists". I imagine it went something like this: Journalist: Hey, can I get a comment on this video, "Plandemic", being distributed on Google Drive? Google employee: No comment. And then Google employee sends a message to another employee and says, "Hey, do we need to do something about this? It looks like that video we took down off YouTube for violating our ToS is being hosted elsewhere." Is it collusion every time a journalist asks someone to comment on a thing happening, and that someone then responds in some way beyond just saying "Yep that's a thing!"
- pnako 7y agoIt's like sending a picture of your neighbor's garden to the police, "asking for clarification" about what is permitted. You can do that, but at least call it what it is.
- retox 6y agoMany modern journalists are activists first.
- ycombonator 7y agoOkay this sealed the deal for me. They have gone full Commie.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- addicted44 7y agoIt's not entirely clear to me, but did Google delete the file from the user's personal, private drive, or did they delete public access to the file? Because the former is unacceptable, but the latter is not as big a deal at all.
- dvt 7y agoHow is (what is basically) a unilaterally executed "gag order" not a big deal?
- jrockway 7y agoDo any cloud providers provide free unlimited outbound transfer? Because that's what a public file on Google Drive is. Cutting off someone who is abusing your free tier isn't censorship.
- salawat 7y agoIt has not been proven Google does that for all 4GB files. Verboten content or not. Without that test, you really can't conclusively say whether it is QoS enforcement or politically motivated.
- innocenat 7y agoIt's common and consistent with what I have seen when Google Drive were used to shared copyrighted content.
- AaronFriel 7y agoGoogle does it with files much smaller than 4GB, and I've personally experienced recordings of lectures my student org produced being blocked after tens of views from non @university.edu accounts. Turns out, they don't want people using Google Drive as a video streaming service.
- virmundi 7y agoThe trouble is where do they draw the line. Say I share a pamphlet about how Jesus reclaims humanity from the corruption of sin. If Google thinks all Christians are superstitious bumpkins, does that give them the right to remove my public share?
- im3w1l 7y agoI've been very impressed with reclaimthenets stories recently, some big revelations.
- AwaAwa 7y agoLooks like they are flexing all the work done for Project Dragonfly. Waste not, want not.
- walterbell 7y agoGood point. There could be a new free-speech AI project for time-based "declassification" of previously censored material, to inform public study of censorship technologies.
- rhizome 7y agoNobody's stopping them from signing up for AWS and throwing the vid into an S3 bucket or whatever, nor are they prevented from buying internet access from a company that offers static IPs and serving the file from an old PC in someone's closet.
- mindslight 7y agoUntil AWS and that ISP apply the same policy...
- walesminutecopy 7y agoThis might be the relevant section in the Terms of Service: Public streaming Drive allows you to store, share, and stream video content, but should not be used as a replacement for a content distribution network. For large-scale public streaming, YouTube is a better fit. Drive will restrict usage when it appears that it's being used for large-scale public streaming. Repeated violations may result in additional action, including terminating your account or ability to use Drive. https://support.google.com/docs/answer/148505?visit_id=637257739027213395-534836487&rd=1 https://support.google.com/docs/answer/148505?visit_id=63725...
- berns 7y ago> Drive will restrict usage... > ... including terminating your account or ability to use Drive. I think that the controversial part is that the file was deleted. I'd find it surprising if some file from my Drive is just deleted instead of restricting public access or using another form of enforcing the policy.
- threatofrain 7y agoGoogle has no obligation to be anyone's mouthpiece or loudspeaker, and we have no information on whether any files were deleted.
- thoraway1010 7y agoThe idea that a file was deleted as a first step is pretty out there. There is NO evidence of that. The usual progression is to deny streaming, then warn and close account ultimately. Question is this a paid google storage / CDN account? That would be different. It sounds like this is bog standard gdrive.
- orestarod 6y agoNext step will be, "Verizon has no obligation to be anyone's loudspeaker". No one is obliged to be anything to anyone if you put it that way, but then there's this thing called discrimination that goes counter to that - it expects a VERY GOOD reason to deny service to someone. "I have no obligation to sell to blacks", for example, does not stand. "I have no obligation to hosts anyone's word when I don't agree with that they say" stands? Perhaps we should get a list of all the things we are allowed to say and stop communicating through the internet altogether, as the list will have every information we will ever need to access.
- yegle 7y agoSimilar news: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16668267 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16668267 What I learned from that post is that as soon as you start share your file, it's no longer a private file and stricter guideline/requirement applies. This is also indicated from the TOS: > Files in your individual drive are private, until you decide to share them.
- jeffbee 7y agoYes, it turns out the the web is not, in fact, a giant virtual seastead unbothered by the norms and rules of society. If you distribute information via computer networks it will be subject to scrutiny to see if it is malware, copyrighted by someone else, exploitative, seditious, etc.
- centimeter 7y agoIt's disingenuous to conflate Alphabet Corporation's political strategies with "the norms and rules of society".
- hootbootscoot 7y agoIt's disingenuous to conflate a private entities exercising their rights to "refuse a problematic client service" with infringement of the constitutionally protected free speech by a governmental entity.
- Thorentis 7y agoOh boy, another "private entities can do what they want" argument. What's the point in saying freedom of speech only applies in public places and protection from the government, and then turning around and handing over control of the biggest tool for sharing information (the Internet) to private companies? Sorry, but the "private companies can do what they want" argument is old and tired when it comes to censorship.
- 7y ago
- tinus_hn 7y agoIs it really personal files if it’s used as a file sharing service?
- elliekelly 7y agoIt definitely seems like the “share a Drive file” method was used to widely distribute a video that didn’t comply with Google/YouTube’s policies. And using Drive in that manner is, of course, also a violation of their policies.
- jrockway 7y agoI don't see any evidence that Google applied a misinformation policy here. It could be that they simply don't want to pay for the bandwidth to serve video without any ads in it. It is a big file and a lot of people want it. That can get super expensive. I don't know how big this file is, but let's say it's a 4GB DVD image. That ties up 1Gbps for 32 seconds, which means that with a 1Gbps link to your server, you can serve it to less than 3000 users a day. Even if you're getting budget residential ISP prices for your transfer, you're talking 1 cent per 10 copies of the video. At AWS prices, you're talking 36 cents for every copy of the video downloaded. This sort of thing is why you either peer with an ISP at 10Gbps or more, charge money for file hosting, or use a p2p file sharing application. Until I see some evidence that this is misinformation censorship (for example, Google removing a private file with a transcript of the video), I'm going to assume this is just limiting the impact on other users from a free user with a popular huge file. As HN always says, if you're not paying for something, you're not the customer.
- tibyat 7y agojust no. no to all of that. it's a trailer. it was taken down from youtube, facebook, twitter, tiktok, and now google drive. for misinformation. name an instance of google removing a google drive file for bandwidth cost.
- Eduard 7y agoOn the other hand, they could support freedom of speech by not limiting access. They do block access, therefore suppressing freedom of speech. Arguing with "they're just saving resources" is ridiculous, especially when considering Google's wealth.
- jrockway 7y agoYou have moved the goalposts dramatically. What started as "random files in Google Drive are being scanned for conspiracy theories and deleted", which would be incredibly worrying, is now "Google should give me tens of thousands of dollars worth of free stuff", which is not all that worrying.
- ThePowerOfFuet 7y agoThis seems apropos: https://shop.fsf.org/stickers/there-no-cloud-sticker-pack https://shop.fsf.org/stickers/there-no-cloud-sticker-pack
- Barrin92 7y agodoes anyone know who the people behind the reclaimthenet.org domain are? The headline seems intentionally misleading and the entire article is biased, as seems to be the case for most of the site, almost exlcusively focussing on censorship of fringe figures out of conspiracy and far-right political circles. There is no reference to organisations, writers or editors anywhere on this site if I'm not missing anything.
- tylermenezes 7y agoIt seems like they've gone to a lot of effort to make that hard to figure out. I looked into this for a while and was unable to find anything. A lot of the articles are also... misleading at best. I dunno, this site just feels pretty strongly like a misinformation campaign.
- rb808 7y agoYeah you know its this guy behind it https://theduran.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/putin-winking.jpg https://theduran.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/putin-winkin...
- shockinglytrue 7y agoThere are authors.. https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=site:reclaimthenet.org+inurl:author&filter=0 https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=site:reclaimthenet.org+inu... But none of them seem to have LinkedIn profiles, they're quite possibly pen names. The contact page lists a UK country code Signal number, so they're probably based there. Some of the names appear on other sites with the same nav structure. It is definitely a signal, but not an automatic indicator of something nefarious. There could be a whole host of good reasons why they're doing that. For example, the site could be launched as an experiment by a non-profit whose core work should not be associated with a risky message (this is my current favourite idea), or might piss off their funders. FWIW there is a ton of newswriting on the Internet occurring under pen names for one reason or other. A lot of writers in the middle east will not or cannot use their real names.
- panarky 7y agoIf it's hard to find out who is funding a campaign, it's a pretty good bet it's malicious disinfo.
- s1artibartfast 7y agoI understand that corporations are private entities and currently within their legal rights to remove content. This means, if they so choose, they could remove speech they oppose form youtube, google search, and emails. Why are most people comfortable with a reactionary approach to this problem, and waiting to see if they exercise this right in a disagreeable manner? Wouldn't it be better to develop a solution before the need arises and legislate a clear limit?
- njharman 7y agoCensoring is a losing battle. Because it attacks a symptom. The cure for ignorance is not trying to hide missinformation (that just empowers the spreaders, gives it credence (they wouldn't bother suppressing it if it weren't true), or drives it into dark places you can no longer detect how much of a problem it is). The cure is to educate people and teach them critical thinking (both of which are expensive and honestly most governments/companies/people in power don't really want a free thinking populace (they want a populace that believes their propaganda)) and to spread the truth (not that effective on populace who lacks high level of education and critical thinking skills)
- logicslave 7y agoMost people dont have the capacity for critical thought on every area of ambiguity/complexity. Its too wide a thought surface, and we have too few hours in a day. So we have things like dictionaries in our minds, filled with information via lots of sources from childhood, tv, peers, etc. Human brains arent logical, they are mostly look up systems.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mistermann 7y ago> Most people dont have the capacity for critical thought on every area of ambiguity/complexity. a) Is critical thinking on "every area of ambiguity/complexity" a true requirement, with respect to the article? b) How do you think you know what people are or not capable of, especially since we've made practically no effort whatsoever to teach these skills?
- godelski 7y ago> Most people don't have the capacity for critical thought on every area of ambiguity/complexity. I'd change that to "most people haven't been taught to think critically". It's clear that the average person has the mental capacity, genetic variations in intelligence aren't that large.
- 7y ago
- MattGaiser 7y agoGoogle Drive is not meant as a mass distribution service for video. Do they let you use it as a back door streaming service?
- etaioinshrdlu 7y agoDo the same rules apply to google cloud storage... or really any google cloud resource?
- izacus 7y agoLast I checked anything under GSuite has very different rules than consumer Gmail accounts.
- WillPostForFood 7y agoThe Washington Post contacted Google, Google Drive took down a file featuring the trailer for the Plandemic documentary. Why is the WaPo out there policing other people's content? That's as bad a Google taking it down.
- hootbootscoot 7y agoNeither are bad. A private company can refuse service to a problematic customer violating their TOS. Google is under no obligation to provide free services to liars who are intent upon stirring up trouble. Think of how many bars ban problematic ex-clientele. The WaPo is acting in the public interest, for once in their miserable life. These Plandemic fans are a public health menace, give them no quarter. Oh, as to the troublemakers: knock it off at once. this is serious.
- panarky 7y agoIt's not a personal file if you share it publicly. No private business should be forced to use their resources to promote dangerous bullshit.
- pbreit 7y agoI cannot believe the bizarro world we've entered. "the problems that social media companies face: the weaponization of their services to amplify dangerous content" Wut?
- heavenlyblue 7y agoIn a slightly parallel universe, it’s going to be quite hilarious if all of the decentralised technologies are going to end up being developed by the types of anti-vaxxers, holocaust deniers, neo-nazis because they were the only ones needing them (and not the illusory political dissidents). So in the end it’s going to have a positive impact. Here’s a supporting example: Snowden didn’t need any of this tech to share it with us. Paedophiles and drug dealers use Tor. I am not being entirely serious.
- pnako 7y agoIt's not that simple. In the west it's the "alt right" or similar that needs to bypass censorship. But in China, it's pro-democracy people. Even inside a country, it changes. Dissenters 50 years ago are not the same ones as today. The left protested globalization 20 years ago; today it's the right. My point is: we should let all ideas out there and not fight to censor the other side. Fight ideas with arguments and evidence, not censorship.
- hkt 7y agoIt seems to me that if Google (and the other platforms) don't tackle this kind of thing, the state _somewhere_ will. It only takes one country to make distribution of this stuff illegal or close to it, and that will amount to an edge of self regulation for the tech giants. They don't want that, so they do something to prevent it.
- a3n 7y agoThen they aren't really your personal files, are they?
- CapriciousCptl 7y agoThe file was widely shared on Google Drive and linked to from a public twitter message— it was very much not a personal file. And the title literally was, “An Effective Treatment for Coronavirus” referring to hydroxychloroquine. Google’s doing its part to purge pandemic misinformation and prevent harm. The authoring “doctor,” as far as I can tell has never had postgraduate medical training and cannot practice medicine without supervision, is trying to achieve writing a document with a title like that I don’t know.
- thu2111 7y agoThe goalpost moving by people here on HN is quite entertaining to watch. Hydroxychloroquine was just bought in bulk by the UK in case it turns out to be a cure. Apparently the only people who are allowed to have opinions these days are academics employed by governments?
- CapriciousCptl 7y agoTo be clear, the UK is undergoing a clinical trial with hydroxychloroquine. Hopefully it works, but as of now it's not known if the harms outweigh the benefits.
- thu2111 7y agoThere are trials yes. And, to be clear, they're also bulk buying it: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/may/19/uk-to-test-hydroxychloroqine-as-coronavirus-treatment https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/may/19/uk-to-test-hyd... I have no idea if this medicine will have any impact but at this point, I've seen so many people claim it's some sort of quack medicine/conspiracy/etc that it's important people realise that it's being taken seriously. As far as I can tell the moment Trump mentioned it a huge number of people decided it must, inherently, be wrong and have been wrongly attacking it ever since.
- knorker 7y agoWow, so you're saying a free of charge Google Drive way to share files isn't without restrictions? I'm shocked! I really thought this misinformation video people found a loophole to not have to pay for what bandwidth actually costs. I really thought that Google had offered a free CDN for everyone, limitless, when they (and Amazon, and Microsoft, and Akamai) charge huge amounts for this as a cloud service. Yeah, that was sarcasm. Bandwidth costs actual money. What's next? They think they can build a Youtube competitor by storing and streaming all the videos from a collection of free Google Drive accounts? Or even a business Google Drive plan? Read the ToS, or better yet use common sense.
- smichel17 7y ago> I really thought this misinformation video people found a loophole to not have to pay for what bandwidth actually costs. I really thought that Google had offered a free CDN for everyone, limitless, when they (and Amazon, and Microsoft, and Akamai) charge huge amounts for this as a cloud service. > Yeah, that was sarcasm. Maybe so, but I came across a streaming site (of questionable legality) that did exactly this. Loaded an iframe with what looked like a random domain (always two first names, like "PedroMaria.xyz"). Then the iframe made a bunch of XHRs to load chunks of movie data from Google Drive. It was really quite fascinating. Aside, this is one of my favorite things about using uMatrix with aggressive defaults -- as you unbreak sites, you learn a lot about what services are commonly used to build websites.
- knorker 7y agoYeah, I'm not surprised. Having worked for multiple service and content providers I would assume that abuse like this happens. One notable case was when a deal to license a database fell through when the would-be client said "I've found a different free way to solve this". Turns out that "different way" was to scrape our website in real time and present it to their clients as their own, without attribution or payment. Abuse happens. Shoplifting happens. That doesn't mean that the shoplifter "found a loophole", nor that it's morally or legally right. And it's not unfair if the selective enforcement is based on "bandwidth actually used" or "in addition to violating our policies you're also hurting the world" (or even "we just plain don't like you"). I.e. in the case above about scraping our data, we just dropped it. They weren't going to be our customer, clearly, and suing (they were in a different country too) or technically blocking them would not be worth the cost. And they didn't consume that many resources at our scale, so whatever. But if that site had been a porn site or something then the cost of doing nothing would include potential PR issues of being associated with them[1]. So in short: This (CDN from article, and using google drive like this) is abuse. A proof of concept likely won't get shut down, but it's not something that'll work in the long run. [1] I'm not against porn as such, but let's say our database was one of children's toys. That kind of company would understandably be hurt by apparently making deals with porn sites to show up there.
- bitL 7y agoOh wow, this is bad! Google went from my favorite geeky company in the 00s to something I would like to avoid now as much as I can. I guess next on their list will be refusing to host any encrypted content on their GDrive just in case it contains something the head honchos at 10E100 don't like... From a disruptor for the better, ending up as an enforcer of the conformity. I guess that's the fate of every winner.
- hootbootscoot 7y agoGood. A private entity (corp) exercises it's right to free speech. Google is under no obligation to provide services for anyone it deems troublesome. Would you question a bartender or bar staff for refusing entry to a problematic client?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- onyva 7y agoAnti-Google article -> Brave ad -> Eye roll.