4 ms·
> diff between food farming and commodity crop farming. What is the difference between these? Aren't crops generally commodities? I’m familiar with the subsist
by MattGaiser 7y ago
> diff between food farming and commodity crop farming.
What is the difference between these? Aren't crops generally commodities? I’m familiar with the subsistence farmer term of the crops they eat verses the crops they sell, but the farmers sell both here.
- tsimionescu 7y agoI'm guessing commodity crops in this context may refer to non-food crops, like corn for bio-ethanol, rapeseed, cotton, tobacco?
- derekbreden 7y agoThat was close to my guess, the only small difference is I would add some maybe-ends-up-in-food-eventually crops as well. My family would refer to the roundup ready corn and soybeans we sold to the grain co-op as commodities, while the small sub-acreage of sweet corn grown to sell at the farmer’s market might be much more likely to be referred to as food. Food being a perhaps overly generous word for partially hydrogenated soybean oil or high fructose corn syrup.
- dd36 7y agoSo, sprayed with more bug poison? I wonder if this disconnect becomes detrimental to the land.
- kasey_junk 7y agoBigger difference is the breed of plant. Commodity corn for instance is not something a human would eat normally without extreme processing. One way it becomes human good is as feed for animals and another is being processed into adjuncts. Sweet corn on the other hand is delicious to eat. I tend to think commodities vs food is if there is a mainline futures contract for it.
- saalweachter 7y agoCommodity agriculture is any agriculture where the products are sold into the commodity markets, basically -- corn, wheat, soybeans, rice, pork, beef, etc. Commodity agriculture is all about scale and price; there are certain quality standards that must be met (your corn must have a specific moisture content; your pigs must weigh in a certain range and be free of disease) but there is no real competition on the quality of the good produced. You assume all hard red wheat is fungible, and buy and sell it by the ton. Some products exist in both commodity and non-commodity markets -- you can produce pork for the commodity markets, or your can sell it door to door.
- MattGaiser 7y ago> Commodity agriculture is all about scale and price; there are certain quality standards that must be met (your corn must have a specific moisture content; your pigs must weigh in a certain range and be free of disease) but there is no real competition on the quality of the good produced. You assume all hard red wheat is fungible, and buy and sell it by the ton. Between regulations and grocery store standards, is that not basically all food?
- saalweachter 7y agoBy calories, certainly. But fresh produce frequently exists outside the commodity market -- the individual grocery stores or chains have relationships with individual producers (or consortiums) to distribute their products. Basically if your food is labeled with the name of the producer it isn't commodity agriculture -- for instance, bags of apples are frequently branded by the orchard which produces them, because the orchard is selling directly to the grocery store (maybe with a middle man or two doing the actual sales and distribution), and not selling into a generic "apple" market the way eg wheat producers do.
- skybrian 7y agoI don't know what the original poster meant, but there are fruits and vegetables that are mostly picked by hand and usually sold fresh, which distinguishes them from things like wheat and corn that can be grown on very large farms with little labor because it's been mechanized. There are a handful of commodity crops grown at very large scale, and then there is everything else. https://modernfarmer.com/2015/03/specialty-crops-refer-to-weird-things-like-fruits-and-vegetables/ https://modernfarmer.com/2015/03/specialty-crops-refer-to-we...
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoIs the concern that the growth of commodity farming will eliminate the production of fruits and vegetables? If so, I see the potential problem. But growth of commodity crops with no change in f/v seems like a non-issue.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoDifference between commodities and food is subsidies. Commodities are also traded on Wall Street.