5 ms·
Not your keys, not your coins™ -- with that as the core philosophy of cryptocurrency, can you even say this was stolen, let alone laundered? It sounds like the
by arcticbull 7y ago
Not your keys, not your coins™ -- with that as the core philosophy of cryptocurrency, can you even say this was stolen, let alone laundered?
It sounds like the person with the keys transferred the coins into another wallet.
Resolved: behaves correctly. At least, as intended anyways.
- save_ferris 7y agoThat makes sense. I guess that seems to somewhat conflict with the concept of the exchange as a service, at least for how laypeople understand currency exchanges in general. It wouldn’t surprise me if most people with exchange accounts don’t understand that coins not in their own wallet aren’t actually theirs. The exchanges don’t really make that clear to their users either, at least the ones I’ve used.
- barkingcat 7y agoIt turns out people want centralization :) I'm sure users mostly understand it but they give the keys away anyway. Core tenant of cryptocurrencies is purely anti-human
- aspenmayer 7y agoCan crypto be simultaneously anti-human [nature] and yet pro-user [intent]? Can the pain points of crypto be smoothed to make them pro-human [nature] without losing the qualities that make them pro-user [intent], supposing that they are pro-user [intent]?
- verdverm 7y agoWhat about the situation, "I paid them, but they never delivered?". How would wage garnishment, as ordered by the courts, work? (This is the main one that needs answering because it is a simple example of the hardest anti-human problem that goes against core blockchain philosophy... reversing or forcing transactions)
- aspenmayer 7y agoTo me that seems both too high a bar and making the perfect the enemy of the good. It’s asking too much of crypto specifically because the same complaint can be leveled against undeclared cash as you are leveling against crypto in your wage garnishment scenario. A hypothetical worker paid cash wages by a cash only business could in theory fail to divulge their full wages and thus fail to comply with a wage garnishment order. However, that is the status quo. To solve it is to solve it for all kinds of undeclared income, crypto included. For that reason I think that the current wage garnishment system is to blame for its own failings; it is also the moral failing or civil disobedience of the scofflaw which allows this situation as much as the existence of crypto. You may as well blame cash for the problems of crypto, and for the problems of wage garnishment evaders. As to how you are making the perfect the enemy of the good: your complaint fails to specifically apply to cryptocurrencies in general or to any specific crypto for the same reasons it fails to apply to cash specifically. That cryptocurrencies cannot mitigate the market failings of cash is not a failure of crypto or of cash. It is no failure at all because cryptocurrency never sought to solve that which you perceive as a fault. The problems you raise may be very real problems in society, but they are not a problem that is in-scope for crypto developers to solve or mitigate. That’s more of a problem for crypto custodians and their customers.
- verdverm 7y agoThis is very confusing and I don't follow
- aspenmayer 7y agoHow is cryptocurrency worse than cash for complying with court orders? If cash is no better or worse than cryptocurrency in regards to complying with court orders, then why single out cryptocurrency?
- arcticbull 7y agoNobody gets paid their salary with cash for a reason...
- barkingcat 7y agoI think you misunderstand, by thinking in terms of nature vs intent you are already anti-human. Remember, Users are Humans. Unless you want to let your cat buy cat food using cryptocurrencies? What I mean by anti-human, I am referring to the concept that to cryptocurrencies, people don't matter, their wishes, emotions, lives don't matter, the only thing that matters to cryptocurrencies is the algorithm and the principles.
- aspenmayer 7y agoI would say that is more ahuman than anti-human, in the same way one can be an atheist rather than a theist. Cryptocurrencies don’t have any regard or deference to humanity, because they lack agency. How then could they rise to become anti-human rather than simply ahuman?
- cortesoft 7y agoI don't think there is anything fundamental about cryptocurrency that would make them entirely immune to theft. You can both believe that the blockchain is working as intended and that the coins were stolen.
- arcticbull 7y agoI don't disagree although the system philosophically, at it's core, has no concept of theft, of permission, or reversal. Keys = coins.
- cortesoft 7y ago> Keys = coins Exactly... and if you steal the keys, you are stealing the coins.
- arcticbull 7y agoCan you steal keys? Can you "steal" a song? Is it a copyright issue? IP issue? I'm genuinely curious what this concept maps onto.
- wolco 7y agoYes it's like stealing a credit card number or generating one. Can someone steal your password?
- tridentlead 7y agoKeys have value, they are not yours, you take them, you stole them.
- hnick 7y agoIt's a bit of a flexible concept when it comes to IP and it's not a clean mapping. If I "steal" a song that you wrote by downloading it, you can still listen to it of course. This is what the pedants love to argue against. The law doesn't call this theft AFAIK, but there are separate laws. However a producer has lost something - the right to control who listens to it. The right to control how it is listened to, the right to an income from your creation. Various other things that people may or may not agree with but exist in law. So, to be lazy, non-legal people say they stole the song instead of all this. This applies to a lot of things such as crypto keys. Knowing the key doesn't remove the key from you. But I have removed control - you can no longer prevent me from taking your tokens/value. It is much like a stranger having a key to your house without your permission. They might never use it. You probably don't want it to be an ongoing situation though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ashtonkem 7y agoThat’s certainly an argument that can be made, but not one that’ll fly if you want more adoption.
- fluffything 7y agoIsn't this just the main trade-off between centralized banks and decentralized crypto? Like, if a bank is able to reset my password, how safe is it really ?
- ashtonkem 7y agoThe bank is regulated externally, they do not have arbitrary control over how they treat you. In fact, if you get hacked the bank will make you whole at their expense, which is quite a bit different from what happens in crypto.