6 ms·
It's so sad that OP bothered to benchmark Nim and Crystal, but no Rust.
by zozbot234 7y ago
It's so sad that OP bothered to benchmark Nim and Crystal, but no Rust.
- stolen_biscuit 7y agoIs Rust really high level?
- pasquinelli 7y agoto me a language is low level if variables are memory addresses and flow is controlled with jumps.
- sfkdjf9j3j 7y agoI think you could make that argument, although it might involve using Arc<T> for everything
- TylerE 7y agoI wouldn't. Rust is WAY too much ceremony to qualify as high level.
- amalcon 7y agoOnce upon a time, "high level" unambiguously meant higher than assembly language. A smallish fraction of the population still uses it that way.
- eximius 7y agoI would qualify a language as high level if you're not expected to deal with pointers in 'normal' use. Yes, Rust has pointers, but using them is NOT normal. C/C++/C#/D, etc are not high level by this criteria. There are also of course degrees to all this. Rust is lower level than a lot of languages by virtue of having native pointer uses, even if it's frowned on. There's also something to be said for language features, but I can't quite put my finger on it.
- catblast 7y agoThe difference between pointers and references can easily become muddled. If you have a language with pointers that are non-nullable, type- and memory-safe, is that not high-level? I think a good real-world example that exposes the problem in your definition is Go. Go has pointers, using them is normal. However, go does not pointer arithmetic and outside of unsafe (like Rust) they are memory safe. I consider golang to be higher level than C/C++ for this reason, and many others (GC, channels, defer, etc, etc) -- I'd also consider it lower-level because of its non-answer/cop-out to error-handling. But what is special about pointers compared to references? If you have a language with pointers that are type-safe and memory-safe how is this distinctive?
- eximius 7y agoI mean, even Python has references to variables. You can't escape references (as opposed to values). The difference is one of model. Pointers are an exposure of the underlying computer architecture. Whereas references are more of a property of common language design. In theory, you could not have pointers but still have references.
- catblast 7y ago> Pointers are an exposure of the underlying computer architecture. Whereas references are more of a property of common language design. Sorry, I just don't follow. How are the pointers in Go more exposing of the underlying architecture than a reference? (I'm using Go as an example to make it concrete, but any language with similar properties will do). The syntax and some of the semantics of assignment and rebinding are different between say go pointers and python references, but that's the point I'm contesting, I don't see how one is necessarily higher level than the other. If you put automatic memory management, null pointer checks, removal of any "undefined behavior", pointers aren't necessarily low-level. It wasn't the pointer, it was the memory safety. I personally think that once you tease it out that it becomes a semantics argument that unfortunately doesn't shed much light on what is "high-level".
- nyanpasu64 7y ago
- ginko 7y agoEven C is a high level language.
- Measter 7y agoIt can really depend how you write it. In some instances you can just throw things together and it can look a fair bit like you might write it in what many would consider high level languages. On the other hand, there are times when you really need to get into the nitty gritty of things for performance reasons, and it ends up feeling quite low level. For example, here's a Rust program which does the same as fqcnt_py1_4l.py: https://gist.github.com/Measter/d31abe88b5e318ba98856bf6f047ef19 https://gist.github.com/Measter/d31abe88b5e318ba98856bf6f047... It's longer than the Python version[0], I'm going out of my way to not allocate for every string. But, and maybe I'm biased here, it doesn't really feel like it's low-level code. [0] https://github.com/lh3/biofast/blob/master/fqcnt/fqcnt_py1_4l.py https://github.com/lh3/biofast/blob/master/fqcnt/fqcnt_py1_4...
- 0xDEEPFAC 7y agoI second you and raise you Ada and C++. C is the furthest thing from a high-level programming languages there is... Comparing scripting languages to compiled languages is apples and oranges. The advantage of scripting is supposed to be the convenience - not speed.
- VWWHFSfQ 7y ago> C is the furthest thing from a high-level programming languages there is how times have changed
- pasquinelli 7y agoi think there needs to be a new set of terms. ah, that probably wouldn't help, because people would then mismatch eachother's idea of what terms mean and which set of terms correspond to which ideas. still, if people are calling c low level then what should assembly be called?
- hexaga 7y agoImo the problem is that 'high' is a relative term. It's calibrated according to whatever the commonly used abstraction level is for the term-speaker. The other problem is that level doesn't really mean anything, or it means something different in each language. Is it feature count? Abstraction potential? Memory-addressed vs objects? Statically or dynamically typed? Closeness of fit to the machine it's running on (imagine a lisp on a lisp machine, or x86 on an emulator - is that high or low level?)? Etc.
- pasquinelli 7y agoIf "level" is ill-defined then low and high aren't relative terms, they're meaningless. But there is a lowest either way, the machine code. Then high level programming languages have the programmer writing code in a model independent of machine architecture. Those models are't one dimensional, so let's not bother trying to put them in order from low to high, let's talk about their features. That's how i'd have it if it were for me to decide, but this isn't how language evolves.
- hawski 7y agoOP had a specific high-levelness in mind, that Rust does not fall into. C is provided as performance baseline, which is a common benchmark. The languages are compared against Python - Nim and Crystal are closer to Python than Rust. For example GC is a requirement at language level implied by the author. Rust is cool, but it does not have a horse in this race I'm afraid.