17 ms·
Tesla says it has health official's OK to run California plant
- jennyyang 7y agoIf health care workers can't avoid getting themselves infected, even though they have expertise and training, there is no way that Tesla will be able to prevent the virus from spreading within the factory. It's a ticking time bomb at this point, just like the meat packing plants and the other factories that have spread the disease. Once a single person with COVID-19 comes into the Tesla plant, it's guaranteed to spread like wildfire. Things like social distancing is merely a tactic to slow the spread down, but it won't actually help you if someone 6 ft from you has COVID-19 and is breathing vigorously or is eating lunch 6 ft from you. If Musk isn't right there on the factory line among the workers and endangering his life along with the workers that he is forcing to come work for him, then I will lose a tremendous amount of respect for him. If anything, this should be a good opportunity for the factory workers to unionize and demand better treatment.
- duaoebg 7y agoIt is weird to me to see people treating the 6ft like a hard barrier rather than a probabilistic guideline.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoPeople don't understand the underlying mechanisms and assumptions that lead to the rule of thumb being what it is so they follow the rule of thumb religiously as if it guarantees everything will turn out alright. If you look you'll see this behavior across a wide range of issues.
- duxup 7y agoAlmost any societal level health policy, about breast cancer screening, colonoscopy recommendations, or whatever... people misunderstand all the time and announce "well that's because it's not effective under X circumstance". It's always hard to explain, and then after explaining the probability stuff ... you get to explain that it is the probability ... that we know of. For anyone who wants hard facts on COVID-19... science will tell us in 2 or 3 years I suspect.
- alexandros 7y agoTesla has run a factory in Shanghai post-COVID, so far as we know successfully. Also most if not all the other car factories in the US are already operating. Also workers aren't forced to come in. This focus on Tesla is not taking into account all the data equally, unless folks are also outraged at every other factory in the US.
- gamblor956 7y agoMultiple reports indicate that Tesla workers were told to report to work last week or be fired, and that if they were fired for not showing up, Tesla would not let them claim COVID19 as a reason for their termination (which is a $600/week difference in unemployment benefits for the next 6 weeks). There was no outrage about other factories because most US factories use more automation than Tesla and workers are generally spaced more than 6 feet apart at "stations" on the assembly line. (See, e.g., the General Mills factories where cereal is made, any other US automaker, etc.)
- natch 7y ago>Tesla said employees were told to report to work or be fired. Bullshit. You are confusing different activities that involve not getting paid. Not showing up for work, the person doesn't get paid, and contrary to your claim (there are no such "multiple reports" unless you are counting reddit comments?) Tesla is being nice and not firing them, but instead putting them on unpaid leave so their job is actually held open for a while. Not even the same ballpark as fired. Yes there are consequences for unemployment since their job is available to them should they want to do it. This is by law, not Tesla's doing. They aren't terminated by the way… another word for fired… just on unpaid leave, again. >workers are generally spaced more than 6 feet apart That's also the case at the Fremont factory.
- javagram 7y ago> Yes there are consequences for unemployment since their job is available to them should they want to do it. This is by law, not Tesla's doing Except it was illegal for Tesla to be opening up early against health department orders, so it seems likely that the law would actually be on the employee’s side. Terminating an employee for refusing to violate lawful government orders is illegal. Of course, non-unionized factory workers at Tesla may very well not have a lawyer on retainer to consult about this and might feel forced by Tesla’s unlawful threat to go in anyway...
- m0zg 7y agoHe's not "forcing" anyone to come in IIRC. Workers can remain furloughed if they'd like. It's just that out in the real world, people need to work in order to survive.
- mikeyouse 7y ago"Come in or lose your unemployment benefits" isn't a choice in any sense of the word. It's a shame we've done so poorly at managing this virus and have provided so little support for people who choose to prioritize their health.
- m0zg 7y agoBe that as it may, the fundamental fact of the situation is that money does not grow on trees and unemployment benefits don't really work if you have double digit percentage of the unemployed. It especially doesn't work if, by closing the factory, you're putting all of its supply chain out of work as well. Also, in order for there to be stuff, someone has to make stuff.
- mikeyouse 7y agoSadly, this is a uniquely American failing. If you can't provide supports for people during a once-in-a-generation pandemic but have no problem taking out $20 Trillion in debt during normal times, things are seriously broken.
- m0zg 7y agoI think you will soon discover that it's not a "uniquely American failing", but a fact of life that applies everywhere. I don't see how it's even up for debate that you can't stop the economy for six months and avoid severe repercussions, including deaths, for years to come, and that the government can't just will the stuff (food, goods) into existence with no work required from the population.
- 6y ago
- AlchemistCamp 7y agoWhy are you so sure? They're using the same protocols they did for the Shanghai gigafactory.
- almost_usual 7y agoThe repercussions for not following protocol in Shanghai is probably a bit different than Alameda County..
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoWhat's your alternative proposal? I'm optimistic Tesla can manage it, but I'm not sure what it implies if they can't - do you think we should just keep factories closed forever?
- skuhn 7y agoThey should keep factories closed, unless they are engaged in solving one of the four problems that need to be solved in order for things to safely re-open: 1. Producing masks, gloves, face shields 2. Producing tests or test supplies (cotton swabs, reagents, etc.) 3. Things related to contact tracing (not sure what material goods this would need off-hand) 4. Vaccine research (again, nothing they could do) The choice is not between re-open now or never re-open. If we actually had at least the first 3 things above, re-opening could be done in a controlled and safe manner. We still don't have those things, months later.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoAlameda County says it has those things.
- pmiller2 7y agoThere are more places than Alameda County that need those things.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoCertainly true! I hope those places get what they need soon. But if Alameda County can safely start reopening before them, I don't see any value in waiting.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pmiller2 7y ago
- TMWNN 7y agoAs alexandros said, there is nothing special about the Tesla factory operating as opposed to any other company's. The only difference is that Alameda County opposed the factory reopening. Not the city of Fremont, not the state of California, not the federal government. It was the county that held its reopening up.
- new_realist 7y agoThe county didn’t oppose a reopening; if anything, Tesla is being given more favorable treatment because they are a big employer, to the point where the county is turning a blind eye to willful flouting of the law. The state gave discretion to the county and the county was enforcing a standard that Elon didn’t want to follow, or else wanted to stage a scene to justify his inevitable relocation to a state with cheaper labor. Now we’re back to the original county schedule.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoTesla, being designated critical infrastructure like all vehicle manufactures per federal guidelines, should have never had to battle it out with county bureaucracy in the first place.
- Talanes 7y ago"CISA's Identifying Critical Infrastructure During COVID-19 guidance and accompanying list are intended to support state, local, and industry partners in identifying the critical infrastructure sectors and the essential workers." Not even recommended guidance, just advisory. AKA "Here's a one size fits all list we expect you to tailor to your particular situation."
- javagram 7y agoPlenty of other car manufacturers were shut down too - Ford, GM, Toyota, basically all of Tesla’s competitors as I understand it across different states not just in California. For instance, here is a story about a Toyota plant in Texas being closed between March and May. https://www.expressnews.com/business/article/Toyota-again-pushes-back-plant-reopening-15235161.php https://www.expressnews.com/business/article/Toyota-again-pu... Never mind that “federal guidelines” have no legal relevance to county or state health orders. The US constitution leaves police power, including quarantine orders, to the discretion of the states.
- koolba 7y ago> If health care workers can't avoid getting themselves infected, even though they have expertise and training, there is no way that Tesla will be able to prevent the virus from spreading within the factory. Health workers are literally hands on infected people coughing in their face. They also have infected people literally delivered to them. It’s apples and oranges.
- new_realist 7y agoHealth care workers are also trained to avoid infection, wash and sterilize every few minutes, and are covered head-to-toe in protective equipment.
- Retric 7y agoMedical workers are generally using basic protection well, but their not walking around in BSL-4 bunny suits. Such methods might be 99% effective, but encounter 10,000x as many viruses and the risks are still significantly worse.
- malwarebytess 7y agoThe objective probably isn't to stop all infections. It's not possible. You act as if this is some kind of a death sentence virus, when in fact for the vast majority of people it isn't a serious illness.
- rgbrenner 7y agoIMO there's a lot to dislike about Elons handling of this.. but the conditions are different than a meat packing plant. This is a meat packing plant: https://postmediacalgaryherald2.files.wordpress.com/2020/03/cal0729-jbsplant-copy.jpg https://postmediacalgaryherald2.files.wordpress.com/2020/03/... Shoulder to shoulder all day long. Those are their stations for their entire shift. Notice also: no masks. And because they've been deemed a critical industry, they aren't necessarily getting masks now either. So no distancing, and no masks. These are also very poorly paid jobs, and it would be unusual if they had health insurance or paid time off. It's pretty much the perfect conditions for covid. Cars tend to be a bit bigger than chickens.. so in a car factory, the workers are usually more than 6 ft apart.
- m463 7y agoI wonder what the realities of the tesla factories are. I've considered taking a tour. All the images I've seen are dominated by large robotic arms with people sparsely sprinkled throughout.
- dannyw 7y agoThe reality is that the coronavirus isn't going away. We need to minimise the risk, i.e. slow the spread down; that's why we do social distancing. Every day and every part of life, we balance safety with living life. Public health is no different: it is a balance, not an extremist view that we must eradicate COVID at all costs. We cannot shut down non-essential until there's a vaccine. That's just not possible. All work is essential, and public governments can't print money forever (without hyperinflation).
- cma 7y agoAll work is not essential.
- rdtwo 7y agoIf Tesla can reopen so should everyone else. Why do those taxpayer leachfucks get a special exemption.
- dang 7y agoCould you please follow the site guidelines when posting here? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- new_realist 7y agoSo, Tesla can legally open according to the original county timeline, before Elon’s hissy fit, even though in actuality they’ve been producing cars for Europe and China for a week.
- willio58 7y agoThey opened earlier, right after Elon’s tweet.
- new_realist 7y agoI meant legally.
- pmorici 7y agoIt's unclear that the county was planning to follow this "original" timeline until after public pressure brought about by Elon's tweets. At this point it's impossible to tell if that are simply saving face.
- gamblor956 7y agoThis is a false narrative. The original timeline was always to reopen certain businesses May 18th, since the first extensions of the lockdowns were to expire on May 15th, and as demonstrated by the entire rest of the state opening up according to that schedule without anyone else throwing a tantrum. Also, the county doesn't need to do anything to save face. They have nothing to prove. The elected officials can always say they were acting on the information of health experts, and the health experts can always point to the CDC, China, and even the re-emerging outbreaks in Wuhan, Italy, and Germany as reasons for not allowing Tesla to restart operations ahead of schedule and before Tesla had demonstrated they were willing to protect their workers.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoAlameda County has announced they're moving into Phase 2 this week, which means basically everyone other than restaurants and public gathering spaces can reopen.
- dmix 7y agoAlameda County is also dropping faster than other parts of California: https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/05/17/coronavirus-new-cases-drop-in-alameda-county-rise-elsewhere-in-bay-area/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/05/17/coronavirus-new-cases... 33 cases today, region of 1.6M people.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoAmerican case counts tend to show extreme day-of-week effects, with Sundays consistently being the lowest, so I wouldn't necessarily extrapolate from today's numbers.
- falcolas 7y agoDriving disease-prevention policies based on an infection indicator that lags by at least 7 days is like day-trading stocks based on last month’s headlines.
- mehrdadn 7y agoIn what sense are the cases "dropping"? When I go to the "Daily" tab of "Alameda County Total Daily Cases", it's literally the same as 1 week ago (33 people on the 10th, and now on the 16th). See https://imgur.com/a/XTGzpVk https://imgur.com/a/XTGzpVk and https://www.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/1e0ac4385cbe4cc1bffe2cf7f8e7f0d9 https://www.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/1e0ac43.... I'm struggling to see a downward trend.
- usaar333 7y agoA single day means nothing - there's high daily variance just from reporting issues and test sites not being open on weekends. Alemada County is alright by California standards, but is the worse performing Bay Area county (hospitalizations are flat for a month, rather than dropping like its neighbors). And 33 a day for 1.6m people is actually on the high side by northern California standards. (As a point of comparison, Santa Clara is at about 15 a day for 1.9 million)
- tito 7y agoAnyone else out there surprised to see Elon "zag" so badly on COVID, including this? I've always been impressed by his agility with ideas, zigging and zagging and I've been there cheering him on. But on this one it seems like he....went off the cliff, Wiley E. Coyote style.
- FriendlyNormie 7y agoKill yourself.
- tachyonbeam 7y agoI think part of it might be that he's a really high energy kind of person, working 12-18 hour days everyday. Being forced to stay quarantined, to stop his life's work, probably drives him insane. He really wants to progress on his projects, which he considers to be very important for the future of mankind (which, let's face it, they could be). Besides that, he's a contrarian. With COVID, we're faced with a situation where there is an extremely strong pressure to conform. There's one narrative being pushed and there's no real dialogue. Elon has a contrarian narrative: our basic human rights have been taken away (freedom of movement, etc) in the name of the greater collective good. He argues that people should be given the tools to help protect themselves but that the government should leave it up to individuals to decide how they manage this. I tend to agree with him. We're told a vaccine could be two years away (or may never come). The fatality rate in my age group is about the same as the flu. I happen to be single, and at the moment, where I'm living, if I have a date with someone, I could technically be fined $1500 (and there have been a few reports of people going on tinder dates who have been). Since when has it been the government's business to legislate in these sorts of matters? I have been making efforts to socially isolate, but it's pushed me into a depression, I started taking antidepressants a month ago. I know two of my friends have done the same.
- pvg 7y agoSince when has it been the government's business Weighing things like the lives of others vs a small disruption in your sex life seems right up government's (organized society's in general, even) alley.
- hbogert 7y agoI read 'california plant' as a euphemism for weed. Do these really cramped titles also read very ambiguous for native english speakers at times?
- TLightful 7y agoLOL .... gave me a good chuckle. Thanks.
- thdrdt 7y agoThere seems to be more going on here. The Tesla California plant has a very bad record when it comes to safety issues. California helped Tesla by looking the other way because they knew the company was starting and that they are very valuable for California. And then Elon called them fascist because he could not open up the factory due to the virus. Of course officials then would like to approve the safety standards before opening up the factory again. On the other hand nothing is going on here. The county already wanted to open up the businesses. Elon lost a lot respect in all this. Maybe he has a lot on his mind like becoming a father again, the virus, selling all his properties, wanting to go to mars earlier than possible, his brain implant project, and so on. To me he sounds a little exhausted. In the latest Joe Rogan he also looks very tired and dim.
- XorNot 7y agoI'd say the evidence is mounting Elon probably has some type of undiagnosed (because lol money) mental health condition he'd benefit from treatment for. His latest episodes on twitter have looked like a bipolar's manic phase except he hasn't been able to (I presume) talk the ear off employees at one of his companies.
- nickik 7y agoPeople really need to stop with the armchair psychology nonsense. Not everybody who send an angry tweet is now biopolar. And not everybody who disagrees with your opinion is psychologically damaged.
- nickik 7y agoThe plant doesn't actually have a 'very bad record' as far as I can tell. They have many regulatory violations, but if the other companies running production on that scale were in California they would likely have just as many. And if those 'violations' actually translation into actual harm, I have not seen much evidence for. Can you actually provide solid evidence about actual people harmed that shows that Tesla is unsafer then any similar plants in the US? > Elon lost a lot respect in all this. With some people he gained a lot of respect. Seems like you are just applying your own option and that of people you know and believe this is societies opinion. "I don't know anybody who voted for Nixon".
- londons_explore 7y agoI'm kinda wondering why he wants to reopen the factory. Car demand is sure to plummet with a long economic depression coming, and electric cars moreso since the price of fuel is the lowest it's been for decades. Considering that, if I were in Elons position, I'd prefer the state to be paying my employees salaries, and leave most of my factories closed. Keep the R&D department going so I have some awesome new products in a year's time when the economy starts recovering.
- kortilla 7y agoPaying employees is a blip on the OPEX that company deals with. If they don’t crank out cars they will need to raise even more money. Until the upper middle class and up start losing jobs, Tesla will still have plenty of demand. Their core customer wasn’t line cooks.
- Melting_Harps 7y ago> Considering that, if I were in Elon's position, I'd prefer the state to be paying my employees salaries, and leave most of my factories closed. Keep the R&D department going so I have some awesome new products in a year's time when the economy starts recovering. Back orders/deposits are clogging up the system, thus affecting the total supply chain of deliverable cars. Model Y was not as popular in deposits as 3 was, that might have changed since I looked at the data, but also 3's line at Fremont is optimized for Y's output. Also, that's the only factory that make S/X/Y chassis for now. so its a bottleneck issue, too. Essentially, this comes down to opportunity costs; people have paid, in part, for a car which if they choose to can/will always be refunded if they don't want it before taking delivery. Tesla would then have to not only give them their deposit back, but also have to figure out what to do with the chassis--taking on a net loss, but also assume liability for its inventory. If Elon is right, Y is supposed to be their most popular chassis yet, so it'd probably just go to the next customer with the same specs. But still, my best guess is that this comes down to opportunity costs and unrealized gains--they have procured all the materials for assembly and its creating a backlog in production/vin assignment along with costly storage fees. Which after the pain-staking processes with Model 3 ramp up, and optimization it has to be near unavoidable to want to learn and iterate as fast as possible to streamline the process to meet Global demand. I still can't figure out why the Gigafactory at Sparks isn't being used as an adjunct of their manufacturing, instead of just cramming ever-more of their entire inventory into Fremont. I agree with Elon's position that most don't take the importance and difficulty of Manufacturing and its Supply Chain/Logistics very seriously at best and totally for granted and way too lightly at worst, because in reality it's a myriad of ever-changing cogs and gears all working in what may seem to the outsider as an effortless machine. It's like plumbing, if you've done it right most don't/won't even notice it until something goes catastrophically wrong: and then they're up in arms about having to deal with not getting fed because someone like Amazon is taking 3.5 weeks to deliver goods when it used to be same day.