6 ms·
You really trust the US court system to be impartial? Should Apple/Google be forced to carry pornographic apps? White supremacists apps? Apps that invade peopl
by scarface74 7y ago
You really trust the US court system to be impartial?
Should Apple/Google be forced to carry pornographic apps? White supremacists apps? Apps that invade people’s privacy? Which government should hold this responsibility? Should we have an international committee deciding this?
- bzb3 7y agoYes, as per https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23221497 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23221497
- scarface74 7y agoThey are all considered “natural monopolies”. They are also regulated on the municipal level. Do you now want each city to regulate apps? Why stop there? Why not regulate what console makers can sell? every physical store can sell?
- bzb3 7y agoIn my country >90% of smartphone users have Android. Yes I would call that a monopoly. Yes I think monopolies should be regulated. Not at the city level since that's ridiculous and sounds like a strawman. That comment was just an example of monopolies that need to be regulated.
- scarface74 7y agoIsn’t the whole beauty of Android that it is “open” and that you can sideload apps and you are not beholden to a “walled garden”?
- falcolas 7y agoAs Epic found out, not if you want to remain on Google's good side. They were facing sanctions from Google due to their sideloading of Fortnight onto Android phones and tablets.
- scarface74 7y agoWhat “sanctions” were they facing? They were called out because their app was a security nightmare. https://www.cnet.com/news/fortnites-battle-royale-with-android-security-problems-is-just-getting-started/ https://www.cnet.com/news/fortnites-battle-royale-with-andro...
- efreak 7y agoMy understanding is that the "vulnerability" here also exists on every computer or other device on which you download an installer to a public folder--any application can watch that folder and silently replace the file with another when the download completes. There's nothing special about that. Android has a secure internal storage area--but internal storage is often limited. It's gotten better, but my previous phone only had 8gb for both the OS and data to share.
- heinrichhartman 7y agoI am not talking the US in particular here. I am saying these decisions should be made by courts not by private institutions, that have stakes in that game.
- scarface74 7y agoSo instead of being made by private companies, they should be made by unelected partisan judges....
- heinrichhartman 7y agoNo?
- scarface74 7y agoThat’s exactly the choice you make in the US.
- heinrichhartman 7y agoI am not talking about any particular existing nation state. I am saying that the problems we are experiencing could be solved by having some form of "constituted digital public spaces and platforms". I am well aware of the practical difficulties in establishing these. But it's our inability to create those spaces that is hurting us here.
- chroem- 7y agoPlease stop. The more we play this tit-for-tat game of political point scoring, the more it causes the whole system to degenerate. It is corrupting every facet of our society, to the point at which we're no longer able to be objective about life and death matters like the current pandemic.
- hoorayimhelping 7y agoYou stop. Stop using $current_panic to justify trampling the parts of the constitution and the parts of the system you don't like. These are legitimate questions that need to be answered or we'll just be in a worse place in the future. It's so transparent; any time there's some crisis, whether it's terrorism or guns or drugs or a pandemic, there are always people calling for us to ignore the actual issues of our system and ram some "fix" through because this time, no seriously, this time it's life or death and we have to act.
- chroem- 7y ago? I'm largely agreeing with you. My only point is that we shouldn't allow courts and corporations to become politicized.
- scarface74 7y agoIsn’t it a little - like 200+ years - late for that?
- chroem- 7y agoWe're approaching levels of hyperpartisanship not seen since the civil war. I don't think this is a healthy state of being for our country.
- scarface74 7y agoYou think we all got together and sung Kum Bah Yah after the Civil War? Are you forgetting about the segregation? The Civil Rights Movement? Vietnam?
- rukittenme 7y ago> Should Apple/Google be forced to carry pornographic apps? White supremacists apps? Apps that invade people’s privacy? My computer allows racist pornography and its the greatest invention in the history of mankind. As far as I can tell, iPhones have not lived up to that legacy.
- scarface74 7y agoYes, but should Apple be forced to sell it? You can buy a DVD player and a TV from Walmart that allows you to view pornographic and racist content but aren’t forced to sell it.
- rukittenme 7y agoApple preventing the sale of a product != Apple not selling a product. I don't ask Apple for permission to visit a website on my iPhone. Why should I ask their permission to install applications? Would it be so awful if I were allowed to run my own software?
- scarface74 7y agoBut you don’t have to ask Google permission to install software. So why are people asking for intervention in this case? Choice is amazing. You had a choice to buy into Apple’s “walled garden” or buy an Android. You didn’t need the nanny state to make that choice for you.
- cft 7y agoYou sort of do: before you sideload an app, you have to toggle a switch, agreeing that you are going to do something potentially unsafe. In the similar arrogant manner, they care about your safety purging Podcast Addict app, like parenting you. The best solution would be an emergence of an Android fork and the corresponding platform, but this seems unlikely due to enormous (as in 100bn perhaps) startup capital required. Do you propose any other constructive solutions?
- falcolas 7y agoI expect them to be more impartial than a multinational for-profit company whose stakeholders care about little other than their bottom line. Pornography and hate speech have plenty of legal precedent. And if I'm honest, if it's legal in a given country, why shouldn't it be available?
- scarface74 7y agoAre you paying attention to the actions of the modern judicial system in the US that votes along party lines? You really think that judges with their own religious and political biases and with lifetime appointments “care about you”?
- falcolas 7y agoBy that same token, are you paying attention to the actions being taken by Google, Facebook, Twitter, and Amazon? There are no clean actors here, but the difference between the judicial system and the big companies is that the judicial system has people who care about more than just profits.
- scarface74 7y agoIt’s even worse. They care about their own ideologies that are often at odds with mine. The difference is that it is much easier to not be beholden to the private corporations you mentioned than the government. Private corporations don’t have the power of the state to take away my liberty, property or life.
- falcolas 7y agoYou do realize the context of this conversation, correct? We're not talking about your liberty, property, or life. We're talking about apps on a smartphone or tablet. > Private corporations don’t have the power [] to take away my liberty, property or life. No, they can only demand you come in for overtime, require you to move where they want you to, or force you to come in while sick, at the risk of taking away your job. A risk which is minor for some of us, but which is the equivalent of a threat of homelessness for others.
- FireBeyond 7y ago> Should Apple/Google be forced to carry pornographic apps? White supremacists apps? Apps that invade people’s privacy? Which government should hold this responsibility? Should we have an international committee deciding this? We already have a situation in which two companies effectively decide what can go on anyone's cellphone (sideloading is not and will not be a meaningful solution for any more than a fraction of a percent of users).
- scarface74 7y agoWhy isn’t side loading viable for Android users?
- a1369209993 7y agoYes, yes, provided they're labeled properly, all of them, and no, respectively. Edit: I guess the first two could use some labels as well, provided the labels aren't legible to parental controls or other nannyware.