5 ms·
There was a time - for over half a century - when Progress and Poverty was the best known economics book in the world. If you buy one, it has a who’s who of peo
by EGreg 7y ago
There was a time - for over half a century - when Progress and Poverty was the best known economics book in the world. If you buy one, it has a who’s who of people endorsing it, from famous economists to writers to presidents.
And somehow, in the last 50 years, we have all forgotten it, and some people only remember the land tax. Not only that, but the same debates rage today, about why there is still so much poverty even while there has been so much progress. Libertarian people know Ayn Rand and Murray Rothbard before they know Henri George, about whom Milton Friedman had a lot of good things to say.
- chii 7y ago> why there is still so much poverty even while there has been so much progress there's been an objective improvement to the % of people in poverty over the past few centuries. It's just that there's an even larger improvement to those who were rich, relative to the improvements to the poor. If you had a choice, you would choose to be poor today, than to be poor a century or two ago.
- bsanr2 7y agoWhy does this matter?
- bsanr2 7y agoNo, seriously, why does it matter that poverty has "improved" over the years? It still exists. It still leads to suffering and brutal, undignified deaths. Is collapsing in your trailer, abusive nursing home, or city street any better than in your hovel or, well, city street, 150 years ago? Like everyone else, society must answer the question, "What have you done for me lately?".
- MiroF 7y agoYes, and peasants under feudalism were much better off than they were as cavemen - none of that justifies economic/social stagnation
- JSavageOne 7y ago> If you had a choice, you would choose to be poor today, than to be poor a century or two ago. The classic false dichotomy that somebody always feels the need to point out in justifying the status quo.
- roenxi 7y agoThe status quo is a jawdroppingly fast and totally unprecedented reduction in poverty [0]. If my goal were to reduce poverty; my strategy would be to defend the status quo. [0] https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty
- MiroF 7y agoYou see how that's non-responsive to the parent, right?
- roenxi 7y agoIf parent wanted a direct response they should have posted a concrete suggestion. There wasn't a lot there to respond to. Technically speaking; there isn't anybody who would even blink at the idea of making things better. The status quo exists because there are a bunch of people who think [proposed change] makes things worse. Poverty isn't even a particularly important aspect of the decision making process and its extreme form might be eradicated in a generation if Africa gets hit by the same forces as Asia. It will be difficult to make such rapid improvement out to be in need of major changes.
- banads 7y agoAnd yet, there are more people living in poverty than the entire global population in 1950.
- chii 7y agothere are a lot more people now than in the 1950's too. As a proportion, is the poverty rate higher today than before? Are the currently poor today better off than the same relative level of poor in the 1950s?
- EGreg 7y agoI upvoted you, to counteract the downvotes. You are correct... obviously science and technology have improved the lot of the ordinary person, and made us all much, much richer. The main issue is that automation tends to hurt workers while it helps consumers. And since most people are both — they have to work harder and harder just to stay in place. Until we put in place a UBI and universal health insurance, pass overtime laws to shorten the workweek etc. we will have technology creating demand shocks for human labor, as happened before the Great Depression on farms, and has gradually happened in manufacturing, and is about to happen to white collar jobs and menial jobs. In the 50s, a single man could support an entire household on one paycheck. Women didn’t compete with men for those jobs, but rather did jobs that now are not valued by the market. Automation didn’t make employers not need their employees, so they would retain them for decades as they built experience. Today, we have two year stint— wait that was 20 years ago, today we have temp jo— ait no, that was last decade, now it’s the gig economy with no protections. You see where I’m going with this? Automation and outsourcing is once again putting people in a race to the bottom. Yes, electronics are cheaper than ever. But some things like rent / land just go up in price, they need a UBI. Paid for by land taxes maybe. Edit: funny, I am getting downvoted also, for agreeing with you
- MiroF 7y ago> Edit: funny, I am getting downvoted also, for agreeing with you If the parent was being downvoted for a certain view, why is this at all surprising?
- jhpriestley 7y agowould you really choose "the wire" over "little house on the prairie"? How can such a comparison possibly be "objective" anyway?
- nabla9 7y ago"The rent of land, therefore, considered as the price paid for the use of the land, is naturally a monopoly price. It is not at all proportioned to what the landlord may have laid out upon the improvement of the land, or to what he can afford to take; but to what the farmer can afford to give." — Adam Smith, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, Book I, Chapter XI "Of the Rent of Land"
- toohotatopic 7y agoThis assumes that the farmer has to remain a farmer. This can be true for one generation, but the next generation can choose another profession. People don't become farmers if they have to pay too much.
- MiroF 7y ago> This assumes that the farmer has to remain a farmer. How does it assume that?
- toohotatopic 7y agoOtherwise it wouldn't be a monopoly and the farmer wouldn't have to accept the offer. The farmer, or rather, the human, can source resources from other markets and sell goods or services that don't depend on farmland. Once that happens, and nobody accepts the high price, the landlord has to lower the price until somebody accepts his offer.
- MiroF 7y agoThe existence of substitutes doesn't make a monopoly no longer a monopoly. Bell was still a telephone monopoly even if I could have used carrier pigeons instead.
- toohotatopic 7y agoIt's not the same. You cannot transport voice over a pigeon, at least not instantly. If you don' allow substitutes then every brand has a monopoly on the products of their brand. Technically that's a monopoly. But nobody complains about McDonalds having a monopoly on McDonalds burgers.
- aww_dang 7y ago"Rather than nationalize land outright, the single taxers would levy a 100 percent tax on the annual land rent — the annual income from the site — which amounts to the same thing as outright nationalization." --Murray Rothbard Georgism is reasonably well known among free-market enthusiasts and libertarians.
- tlholaday 7y agoRothbard's error: under land nationalization, state actors decide who uses the land; under single tax, who uses the land is determined by auction.
- aww_dang 7y agoThe single quote is understandably a narrow view of the larger article. My view is that the 100% tax on income from the land removes profit motive and price discovery in a way which is similar to outright nationalization. However, I agree with your assessment of the quote as a stand alone item. https://mises.org/library/single-tax-economic-and-moral-implications https://mises.org/library/single-tax-economic-and-moral-impl...
- snidane 7y agoIt removes profit incentive of reselling land to somebody who wants to use it. It doesn't remove profit incentive of the activity you'd want to perform on that land. Land under 100% LVT only becomes an input to production. And makes it unprofitable for holding it for somebody else. When you are in business of making apple pies you simply buy apples as input. You don't need any middlemen holding them for you if you can hold them yourself.
- EGreg 7y agoIn fact it is similar to the error of those who equate slavery and wage slavery. With the latter, you have a choice of employer, even without safety nets.
- sudosysgen 7y ago