7 ms·
> UBI should cover government-regulated and government-provided essentials to living. The reason you don't do this is that the government is not better at maki
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> UBI should cover government-regulated and government-provided essentials to living.
The reason you don't do this is that the government is not better at making diapers and laundry detergent than Procter & Gamble nor better at manufacturing Tylenol than Johnson & Johnson nor better at growing tomatoes than local farmers.
If you give people $300 then they can buy $300 worth of food. if you give people $300 worth of "government food" then they'll have $150 worth of actual food because half of the money will go to the agriculture companies with the best lobbyists, and the same lobbyists will get to choose what kind of food it is. Government cheese is not an ideal. Meanwhile if you have $300 then if you want to you can grow your own tomatoes in your back yard, eat those, and use some of the money for something else entirely.
Also, special fail for these:
> * Universal healthcare: free (and free condoms)
> * Free education (from abc to PHD)
Suppose the government could provide healthcare for $10,000/year. Okay, let them do that while giving everyone $10,000/year to buy it with. But don't force them to.
Suppose a private health insurance company could provide coverage for $5000/year with a $10,000 deductible, instead of $10,000/year with no deductible. You're taking more risk, but not that much more (best case you gain $5000/year, worst case you lose $5000/year). And overall you would expect it to be a gain because you're paying the first $10,000 out of pocket, which makes you price sensitive, which causes you to not waste money on unnecessary care, which lowers average costs.
It's the same thing for education. Give parents money and let them choose a school. Solves the entire mess with school quality being tied to home prices. Doesn't screw over parents who home school, because they still get the money. And if the government can provide the best schools for the best price, parents will choose them anyway. But if not, they shouldn't be forced to.
- perseusprime11 7y agoThis feels like BS. Sorry! K12 is free. There should be no problem expanding to college and beyond. Also, see no reason to not have a good universal healthcare that is detached from your employer. These are smart ideas worth pursuing.
- chii 7y ago> provide coverage for $5000/year with a $10,000 deductible, instead of $10,000/year with no deductible. that's the wrong way to think about it. The above makes an implicit assumption that by doing this you "save" $5000/yr because the insurance company is "more efficient". That's wrong - you actually cost $5000 (this being the "profit" the insurance company makes if you _didn't_ need the medical treatment that year). Under the gov't version, if you were healthy, you're "free". You only cost when you actually need the medical treatment. Healthcare should not be done under a private insurance model. Any profit made by the private insurer is a cost to providing medical treatment, and does not contribute to the outcome. By making medical treatment a tax payer funded scheme, the cost of an unhealthy society is spread out amongst all. Not only does this give the gov't buying pressure to lower the margins of all medical treatments, it also makes a policy pressure for gov't to give preventative measures for good health outcomes (like legislating low sugar foods, or incentivize exercise and good diet etc).
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Under the gov't version, if you were healthy, you're "free". You only cost when you actually need the medical treatment. Government insurance is still insurance. It isn't that each individual costs the government $10,000, it's that most cost them nothing and one in ten gets cancer and costs $100,000. Insurance is the same. The large majority of the money isn't going to the insurance company, it's going to healthcare providers. > By making medical treatment a tax payer funded scheme, the cost of an unhealthy society is spread out amongst all. This is literally the definition of how insurance works. It's also why insurance sucks, because it allows people to make risky/unhealthy choices and socialize the costs of those choices, and therefore why high deductible insurance is more efficient by introducing at least some price sensitivity. > Not only does this give the gov't buying pressure to lower the margins of all medical treatments This is equivalent to legislating prices. They can already do this regardless, but it's a bad idea for the same reason price controls in general are. How do you determine what the price should be? Too high and you're overpaying, too low and you force providers to lower the quality of care to meet the price target. If this was so easy then why wouldn't the insurance companies be doing it too? > it also makes a policy pressure for gov't to give preventative measures for good health outcomes (like legislating low sugar foods, or incentivize exercise and good diet etc). Couldn't they do this anyway? Also, wouldn't they have the opposite incentives, because then the companies making blood pressure medicine or whatever would lobby against any such programs, and be more proficient lobbyists because they're already dealing with the government to begin with? And if the government really is so much more efficient then they should easily be able to out-compete the insurance companies and other healthcare providing systems on fair terms in a competitive marketplace, right?
- subhobroto 7y ago> The large majority of the money isn't going to the insurance company, it's going to healthcare providers. I have upvoted you but on HN, the prevailing belief is that doctors are gods and insurance companies are evil. The data clearly shows that, on the average, insurance companies lose money while hospitals charge a 10000% markup - that's right, a 10000% markup. I have written extensively on this topic (see my Quora) but I am finding it incredibly challenging getting people to see the reality. Because I am often a contrarian here I am no alien to the downvote silence system here on HN - it's likely you can't respond to this comment of mine because HN won't let you for a few hours. My email is in my profile, would love to connect with you - a person aware of reality. Thank you
- Barrin92 7y agothis whole school choice and insurance choice neoliberal mantra is what has gotten us into this mess to begin with. The entire insurance sector is a huge waste of manpower and essentially just huge dump for the surplus of white collar university graduates that have nowhere to go. There's not a single person on the planet who derives benefits from navigating the trade-offs of byzantine insurance plans, and school choice is a good way to speed up social and racial segregation and enabling quasi fraudulent religious schools that teach people nonsense. It's time we do away with this altar of choice. I moved from Germany to the UK years ago, and I've never enjoyed anything more than the NHS because I literally do not have to waste a minute of my life on health insurance any more. I pay X amount of taxes, I go to the doctor, I get treated, I go home.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> The entire insurance sector is a huge waste of manpower and essentially just huge dump for the surplus of white collar university graduates that have nowhere to go. US health insurance is garbage specifically because it's tied to employers and employers have strong tax incentives to use insanely inefficient low-deductible plans that both destroy price sensitivity and involve the insurance bureaucracy in small time medical procedures. > There's not a single person on the planet who derives benefits from navigating the trade-offs of byzantine insurance plans The cost difference between different insurance plans is thousands of dollars a year. It's one of the most financially impactful choices most individuals can make. Meanwhile if you don't want to make it then... don't? The government could easily recommend a specific plan and anybody who doesn't want to spend a few hours choosing for themselves a thing that could impact them to the tune of $100,000 over their lifetime could just choose that one and be done. > school choice is a good way to speed up social and racial segregation Sending kids to schools based on racially segregated school districts is the status quo. You're saying giving those parents the option to send their kids to the same school as the white kids is going to increase segregation? How is that supposed to work? > enabling quasi fraudulent religious schools that teach people nonsense. Those "schools" already exist. If they're dangerous enough to deny parents the right to use what is really their own tax money to send their kids to then they're dangerous enough to shut down entirely, right? Unless you run into some questions of free speech and religious freedom doing that, but then I'm not sure how you were expecting to avoid them to begin with when using "we need to deny them the ability to do that" as an argument. > I moved from Germany to the UK years ago, and I've never enjoyed anything more than the NHS because I literally do not have to waste a minute of my life on health insurance any more. I pay X amount of taxes, I go to the doctor, I get treated, I go home. So buy a low deductible insurance plan that covers everything. It costs more than making individual choices, if you don't like to do that. But the cost comes either way -- either you pay with time or you pay with money. (The status quo in the US is ridiculously broken because you pay with time but then it's still costs a ton of money for multiple independent reasons. Nobody thinks the status quo in the US is a good idea.)
- arcticbull 7y agoEverything you say just isn't true in many places on Earth.
- d0100 7y agoYou are misunderstanding me. The government gives you $300 and makes sure that enough healthy food is available for those $300. You don't get $300 worth of food. You get money. Cold hard cash. And the option to buy cheap food from the government. Companies can also make cheap food targeting those $300, and I'm sure there already exists non-government government cheese. About education and healthcare. The government just needs to provide the bare minimum. Broke an arm? Goverment will cast it. Still crooked? Get in the wait line or go work for money and get an insurance or pay for the surgery. Want a better education for your kids? Homeschool if you can, or just work for more money and pay for one. UBI should be: survival -> socialism good (material) life -> capitalism
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> And the option to buy cheap food from the government. But then why do you need this at all? There is already food available in the market. If you have $300 you can buy it. There is nothing the government needs to do other than give you the $300. > The government just needs to provide the bare minimum. Broke an arm? Goverment will cast it. There is a pretty good argument that the local government should provide emergency medicine for the same reason they provide fire departments -- you can't choose a provider while you're bleeding out. But most medical care is not provided under emergency conditions. > Want a better education for your kids? Homeschool if you can, or just work for more money and pay for one. But that's the problem. The government takes $10,000 from you and then gives it back if you use their schools. If you want to use your school and it only costs $8000, not only do you not get the $2000 back, you don't get any of it and end up having to pay $18,000 for what should have cost you $8000. So your school doesn't just have to be better than the government's school, it has to be so much better that it's worth paying twice. There is no legitimate reason to impose that requirement instead of allowing people who don't use the government's school to get back the money they saved the taxpayer.
- d0100 7y ago> There is already food available in the market. Leave it to capitalism to inflate UBI out of usefulness. Let the market compete with the baseline, never replace it. > you don't get any of it and end up having to pay $18,000 Well, supply and demand should work here, right? Isn't the market the mythical machine of just prices? If the market won't pay taxes + $8,000 for private school, there will be no schools for that price. If it does, it is worth it and you'll pay. I'm very confident that all this quarantine will do is show the world that disrupting the market won't break the world. The world will just adapt. It should be the same with UBI. UBI could just be a government guarantee that a citizen will never become homeless/neglected because of lack of work(by any cause, be it skill, opportunity or mental health). It's the new baseline. "Losing everything" now would mean just going back to surfing the web and eating government cheese in some cramped apartment. Not homelessness, starvation, abuse and neglect.
- ashtonkem 7y agoFun fact: government cheese actually used to be pretty good, because it was made and stored in a cave the government owned. It turns out that caves are pretty close to the ideal place to make cheeses, so the government’s stuff wasn’t bad!
- dlkf 7y agoThe cliche that total scientific socialism sounds great in theory but doesn't work in practice actually applies far better to laissez-faire capitalism (scientific socialism doesn't even look good on paper). Your arguments against free education and universal healthcare sound clever apriori, but they are completely at odds with the evidence. Countries with universal healthcare and robust public school systems invariably have better outcomes on both fronts.