6 ms·
But Windows is a painful OS to use for anything other than gaming. Ideally, I'd like to see the exact opposite of this: run Linux with a Windows subsystem just
by mcv 6y ago
But Windows is a painful OS to use for anything other than gaming. Ideally, I'd like to see the exact opposite of this: run Linux with a Windows subsystem just for gaming.
- albertzeyer 6y agoThat's exactly what Wine is.
- mcv 6y agoIt's exactly what Wine wants to be. Sadly that's not quite the same thing.
- boudin 6y agoWhat do you mean? Wine has a different architecture because distributing microsoft binaries is not legal, so technically it's not the same thing, but it still does an amazing job and a lot of apps/games works flawlessly.
- mcv 6y agoIt does an amazing job, but a lot of apps and games do not work flawlessly. Or didn't, last time I tried Wine. Maybe this situation has changed a lot since then, which would be awesome.
- dependenttypes 6y agoEvery single versions has a lot of improvements, esp regarding compatibility. I suggest giving it a try once again.
- zokier 6y agoThat directly implies that every single version has had lot to improve. And this is not to diss wine, but it is difficult problem they are tackling.
- majewsky 6y agoHolding software to that standard eliminates most of it. "No, I haven't tried Google Docs yet. They're still adding features and fixing bugs. I'm holding out until it's stable."
- zokier 6y agoContext matters a lot. I'm not holding Wine to unreasonable standards, its a matter of recognizing reality of the situation and that Wine is not such a exact mirror of WSL and as such it will continue to have significant issues.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoAre you familiar with Proton? Steam have put a lot of work in to making WINE work flawlessly for many games. https://www.protondb.com/ https://www.protondb.com/
- Unklejoe 6y agoIt seems like over the last 5 years, Wine has improved a ton. Or at least - it seems way more active. Not sure why, but I suspect that Valve has a lot to do with it.
- ghusbands 6y agoAnd a lot don't. And then you have to spend a lot of time researching why and messing around with config options and maybe even compilers. And the games sometimes stop working after an update. Conversely, if you run Windows, it's rare that you need to work hard to run a game.
- boudin 6y agoThis is definitely not my experience. Off my 100 games on steam, gog and egs, 2 doesn't work straight out of the box. - rocksmith 2014 that can work by switching to alsa audio but the audio lag make the experience subpar - bit trip beat that i know can work by changing something but didn't try
- ddalex 6y agoI mean, it's good enough for lots of games. But there is another way there - running Windows in a VM with GPU passthrough - works beautifully in my case.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoApart from photoshop video production audio and many other professional uses. Like the previous response what does this buy me as compared to developing and running natively in windows - as there are native compliers that support cuda etal on windows.
- kawsper 6y agoYou can do that today with Qemu and PCI-passthrough. You just boot a VM, and pass it a physical grapics card. Check out https://old.reddit.com/r/VFIO/ https://old.reddit.com/r/VFIO/ I guess this will be the standard until we can have nicer graphics drivers for Linux.
- monocasa 6y agoThat requires two GPUs though, one for the guest and one for the host.
- pepino 6y agoNot with Intel: https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Intel_GVT-g https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Intel_GVT-g
- monocasa 6y agoRight, it's easier to have an SR-IOV situation with an integrated GPU that doesn't have it's own VRAM. That's not the usual situation for people that are trying to use this scheme.
- kawsper 6y agoYes, this is true, I use my on-board Intel graphics card for my host, and my Nvidia card for my guest operating system.
- mpartel 6y agoWine / Steam's Proton does a decent job, and some older games even work better with Wine than with Windows 10. If you have a spare GPU, a VM with PCI passthrough does an even better job, except for some anti-cheat software that artificially discriminates against this setup. In theory it ought to be possible to switch a single GPU to/from a VM without a reboot. In practice I have no idea how huge a refactoring to the Linux graphics stack that'd require.
- mcv 6y ago> "some older games even work better with Wine than with Windows 10." This has been true for 16 bit games since long before Windows 10. Ages ago one of my favourite games stopped working on Windows, but Wine had no problems with it. So my impression has always been that Wine is excellent for really old games, but slightly more recent games, it could already be very hit and miss. > "If you have a spare GPU, a VM with PCI passthrough does an even better job, except for some anti-cheat software that artificially discriminates against this setup." Doesn't every CPU these days have onboard graphics? My Thinkpad X1E should support hybrid graphics, so it'd be nice if I could give the GPU to a VM and have the desktop use the CPU graphics. But if a Windows VM does a better job, that means Wine doesn't yet do as good a job as Windows. Though it's certainly true that Steam support for Linux is growing. But I don't think every Steam game already works on Linux.
- mpartel 6y ago> Doesn't every CPU these days have onboard graphics? On laptops, pretty much. On Intel desktops, yes, aside from Xeons. On AMD desktops, only some lower end Ryzens have "G" models.
- azernik 6y agoWine has gotten very good at recent games... or more specifically, Proton has. (Proton is a Steam-maintained fork of Wine, and is built in to the Steam client.) Official Proton "support" is limited, because it requires certification by Valve and/or the game developers that the game runs well (the equivalent of a "native" rating on winedb/protondb), but if you're willing to go down to "gold" levels of support it still runs 70-80% of all Steam windows games. See https://www.protondb.com/ https://www.protondb.com/
- jholman 6y agoWindows is a painful OS to use for anything other than gaming and web browsing, I agree. (Well, it was, until WSL.) If I ever again own a work-first non-gaming desktop, I will once again install some Debian GNU/Linux on it. (My gaming desktop, of course, runs Windows.) On laptops, however, I continue to find myself jumping through idiotic hoops to use Linux. The driver support is always just-barely-good-enough. Maybe it's audio, maybe it's graphics, maybe it's power management. Maybe it's something involving networking-after-power-management or some crap involving "don't unplug your headphones while the lid is down". On my current work laptop, a beautiful Thinkpad Carbon X1, I can't get the power management to work properly, so I just have to accept that there's no hibernate. I'm constantly forgetting to shut down, put it in my backpack, and then pull it out drained. What a pain in the ass. Could someone fix this problem, probably. Can I? Not in the dozens of hours I've put into it. I hate doing IT, I hate it I hate it I hate it. However much Macs make me want to vomit in my mouth, I can see the appeal. The drivers work at least 90% as well as Windows drivers, and the UX is at least half as good as a lightly-tuned Linux machine. "Jack of all trades, master of none, is oftentimes better than master of one" Anyway, before this lockdown ends, I'm upgrading my laptop distro to this new distro I've heard of out of Redmond, I think it's called "Windows".
- simiones 6y agoMany companies, including the one I work for, have most development happening on Windows. It is far easier to manage for Enterprise use-cases, with all relevant services integrated and obtained from a single vendor. Not to mention that there are quite a few development environments for more obscure platforms that still only exist for Windows. Overall, since most development time is spent in an IDE, the OS is really of little relevance to software development. Sure, some people insist in using command line tools, and that is unlikely to be pleasant on Windows, but a lot of other developers don't, and we couldn't care whether we're running our Emacs on Linux or Windows or Genera or whatever.
- larrik 6y agoI disagree, Windows is very painful for me to use at a basic level compared to Linux. I would be very unlikely to take a job that forced me to develop under Windows.
- simiones 6y agoThe same is mostly true for me when trying to use a Linux desktop. However, if I'm using IntelliJ or Emacs and Firefox, I don't really need to care what OS is running underneath too much. Edit: of course, Linux and Mac are available for devs that prefer them. It's still much easier for IT to manage 7000 Windows desktops and a couple hundred Linux ones than it would be to manage 7000 Linux desktops.
- Icathian 6y agoI'm not sure I agree with that. 7k "normal" machines for any given value of "normal" seems like it would always be easier than 7k "normal" machines and 200 oddballs. Is the sysadmin tooling for Windows really that much better?
- simiones 6y agoAre there even systems for managing many desktop machines running Linux? - Could you push a patch to Linux systems and have it install at the user's convenience (with some end date)? - Can you do that in waves without manually configuring things? - Can you remotely wipe a system if required? - Is there any popular anti-virus software for Linux, to protect company files in home folders from user mistakes? - Can you help users install some software without giving them full access, but also without requiring IT intervention for every installation?
- syshum 6y ago>>run Linux with a Windows subsystem just for gaming. aka wine / proton
- lostmsu 6y agoPainful? What exactly is painful? Apart from the Settings/Control Panel debacle, I don't know any issues you could be facing on Windows, unless you do a lot of C/C++ development which is still problematic due to the lack of a proper package manager.
- fesoliveira 6y agoI must disagree with the C/C++ take. Visual Studio is still, for me, one of the best IDEs out there, and the single best one for C/C++ development. And for the longest time, Windows indeed didn't have a good package manager, but over the past few years we've had vcpkg, which fills the vacuum pretty well when it comes to getting libraries without much hassle.
- lostmsu 6y agoI still did not have good experience with vcpkg, but, admittedly, I don't do a lot of C++. How do you configure compiler to use libraries downloaded from vcpkg? CMake? Something else?