10 ms·
Millions of US farm animals to be culled by suffocation, drowning and shooting
- ge96 7y agoThis is an ignorant "wishful" thought/question on my part but, what would be the cost to "donate" this food instead of just killing. I think I understand that it costs money to go through the full process, but if they're in an "adult" stage and are "edible" after processing. Is it really better to just kill/accept the loss than to get some use out of it? I think logistics is the main issue anyway, costs money to transport/refrigerate.
- sieabahlpark 7y agoThey can't afford to do that.
- microcolonel 7y agoBecause of the extent of regulations on processing, chances are every part of that transaction would be illegal; from transferring the animals, transporting them, processing them (the thing we're lacking the capacity for, that is causing this need). Even if you could competently process them, you almost certainly would not be able to legally process them. There's a lovely book called Everything I Want To Do Is Illegal that I think every American who eats food or votes should read.
- ge96 7y agowow I didn't even consider the legal part, interesting and processing comes before transportation concerns right
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoSo reading the blurb for that: "Drawing upon 40 years' experience as an ecological farmer and marketer, Joel Salatin explains with humor and passion why Americans do not have the freedom to choose the food they purchase and eat. From child labor regulations to food inspection, bureaucrats provide themselves sole discretion over what food is available in the local marketplace. Their system favors industrial, global corporate food systems and discourages community-based food commerce, resulting in homogenized selection, mediocre quality, and exposure to non-organic farming practices. Salatin's expert insight explains why local food is expensive and difficult to find and will illuminate for the reader a deeper understanding of the industrial food complex." from https://www.bookdepository.com/Everything-I-Want-Do-is-Illegal-Joel-Salatin/9780963810953 https://www.bookdepository.com/Everything-I-Want-Do-is-Illeg... makes me think, given the implied negatives of child labor regulations and food inspection, that anyone reading that book should follow up with a quick read of The Jungle by Upton Sinclair, the same way that I found Oliver Twist a useful tonic after my first exposure to Atlas Shrugged.
- microcolonel 7y ago> makes me think, given the implied negatives of child labor regulations and food inspection, that anyone reading that book should follow up with a quick read of The Jungle by Upton Sinclair, the same way that I found Oliver Twist a useful tonic after my first exposure to Atlas Shrugged. It's amazing how quickly you assume that the way those laws apply to Joel's farm is reasonable, or that what Joel is doing is the sort of thing the public were interested in interfering with when they supported those laws. Your reflex to defend the application of laws by their title is why no matter how much stink is made by people who actually read the US PATRIOT or EARN IT act for example, or any number of other brilliantly-framed pieces of legislation, there is always a gallery of opinionated people who will gladly judge a book by its cover with no less certainty, and with even more smug self-importance, than they would by its content. If it has never occurred to you: not everyone impacted by the law is a crook.
- carapace 7y agoSteady on my friend. OP just doesn't know who Joel Salatin is.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoI commend you on your reading in English despite your having a full command of the language as yet, just keep your nose to the grindstone because education is its own reward. As an example, allow me to clarify some matters that might not be apparent to someone approaching English as a second language. Firstly, child labor regulations and food inspection are not the titles of laws, they are classes of laws; this is why they are in lowercase instead of capitalized like the USA PATRIOT Act. So you see, it was not defending the application of laws by their title but instead by their category, an easy mistake to make and you shouldn't be embarrassed about it but I thought it should really be corrected. After all it is nice to be able to understand the difference, as subtle as it is. Also as you will note I slightly corrected the actual title of the USA PATRIOT Act because, while also a minor quibble there are all sorts of jerks out there who will take up any arguable point and make it cause for battle! Especially when combined with the "who actually read the" bit right before. Another thing that has probably escaped you, not having a first hand familiarity with American culture is the little nuances of the blurb talking about child labor regulations etc. Perhaps it is unintentional but there are political forces in the U.S that would like to get rid of these and other classes of laws that exist to restrict some things that businesses might otherwise like to do, like having children work in factories and selling food that has been made in unsanitary conditions, and so when I see marketing for something that seems to argue against these classes of law I worry that the book being marketed actually argues against them - I suppose you can see why that might be, right? Anyway, as I haven't read the book, which you pointed out, I can't really say if it is like I suppose when I read the marketing for it, but as I said the marketing "makes me think" it is, if it shouldn't make me think that then the marketing is bad marketing but if it should make me think that it means that the book hopes to get people who are predisposed to side with those political forces to buy the book. Perhaps the book might even be so written as to even more convince people that these classes of regulation are a bad thing and for this reason I suggested anyone reading the book should read another book called the Jungle which was an initial cause in getting at least the food inspection class of laws passed. So the upshot of that bit of nuance was I was not actually judging the book by it's cover, which seemed pleasant enough, but by it's marketing which perhaps only incidentally implies the book is harmful in some way. Of course I was only being facetious when I suggested anyone read The Jungle because I don't think it was actually that good but I just meant that the people who subscribe to the theories that those classes of law are bad things seem to labor under some sort of ahistoricity and as that is a lack of knowledge it would be nice if the lack could be rectified somehow. Finally when you say "there is always a gallery of opinionated people who will gladly judge a book by its cover with no less certainty, and with even more smug self-importance, than they would by its content." oh boy, don't I know it! It really does seem some days that even the most passing and light-hearted of comments will bring some pretentious little martinet out of the woodwork, taking personal affront, and wanting to start a battle over it all. This is really why I wrote this overly long reply to correct some of what you wrote, as admirable as it otherwise might have been, because I would hope to keep you from being drawn into a confrontation with one of these combative types, who, as I noted before, seem intent on getting the smallest mistake or deliberate misreading as a tool to spitefully attack your character. on edit: minor grammatical fixes.
- thrower123 7y agoI'm sure that you could work a deal under the table to buy a hog or a bullock, if you were willing to redneck it up and process it yourself, but there is so fucking much red tape in the way of doing this at scale.
- h2odragon 7y agoMy local craigslist has people selling "butcher size" (~300lb) hogs at $100 and less; which is cheap. Processing a critter that size at home is a big task; unpleasant and exhausting and messy.
- StavrosK 7y ago> Processing a critter I think we should go even farther with our euphemisms and call it "harvesting a resource". I love meat, even though I consider killing animals unethical, which makes me a hypocrite. Still, I think the least we can do is call the process "killing an animal".
- antisthenes 7y agoI mean if we're going to engage in silly pedantry, critter means animal. Also, ethics aside, the comment above was referring specifically to processing, not the act of killing. Killing is comparatively fast and far less messy. Butchering/processing a 300lb carcass is where the real effort lies.
- StavrosK 7y agoThat's fair, it just sounded a bit too clinical.
- jarito 7y agoI get the resistance to whitewashing, but the terminology of 'processing' seems more accurate. Killing the animal is only the beginning of the process and is generally the least time intensive. Properly butchering an animal while maintaining food safety, producing the proper cuts, etc. is a process that requires tooling and expertise. I would hope that everyone understands that creating a final meat product involves killing, but we shouldn't trivialize the process requirements just to drive an emotional point home.
- globular-toast 7y agoThe cost would be non-zero, so it won't be done. In fact, it would be very much higher than non-zero. You can't just march these animals down the road to the market one morning and give them away. Just because there are sentient beings involved you shouldn't think that this is any different from any other huge industrial operation. A car manufacturer can't expect to be able to liquidise a bunch of parts. Without the correct tooling it's worthless to anyone. Meat is the finished product, not animals. And those animals have no more rights than a hunk of metal.
- danharaj 7y agoThere are powerful people out there who feel the same about you.
- globular-toast 7y agoWhat a bizarre statement. Do you have a point?
- danharaj 7y ago> The cost would be non-zero, so it won't be done. There is a also cost to not doing it but your analysis implies that we shouldn't care about it, because it's not a cost accounted for by industrial practice.
- BostonFern 7y agoPeople, this is a descriptive characterization, not a normative one. It's perfectly sound.
- danharaj 7y agoAll communication has a normative component. The normativity of a description is what it considers relevant and what it considers irrelevant.
- deleted 7y ago
- Analemma_ 7y agoWho would take it? If you handed me a live adult pig or steer for free, I wouldn't know how to turn it into edible meat. The only people who can do this at the scale necessary to avoid a culling are the processing plants, and their being bottlenecked is the reason we're in this situation.
- ge96 7y agoWell my thought was poor people/food shelters/etc... I also realize it's even a larger joke to think "send it to "poor" countries". But I understand what you're saying, I wouldn't know how to cut apart meat and do it in a sanitized manner.
- astura 7y agoThe logistics just aren't there. You'd have to find people willing to take them, transporting them, slaughter them, and distribute the meat. We are talking about slaughtering and butchering millions of animals in a non-factory setting, not practical. On top of that transporting animals and/meat at that scale is not cheap or easy. This sort of operation is very difficult to do on an ad hoc/emergency basis. If an organization would just pick up any unwanted animals on demand, I'm sure the farmers would be happy to hand them over.
- zadkey 7y agoThe alternative is by butchering. (E.G.) there was sufficient demand for meat/processing ability at plants. Though I honestly wish there was a more humane alternative to culling. These industrial farms don't have room to spare for animals that aren't wanted. I wish there was some kind of park or nature reserve or somewhere that they could be sent to live out their lives in peace instead of the culling. Or if such places already exist, laws that mandate that they be sent there.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI wish so too. But honestly, space could likely be found. The problem is - and would be with your hypothetical nature reseve - that somebody has to pay for a) feeding these animals beyond their expected lifetimes, and b) fuel necessary to ship them to their reserve en-masse.
- PeterisP 7y agoWho would feed them? Releasing large quantities of animals to nature is both anti-ecological and inhumane, as it results in destruction of that ecosystem, starvation, cannibalism, etc. Like the horrible aftermath of the cases when activists have "freed" animals from fur farms, resulting in them dying within weeks but also taking all the local wildlife (e.g. nesting birds) with them. You can successfully do a controlled release of a limited number of animals given proper preparation. But if we're talking about releasing large numbers quickly, culling is much more humane than that that.
- ksdale 7y agoVery few animals besides apex predators in the wild live long enough to die of old age. Rather they die from starvation or disease or are eaten by something else. Life on industrial farms sounds terrible, for sure, but death in nature is also terrible, to the point that I'm not sure it's a mercy to "set them free".
- bbrree66 7y agoOr we just don't eat meat..... no that's too crazy! Moron. EDIT: Downvote to your heart's content! Truth is not decided by consensus. What I said is true, even if you don't like it.
- hprotagonist 7y agoFor small animals, CO2 is humane. It's widely used for laboratory research animals, and it's generally the least-worst option for them. I don't know how well it scales up by body mass above roughly a canada goose, so use on pigs doesn't seem immediately sane to me. Drowning doesn't seem viable. A bullet to the head (or a bolt gun, or whatever) is probably the fastest way to remove sensation from neural tissue for large farm animals. The shock wave takes milliseconds to turn brains to soup.
- lol768 7y ago> For small animals, CO2 is humane Do you have a citation for this? Everything I've seen would suggest to me it's categorically less humane than using an inert gas like nitrogen or helium in the absence of oxygen.
- hprotagonist 7y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5605172/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5605172/ has a lot of reading. it's so far the least-worst option: we know there are issues, but the alternatives to date so far have been worse, including inert gases.
- AndrewOMartin 7y agoI think the effect of CO2 is very similar to the hypoxia from low air pressure. Here's a video of a TV presenter and ex-member of parliament undergoing the experience. The point of the scene is that you lose any faculties long before any unpleasantness or damage. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DiEJKvbpOF0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DiEJKvbpOF0 If I'm wrong, and this is completely irrelevant to the discussion, just try to enjoy seeing a Tory bought to the brink of oblivion [satire]
- bloak 7y agoWhy is CO2 different for "small" animals than "large" animals? If CO2 is humane for chickens, say, then why do they sometimes use Nitrogen or Argon, which are more hazardous for humans and probably more expensive?
- peterlk 7y agoThis implies to me that if they "gave away" the extra animals to family farms, there would not be enough takers. Is that true?
- StavrosK 7y agoKeep in mind that sometimes killing the animal might be the humane option. I certainly wouldn't want a cow left to starve in what's essentially some guy's backyard box. I've seen enough dogs kept in such conditions.
- bbrree66 7y agoThis is a crazy thought so please keep an open mind........ if we didn't mass produce animals to kill and eat them.... we wouldn't have this issue in the first place.
- bluedino 7y ago700,000 pigs alone would need new homes per week.
- karatestomp 7y agoThere aren't that many family farms, and they're going to tend to have about as many animals as they can support already, unless there's some reason they don't want more (just like any business—otherwise you're wasting capital). You might find some hobbyist-types who have extra capacity and would take a cow or three hoping to sell them later since they're relatively easy to care for if you have fenced land (pigs are a bit more specialized; chickens are already cheap and most probably want the egg-laying kind, not the mutant factory farm meat kind), but that wouldn't go very far.
- jordache 7y agoha and the righteous ppl here in the west wants to wag their fingers at animal farming treatment in asia
- globular-toast 7y agoCO2 and drowning are horrific ways to die. To anyone who disagrees why not try waterboarding or taking a breath of CO2. Neither one will kill you, but they'll be the most uncomfortable things you've ever felt in your life. If they can use CO2 they should be able to use CO or Nitrogen. Both of these cause a completely painless death in mammals. It was shown in a BBC documentary called How to Kill a Human. The topic was how to execute prisoners for the purpose of capital punishment, but the effects of Nitrogen were shown on a pig. It was completely oblivious to anything happening and voluntarily subjected itself to more Nitrogen after losing consciousness.
- jstanley 7y ago> voluntarily subjected itself to more Nitrogen after losing consciousness. How can you argue it did anything voluntarily if it was not conscious? I'd think it was merely subjected to more nitrogen because it was unable to move away, no?
- globular-toast 7y agoI sadly can't find the video right now (there are other clips available on Youtube). The experiment involved putting some food in a gas chamber into which the pig could stick its head. The pig voluntarily went for the food and the chamber was filled with Nitrogen. The pig lost consciousness and fell backwards away from the chamber. Now breathing air the pig regains consciousness and after fully waking up goes right back to the food.
- indifferentalex 7y agoReally hope information like this regarding our meat-industrial complex disappears into obscurity before the aliens visit, or that they at least don't judge us by the biblical "sins of your forefathers"
- marcinzm 7y agoAssuming universal ethics onto a human is the subject of whole fields of study. Doing so onto something that isn't even from the same evolutionary tree seems silly. An alien evolved from predators might find vegetarians merely dinner and not worthy of talking to.
- indifferentalex 7y agoGood point of course, however irrational it might be, I can only imagine the scenario where there's a really awkward confrontation between us and the ETs over one of these articles. Will take the bravest of us to start throwing bacon jokes.
- karatestomp 7y agoSame as the problem with Pascal's Wager: if you don't know the motivations and values of the entity you're trying to please and can't even really narrow the possibilities down much, you might find the "wrong" behavior/belief is actually the one that pleases them, and the "right" one pisses them off.
- vzidex 7y agoI disagree, Pascal's Wager deals with the situation where you don't know whether the (omnipotent) entity you're trying to please exists or not. This comment thread assumes the omnipotent entity (aliens) exists, and so you'd be taking a coin flip as to what behaviour they find pleasing. Pascal's Wager resolves to: (infinite gain * non-zero probability of success) > (finite gain * non-zero probability of failure) While this situation is more like: (infinite gain * non-zero probability of success) ~= (infinite gain * non-zero probability of failure).
- mensetmanusman 7y agoUNICEF is now predicting 6,000 child deaths per day due to food and medical supply issues. It turns out you need an economy to fight the virus. All these knock on effects will be great learnings. Probably will turn out that future policy will be a local function of population density, public transportation usage, etc.
- syshum 7y agoHopefully this will shutdown all the "if you want to talk about the economy you want people to die" rhetoric i keep seeing all over the place. The economy is how people survive, it is not wall street like many people seem to believe, no economy == no food. No amount of government money printing will solve that
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIt's not as simple as that either. There was no option for COVID-19 to not cause problems like these, unless every nation cooperated to pretend the virus doesn't exist and sweep the deaths under the rug. As it is HoReCa sector was going to have very tough times with or without a lockdown, most of the demand for eating out would've evaporated anyway, and to the extent they didn't, you'd have that many more temporary closures as infected people were traced back to various venues. Consider also that meat processing plants weren't going through shutdowns due to being non-essential, but because they had actual outbreaks on-site. Economics isn't Wall Street, and we've learned it's impossible to do a clean split between essential and non-essential businesses, as the connections upstream in the supply chain are convoluted and non-obvious (and often enough, companies themselves don't have visibility into their own chains). But that doesn't mean we would be better off pretending the pandemic isn't happening, and just enduring the cost in lives.
- syshum 7y ago>> Consider also that meat processing plants weren't going through shutdowns due to being non-essential, but because they had actual outbreaks on-site. Yes but much of this could have been mitigated by an actual mitigation plan not this failed policy of "stay at home" and attempting to arbitrarily define essential and non-essential. You know things like Mask wearing that was advised against by the government and "The Experts"™ we are all suppose to surrender our lives to >>we've learned it's impossible to do a clean split between essential and non-essential businesses That is because every business is essential to the people that own, work, and consume goods / sevices from those business. The idea that the government is the best entity to to choose what is and is not essential is just asinine on its face >>But that doesn't mean we would be better off pretending the pandemic isn't happening the number of people saying that is statically 0, sure you have some nut cases that CNN and MSNBC love to parade out on the nightly news as an example of the "average person" that is agaist the lock down orders, but in reality there are more people like me that are using logic and reason to see through the emotional panic and fear that is at the core of the lock down orders to see how irrational and ineffective they really are. We are also advocating for actual mitigation that is proportional to the risk that this virus poses based on actual data, and revision of those plans as new data comes in In Feb and march based on the data at that time the lockdowns made sense. As we have learned more about how it spreads, who is at risk, what can be done to mitigate the spread and about 100 other things complete shutdowns make less and less sense outside of a few high dense area's of population.
- vzidex 7y agoTo anyone reading this thread and thinking "The horror!": Being culled through these various methods is no better or worse than they would have experienced under "normal" conditions - i.e. being raised until they are fit for slaughter and sale. No animal wants to die, and the methods used to kill them when being sold are just as cruel as the "culling" techniques listed here [1]. If you don't like what you're reading in this article, go vegan. Otherwise, you're paying for other people to inflict this sort of suffering on animals. [1] Dominion (2018): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQRAfJyEsko https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQRAfJyEsko
- bbrree66 7y agoThis is the only reasonable response in this entire post.
- sokoloff 7y agoThough I'm a meat-eater, I upvoted this for the unvarnished truth it contains.
- vzidex 7y agoThank you. In the spirit of full disclosure, I'm not successful in following a 100% vegan diet myself. I still get fried chicken with my significant other (who follows a normal Western diet) sometimes, as a guilty comfort food when I'm struggling mentally or especially stressed. I still eat mayonnaise and margarine when I'm visiting my parents, because I don't want to hassle them to buy the vegan variants just for me, and I decide that I am willing to use those products occasionally, knowing the suffering that went into them. Very few people are 100% perfect in following their chosen diet - vegan, vegetarian, keto, weight-loss, etc. The important part is to try your best, and bear in mind the consequences of what you're consuming.
- im3w1l 7y agoAnother point of view is that slaughter is "special" and while permitted requires us to to be respectful and make good use of the meat and bones.
- bronzeage 7y agoThis is the breakdown of capitalism as a resource-routing mechanism. On the one hand, a vital resource with much needed demand. On the other hand, someone having to throw that resource away at a cost. I'm pretty sure people starving would volunteer to take animals away, but after the whole process was optimized to the cents before the crisis, there is just no room for flexibility during the crisis.
- digi59404 7y agoThis isn't capitalism. Capitalism would mean that instead of culling these animals, The farms would be able to butcher and sell the resources to people nearby and far. But instead, They're prohibited from doing so by hundreds if not thousands of laws. This is more like Corporate-Capitalism, or Crony-Capitalism, or I don't even know. But it's not just Capitalism.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoI'm not sure whether it's capitalism at fault here, or not. For example, the EU is far from a communist utopia but so far I haven't heard anything about farm animals being culled over here. That's certainly not because we lack industrial farming. I don't pretend to understand how industrial farming processes work and I wouldn't be surprised if the same news surfaces about the EU soon, but so far that's not been on the radar. So it's still possible that two capitalist economies can manage their resources in different ways. To be honest I think we should also challenge the assumption that capitalism is incompatible with sustainable production. For example, wikipedia tells me that "Capitalism is an economic system based on the private ownership of the means of production and their operation for profit". I think most people living in the West today would not consider private ownership and operation of the means of production to be directly responsible for, e.g. the destruction of the environment, or atrocities like the currently discussed cull of farm animals in the US. Different processes seem to be at play here. But I don't exactly have the knowledge to discuss this issue at depth. Edit: I'm 100% with you on the exasperation with the situation, whaterver caused it. It makes me want to pull my hair out just to think about it. People are starving and animals are being culled instead of being slaughtered to feed them. Because profit margins. That is the absolute pinnacle of stupidity.
- bborud 7y agoThis is a good opportunity to read up on the balance of livestock to wild animals in terms of sheer numbers and have a good think about what this means. (And in case someone thinks I'm a vegan here to lecture: last night's dinner was Boeuf Bourgignon cooked for 5 hours)
- TeMPOraL 7y agoFor the sake of the undercaffeinated among of us, could you elaborate a bit more on what it means?
- vzidex 7y agoI'm guessing they mean that the population of livestock is orders of magnitude greater than the population of wild (mammals and birds) animals on this planet. I forget the exact figures and am lazy to Google them, but I remember that cows, pigs, and chickens far outnumber even the population of people on this planet.
- bborud 7y agoI've seen various estimates over the years as well as various ways of measuring this. I think that the most useful is to look at the resource draw, which roughly is about biomass. I didn't post any numbers on purpose because I don't believe in just throwing out numbers that require a lot of context. I was being sincere when I said that "This is a good opportunity to read up...". One should spend some time trying to understand our footprint. But yes, our food completely dominates the picture. Many places in the world most mammalian wildlife is little more than a footnote. If this comes as a surprise to anyone, this makes me a bit upset and worried.
- gadders 7y agoYes, not the OP but Beef Bourguignon is a beef stew braised in red wine, often red Burgundy, and beef stock, generally flavoured with carrots, onions, garlic, and a bouquet garni, and garnished with pearl onions, mushrooms, and bacon.
- gdubs 7y agoI was reading Carl Sagan’s “Dragons of Eden” years ago and realized that while humans may have intellect, emotionally we’re very similar to other animals. Then I had the thought: when it comes to being slaughtered, what’s worse; having an intellect, or having emotion? I know that if I were subjected to confinement and ultimately slaughter, it would be my emotional response — not my intellect — which would define my experience. The universe eats itself and I’m not really qualified to make a moral judgement on killing animals for food — I’m particularly loathe to make black and white judgements. But, I’m able to eat a mostly vegan diet, and so that’s what I do.