9 ms·
It's no surprise that a couple of economists might disagree about it: The definition of the American Dream isn't one upon which everyone would agree to begin wi
by ineedasername 7y ago
It's no surprise that a couple of economists might disagree about it: The definition of the American Dream isn't one upon which everyone would agree to begin with. However, a common theme is something like social/economic mobility without regard to circumstances of birth. And to that extent, it would be hard to argue that the American Dream has been universally available to all Americans at most points in our history.
- sokoloff 7y agoI would argue that perfect social/economic mobility is probably not only unattainable but perhaps even undesirable. It should be high, such that gifted children of any background can flourish, but should almost surely fall short of whatever 100% “everyone draws straws” perfectly uncorrelated would be. I believe that raising the next generation is our most solemn obligation as parents. It seems overwhelmingly likely that this would confer some benefit to the more well-to-do that cannot be entirely eliminated short of universal boarding schools and even that might not be enough. Why do children of professors grow up to be professors, doctors to doctors, plumbers to plumbers, etc? I’m sure there’s some genetic component, but I suspect the overwhelming influence is what they experienced and how they were raised. When I was growing up, both my parents were teachers and at some young age, I just assumed that literally every adult was a teacher. It was the only job I knew and saw daily. I believe that having and even encouraging parents to strive, scrimp, save, and sacrifice for their children is an overall positive force for society. My parents benefited greatly from it, as did I, as will my kids. If you took the actions required to make outcomes totally uncorrelated, I think you’d remove a lot of this sacrifice and effort that society benefits from when parents raise their kids to be “better off” than they were.
- badrabbit 7y agoSo being "gifted" should factor in? What if I and many others care about character and empathy much more than any intellectual capacity? It's always been the idea and should be that those who do right,act honest and work hard even if they don't work smart, should have upward mobility, as in regardless of birth you can enter the lower mid-class tier. Obviously your talent and skill should and would determine your mobility to upper and upper-middle class.
- sokoloff 7y agoThat was just one example, but yes, I’d certainly hope that being particularly gifted in some dimension of life would factor in to outcomes. Maybe that’s having a cannon of a pitching arm, outstanding musical or singing ability, or particularly strong academic performance. Society benefits when the best scientists are working on science, the best mathematicians at math, the best musicians are performing, and even when the best athletes are playing pro sports. I’d like these talented people to be able to develop, showcase, and benefit from their talents without regard to who their parents are.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoAnd if you’re not exceptional in that narrow band kick rocks?
- sokoloff 7y agoIf you’re the average person, I think it’s reasonable to expect an average outcome. In the modern world that should still be quite an enjoyable life, but for self-evident reasons, I would not expect everyone to have an above-average life.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoYikes. Mask really coming off here. I hope those of us that didn't go to MIT like you have a place in this society.
- esotericn 7y agoHe's literally saying that a 49th percentile person will definitionally only be able to have a 49th percentile life under any system. Well, I suppose you could perform random shuffling. 50% of people will still end up with a below average outcome, though.
- 7y ago
- ineedasername 7y agoI was referring to people mostly or wholely denied such mobility regardless of aptitude.
- maxerickson 7y agoThe other way to look at this is that you are punishing children that draw parents that don't care. I think it's likely that society will probably work better with high mobility vs the random draw that "perfect" mobility requires, but that's a fuzzy feeling based on human groups being complex, not the distilled moralization that you are using. I suppose the less complicated discussion is about raising the baseline outcome being better than working to make outcomes the same. Raising the baseline is about absolute outcomes rather than relative outcomes, so the latter aren't as big a piece of the discussion.
- papeda 7y agoI'm not sure random draws are even better from a zoomed-out "total welfare" score. People get lot of value from preparing for the future and believing good things will probably happen, especially when it comes to their kids. The random straws outcome makes that impossible. That's a lot of utility to leave on the table. The flip side is that parents who could not ordinarily build for their kids' futures might feel better. I wonder if that's enough to compensate.
- maxerickson 7y agoYes, my second paragraph is addressing random draws probably not being ideal. But I'm saying that I think that because humans and groups of humans are complicated, not just because I think it's important to reward parents that value and plan for their children's future.
- pessimizer 7y ago> you are punishing children that draw parents that don't care. Worse: you are punishing poor children who don't draw parents who sacrifice everything until they rest in an early grave, while rich children who have parents who don't remember how many kids they have after a few drinks get every opportunity in the world. This is a specifically middle-class moralization that defines merit as the product of the ability to suffer and "giftedness," and measures merit by looking at outcomes.
- 7y ago
- pessimizer 7y ago> society benefits from when parents raise their kids to be “better off” than they were. Society doesn't benefit from this. Low-status jobs still have to be filled, at least until technology eliminates them. Making sure that your kids aren't the ones that do them isn't a benefit to anyone but you and your kids. > I believe that having and even encouraging parents to strive, scrimp, save, and sacrifice for their children is an overall positive force for society. This is less a thing that doctors have to do than a thing that plumbers have to do.
- zozbot234 7y agoLow-status jobs are low-status because they don't really need to be filled, at least not at the current margin. Seeking a "high-status" job, for oneself or one's kids, is by and large a socially-beneficial activity.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- freepor 7y agoNot sure about that. Plumbers make a lot of money.
- derrick_jensen 7y ago>Society doesn't benefit from this. Low-status jobs still have to be filled, at least until technology eliminates them. Its purely additive. Being well off doesn't mean you can't do these jobs, just that better options are available. Market forces will make the pay desirable if they are needed more than they currently are. >This is less a thing that doctors have to do than a thing that plumbers have to do. Sure, but it doesn't change the fact it's a good idea. I'd even argue that most blue collar jobs, in having less obligations and a more clock-in-clock-out mentality, frees up parents to spend more time with their children.
- throwphoton 7y agoWhy should society accommodate "the gifted" instead of the other way around? Highly talented individuals almost intrinsically less in need of society's assistance.
- sokoloff 7y agoI want a poor, black child with outstanding talent to be able to have that talent identified, nurtured, developed, and maximized. Based on what I see in my fairly progressive town (Cambridge, MA), I don’t think we’ve gotten to even this basic level of equality of opportunity. It is not about society’s accommodation/assistance of specifically the gifted but rather about ensuring that people of all conditions can develop their potential. Society should care about this because it’s the long-term flywheel that improves the human condition. The pie can get bigger, too. It’s not just about dividing a fixed pie most evenly.
- esotericn 7y agoBecause society needs their assistance. The alternative is that you end up with nonsense like hungry grads working at FAANG to fuck the world. Channeling people into useful pursuits pays dividends.
- leetcrew 7y agowhy should "the gifted" accommodate society if it intends to give them nothing in return for their excess productivity?
- 1996 7y agoI agree on the basics, but society provides 2 things: a very comfortable salary to get good and services, but even more important than that: it alleges boredom The practical world is full of interesting problems. Gifted humans need to really feel useful (to put their gift at use) more than they need the matching income.
- leetcrew 7y agothere's a lot of evidence in the open source community that people don't necessarily need to be paid (a lot or at all) to do work they find interesting. it's great that some people are willing to do this, but I don't think it's fair in general for society to benefit from the work and have the only reward be the satisfaction of a job well done, unless the people doing the work are okay with that. furthermore, there may be a lot of overlap between useful/important and interesting work, but I doubt they map perfectly. there probably needs to be some material reward for important work so that it gets done even if it's boring. I certainly don't think we have a great state of affairs today. some people get paid huge amounts of money to do work that I feel is harmful. imo the goal should be to take care of everyone's basic needs, but also to reward people proportionately for their contribution to society.
- unclebucknasty 7y ago>I believe that having and even encouraging parents to strive, scrimp, save, and sacrifice for their children is an overall positive force for society Compared to what? Doesn't society most benefit from members who are fulfilled via actualization of their potential? Wouldn't that mean more content people and more contributions to society? Is requiring parents to "scrimp, save, and sacrifice" really the optimal design for achieving this?
- whiddershins 7y agoI don't think anyone has ever said that it was universally available. What we tend to hope is true, is that the percentage of our population it applies to is growing, not shrinking.
- Swizec 7y agoAs someone who left a lower middle class upbringing in formerly communist Europe and arrived at upper middle class coastal USA life ... eh it’s doable. People are just lazy and like to bitch and moan and avoid responsibility for their lives.
- willis936 7y agoSpoken like someone who has no idea what they’re talking about.
- Swizec 7y agoHow so? I’m living proof that you can still pull off the social mobility part of the american dream. Arrived in this country with some $3000 to my name, now here we are 5 years later I am little different than any other spoiled coastal US person.
- willis936 7y agoYes. I believe that someone rich enough to move from Russia (and the correct ethnicity) had only $3000. In those 5 years you also spent $100,000 on an education so that you could get a job that paid you well? Was an education not part of the “$3,000” or are you saying the American Dream is to be very white, gamble with your life, and be very lucky?
- throwlaplace 7y agoyou're a white guy that moved from slovenia with a degree already and $3000 in cash. slovenia isn't moldova or romania or ukraine - gdp per capita ppp is 36k. your $3000 is twice the median savings of black people and hispanics in this country https://www.valuepenguin.com/banking/average-savings-account-balance#median-savings-balance-by-race https://www.valuepenguin.com/banking/average-savings-account... what social mobility? you were middle class and you're still middle class my family actually immigrated as poor people (refugees) 30 years ago from a shit country (moldova) and we're all doing very well in tech now but that doesn't mean i'm blind to the inequalities faced by systematically marginalized people.
- mc32 7y agoI think the dream has a couple of faces. One is the one marketed by companies interested in consumerists. They want the aspirational aspect so that people reach every further to attain this kind of goal. The other is the vision people in whose parents didn’t have it all but their children aspire to be more and to be part of the first class of dreamers. Now, part of this other aspect is that for many it’s a kind of dream. We wish it, but we may not achieve it this generation either, but maybe next. That said, if enough people achieve this dream, the dram is fulfilled and there are no more dreamers because they’re all fat cats now.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoBoth economists largely agree with your given definition, and both agree that it is flagging. They disagree on the cause and subsequent attempt to reverse the trend.
- nickysielicki 7y agoMy grandfather (still alive) had his Polish village burned down and he found himself doing forced labor in Germany during WWII at the age of 14. Not only was there not much to return to, the borders were redrawn and his previous hometown wasn't even in a country that he held citizenship in. He came to the US and worked in the forges for Falk in Milwaukee. He didn't speak English, but he worked hard, lived responsibly, and paid for the education of his two children. My dad became an electrical engineer, and my uncle got a doctorate in veterinary medicine and owned a clinic. Going a generation further, me and all my siblings have college degrees from great schools. This whole story plays out from 1940 to the present day. I'm just trying to understand where it is that my family got lucky, and why I should feel sour about this country and the opportunities it gave us. Where else on Earth is this possible? How did we get so lucky, and why is everyone so sure that it wasn't just that we worked hard and had the right priorities? “The ~Christian Ideal~ American Dream has not been tried and found wanting. It has been found difficult; and left untried.”
- dragonwriter 7y ago> I'm just trying to understand where it is that my family got lucky Between the inputs and the outputs. For example: > He came to the US and worked in the forges for Falk in Milwaukee. He didn't speak English, but he worked hard, lived responsibly, and paid for the education of his two children Plenty of people at the same time put the same inputs of hard work and responsible living in, and got different outcomes due to forces they didn't control. The success of American elites (this is true of capitalism generally, and the greater prosperity of American capitalists compared to much of the rest of the developed West is due specifically to failing tomitigate this aspect of capitalism as much) is built on the precarious position of the working class.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bsder 7y agoThe issue is that there is NO job today for that immigrant who doesn't speak English--let alone one that supports a family in this day and age--let alone one that pays for college. And why should you feel sour? There is nothing wrong with being lucky. However, the problem is that too many lucky people assume that their result is due to work rather than luck and then attribute a lack of result to a lack of work instead of a lack of luck. This is akin to winning the lottery jackpot and then blaming other people not hitting the lottery because they just didn't buy enough tickets rather than the odds being explicitly stacked against them.