5 ms·
Every experiment in UBI says otherwise. Direct cash grants usually lead people to do more work, because now they can do the work they enjoy. Also, look around
by jedberg 7y ago
Every experiment in UBI says otherwise. Direct cash grants usually lead people to do more work, because now they can do the work they enjoy.
Also, look around groups of wealthy people. The ones who don't have to work anymore. Sure, some of them live a life of leisure, but many of them still work, because they get bored otherwise.
- bzb3 7y agoThere are lots of jobs people don't enjoy. Who's going to do those? If they raise the salaries and start getting applicants, who's going to buy the much more expensive produce? They'd have to increase the amount of ubi, and there you have inflation.
- eanzenberg 7y agoThe robots, obviously! /s
- jedberg 7y agoNon-citizens don't get UBI, so it would fall to immigrants. That's in fact the biggest issue with UBI -- it creates a de-facto class system.
- matz1 7y agoAutomation, immigrant, increase pay.
- formercoder 7y agoSome fold, some raise wages, some invest in automation. Inflation is possible, but not guaranteed.
- asdff 6y agoYou are assuming a business and industry is a god given right. If a business fails to get applicants, they need to raise wages or relocate to where there is labor. If they need more income to pay for these workers then they will charge more. If the price they charge for their goods or services is too high for the given level of demand, the business will just fold. And that's OK, there area a lot of parasitic zombie companies around that could use a culling, wasting peoples working years doing inane tasks rather than starting a project of their own and innovating. As they say, imagine if Mozart never held a violin but was busy working double shifts flipping burgers for 30 years instead.
- eanzenberg 7y ago>>Every experiment in UBI says otherwise. Direct cash grants usually lead people to do more work, because now they can do the work they enjoy. But probably less "meaningful" work, in however society defines meaningful. >>Also, look around groups of wealthy people. The ones who don't have to work anymore. Sure, some of them live a life of leisure, but many of them still work, because they get bored otherwise. This is due to earning a return matching their effort. At some point, if enough income is withheld at that level, what's the point? Or, they will leave en-mass to countries more willing to employ entrepreneur muscle. These aren't anecdotes. Look at emigration from USSR, China, Venezuela or others of their scientists, professors, doctors, lawyers, financiers, etc.
- jedberg 7y ago> But probably less "meaningful" work, in however society defines meaningful. Typically in these experiments the people start small businesses. When the risk of failure has a floor it makes you more likely to take on the risk. > At some point, if enough income is withheld at that level, what's the point? Most UBI proposals are VAT taxes. The more you consume the more you pay. So if you're a wealthy person, you will still see the return on your effort.
- eanzenberg 7y agoWhy would the tax be regressive?
- eanzenberg 7y agoAlso, how can it be funded by vat anyways? We’re talking about trillions per year to fund. Are you taxing cars 1000%? It doesn’t add up.
- snovv_crash 6y agoI think you're overestimating how much would be paid out. Taxes can go up on the employed by roughly what they receive in UBI, unemployed get UBI instead of unemployment benefits. It all balances out.
- BurningFrog 7y agoPeople will always to things they enjoy. No one questions that. We have paid employment to get people to do things that need to be done!
- DaiPlusPlus 7y agoHow many jobs exist for things that don’t “need to be done” though? I’m aware the definition of “need” is a can of worms - but as an example, I know plenty of people who started doing call-center work in their early-20s while they “figure out what I want to do with their life” and by the time they know what they want to do (and it’s definitely not call-center work!) they’re trapped in their jobs, especially as after a few years they will have moved-out of their parents’ home - so having to pay rent and cover their cost-of-living while they’re getting started or experimenting with their own personal life projects (e.g. doing art, etc) is unfeasible - and don’t suggest getting a loan either. Meanwhile people with wealthier and accommodating parents can afford to take their time living off their parents - I see this as an example of the inequality of opportunity in our society. Another example is the unseen and underreported unpaid work that exists, such as when a family has a child and the child has a disability that requires extra care: if they’re a married couple then one of them would drop-out of their career to become a full-time - unpaid - caregiver. If it’s a single—parent situation then the outcomes are often heartbreaking. This isn’t the society I want to live in. UBI would mean the cost of labor for “McJob”s would rise - probably significantly (UBI would mean the end of the minimum wage, however) - but having fewer people doing jobs they don’t want to do means greater net happiness and we’d see further rises in automation - which further raises GDP. I see employers using human labor for unrewarding work because it’s cheaper than automation as a terrible local-maxima in our system. We just need to push past it to get to an even bigger maxima.
- maxbond 6y agoAre you familiar with the concept of Bullshit Jobs? In short, I'm not convinced that all or even most jobs are actually necessary. Surely it's reasonable to expect that people will be passionate about the things that actually need to be done, precisely because they are necessary. One of the most intense people I've ever met has cleaned SUPERFUND sites for decades. I'm not sure how well paid they are, but I am sure it isn't about the money. If they have trouble attracting people, they'll raise wages, and surely we can expect that what some people enjoy is making lots of money. Would it be so bad if working a shitty job no one would do voluntarily was well compensated, instead of poorly? In experiments with UBI, many of the people who quit do so to spend more time with their family - and keep in mind, domestic work is _work_ that is _necessary_ and incredibly valuable to society - or to retire earlier. Doesn't that sound reasonable? Do we really need to force people to work when they could be engaged in other activities valuable to society or to themselves? Wouldn't it be nice if there was more room for young people to be promoted? Another thing idea I've been toying with is the devil's bargain of trading UBI for eliminating minimum wage. I was watching a video about getting into locksmithing, and the speaker joked that if you made some faux pas, your potential employer would value you at $2/hr and send you packing. But that begged the question for me; what if I could work for $2/hr, with very few barriers, and get enough experience to earn more? In order to be hireable, I'd have to work at a negative rate, investing money in tools and locks to practice on. I have the privilege of having a family that could support me while I did something like that. But what if we could all do that, not because you won a socioeconomic lottery, but because our society was willing to invest in you and take a chance on you, regardless of your background?
- kaffeemitsahne 7y ago>Every experiment in UBI says otherwise. Has even one of these been a permanent (for the recipients) experiment?
- zhoujianfu 6y agoI don’t know why they don’t do this at $1K/mo for life for 30 people (and then study them qualitatively) instead of $250 one-time for 20,000. What is a one-time payment of $250 going to tell us about a UBI?
- mason55 6y agoThe biggest problem with UBI is political. Even if you manage to implement it you have no guarantee that the next administration will continue it. If you can't guarantee that your $1k/mo will really be for life then you can't take the risks on things like starting a small business because you might have to go back to work one day and if you have a large employment gap that's going to be tough.
- zhoujianfu 6y agoIn this case you would set up a trust and fund it with the $5M so legally the only thing that could happen with the money would be $1K/mo to the recipients for life. I just meant in terms of what to do with this $5M that might be more useful for studying UBI.
- timwaagh 6y agobecause it would cost 18 million.
- zhoujianfu 6y ago(I was assuming you could get a 7% annual return on the $5M, which is $350K, or about $1K/mo times 30.)
- EpicEng 7y ago>Every experiment in UBI says otherwise. There has never been a test on a scale which would lead people to do it though. If you know you're part of a short lived experiment you're not quitting your job.
- zhoujianfu 6y agoYeah, I think it would have been better if they doled out the $5M as $1K/mo for life to 30 people and studied them qualitatively..
- osdiab 6y agoThe GiveDirectly trial is a 12-year long one - not whole life, but also not insignificant.
- ThrowawayR2 6y ago> "Also, look around groups of wealthy people. The ones who don't have to work anymore. Sure, some of them live a life of leisure, but many of them still work, because they get bored otherwise." People who built their wealth, they keep working because it's in their personality makeup. People who inherit wealth often wind up frittering it away.
- Grue3 6y agoWhat about work nobody enjoys doing? Who will do this work?
- jedberg 6y agoImmigrants who don’t qualify for UBI. That’s why it’s important we don’t accidentally create a two class system with UBI.