5 ms·
Not sure why he put this at the end: > One final note: according to Wilhite, GIF is pronounced with a soft “G,” like “jif.” That settles the never-ending debat
by jedberg 7y ago
Not sure why he put this at the end:
> One final note: according to Wilhite, GIF is pronounced with a soft “G,” like “jif.” That settles the never-ending debate for me.
Now all he's done is make 1/2 of the population immediately discount everything else he said, regardless of its merit.
- dguo 7y agoAuthor here. I added the "for me" to try to convey that it's a personal choice. I don't care what pronunciation others use. In this case, it doesn't bother me if someone chooses to discount what I wrote just because of that statement. That's on them. I know it doesn't add much to the post. I just really liked the video of him accepting the Webby award. It was nice to see the person behind the technology, and I like letting creators decide things like pronunciation and casing. For example, I always make sure I spell "GitHub" instead of "Github" for no reason other than that's how they spell it themselves.
- julianeon 7y agoI took it as a fun throwaway comment, which you tacked on to the end. Whatever way you pronounce it, the important thing is to realize that videos have advantages over gifs that you should always keep in mind - which came through loud and clear.
- WalterBright 7y ago>> One final note: according to Wilhite, GIF is pronounced with a soft “G,” like “jif.” That would be correct if GIF stood for "Gerbil Interchange Format" rather than "Graphics Interchange Format".
- saghm 7y agoI've never understood that argument; why would an acronym need to preserve the exact sounds of the letters in the original words? I don't think it's very uncommon for them not to. "UNICEF" is not pronounced "yoo-ni-chef", "POTUS" is not pronounced "po-thuss", "OSHA" is not pronounced "oss-huh", etc.
- franciscop 7y agoAs a Spaniard, that's exactly how I would pronounce those acronyms. Time to learn a bit more about English :) Funnily enough, in Spanish "gi" is pronounced "ji" as in "Girar" (pronounced Jirar), while "gui" is pronounced like "gi" and "güi" is pronounced "gu-i". But "GIF" in Spanish is still pronounced with a soft "g", contradicting the general rule. Edit: wait Google Translate says those are pronounced that way? https://translate.google.com/#view=home&op=translate&sl=en&tl=es&text=UNICEF%2C%0APOTUS%2C%0AOSHA https://translate.google.com/#view=home&op=translate&sl=en&t...
- saghm 7y agoI've always heard the acronyms I listed as "yoo-nih-sef", "po-tuss", and "oash-a" (the first syllable like "ocean"). It would be genuinely surprising to me to find out that those were not the standard pronunciations, but I guess it's possible that I've been living in a bubble my whole life! From the limited Spanish experience I have (a few years in middle school and high school), I was aware of the subtleties of how "g" is pronounced with relation to the following vowel, but I didn't know about how "GIF" was pronounced! It fits what I remember about loan words though; I think we had the word "hockey" as a vocab word once during a unit where we had all sports words, and we were taught that it was pronounced the same way as in English, which stuck out to me given that "ho" at the beginning of a word in Spanish would usually not have an "h" sound like in English. Of course, "ck" is basically never found in real Spanish words either; from what I recall, "k" isn't really used much at all besides in loan words!
- slim 7y agoI think it was a joke (an attempt to start a classic flame war with a classic argument)
- Dylan16807 7y agoIf so it's a bad joke to use, because a million people that didn't think that argument through use it unironically.
- ebg13 7y ago> That would be correct if GIF stood for "Gerbil Interchange Format" rather than "Graphics Interchange Format". Exactly like the well known Joint Potatographic Experts Group, yeah? I guess it's time to start saying JayFeg.
- naniwaduni 7y agoJΦEG
- mkl 7y agoI say "Giraffe-ics Interchange Format" when I explain it that way. Plus the only English words in common usage that start with "gif" have a hard G.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoIt's correct because the original developers said so.
- chrismorgan 7y agoEveryone knows that it’s actually pronounced like the g in “garbage”.
- casefields 7y agoBecause everyone knows Gin is for drinking, gif is for watching, gym is for exercising.
- Intermernet 7y agoThe G in GIF is pronounced like a J, as in José.
- gifnamething 7y agoI'm not sure why anyone else thinks they have a say in how to pronounce a name. I hope I don't meet anyone who tells me I'm pronouncing mine incorrectly.
- jedberg 7y agoGif isn't a name, it's an acronym. The creator of an acronym doesn't get to decide how it's pronounced -- it follows the rules of standard english if it's an acronym of english words. Yes english has a lot of edge cases, but it has defaults too. In this case, english rules dictate that any word that starts with "gif" is a hard g sound. You will not find an english word that starts with "gif" with a soft g. The only reason there is a controversy at all is because the creator insists on his incorrect pronunciation with a soft g. If he wanted a soft g, it should have been a "jif".
- Dylan16807 7y ago> In this case, english rules dictate that any word that starts with "gif" is a hard g sound. You will not find an english word that starts with "gif" with a soft g. English rules tell you how to pronounce "gi" at the start of a word, and the "f" doesn't change it. Girl. Giraffe. Giddy. Gin. It can go either way.
- gifnamething 6y ago>Gif isn't a name, it's an acronym Those aren't mutually exclusive. >You will not find an english word that starts with "gif" with a soft g. If I was going to make a post with an assertion like this, I'd pick up a dictionary.