9 ms·
Amazon is handing out 'Thank you' t-shirts to warehouse workers as it cuts pay
- ccthr 7y agoReading this makes me thing I should divest. I feel ashamed owning shares in a company that thinks 20 hours unpaid time off a quarter is reasonable.
- wheelerwj 7y ago> I feel ashamed owning shares
- netsharc 7y agoIt's getting harder and harder to participate in the modern world for me. So far I've deleted my accounts on Uber (because of the harassment reports) Airbnb (because they don't give a fuck about scams), and last, Twitter (because they were enabling Nazis, and continuing to use Twitter is basically endorsing Twitter in my eyes). But the majority of the world seems to just shrug and are fine with the terrible behaviours.
- chadcmulligan 7y agoThe slaves must free themselves - I always think of the start of the mining unions - the strikes went on for a long time, and they were very nasty, it was a huge fight. People have been tricked out of these rights that were hard won, capital won't easily go back to decent conditions for workers without a fight.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoEarly 20th century unionisation only happened in the US after pitched battles and gun fights, and when that didn't stop it it was bought off where possible. A lot of that history seems to have been suppressed to the point that hardly anyone knows about it. It's certainly not something you'll see being mentioned on any mainstream media channel.
- chadcmulligan 7y agoyes its disappointing, younger people don't realise how much blood, sweat and tears went into obtaining the working conditions they have now, and as you say, it's not taught much any more. I remember going to a huge meeting and strike in the 80's, things were a lot more civilised then. I was a young apprentice, there was an older guy who was 'blackballed' - he had turned on a switch against the slowdown rules (a partial strike) - no other worker would talk to him. There were strike funds for people who couldn't afford it, it was a very exciting thing for a young kid, I don't know if it happens any more. People dying on the job so the owners can make more money is nothing new.
- partyboat1586 7y agoReminds me of the weekly clapping for the NHS here in the UK when what they really need is a pay rise and PPE supplies. Sometimes thank you is not enough. In the case of Amazon this seems much more sinister and cult like. I struggle to believe that any of the warehouse workers buy into it.
- ccthr 7y agoAgreed. Where could we get the tax money to make those pay rises from? hmmm
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- eecc 7y agoBermuda? Panama? Switzerland? Cayman Islands? Bermuda? Delaware? Oh there’s plenty places
- deadgunslinger 7y agoDo you believe permanently raising wages to offset black swan events such as the COVID-19 epidemic is a wise move? What about the next black swan event? Are they going to be paid enough then or they'll need a pay rise again? Healthcare professionals are paid much more compared to the average UK citizen. Especially doctors, the average pay (100k pounds) is in the 2% of the earners. Emigrant doctors couldn't even dream of finding comparable wages in free market scenarios in their own countries and come to the UK. I think the best we could do collectively is to pay out generous bonuses to frontline nurses for the duration of the pandemic.
- partyboat1586 7y agoI meant nurses (and other underpaid NHS workers) not necessarily Doctors sorry if I didn't make that clear.
- lostlogin 7y ago
- pwdisswordfish2 7y agoI’ve said it before and I won’t tire of saying it: »Gut, das ist der Pfennig! Und wo ist die Mark?« https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ihb2XqEsa4g https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ihb2XqEsa4g The same bullshit is happening everywhere. In the German Bundestag MPs gave standing ovations for care workers. Meanwhile those continue to slave away for pennies, now more precariously than ever, while the next items on the MPs agenda are bailouts for airlines and fucking car manufacturers. We can’t live without the care people and we don’t want to live without the fulfillment slaves. »Sie schulden euch Glück und Leben.« They should have huge leverage, especially in these times, why will they not organize?
- pwdisswordfish2 7y agoCheck out this CNBC interview with one of the warehouse organisers who was fired. (Which led to Tim Bray quitting.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15HUGc7R8hw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15HUGc7R8hw At one point it almost seems like he is suggesting to this poor guy that it is unreasonable for him to protest for better working conditions because "people like me" need to be able to place orders on Amazon while in lockdown. Imagine the difference in salary between the guy working for CNBC and the guy working in the Amazon warehouse. Feels as if we are watching some dystopian fantasy film like Hunger Games.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoI think it's a knee-jerk feeling that during an emergency you shouldn't refuse to work because you are making it harder on everyone else, as well as taking advantage of the emergency. That sounds reasonable enough, until you think about the fact that unless they organize and demand improvement now they won't have the leverage to do it after the emergency is over.
- brailsafe 7y agoWatched and agreed.
- econcon 7y agoHow many Germans actually work in healthcare? Doesn't healthcare in Germany constitute very large portion of immigrants workers?
- the-dude 7y agoIn the meantime in France, unions are holding Amazon accountable.
- zpeti 7y agoI’m genuinely interested in what people who think of amazon as an evil company think it should do. It hardly ever makes a profit. Any profit it makes is from AWS usually. It is popular because it’s so cheap, which is why people buy there. So really the solutions can only be: 1. Raise prices and consumers suffer 2. Keep wages low and workers suffer 3. Stop existing. I wonder how many people who complain about amazons working conditions don’t shop there and buy the same product for a higher price elsewhere. I’d guess not many.
- ccthr 7y agoit makes no profit yet Bezos is the richest man in the world by some margin? How can you buy into that narrative. The no profit book keeping is just a way to avoid paying tax. As a shareholder I would rather see them pay fairer wages, be taxed appropriately and have a slower rate of growth. If the cost of scaling at the speed they scale comes from unethical business practices then the answer is to scale slower, not exploit the worlds poorest and most vulnerable so that Jeff, myself and a load of other privileged capitalists can get even wealthier.
- zpeti 7y agoI’m not buying into anything but investors are. Amazon isn’t profitable. It’s not to avoid paying tax, it’s to reinvest. And because investors don’t care about profits in amazon it makes bezos the richest man. This doesn’t have anything to do with my initial comment though. Amazon is cheap because it pushes costs down in every area. Including workers. And consumers like that.
- ccthr 7y agoMy answer to your initial question (what do people think amazon should do?) Invest less in growth and more in the human capital that is essential to running the business. Playing by a different set of rules guided by Jeff's meglomania has driven them to the top and that is laudable. Once you've conquered the world do you still need to keep squashing the people you lead? What is it serving at that point other than pure egotism ?
- mjmasn 7y agoAside from the general tone-deafness of this move, shouldn't the management at the warehouses be the ones wearing the thank you t-shirts? To you know, thank the workers... I'm sure those workers would probably prefer and deserve a bonus and a heartfelt individual thank you though.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoWorkers are resources, not people. You're not considered a person in the US unless your net worth is high enough to make work unnecessary, and you can deal with a serious medical emergency without being bankrupted by it.
- pauletienney 7y agoPersonnaly, the COVID episode is the final straw. I live in France rural area. Amazon brings huge benefits and comodities there but I can't stand their attitude towards employees anymore.
- jason0597 7y agoShouldn't French Amazon employees be safe due to French labour laws?
- pauletienney 7y agoActually most of stories that influenced my decision are from US: employees fired by algorythm, fired because trying to unionize, etc. It seems all of this is impossible in France but still, this is not a culture I want to support.
- koheripbal 7y ago...but what if your impression is just based upon the bubble of news you consume? Isn't it possible you, from France, don't get unbiased news about US companies?
- pauletienney 7y agoI consume a lot of news from US and France on a quite large political spectrum, so I think the bias is quite reduced. I also discussed with an Amazon french warehouse manager. My decision is cold and well thought. Btw I would love to be wrong because I will miss their services.
- koheripbal 7y agoThe base salary in the warehouse is $15 per hour in the US, and similarly higher than average in France. It's a bit odd that the one retailer than meets the most aggressively demanded Progressive goal, seems to be the target of near-daily attack articles. It's almost as if there's something else going on with all this anti-Amazon news... isn't there?
- ReticentVole 7y ago"Give me enough medals and I'll win you any war"
- waschl 7y agoI am trying to reduce my Amazon-usage to a minimum, which works better and better. Only feature which is left are actually the wishlists to keep track of my own desires and ideas for gifts to others. Anyone knows a good alternative for any kinds of goods, which integrates with all kinds of online shops? I live in Germany.
- CaptainZapp 7y agoWhile certainly less convenient, but what about a real low tech solution: A notebook. While certainly not as spiffy it has the added advantage of being completely vendor agnostic.
- mrweasel 7y agoDoes Amazon management simply don’t see that stuff like handing out t-shirt is actually making them look worse? They could have cut pay and saved the cost of the shirts.
- throwawayer17 7y agoAnd just because he's a human a man would like a little bite to eat he wants no bull and a lot of talk, that gives no bread or meat.
- dajohnson89 7y agoClickbaity title (and worse than the article headline). Amazon is not cutting pay. It is removing the hazard pay, which was extra on top of the normal wages.
- d3nj4l 7y agoGiven the current scenario, isn't all pay hazard pay? Edit: And it's mentioned in the article as well: > The token comes as Amazon announced it would be cutting the $2 per hour wage hike it brought in for staff in mid-March as hazard pay for coming in during the pandemic. The "Hazard Pay" was a pay rise for coming in during the pandemic, which as far as I can see hasn't ended yet. Cutting hazard pay right now, in real terms, is cutting pay.
- koheripbal 7y ago> isn't all pay hazard pay? Not really. Not all jobs are risky. I fail to see how being in a well ventilated warehouse is risky. It's not like they're interacting with customers.
- panarky 7y ago> I fail to see how being in a well ventilated warehouse is risky Just because you don't understand it doesn't mean it isn't happening. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/03/24/amazon-warehouse-workers-coronavirus-positive/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/03/24/amazon-...
- koheripbal 7y agoLiterally nothing in that article supports your argument. 2 million people have tested positive - most of them probably did not contract it at work.
- d3nj4l 7y agoDid you even read the article? > In the past few days, workers tested positive for covid-19 at Amazon warehouses and shipping facilities across the country. > workers complain Amazon hasn’t provided them with enough information about the spread of virus in their facilities > [a worker] only found out there was an infected co-worker after confronting a human resources staffer in the break room > Some workers complained that Amazon pushes them to meet the per-hour rate at which it wants orders fulfilled, a practice that they worry discourages safe sanitary practices such as washing hands after a cough or sneeze. Others have complained about “stand-up” meetings, where workers stand shoulder-to-shoulder at the start of each shift. All of these support the notion that working in a warehouse is risky during the pandemic. In any case, how does the proportion of people who contracted the coronavirus at work to total number of positive cases so far have to do with anything? If your hypothesis is true (and you've given no evidence for that), it could very likely be because of the lockdowns we've had so far, which have prevented people from going to work in situations where they could've gotten it. Regardless, the proportion has nothing to do with how risky working in a warehouse is in the first place!
- espadrine 7y agoThe title is purposefully misleading. Amazon is not handing out ‘Thank you’ T-shirts to its warehouse workers. It is handing out “Thanks to you, we will deliver” T-shirts to its fulfillment associates. It is a societal statement on their power dynamics, not a hypocritical act. Amazon wants to be seen as exploitative today, because it will morally justify the layoffs tomorrow once all this is automated away.
- rumanator 7y ago> is handing out “Thanks to you, we will deliver” T-shirts to its fulfillment associates. Is it too hard to say "warehouse workers" instead of convoluted and misleading terms like "fulfillment associates"? > It is a societal statement on their power dynamics, not a hypocritical act. There is no societal statement. It's self-serving PR. And if Amazon is so hell-bent on announcing pay hikes and toot their own horn on how great they are for increasing wages then it should also be ok when they are called out for backpedalling on their actions. > Amazon wants to be seen as exploitative today, because it will morally justify the layoffs tomorrow once all this is automated away. Since when does Amazon have a plan to cease to be exploitative? Last time I've checked, Amazon was firing warehouse workers for complaining about unsafe working conditions, and then mobilizing VPs to put on smear campaigns targeting their own workers to avoid having to do anything about the problem.
- eecc 7y ago“fulfillment associates” - wow, the word employee is too laden with Socialist entitlement! Let’s new-speak them into “associates”... sounds like a Country Club membership
- IceDane 7y agoFound the Amazon manager.
- espadrine 7y agono. I try to objectively characterize their reasoning. I see comments about how it is awful of me to call them “fulfillment associates”—but this is the term Amazon picked[0]. And they chose it to represent how they see it fit in their worldview. My personal feelings? I am saddened by the lack of compassion. But the only way for people to optimize for the fulfillment of all lives instead of the minimization of all costs requires, at this point, a far teleportation of the Overton window in the political discourse. [0]: https://www.amazon.jobs/en/landing_pages/versandmitarbeiter https://www.amazon.jobs/en/landing_pages/versandmitarbeiter
- brainless 7y agoI have Tweeted this before and it is relevant here: Our situation with the virus is not dystopian, but our handling of it from the world leaders, business leaders certainly is.
- loraa 7y agoLast time I worked at a company where I thought I was better I left. People should complain less and quit, and go get that dream job.
- hardsoftnfloppy 7y agohttps://youtu.be/jLly1AUD9LI https://youtu.be/jLly1AUD9LI