3 ms·
Long term the Tillable idea won't fly. I worked with farmers as a fertilizer company agronomist for twenty years. If I understand it correctly Tillable is try
by rmason 7y ago
Long term the Tillable idea won't fly. I worked with farmers as a fertilizer company agronomist for twenty years. If I understand it correctly Tillable is trying to insert themselves in the middle, acquire the right to sublease large amounts of land and mark it up.
Say you own a farm and lease it out. The family you lease your land to might be a neighbor. In the winter they might plow your driveway gratis. They add fertilizer and lime as needed. I've known farmers to even add small amounts of drainage tile at the beginning of a lease.
Now consider I'm a super large farmer who has rented your land through Tillable. Farming is a super thin margin business. I live two counties over so I am not going to plow out your driveway or look after your farm for you. I will pay top dollar, I will in effect mine your land to make a profit.
I won't put on fertilizer if levels are high and skip the lime. I will make a nice profit for a few years and then when yields drop I will drop the lease. Over time the price of the lease will drop sharply. So in effect the landlord will gain a few bucks short term but lose big time over the long term.
On a small scale I've seen this happen. When the landlord offers it back to the original renter he will be shocked and angry when he either refuses or offers a pittance.
The landlord either has to invest his own money on lime and fertilizer building the farm back up or have a series of short time renters from outside the county who take a chance on the land.
- jefftk 7y agoIt sounds to me like you're making two points: 1. Tenant farmers often pay their landlord partially in kind, with things like driveway plowing. Outsider tenants wouldn't do this. 2. The tenant farmer has a wide range of options for how well to take care of the land, which affects its long-term value. Outsider tenants would optimize to maximize production during their lease at minimum cost, hurting long-term value. I don't think (1) is a major issue: landlords can consider the in-kind benefits they get just as well as cash compensation. But (2) seems very serious to me. Market rates for land are much lower than they would be without the issue that the landlord needs to trust the tenant to be a good long-term steward. Whether Tillable can succeed long-term depends on whether they can solve this.
- empath75 7y agoSo then the land owner goes bankrupt and has to sell the land and Tillable buys it.
- toss1 7y agoYup, just like the formerly innovative companies that end up being managed by the financial types. They now optimize for current profits and not market-leading innovation, so profits improve - for a (sometimes long) while. Then, the profits decline, and no amount of financial sleight-of-hand can make it improve, and the company is too far behind to invest in R&D to again lead. It is making money by extraction not by creation. Nice while it lasts, but unsustainable. If this method takes over for farmland, expect another 1930's dust bowl type of farm out put crash in some years (esp w/the increasing scarcity of critical potash/potassium). So, let's hope this new 'Tillable' biz model dies sooner rather than later.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoI hear this a lot, but all the farmers I know (UK) are wealthy, they have big houses and expensive vehicles, large families, buy up lots of local properties (buoying property prices, ie pushing them higher) ...? So, does the small margin matter if it covers high wages for the limited number of workers needed? Or am I mislead?
- jameslk 7y agoSounds like issues that can be mitigated with a review system? The land owner can submit ratings on how well the farmer took care of their land. Once it's all on a platform, they can quantify all these things, reducing the farmers down to a set of metrics. Obviously pretty dystopian but this is what I've seen it done on other marketplaces, such as Upwork.