8 ms·
Facebook employees may face pay cut if they move to cheaper areas to remote work
- m3kw9 7y agoWhat if that actually ends you up with more?
- gnu8 7y agoIf the employee comes out ahead then they might be fooled into thinking that Facebook is not picking their pocket.
- oliveshell 7y agoThen maybe the pay increase will help ameliorate what I can only imagine is the subtle pain in one’s soul caused by working for Facebook in 2020.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Fej 7y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23261394 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23261394
- dan_can_code 7y agoI suppose this is a good and a bad thing. It's good in a sense that if remote companies wish to attract better talent, they just have to out-pay Facebook. It would be bad if all tech companies decided to pay everyone less however, following Facebooks lead. It will be interesting to see how this plays out.
- klodolph 7y agoEvery company that I’ve worked for which has offices in the SF Bay area and offices somewhere else has had a location-based adjustment to pay. Every single one. Honestly, if I exercise my imagination a little bit and try to remember what it was like to live in a city which didn’t have jobs from most of the “big tech” companies, I would have loved to see a greater variety of job opportunities without being asked to move to SF/Seattle/NYC etc. It would have meant that I could get career growth and keep my friends and support network.
- demarq 7y agoBut Also every company has a clause that prevents your pay being cut no?
- klodolph 7y agoNo. If you relocated out of the SF bay area you would lose the adjustment. This has been true as long as I can remember. I remember seeing old email threads with people complaining about it.
- michaelcampbell 7y agoNo. In fact, not a single company I've worked for has such a clause.
- demarq 7y agoI've had that in quite a few companies. Their only recourse is to fire you if you unperformed, but reducing your pay is not allowed in the contract. This makes sense to me because I agree to do the job fox x dollars, you shouldn't be able to turn around and make me do the same job for less without my agreement and a new contract.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI think that's a very uncommon structure, but regardless it's a voluntary pay cut in this case. Facebook isn't saying anyone has to move, and they won't get their pay cut if they don't.
- selectodude 7y agoI think you're coming from a place where you're receiving contracts for employment. My employer's contract is "fuck you, show up to work and we can fire you and change the game whenever we please, also, fuck you.". I think that's the employment status for most people, at least here in the United States.
- ckdarby 7y agoDoes anyone have a good explanation why companies do this? Wouldn't it be more beneficial to continue the same paying structure because of the retention? My gut feel would be that if Facebook continued paying same rate even though people weren't in the bay area anymore that nobody would ever be able to compete and therefore the retention would be much longer.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ciarannolan 7y ago> Does anyone have a good explanation why companies do this? 1. To make more money 2. Because they can
- ghaff 7y agoAt some point, having everyone in golden handcuffs isn't necessarily a wholly positive thing. If you're working for Facebook in a low-cost area at a (high-end) SV salary, you've got a huge incentive to just tough it out even if you hate your job. Companies adjust pay scales because they mostly can and I doubt there are a material number of large distributed companies that don't do so. If they pay competitive Bay Area salaries everywhere, then they're paying more than they need to in order to hire people elsewhere.
- tosers4 7y agoThis. Tbh even recently we have had something similiar in our city about a companie moving there and the pay was ridiculously above the median, golden handcuffs was of of the topics of the discussion, specially by colleagues that were part of a consulting company already working for them before them moved in. It's not a nice feeling knowing that if you leave a job, there is no way you can get the same payment. One of the nice things about being a programmer is that I can leave my job whenever I need, as employment is abundant, but if there is no comparable paycheck, then that perk goes away. And that is a very nice perk that lots of people here take for granted.
- edu 7y ago
- jhamilton 7y agoThis is disgusting. The value a worker provides the company does not magically go down just because their expenses go down. If I am providing the same value that another worker is, we should be compensated similarly regardless of where we choose to live. Anything less is theft
- CyberFonic 7y agoYet another example of how clueless managements are. They are incapable of actually assessing value of the actual work performed. So they use proxy metrics like LoC, hours worked, in-person presence in the office. If you want to paid very well, then churn out thousands of lines of rubbish code, be in the office for 70+ hours, attend their meetings, pay rapt attention to their PowerPoints and laugh at their jokes. Bingo!
- blueskymr 7y agoThis sounds facetious. To help yoy grok why what FB is doing makes sense, view this from the reverse situation: Let’s say you live in a low cost area (e.g. AK) and then move to the Bay Area, working for the same company. In that case, with your COL doubling, would you expect a pay raise? Of course you would! Because your net pay would reduce significantly otherwise. So, the reverse should true too.
- bbrree66 7y agoYour pay is a function of supply and demand here, not value provided. Working for a company is an opt-in choice, so it's not theft. If you want a better agreement go work somewhere else. And when enough people do that, pay will go up to compete for those people. But if a company can get away with paying less, they will. And arguably, they have a fiduciary responsibility to do so.
- cactus2093 7y agoDo you know of a single company that doesn’t do this? Even HN darlings famous for being remote-first like Gitlab adjust salary to cost of living.
- pedrosorio 7y agoWhat if you want to work remotely from a nonfixed location?
- derision 7y agoYou still need a fixed mailing address for many things, so I assume they'd use that
- jedimastert 7y agoDo to a lot of things (citizenship, licenses, taxes, etc) you aren't legally allowed to be employed without a address on a form somewhere
- ghaff 7y agoFurthermore, most companies still exercise some control over remote work whether formally or otherwise. That someone can work remotely mostly from a fixed address in the same country, doesn't mean they automatically have the right to work from a beach in Thailand or as a digital nomad.
- themistokl1k 7y agoi mean that was wildly expected, right?
- CyberFonic 7y agoThey should be paying you more, because they are saving on office space rental when you work remotely. So they are not only saving on salaries, but on rents as well. Cheeky bastards.
- bbrree66 7y ago"should". Why? Their job is to be as profitable as possible.
- jedimastert 7y agoWhat responsibility does a company have to pass profits onto it's employees? If you a share of the profits, buy some shares.
- thinkingemote 7y agoIt's verging into the same old "this is not censorship it's a private company" argument. What right has any human against a private company? Why even comment in this thread? Sarcasm btw.
- jondubois 7y agoThis is in itself is an admission that capitalism doesn't work and that Facebook is a monopoly. If the environment was truly competitive, then companies would not be able to conflate the value of employees' skills with their location. It sounds like Facebook has the power to fully dictate the wages of their employees.
- edu 7y agoIMO it's not that much just Facebook, but the _market_ and now the market is suddenly bigger (all the good talent that didn't want to move to SF).
- bbrree66 7y ago...... what? This is an example that capitalism does work. If someone wants to live in Random City A then Facebook will still have to compete with the local wages there to get people to work for them. The labor market is supply and demand driven. And of course Facebook decides the wages of their employees, how else would it work? The employment agreement is two sided, if people don't like the offer they can go work somewhere else. Massive caveat: Facebook is an absolutely garbage company and the world would be better off if they didn't exist. But paying less based on location is reasonable.
- chosenbreed37 7y ago> Massive caveat: Facebook is an absolutely garbage company and the world would be better off if they didn't exist. But paying less based on location is reasonable. Mmm...would garbage companies also include any of these Tik-tok, instagram, snapchat? Would you care to point out some non-garbage companies as well? I'm not against your perspective. I've encountered a few times already just on this thread. I'm just curious to see what is considered a good company. Amazon, Tesla, AirBnb, Netflix, Google, Microsoft, Salesforce, SAP? Or maybe there are no good guys.
- bbrree66 7y agoIt's a good question. By garbage here I mean their entire existence is based on wasting people's time and then making money by showing Ads. Their entire incentive structure is to get people as addicted as possible. They are not trying to add value to the world. Also, most people aren't aware of the trade-off they are making (data being sold), or how they are being manipulated, which makes it doubly terrible. Or that there are armies of behavior psychologists trying to get them to spend as much time as possible on the site. "Good" is a sliding scale here, we each have our own subjective definition. I try to define it as "Is the world a better place because this company exists?" I personally would answer Yes for the companies you listed.
- BooneJS 7y agoI transferred out of the Bay Area a year ago, and my FAANG salary was cut 15%. For them, salaries are based on “Cost of Labor”, or the cost of getting a person to join in that area, not “Cost of Living”. I’m still doing just fine.
- random32840 7y agoCan anyone explain why companies do this, but still hire from the expensive areas? If they pay less for the same level of skill in Texas, why don't they stop hiring in SF full stop and only hire in Texas? Is it just a bluff and they'll cave if you challenge them?
- jedimastert 7y agoBecause they don't pay people based on how much they're worth. They pay based on how much you'd say yes to.
- random32840 7y agoRight - but you have the same value either way, you just have to apply leverage, right? The gig's up if you don't have to say yes to the lowball offer. What force prevents you just pitting two+ SF companies against each other in a bidding war?
- ghaff 7y agoOne argument is that, especially for large companies like Facebook, if you exclude the tech hubs, it's hard to hire enough people with the skills they need. I think it's also the case that there are probably quite a few employers who don't necessarily try very hard to outbid the big companies in places like SV.
- edu 7y agoOne important point is that this is people that _willingly_. move from Bay Area to cheaper areas, not expatriates.
- yalogin 7y agoI am surprised to see comments on HN accusing the company of theft and greed for doing this. Isn’t the cost of living in an area the biggest factor in the salary? If so moving to another area will automatically reduce the salary. I don’t think they are being unfair or greedy. You don’t want the salary structure to in a remote area to be the same as the Bay Area. That will be unfair to the rest of the companies that want to hire in that city.
- tom-thistime 7y agoComplete speculation, but we may be looking at comments from people who genuinely don't understand (or believe) that you can buy a typical Silicon Valley style house (1200 sq ft on zero acres) in most of the country for 150k to 250k. The standard of living on the same money is completely different.
- generalpass 7y ago> I am surprised to see comments on HN accusing the company of theft and greed for doing this. Isn’t the cost of living in an area the biggest factor in the salary? If so moving to another area will automatically reduce the salary. I don’t think they are being unfair or greedy. You don’t want the salary structure to in a remote area to be the same as the Bay Area. That will be unfair to the rest of the companies that want to hire in that city. If this were the case, it would not be that so many companies have moved out of the Bay Area. I know of a small manufacturer that moved their entire operation 3000 miles away with 7 years left on their lease. That was a few years ago and the building is still empty. The businesses that remain are ones where the salaries align with the living expenses, not the other way around. I suspect this trend of lowering pay based on location will work while there are limited employers hiring remotely. If there is broad embracing, then salaries will likely rise to reduce attrition.
- actuator 7y agoCost of living is not the factor here, cost of labor is as others have mentioned. If not, for example London tech salaries would have been comparable to NYC/SF/SEA if you compare cost of living.
- carterklein13 7y agoI feel that I'm in the minority here, but this appears to be a somewhat understandable move. To be able to live in the location you most desire is, frankly, still a luxury for the time being and while I hope that's not the status quo forever it's definitely the case now. And, to attempt to refute the points made that the worker a value adds to a company doesn't depend on location, I completely agree with the basic premise - but I feel that salary should be adjusted so that all employees can share a similar quality-of-life across the board wherever they're geographically based. Maybe I am a little bit biased because I'm currently on the other side of this coin. I work at a company based in the US South, and managed to get into their more cutting-edge and innovative NYC office. Plus, I'm from NYC and love the city, it's my ideal location to live and work. Yet, while their NYC office is "cost-of-living adjusted" for salary, I am certainly worse off than the employees based out of the HQ. The difference in pay to provide the same quality-of-life between a huge global city and a mid-sized regional city can be staggering. And obviously, I know I could live way out in an outer borough or in Long Island / Westchester / NJ and have the same overall costs associated with someone in the HQ, but then I'm 60+ minutes from the office and my ideal life/work location anyway.
- ghaff 7y agoThe Bay Area salaries paid by the big tech employers are not really representative of the "CoL allowances" historically paid for working in places like Manhattan and SV. With some exceptions, like successful Wall Street traders, Big Law, etc., additional comp earned in those places was still not usually enough to make up for higher living costs. Today that's probably not the case at at least a handful of big companies.
- carterklein13 7y agoI'm a bit confused by your wording of your first sentence, honestly. Also, what's probably not the case? I feel that working at a big tech firm is akin to working in IB/consulting/law at this point in terms of pay/bonus (bonus at big tech being the RSUs as opposed to cash, but a "bonus" nonetheless). I'd just like to best understand your point, as this is going to be an interesting topic we're going to see more and more in the coming months/years I think.
- marcoperaza 7y agoI'm amused at all the highly-paid software engineers in this thread who legitimately feel entitled to their Silicon Valley pay-scale. The only reason you make more than the fellow laying your tile is because of supply and demand, not because you deserve it. If anything, he certainly works harder and longer and risks more health consequences than you. If Facebook is offering less than the market price for that labor, then employees will go elsewhere. Otherwise, they're paying the "right" amount for workers in that market. There's no moral dimension to this question.
- IdoRA 7y agoGS wages are adjusted to MSA, so why shouldn’t Facebook do the same?
- tom-thistime 7y agoFolks, with utmost respect: The only reason you're making 300k is that your physical butt is in Silicon Valley.
- jedimastert 7y agoA lot of people are asking "why would they pay less" and that seems like a silly question to me. They'd pay less because of course they would. Less money spent is less money spent. The real question is "why would they pay more?" It's not charity. I'm sure the company would be much happier to pay a livable wage in rural Kentucky. But for a livable in rural Kentucky wouldn't pay for rent and food at the same time in SF or NYC, and up until somewhat recently you needed all of your workers to live in the same place, which meant a high population density, and proximity to where everyone else is, because all of the talent was migrating to the same place.
- ReticentVole 7y agoWhat's to stop you nominating a family member's address as your household address and just physically living in another area?
- DanBC 7y agoIt's fraud.
- demarq 7y agohonestly I've never seen so many people rush to defend a corporations right to pay them less.
- gridlockd 7y agoThat's a very one-sided view. What about the worker's right to get a competitive edge by charging less for their labor? Why the hell should most of the jobs go to people who are in Silicon Valley? Why should people have to pay extortionate prices to live there?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tfmattder 7y agoI do the same thing: I value a 100% effort let's say at 250k, if I get paid 100k I give my ~40%. So far it has worked well. I get paid similar to my peers, and doing the same amount of work takes around ~40% of my day, although it's really variable. I tried to work harder, but it's not worth it. I got small pay rises, but far bellow my effort. It was also psychologically harder as people would try to stop me one way or the other. With this dynamic, I can have peaceful work days now: I learn new technologies or spend time in the games room (with my family now), and almost never need to stay longer. In contrast, I see my peers working at home at 10-11pm or even on weekends to finish off things for the sprint. I even realized giving more difficult solutions makes my work life much easier, because people can't keep up :) (I have tests I don't commit and other automation projects that make my work much simpler). It's ok when companies say this, but I have to hide my situation as I probably would get fired (or given more work) if people get to know what I do.
- gexla 7y agoRIP high tech salaries. If you were teetering on a decision between working in a FAANG company or starting your own business, then this adds some weight for the "own business" side. I get that high salaries are partly a result of war for talent. This demand will continue to prop up salaries to a certain level. But how much does location play into scarcity? Line up all the people around the world who could work for a FAANG company. Eliminate everyone who can't get a visa to work in the US. Add back all the people living in the US who could work for a FAANG company. Eliminate everyone can can't or won't live in one of the most expensive cities in the world (maybe not a concern for foreign workers at this point because they have already accepted and received the visa, but it will cut out a lot of US citizens.) Eliminate everyone (mostly US) who already has a job and isn't bothering to look for another. Add moving into a city with not enough housing as friction. Add available office space as friction. Am I missing anything? How many more people do we now have that can compete for jobs at these companies? 2X? 10X? If FAANG companies are now hiring from anywhere in the world, why wouldn't China create a state backed initiative to run Olympic level intensive programs specifically targeted at filling seats at these FAANG companies? It would be a national program for creating high paying jobs and it would provide a sense of national pride of having the greatest talent for the industry. Why wouldn't these countries become as competitive with providing workers for the tech industry as they have become with manufacturing? Aside from having a greater pool of available workers to pull from, this is a major reset event. The other side of this reset could look very different than it did a few months ago. WFH is just the first big change.
- purplezooey 7y agoWould be nice if Menlo Park would rise to the challenge and actually allow some housing to be b built.
- austurist 7y agoIt is understandable. And it is also easy to define what a "fair" cut is: if there is no incentive to migrate between the regions of different salary levels.