12 ms·
Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR
- Tomte 7y agoI'm not surprised. Parents have ultimate authority over things affecting their children. If Mom says no, why should Grandma be allowed to publically(!) post photos, for the whole world to see? Edit: keep in mind that at least in my country you need permission from the person depicted when publishing a photo of him (with exceptions for important events, important people and so on). And parents act in stead of the child, legally. When the parents say "no", legally the child has said no.
- noworriesnate 7y agoAgreed. My wife and I are both agreed that we want no pictures of our children posted online until they're old enough to make the decision for themselves. This is something we both believe very strongly since we've seen firsthand the inhuman way technology treats human data (we both are engineers). However her mother does not respect our wishes and we occasionally find something she posted online or used when teaching a class. It's very annoying, but we just argue with her when she does it rather than doing something legal.
- Pfhreak 7y agoNo idea why you'd be downvoted. Grandparents absolutely do not have the right to post pictures of their grandchildren without the parent's permission.
- Tomte 7y agoHappens in every GDPR discussion. Even when you post strictly factual information without any opinion, you get downvoted if you showed in other comments sympathy for the GDPR.
- gpm 7y agoForget all the family drama for a second, the headline is then > Person A ordered to remove pictures of person B from facebook. That's legal? That's not a blatant free speech issue? (This isn't to say Grandma isn't being an asshole by posting them, but generally you have a right to be an asshole) Edit: I just want to say I'm pretty happy with the discussion this post generated :) Also, it's been bouncing around from -4 to 0 points repeatedly.
- derefr 7y agoWould you say that if Grandma released a commercial documentary containing images of people that she hadn't gotten consent to appear in the film? Likeness rights are likeness rights. Nothing to do with free speech. For IP law reasons, people don't have a right to distribute pictures with your likeness in them, unless you explicitly grant them that right. (If things didn't work this way, the modelling industry would collapse.)
- ghaff 7y agoIn the US... Commercial documentaries have images of people who didn't give consent all the time. >For IP law reasons, people don't have a right to distribute pictures with your likeness in them, unless you explicitly grant them that right. Of course they do. Every newspaper does it every day. >(If things didn't work this way, the modelling industry would collapse.) People can nonetheless charge for sitting for a photo shoot. And the use of images in marketing/advertising contexts (e.g. in an ad, in a company brochure) does indeed require explicit permission. You also get into publicity rights etc. of famous people. But if I take a street photo of you and illustrate my blog with it or publish it in a book of my photos? I absolutely don't need permission for a photo otherwise obtained lawfully.
- derefr 7y ago> People can nonetheless charge for sitting for a photo shoot. It's more about royalties. The professional modelling industry (of any kind—hand models, for an unusual example) would be unsustainable if the only payment were direct work-for-hire. Models need to make money from downstream uses of their likeness, just like people who produce music need to make money from downstream sampling of their song. Otherwise, the most profitable position would become that of the "sampler" (who, after all, wouldn't need to license anything, and so would get their source material for free!), strangling out those who rely on original licensed material, and thus killing any demand for those who produce such material. > Every newspaper does it every day. The thing that journalists and documentarists are doing, in such cases (though not all—they often do license!) is fair use. And fair use is a defense, not a legal justification (i.e. it's like murder in self-defense, not like executing someone as part of your legal duties as a state executioner.) In other words, doing something under fair use does not protect you from getting sued; it just means you potentially have a good argument to use, if-and-when you do get sued. Yes, oftentimes certain types of likeness rights are "obvious fair use." For example, a picture taken of a place, where that place contains a crowd—the photographer is unlikely to attempt to acquire likeness rights for anybody in the crowd. But technically, any one of those people could still sue for an infringement of their likeness rights. Now, normally, such a crowd-member who sued wouldn't win... but if the person in the crowd was an "ex-celebrity" who'd gone into hiding and had made a statement that they didn't want to be in the public eye any more; and the paparazzist took the photo specifically because the ex-celebrity was in the crowd, with the intent of printing it out on the side of a building and highlighting with a spotlight just the little bit of it where the person is? They'd have a very good case. Even though it's still "a picture of a crowd, in public." As well, you lose any notion of this implicit "obvious" fair-use defense, when you're no longer taking pictures of public places. A nudist beach, for example? Usually they've legally arranged to be considered "public-access private commercial facilities." You have no fair-use defense for pictures taken there, any more than you do for pictures taken inside a Starbucks. A home is a private place. Grandma isn't taking street photos. In fact, without an explicit grant of rights, she's not just infringing upon the subject's likeness rights; she's surveilling private property. Just like most retail stores say you are, if you go in and take pictures of the shelves.
- gnicholas 7y agoI live in the US, where laws are different than where you are. Can you help me understand: what happens if a child posts pictures of him/herself, against the wishes of the parent? Can the child be punished with the same fines as the grandparent in this case?
- grayfaced 7y agoIn US, if the child is under 13, they'd be covered by COPPA and it'd fall on the service provider. Can't answer for GDPR. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_Online_Privacy_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_Online_Privacy_Pr...
- narag 7y agoParents pay their children's fines. Why would they suit... themselves?
- gnicholas 7y agoThey wouldn't do it for the money — they would do it to force the kid to take down the photos.
- derefr 7y agoI think the GP's point is that there's an implicit "or... what?" here. The parent would sue the child to either take down their photos, or... what? What would be the consequence if the child didn't comply with a ruling against them? The only potential legal consequences would be on the parent themselves. In effect, the law has no leverage against children, except insofar as children can be influenced through their parents. If the parent were the one suing—because the parent also has no leverage—then nobody has leverage.
- Tomte 7y agoParents usually have plenty of extra-legal leverage. That's why such a "case" wouldn't go to court, just as a dispute over the chaos in the child's room wouldn't. Application of that leverage is called "parenting". :-)
- karatestomp 7y agoIf Grandma were running around distributing fliers with the kids' photos on them, there'd be no controversy—that's weird, and of course the parents can ask her to stop, and if they ask, she should, and it was kinda crazy to do it in the first place. Posting them on Facebook is exactly that but 1,000x worse, but it's "normal" so we have a debate about whether it's right for them to ask her to stop.
- mminer237 7y agoIt's pretty common for grandparents to show and send people physical photos of their grandchildren.
- karatestomp 7y agoVia billboard? Published in the paper?
- topkai22 7y agoMine used to send them out to 250 of her closest friends every Christmas card time, and get them included in the church newsletter occasionally.
- awillen 7y agoThe headline of this is so clickbaity in making it sound like some little old grandma posted pictures of her vacation and big evil government made her remove them. She posted pictures of grandchildren against their mother's wishes. She's just being selfish, and the fact that she's a grandmother isn't really germane to anything.
- kedean 7y agoThe description of the defendant as "a grandma" is definitely meant to get you on a particular side of the story before even reading it.
- mellosouls 7y agoShe's not called "a grandma" which is folksy and so you would be correct. She's referred to as "grandmother" to indicate the relationship which is relevant to the story and the presumable toxicity of the situation.
- mellosouls 7y agoIt says the complaint was made after they fell out - I agree she should take them down, no question. But the story could be read as the daughter spiting her mother by making her take down photos she was happy with before the fall out. I'm not claiming that's what happened - maybe they fell out because of this - just saying we shouldn't rush to judgement on her motivation for pushing back.
- andrewmutz 7y agoI agree that the grandmother should respect her daughter's wishes and take them down. I would disagree that it is the role of the government to enforce this.
- mattbee 7y agoI disagree, the detailed headline helped me to predict the story correctly. Her use of Facebook as a grandmother was very typical and the disagreement one I'd heard before. It'd be irrelevant if she was posting data she'd got e.g. from her job.
- wjnc 7y agoThe verdict [1, Dutch] is somewhat less interesting than it seems since it was a summary proceedings with both lawyers (and the judge) not really versed in GDPR and due to covid quite limited interaction. The grandmother could have argued legitimate interest (she is a grandmother and took care of one of the children) and have demonstrated limited visibility (now there was no mention of posting publically or not, so the judge went with publically) and the case would have started to get interesting. Now it was just a slam dunk. No permission, no argument for use case under GDPR, done. [1] https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/inziendocument?id=ECLI:NL:RBGEL:2020:2521 https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/inziendocument?id=ECLI:NL:...
- hirundo 7y agoWhich demonstrates how easily such laws are abused even when they don't technically apply. How much money and time are grandma willing to invest for the sake a few pics? How much less likely is she to post more? Whatever the benefits and details of the GDPR its chilling repercussions are non trivial.
- Tomte 7y agoThe "chilling repercussions" of making illicit publishing of personal data illegal? That is the whole point of privacy laws! It's like saying that laws against theft cost you so much money since they make you pay in the supermarket.
- Tagbert 7y agoThere is a long tradition of grandmothers showing pictures of their grandchildren. Is that now banned or does it require prior notice in writing by each child? Does she have to wait until the child is an adult and can provide legal authorization?
- Tomte 7y agoTo an unrestricted public? I have never heard of the long tradition of grandmothers publishing their grandchildrens' photos in a newspaper or handing out photo leaflets. They usually show those pictures to a few friends. In person. In their photo album at home. (The GDPR doesn't cover that, obviously, because it is meant to address the rather new phenomenon of world-wide audiences)
- crazygringo 7y agoDoes this mean that, broadly, under GDPR if anyone in any photo you've ever taken and put on social media complains, you have to take it down? Or is this because the subjects are minors? Or some other technicality, like whether or not the photos were taken in a public place or similar?
- aphextron 7y ago>"Does this mean that, broadly, under GDPR if anyone in any photo you've ever taken and put on social media complains, you have to take it down?" We can only hope. No one has the right to post a picture of me on the internet anywhere ever for any reason.
- viro 7y agoYou're joking right?
- koboll 7y agoThis is silly. You don't retain any claims on images just because they include you. Extrapolating this idea leads to absurd conclusions. If I take a photo of a crowd at an NBA game and publish it in a book of NBA photos, should any member of that crowd be able to force the publisher to stop selling the book until they've removed the photo? If not, why should it work differently on the internet?
- Thaxll 7y agoLaws are different per country but usually it has to do with the intent of the picture, if I'm in background of your NBA photo I'm not the main subject so it's ok and I have not right to ask you to take it down.
- xphilter 7y agoNot to be a stickler, but if you’re at an NBA game you contractually agree to allow that photo to be taken and displayed (under US law). Obviously it’d be different under EU law though.
- throwawaymanbot 7y agoStay off Facebook.
- jimmaswell 7y agoWho took the pictures? In a sane legal system it would boil down purely to who owns the copyright, barring an exceptional circumstance like revealing medical information. This privacy stuff has gone to absurd extremes. Soon it will be illegal to say someone's name without written permission over there. What a crazy legal landscape Europe is.
- Barrin92 7y agoIn many European jurisdictions people have a 'right of their person to their own likeness', meaning that publishing pictures requires consent. This seems like a straightforward application of this, and more importantly gives the children power to control what information of them is on the internet. The European legal landscape is perfectly fine and gives children the right to put a limit on what their (grand)parents can do with their image. It protects the privacy of children, which honestly shouldn't even be controversial.
- aaomidi 7y agoWhat on earth are you on. My picture is mine. Not the person who took the picture. I hate family members who think they're somehow entitled to me and my body and my face. Like no. I will be the person deciding what I'm comfortable with.
- gnicholas 7y agoSo do you just have a problem with people posting photos of you on social media, or even just having photos with you in them for their own memories? It seems like your critique would apply equally to both.
- rootlocus 7y agoDo you go around projecting your memories on a public display accessible to anyone, any system, any algorithm, any time, possibly forever?
- 7y ago
- advisedwang 7y agoWhy isn't this between the mother and Facebook? Surely Facebook has some responsibility for posts on their platform. That also seems like a much more scalable as it can be part of flagging process.
- kube-system 7y agoFacebook really isn't in the business of intermediating domestic (or legal) disagreements.
- koheripbal 7y agohun? They aren't an intermediary. The pictures are posted on Facebook. They are the primary. It doesn't matter who uploaded them to Facebook.
- kube-system 7y agoThey're neither an intermediary nor a primary party to the dispute. Facebook is not an arbitrator. The case, as mentioned in the article, was between a woman and her mother. You'd have to ask them or their lawyer why they pursued action this way. I suspect from the context in the article that it was a recurring issue, and the article mentions that it wasn't just posts on Facebook, either.
- andrewxdiamond 7y agoFacebook is not in a position (and shouldn't need to be) to determine who has what rights to what images. They deferred to the governing bodies on this issue, and the courts decided that the parents had the right to demand the photo(s) are taken down. The parents could presumably now go to FB with this ruling and have them take the photos down. If FB did not defer to another party, they would have to determine if the accusing party has the legal grounds to demand the pictures are removed. How would FB know that those are the parent's kids? Or that the parents have custody? Or any other nuanced edge case? It's best for everyone if FB defers to the bodies that defined these laws for judgement. Otherwise, you'll end up in a system like YouTube where copyright protections are easily abused against small organizations that can't fight back.
- bosswipe 7y agoGood! I don't post photos of my kids on the internet and I get so annoyed when other people take it upon themselves to post them for me. Clearview AI has made it even more clear than it already was that any data you give these companies can and will be used against you.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoMy wife and I have the same opinion. So far, both sides of our family are complying to our wishes, except that one or two times my in-laws managed to put our kid in a Facebook story by accident - apparently the Messenger app is confusing enough that they don't even realize when it happens.
- sneak 7y agoThe trick is to ban visitor smartphones and not to have an account, which is the only way to actually disable Messenger.
- ryanmcdonough 7y agoWhich world are you living in where banning visitors having their phones is a reasonable thing to happen?
- pier25 7y agoI think it was a joke
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sneak 7y agoIt is a common social custom in my circles to not use one’s phone when visiting the homes of others as a guest, a faux pas on the same order as bringing an uninvited stranger along as your guest in a visit to someone’s home. Taking non-macro or identifying photos, especially of the residents or other guests, would be quite rude without advance permission. I grant that many of my friends and associates may be more privacy-oriented than most, but it isn’t just tech/nerds-who-use-Tor.
- awinter-py 7y agothis despite granny's TOS clause clearly granting perpetual likeness rights in exchange for periodic babysitting
- aaron695 7y agoAnd the thing that matters isn't mentioned by BBC? Was it a public post or private? BBC doesn't even seem to understand the issue at hand. Public/The court didn't know - http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/2020/05/privacy-rights-and-social-media-can.html?m=1 http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/2020/05/privacy-rights-and-soci...
- rootlocus 7y agoFirst, facebook can stil datamine that photo even if it's not public. Second, if it were private, gradma would still be sharing it with people outside the control of the parents (what if gradma was dating a pedophile?). Third, gradma could've easily changed them to public any time.
- aaron695 7y ago> First, facebook can stil datamine that photo even if it's not public. This is not relevant to the article, why can't we just talk about the article. There are plenty of other articles on HN about privacy within applications. The court specifically mentioned the 'general public' "The court acknowledged that "it cannot be excluded" that placing a picture on a Facebook or Pinterest page might be exempted from GDPR scrutiny on the basis of this provision, but held that it had not been established that A's pages were inaccessible to the general public." When you publish on Twitter or Facebook publicly you are no different to a newspaper, you are publishing to the public record. The BBC clearly doesn't get this, which I assume means a lot of the general public doesn't either with such lousy media.
- savrajsingh 7y agoHow can I explore photos that people I've blocked have uploaded, and get facebook to remove them? Seems like that should be possible.
- sokoloff 7y ago> How can I explore photos that people I've blocked have uploaded, and get facebook to remove them? Why do you think you should have the right to review the photos that other people uploaded, whether or not you've blocked them?
- savrajsingh 7y agoOh, I would restrict to photos I’m in
- subhro 7y agoGood. I hope people do not feel I am being overtly critical, but deleting the photos mean nothing. Once something is posted on the internet, especially Facebook, it can not be un-posted. At least, that is what my understanding is.
- lgl 7y agoYou're not wrong in the sense that things get cached, mirrored, scraped, etc, and probably live forever inside Facebook's datacenters even when "removed", but there is still a valid case for not wanting the pictures posted on a public profile for all eternity.
- joshspankit 7y agoThis is exactly the point: it being in FB’s “big pile of everything they’ve ever seen“ is entirely different than it being publicly available. And therefore there is a purpose to having it taken down.
- krapp 7y ago>Once something is posted on the internet, especially Facebook, it can not be un-posted. At least, that is what my understanding is. But in the thread next door everyone is screaming that social media companies have complete, absolute and unchecked power over all forms of human communication and expression, and that when someone is deplatformed or their channel is banned, they and their content are all but permanently erased from human society.
- jrockway 7y ago> The woman must remove the photos or pay a fine of €50 (£45) for every day that she fails to comply with the order, up to a maximum fine of €1,000 Does that mean you can just write a check to not be covered by the GDPR?
- owenmarshall 7y agoYes, but you’d better have a big checkbook: willful violations of the GDPR scale up to 4% or €20m of annual global revenue - whichever is higher.
- ciarannolan 7y agoWhat's grandma's global revenue?
- M2Ys4U 7y agoI imagine that would very quickly turn in to contempt of court.
- rootlocus 7y ago> Does that mean you can just write a check to not be covered by the GDPR? Does that mean fines are checks you can write to not be covered by the law?
- mellosouls 7y agoAm I the only person to think that even parents should not be able to post - for anything other than a transient period (maybe not even that) - photos of kids in a public web space? It has always seemed obnoxious to me, the choice being made on somebody else's behalf to consign their privacy to the dustbin for eternity through this method.
- azernik 7y agoSocial and legal norms give parents astonishingly broad powers over their children's lives; this is indeed an important decision, but not any more important than the other things parents can decide uni-/bi-laterally.