3 ms·
Looks optimistic when large scale serological testing in Spain, which has a higher per capita death rate[1] suggest prevalence under 5%, and under 12% in the ep
by notahacker 7y ago
Looks optimistic when large scale serological testing in Spain, which has a higher per capita death rate[1] suggest prevalence under 5%, and under 12% in the epicentre of the disease in Madrid.
[1]yes, caveats apply
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoPotentially, but it's not unheard of for a disease to be differently severe in different places for inscrutable reasons. (Of course, that also does suggest those of us outside of England shouldn't generalize the findings too far.)
- makomk 7y agoIt's not necessarily all that inscrutable either. We know that a lot of deaths are in places like nursing homes, and that measures which reduce spread amongst the general population aren't necessarily going to be as effective at preventing spread in nursing homes since those obviously have to be staffed, etc.
- vannevar 7y agoIf you take the low end of the prevailing IFR estimates (~0.5%), the 5700-odd deaths would mean an infection rate of ~12% in London (population ~9M). If you assume 40% of deaths are not properly reported as COVID-19, that gets you to around 20%. But NYC, with a similar population, has had three times as many confirmed deaths, and antibody tests there suggest a total infection rate of 20%. LA antibody tests indicated something like 4%. I'm betting that when antibody tests are done, London will be lower than 20%, and the other areas are likely at the low end, or below, this estimate of 5-14%.
- joshuahedlund 7y agoYes, it would be one thing if this was an antibody/serotological testing result and we could add it to the mix of similar studies, like the ones suggesting ~1.1% rate in Spain (with 5% infected) or ~0.8-1.0% rate in NYC (with 25% infected). But this is not empirical data; it's pure modeling.
- gwd 7y agoIt's worth pointing out that the overall IFR is estimated at between 0.49% and 0.83%, with 0.63% being the median. That's only a bit lower than your NYC quote, and still about twice the IFR from the study from Germany (0.34%).