11 ms·
A 125-year-old delivery network that feeds Mumbai
- Nextgrid 7y ago> “We've known this person so long we know he'll do a proper job." > The delivery schedule also has built-in buffers. If a delivery is due at 13:00, the dabbawala will aim for around 12:00 [...] For every 15 to 20 dabbawalas there is also always someone on stand-by in case one of them gets delayed. > At 12:45 a dabbawala races around the corner on a bike and rushes shouting into an office building. [...] The dabbawala was late by his own standards but the customer was probably never aware of the hiccup, he says. > A dabbawalas’ commitment to the job is partly because it pays well – roughly 12,000 rupees (£140) a month, a good salary in India for what is essentially unskilled labour. The fame of the dabbawalas also gives the job a certain prestige. > And as a cooperative all dabbawalas are equal partners with supervisors called mukadams who are elected. It seems like there's no major secret here. The key to achieving such things is... surprise surprise... treating your workers fairly and paying them well so they actually give a shit about their job, and feel appreciated and proud of what they do. The same would actually translate to many other industries. The food delivery startups could achieve the same if they paid their delivery drivers fairly (at the moment most don't even make minimum wage - compared to the dabbawalas’ "good salary") instead of pissing away their money into marketing/advertising or into someone's pocket, whether greedy investors or "engineers" to build a blockchain-based, Kubernetes-powered microservices playground.
- searchableguy 7y ago> 12k rupees/month > good wage That's unlivable wage. Also, those companies you have listed pay more.
- Nextgrid 7y agoI took the fact that it appears to be a good wage from the article; I am not familiar with the local market so I couldn't double-check that myself. However, they do appear to be thriving and providing a good service despite the local companies supposedly paying more so something doesn't add up. If the companies truly paid more then the whole system would breakdown as all their couriers would jump ship to the delivery startups.
- searchableguy 7y agoThings don't change overnight. Your legacy code doesn't get rewritten in rust overnight even if rust provides actual significant benefit for you. I will give it a few more years. People who work those jobs are also majorly illiterate and may not be willing to change as implied in the article.
- legolas2412 7y agoNot OP, but just adding source https://www.livemint.com/Companies/cYbdfsYk93HFhMuC0XgaNN/Swiggy-Zomato-hike-delivery-boy-salaries-as-competition-gro.html https://www.livemint.com/Companies/cYbdfsYk93HFhMuC0XgaNN/Sw...
- namdnay 7y agoFor unskilled labour in India, that’s very good money. The average wage in India is around 350-400 INR per day worked
- legolas2412 7y agoBut Swiggy etc pay 25-50k https://www.livemint.com/Companies/cYbdfsYk93HFhMuC0XgaNN/Swiggy-Zomato-hike-delivery-boy-salaries-as-competition-gro.html https://www.livemint.com/Companies/cYbdfsYk93HFhMuC0XgaNN/Sw...
- econcon 7y agoI am curious, is there any reason why dabba people don't switch to Swiggy for job? If they'll make more there.
- _curious_ 7y ago"The dabbawalas have deeper reasons for doing it. Serving their customers is like serving their god.” It could be because they see their purpose as delivering food to people on time and it doesn't seem like the nascent services have figured out how to do that well at scale - thus they may make more over there but are less fulfilled in their life mission?
- manquer 7y agoSwiggy and other delivery startups are more demanding in work hours (to make good money you need to do late nights weekends etc) and also needs you be able to drive a scooter . Also these startups need you to be able use their mobile app, maps and gps and find the customer these require literacy and few other skills Dabbawalas may not have readily.
- pkaye 7y agoDabbawalas are more involved with transporting home cooked food to the worker. The worker leaves early in the morning and some time later the spouse will have a hot meal packed up. The dabbawala will come pick it up and aggregate orders going to common destinations, move it by train, etc. I presume Swiggy is only for restaurant cooked food. Secondly the dabbawala jobs are more like a stable union job. You don't get the top money but everyone looks after each other. Of course with time customer preferences may change towards restaurant food. Or maybe workers start using plastic containers and microwaves.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- black_puppydog 7y ago> And as a cooperative all dabbawalas are equal partners with supervisors called mukadams who are elected. That would seem to make it pretty fundamentally incompatible with the wage extraction operations that are uber, deliveroo etc.
- iguy 7y agoAnd the fact that the average length of employment at this is measured in decades, possibly generations. It's an ecosystem not a startup. (Which doesn't mean there aren't things to learn, of course, for those trying to run more conventional businesses.)
- abdullahkhalids 7y agoA coop operating alone in this space, or competing with other coops, would definitely make a profit. But a coop can't compete with a VC backed startup that will use every legal, illegal, ethical and unethical trick in the book it can get away with to, to destroy its competitors.
- nicoburns 7y ago> But a coop can't compete with a VC backed startup that will use every legal, illegal, ethical and unethical trick in the book it can get away with to, to destroy its competitors. Yes, and I think aspect of capitalism is under-discussed. The conventional narrative is that it doesn't matter how much wealth somebody else (or some other company) has. You can compete on your own merit. But companies like Uber and other VC-backed "unicorns" show otherwise. They can afford to give away their product for free on the back of money that they didn't earn in any meaningful way. And it completely breaks the model.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- econcon 7y agoMissing info is 1. If these guys pay taxes or charge GST on food delivered. 2. How many units they deliver each day 3. What the cost of delivery of each unit and what's the value of the food content?
- essdas 7y ago1. They don't make the food, they only transport it. Payment of taxes or GST on food delivered is between the food maker and the food receiver – dabbawala is not involved. 2. Article claims roughly 200,000 deliveries per day. 3a. Cost of each delivery is Rs. 800 per month / 24 working days = approx Rs. 33 (or less than half a dollar) per delivery. Normally the delivery involves a pick up as well (previous day's container is picked up along with today's delivery). 3b. Value of food content is irrelevant – it can be super expensive or dirt cheap, dabbawalas only care that it is packed in certain types of containers.
- on_and_off 7y ago>The food delivery startups could achieve the same if they paid their delivery drivers fairly They could, but they do everything to give the perception that food delivery is cheap. UberEats takes a 30% cut of the restaurant price. Most of them don't increase their prices in response. They really should consider it (and fortunately, some do), it devalues their offering (and restaurants already work with razor thin margins). Same thing for their drivers salaries. Better to drive it into the ground than paying them a living wage and see a slower adoption as a result. Not sure the quotes around engineers are needed. I have zero sympathy for most of these companies but it is still an engineering challenge to do food delivery at scale.
- werber 7y agoI looked at ordering some white castle for pick up today. There 5 dollar combination i normally Get was 7.50 plus convenience charges. Similarly, i looked at ordering delivery sushi and it was close to 50% more not including charges Friday. There’s not a lot of options here in Detroit, but, it seems like the platform charges are getting transferred to the customer.
- jjeaff 7y ago>The key to achieving such things is... surprise surprise... treating your workers fairly and paying them well so they actually give a shit about their job Easier said than done. Not that I disagree, but business models like these are difficult in more developed countries. It's the same reason you will find middle class people in many less developed countries with domestic staff. The wealth divide between the middle class and poor is so extreme in places like India, that you can afford to charge your regular customers enough money to pay poor employees a "good" wage. "Good" in this case is of course very relative. Relative to many other poor people that have no job at all.
- bobthepanda 7y agoIndeed. Better economic opportunities and higher levels of general education make it hard to employ people and make money off this work at the same time. At least where I live in the US the gig platforms are staffed by people who can't hold down traditional employment for various reasons, and even with the below-minimum wage these services by and large do not really make money. The flip side of this trend is the ubiquity of vending machines in Japan, which have the advantage of requiring no sales staff. This is very useful in a country where the labor force is shrinking and demand for low-skilled workers outstrips supply.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- seemslegit 7y agoNo the secret is to have a caste of workers with low expectations, lack of better opportunities, and high work ethics - grounding it in religion and making it a 'mission' instead of a job helps.
- mke 7y agoPlus, more rent-seeking profit opportunities! Engineers create a social credit rating system for the spouses making the meals!
- al_chemist 6y agoImaginary review: "Terrible cooking, too much salt. 2 stars (+1 star for being my wife)"
- formatjam 7y agoDabbawalas are getting paid in good salary because they are a lot more efficient comparing to Uber drivers. From other reports / business review I am reading, there are about 200k customers with 5k Dabbawalas workers. That is avg 40 lunch deliveries per person. That is a LOT more efficient than Uber drivers. The Dabbawalas is more efficient because: - built on top of public transit: dramatically lower cost, no need to pay for gas - have a pre set schedule and demand / not on-demand: enable huge supply chain optimization.
- Kalium 7y ago>The food delivery startups could achieve the same if they paid their delivery drivers fairly (at the moment most don't even make minimum wage - compared to the dabbawalas’ "good salary") A quick data check suggests that a software engineer in Mumbai can easily make literally ten times this "good salary". Would you consider paying food delivery workers in London 10% of an software engineer's pay packet a "good salary"? Fair treatment? Some crude calculations on my part suggest that it would be well below minimum wage in the UK. Is it possible that there might be more going on than "good salary"? Other commenters point out that there's a deep gulf in expected living conditions that enables such a low level of pay to be a "good salary". Taken together, these suggest to me that this is a model that exploits extreme poverty and inequality. One that perhaps we should be glad cannot be replicated in many other places.
- aphextron 7y ago>"The new wave of food-delivery start-ups wants to know how they do it." Miniscule labor costs and scant workers rights. The "gig" economy is simply replicating in the west what has already existed in highly stratified societies for generations now that wealth inequality has finally reached a point where it can be profitable.
- pen2l 7y agoI visited Pakistan a few years ago, my homeland, after some 20 years of being in the states. I was being driven around by my 18 year old cousin. At some point, just completely randomly, some youngin' - I would estimate about 15 years of age, entered the car, in the backseat. My Urdu was a little off, I couldn't make out exactly what had happened, I assumed the guy was my cousin's friend. No, it turns out he was just doing a chore for a few pennies. It's the strangest fucking thing, dealing with these people. They're always there, just one command away. Being in America, I say my thank yous to cashiers or anyone of lesser means, exchange pleasantries, I never see them as lesser humans than me. But in that part of the world, if you look a certain way and dress a certain way, these folks will come to you for chores for a few pennies -- and they will almost present themselves as if they are lesser persons than you. And I would be speechless in those situations, I wouldn't know what to do or say. That properly fucked me in the head for a good while.
- rexpop 7y agoWhat do you mean, "fucked [you] in the head"? Like, you could not understand why someone would act like that? You had difficulty reconciling your expectations of human society with your experience in Pakistan? What changed?
- pen2l 7y agoI meant it was shocking to see humans behaving so subserviently, being so at terms with their situation: making pennies for chores and yet being so hardworking. I don't want to call it slavery, but it's something around there.
- youeseh 7y ago> A dabbawalas’ commitment to the job is partly because it pays well – roughly 12,000 rupees (£140) a month, a good salary in India for what is essentially unskilled labour. The fame of the dabbawalas also gives the job a certain prestige. Similar to being a bicycle messenger. You could make $20 an hour if you're efficient, which is more than working at a big box chain or delivering for a ridesharing service, and it has prestige. Source: https://www.breakawaycourier.com/news-and-blog/2011/8/3/how-much-money-do-bike-messengers-really-make.html https://www.breakawaycourier.com/news-and-blog/2011/8/3/how-...
- mynegation 7y agoWhile it is always good for executives to learn how long-established and well-run things work, it looks to me a lot in this system depends on the social context of Mumbai (or other big cities in India): big income disparity and the prevalence of stay at home domestic partners. I mean the first example in the article is a stock broker who has food delivered from home, cooked by their spouse. Why would this work in countries with a set minimum wage, double income households, and restaurants that have to be able to maintain their margins after delivery fees (something that domestic partners do not have to do)?
- that_girl 7y ago+1 The social context is what's missed in interpretation by outsiders.
- paulkrush 7y ago"3.4 mistakes per million deliveries". There are lessons to be learned from these guys, but I think definition of a mistake and this stat in general is, well, flexible.
- namdnay 7y agoLike all statistics in India :)
- econcon 7y agoIt would be interesting if someone makes a complaint portal for Dabba Walla and post some statistics on how many real complaints do you actually receive.
- essdas 7y agoIt would certainly be interesting, however in the absence of hard data perhaps some anecdotal evidence is better than no information: Case 1 ------ 10 years x 280 deliveries per year x 2 deliveries per day (pick up + drop) = 5600 deliveries. Number of mistakes = 0 That puts the error rate at < 1/5600 (or approximately 0.0002). Case 2 ------ 4 years x 280 deliveries per year x 2 deliveries per day (pick up + drop) = 2240 Number of mistakes = 0 That puts the error rate at < 1/2240 (or approximately 0.0004). Both cases together ------------------- Error rate < 0.00012
- wenc 7y ago3.4 mistakes/million (also known as 3.4 DPMO = defects per million opportunities) is just a a statistic from a normal distribution. It comes from the Six-Sigma literature [1]. It's the number of rejects in a 6σ process, assuming a 1.5σ mean shift (1.5σ is an arbitrary assumption for a shift in a long-term process). You can get a reasonable estimate through random sampling -- which is the basis for most of inferential statistics -- so it's not that flexible. If an adequately powered study was conducted (with a large enough sample size and sufficiently randomized sample), I don't see why the results can't be trusted [2]. A mistake is not that hard to classify (in logistics there are failure reason codes -- wrong address, wrong order, missed delivery, etc. and typically certain categories dominate -- the others are noise). That said, 3.4 DPMO is kind of a magic number (sort of like 95% confidence intervals -- why 95%? Because Pearson or someone decided it and it stuck). [1] https://www.qualitygurus.com/why-is-6-sigma-equal-to-3-4-dpmo/ https://www.qualitygurus.com/why-is-6-sigma-equal-to-3-4-dpm... [2] Side: Systematic misreporting might be an issue of course, and there's not much that can be done there except design a system of incentives and penalties around it. Customer complaints and lost clients are often visible in such systems.
- _curious_ 7y agoFascinating topic and read. You can see it in their smile and hear it in their tone...these people take a rare sense of pride in their work. Dabbawalas appear to be a happy, grateful, and fulfilled workforce that do a sufficient job. Add in the cultural prestige and this model strikes me as very tough to compete with. So why? What aspect of this current approach is broken or inefficient like to the point of justifying the time, money and effort to compete with as a startup? (I didn't gather that part from the article). Is it marginal food cost? Is it merely because it's a big market operating the old-school way and therefore easy money is being thrown at trying to capture share or supplant using apps? No wonder these ventures are having a tough go at things...seems to me as a solution seeking a problem.
- sk0g 7y agoNothing has to be broken for a startup or a big corp to attempt to make money themselves. There's money to be made in offering choices - enough money to justify the expenditure in getting something new up and running, seemingly. Speaking of solutions seeking a problem, early on in my career I was at a blockchain startup of sorts, though I have no idea what blockchain work they actually did. I got a few offers from other blockchain companies too, and I could never figure out what problem they were solving that a database wouldn't solve even better.
- sokoloff 7y agoSeparating investors from their money is a problem more easily solved with blockchain that a run of the mill database.
- sk0g 7y agoYou say that like they're mutually exclusive! One project, a custom Ethereum based coin was running behind on time - like way, way behind. A DB based system was delivered as a prototype (where I noticed floats were used for transaction amounts!), and since the coin was "cloud native", whatever that means, it stayed that way. Client did ask for source code but the company wasn't able to serve that, for obvious reasons...
- balladeer 7y agoThere's an awesome film that interestingly uses this food delivery network - The Lunchbox (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2350496/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2350496/). It stars recently passed away actor Irrfan Khan, Nimrat Kaur (she's in Homeland), and Nawazuddin Siddiqui. They are among the finest from here. It has Max Richter's music and is on Indian Netflix (not sure about rest of the world).
- Robinxd 7y agoMoved to Thane, which is right next to Mumbai around six months ago. Although not really related, but I get a good meal of my choice at roughly INR 70($1)/meal , and I can order in between snacks for a smaller price if needed. And I can stand their while it's cooked or not, all at the comfort of just going to an apartment that is next to mine. It's cheap, healthy and convenient. At my work place, I can't decide the food I want, and I pay 3 times more.
- spiderjerusalem 7y agoYes, a fair amount of middle/lower-middle class women in big cities in India make some side cash with this system. Basically just cooking extra portions of lunch and dinner of whatever they're making that day anyway and feeding the busy single neighbours for a very reasonable amount.
- S53Vflnr4n 7y agoH4 spouses in the US do the same.
- senthil_rajasek 7y agoEverytime a story about India is posted the HN crowd picks apart the negatives of Indian society like caste or poverty. That's the first comment I see when I get here. Always. STOP THIS! If you want to focus on the negativity start a separate thread imagine every story about the valley bringing up it's inherent white privilege or racism as the first comment.
- fermienrico 7y agoThis is not how HN works. Criticism and counter points are the reason why I come here. Taking offense to criticism is how we regress as a society. It has nothing to do with racism except that its a construct in one's mind based on prior experiences, biases and taking excessive pride in one's identity/culture. One can still do that, but that should not mean the public is barred from criticism.
- senthil_rajasek 7y agoThis is a false equivalence. I bet if HN audience were mostly minorities every story would not be critical of non-western cultures.
- fermienrico 7y agoWhat's wrong with criticism of minorities?
- senthil_rajasek 7y agoEntitlement.
- papeda 7y agoThis article focuses on a delivery network powered by a large pool of cheap, unskilled labor. The role of poverty levels in India is very relevant to this topic. Your comment is also the only one that brings up caste.
- 7y ago
- gjkood 7y agoFor a nice introduction to the subject of Mumbai Dabawallahs I would strongly recommend watching "The Lunchbox" [1] starring the late Irfan Khan. A great actor tragically taken from us at a relatively young age. Beautiful movie. Enjoy. [1] https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2350496/?ref_=nv_sr_srsg_0 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2350496/?ref_=nv_sr_srsg_0
- papeda 7y ago+1. A slow, naturalistic movie that's also conventionally entertaining. Plus, as a timely feature, one of the protagonists spends a bunch of time standing on crowded trains, sitting in a crowded office, and eating lunch in a crowded canteen.
- fedede 7y agoI actually a Spanish startup that was partially inspired by this. The difference is that one person delivers many dishes in a ride, so costs can be cut and wages can be higher. It’s actually doing pretty well and expanding on many cities in the country.
- that_girl 7y agoAnother point I might add: Please factor in the rate of unemployment and the limited choices for labor when measuring the happiness of these "unskilled" workers. I agree that we can learn a lesson of efficiency from these guys, but I don't agree that we can learn a lesson of cooperative society and sharing of dividends. Lack of exposure means we rationalize the existing situation and convince ourselves that this is good. I'm sure there are some dabbawalas thinking "It is what it is. There are no other jobs available, so I might as well."
- that_girl 7y agoIn other words, they are making a system work, doesn't mean that the system is right in the first place and is universally applicable.
- supernova87a 7y agoOf course, you know that this system is able to exist only because the office workers have odd food preferences, and the delivery people get paid like shit, and there's tons of people willing to do the job for such low wage? If the alternative to having this service is me just carrying a small tin box along with me to work, what are the odds I'm going to shell out $10 each time if it were implemented in any country that has a Western minimum wage?
- nyolfen 7y agoperhaps you should read the article
- russfink 7y agoDumb question here - why don't people take their own lunch to work? I know there are valid reasons, can someone help me understand?
- youeseh 7y agoIt arrives hot. It is prepared by your partner / parent / cook just the way you like / need it. It makes for a much more interesting conversation. It is something Indians are used to from a fairly young age. Going to school, you'd take the lunch that mom made with you. Now that you're working.. providing for the family, you deserve an upgrade! :D
- burner831234 7y agoI think its a great question. There is a high cultural value in eating warm/freshly cooked meals. While you can get sandwiches even those have warm components (vada pav, grilled cheese etc). These meals are made in the late morning usually by a female member of the household and sent off.
- thewarpaint 7y agoThis was also strange to me. I'm used to people bringing home made food with them to the office, then heating it up at lunch time and eating it. But I cannot imagine being sent a freshly cooked meal in the afternoon. Mind-blowing.
- vaidhy 7y agoIn Mumbai, the person working is likely to leave early (say before 7am). The person cooking (typically mom or spouse) gets to lunch later, around 10:30 and it gets delivered. Most Indian food is not great when eaten cold. This also avoids needing to buy and store vegetables since you can get to the market in the morning and buy what you need for the day. It makes life easier for all concerned.
- PeterisP 7y agoIt does rely on having a "homemaker" who is not working and stays at home to cook; in many other countries that's not really an option for the majority of workers as both spouse and mom (if not very old) would be working.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThere is a Top Gear bit on Dabbawala, part of the India Special iirc, which is quite informative in addition to the usual tone of the show. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lNIDvr7NNwo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lNIDvr7NNwo
- nine_zeros 7y agoVery interesting system. I wonder if this could work with regular gig economy as it exists in the US. Why aren't there more co-operative businesses here? What stops taxi drivers or gig workers from forming a co-op with decent benefits?
- citizenpaul 7y ago" new wave of food-delivery start-ups wants to know how they do it." Umm is this really a question? Near destitute poverty level wages and quality of life.
- formatjam 7y agoThe Dabbawalas "secret" is: - built on top of public transit: dramatically lower cost, no need to pay for gas - have a pre set schedule and demand / not on-demand: enable huge supply chain optimization. These 2 are the key differences between the dabbawalas and uber eats supply chains. Uber can also does similar optimizations if they offer a lunch subscription service that u pre-book ur lunches. - uses vanes to do batch pick up / drop off: restaurants (small van)-> local hub (large van)-> destination local hub -> final mile delivery on bike / foot. This will provide efficient supply chain to keep cost down and reliable if theres enough demand. However, demand might be low because US customers looking to save money are used to pack their own lunch and microwave at work. This is not an option in Mumbai because of crowed train in rush hour.