9 ms·
New Munich city government agrees to use open source software where possible
- brutal_chaos_ 7y agoExcept they didn't. It's just a campaign to strongly consider open source software in future contracts. Currently, there is a contract with Microsoft that isn't ending just yet. So they will have a mix of LiMux and Windows for the foreseeable future.
- seemslegit 7y agoThis is a bluff that almost every government and municipality with huge contracts with MS does whenever they come up for renewal as part of their negotiations, nobody in MS is impressed. In other news: 2020 is not the year of the linux desktop.
- lucb1e 7y agoDo you assume it's bluff or is there more behind that statement? I understand that it has been in the news that MS spent a lot of energy on preventing people from moving away from Windows, and I think I remember steep discounts but it has been a while since I read about it, but while the government could be going "haha let's put out another statement and get more discounts" I would say it's more likely that there are people in power in Europe that genuinely want to lessen our dependency on the benevolent big brothers from the USA. But that's just how the news reports it, perhaps I'm not cynical enough. Anyway, if you know of a statement by anyone in a relevant government that claims this was a negotiation tactic, that would be interesting.
- seemslegit 7y agoThe statement is in the language of the agreement as reported: "Where it is technologically and financially possible, the city will put emphasis on open standards and free open-source licensed software," Which in practice binds absolutely no one to absolutely anything.
- sho_hn 7y agoThey're already on Linux currently. A government change and Microsoft Germany moving their HQ to Munich made them reconsider. Now the government changed again. The actual migration to Linux went mostly fine and was largely a success as far as government software programs go, FWIW.
- buran77 7y agoFrom my personal experience most times the hardest part is to convince the users. You can throw a lot of resources at the migration, money, good technical experts, and get it done right. But making the regular users happy? That's a whole different subject. Truth is most users still run Windows at home and are familiar with it. Getting used to something else will meet some resistance. Then you have the minor compatibility issues especially in a people facing institution. To this day eventually this attrition pushes many back to the more compatible and familiar solution. I've seen (usually very small) companies going to Linux and other FOSS solutions without actually understanding this beyond "they're free". Migration went great. Later on I came back to do the migration the other way around once they faced that attrition and realized that support costs were dwarfing the license cost.
- mschuster91 7y ago> From my personal experience most times the hardest part is to convince the users. Former actual LiMux team member here, so I can speak from experience (almost a decade ago though). The hardest part was convince users to be happy on utterly inadequate and aged hardware. No, 1 GB of RAM won't cut it when you have to have Firefox, Thunderbird, OpenOffice and some fucking Java crap open at the same time, and 1024x768 screens won't do so either.
- bitL 7y agoYeah, that must have been a huge problem. These days however an OKayish notebook can be had for $400 or an i3 NUC with 8GB RAM and 256GB SSD with an IPS 1080p monitor for $500, and those would run any Linux well for foreseeable future without killing city's budget.
- dijit 7y agoPessimistically, I agree with you. But that lends the question; what does it take to end the Microsoft monopoly on our governments? It can’t just be open document standards. I think it goes further than that; into our schools maybe. I don’t have answers, but it’s a serious question I have.
- seemslegit 7y agoEasy, just create a software ecosystem that is superior to or at least on-par with the commercial offerings (being open source is not by itself valuable for the users), then grow a generation of non-technical users into that ecosystem
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- loudmax 7y ago> on-par with the commercial offerings That should be "offering" singular, not "offerings" plural. And it's totally feasible to produce a superior ecosystem. The hard part is absorbing years of financial loss while building the new ecosystem from the ground up while it isn't compatible with the existing proprietary system.
- seemslegit 7y ago> That should be "offering" singular, not "offerings" plural. Why ? An ecosystem consists of multiple offerings and there are also multiple commercial ecosystems. > And it's totally feasible to produce a superior ecosystem. The hard part is absorbing years of financial loss while building the new ecosystem from the ground up while it isn't compatible with the existing proprietary system. Being able to finance something is an inherent part of its feasibility.
- dijit 7y agoI think that this is not a charitable interpretation of the situation. While I generally agree that FOSS software (Libreoffice calc) is inferior for business needs, a _lot_ of the issues actually stem from compatibility. Not just compatibility of the document system and interpretation, though that is a large part. But compatibility of functionality too, along with UI design. People are more likely to re-train for a new UI on a new edition of their previous software because it is seen to them as a progression, but they are not so open to changing UI paradigms with different software that does the same thing. In order for something "better" to be accepted it has to not just be better- it has to be _so_ much better that it trumps everything else. in the very best of cases it has to be 100% compatible in all areas and _still_ at least substantially better. That's without getting in to opensource financing, which is a difficult topic. Though I can imagine if Munich put their resources into a FOSS foundation which was providing productivity software it would help tremendously. I don't think they're going to do that because Linux (and ecosystem) is seen as cheaper, so why negate the cost saving?
- FeepingCreature 7y agoThe term is "threat". A bluff is a threat you can't follow up on. Munich have shown they can and will follow up.
- tuukkah 7y agoKey quote: "So these kinds of decisions must come down to political philosophies about the marketplace as well as increasingly important issues like digital sovereignty. This issue is one reason why this time Munich is unlikely – or any other German city or state – to flip-flop on open-source software decisions again. "
- therealmarv 7y agoThe last u-turn was only decided by a bunch of politicians who like Microsoft Windows privately more than Linux. This is all politics. Nothing more...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- type0 7y ago> As yet, none of the big players appears to have lost significant business to the free software movement in Germany. But it seems likely that commercial vendors will have a tougher time here in the near future. Free software and open source doesn't mean non-commercial. SUSE in Germany provides commercial support to their distro for example. Such a weird article, zdnet doesn't getting any better...
- blaser-waffle 7y agoYeah the US Fed Gov loves linux, and Red Hat is all over the place.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoI can't imagine any US party echoing the FSF's statement, even if just in a statement of political intent. It's impressive that the movement has enough public interest to make platitudes worthwhile in Germany.
- tpush 7y agoThe FOSS movement in Germany always seemed to me a tiny bit more mainstream than the one in the US. Tech publications report more on Linux happenings (as opposed to the sometimes intense Apple focus of US tech publications). Linux also has more market share in Germany than any other western country, I think.
- xfiz 7y agoAccording to statcounter, Germany has the highest usage of Firefox and fourth highest usage of Linux (behind Ireland, Greece and Luxembourg) among European and North American countries. Additionally, you have the Chaos Computer Club, which is somewhat prominent and could influence the thinking about FOSS.
- user5994461 7y agoWhy would the US government try to avoid Microsoft? It's a well-known local company. And the government can get a good chunk of the license costs back throughout company and employment taxes.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoIn the eyes of the FSF and people with similar ideals, the benefits gained by spending that money on free software dwarfs the tax revenue gained. The German people seem to have enough support for free software to at least make the government notice, which does not seem true in the US.
- OrangeTux 7y agoThere is another interesting section in the document[1]. The city introduces the "Munich Open Source Sabatical". The city will pay professional programmers for 3 till 6 months to work on open source projects that benefit the community. > Die Stadt München unterstützt die Entwicklung von Open Source-Projekten mit einem "Munich Open Source Sabbatical". Professionelle Programmierer*innen, die sich für drei oder sechs Monate ganz auf die Fortentwicklung eines Open Source-Projektes kon-zentrieren möchten, können sich dafür auf ein städtisches bezahltes Stipendium bewerben. Die Projekte müssen einen kommunalen Nutzen haben. [1]: https://www.gruene-muenchen.de/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/Druckfassung_Koalitionsvertrag-2020_2026.pdf https://www.gruene-muenchen.de/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/Dr...
- tuukkah 7y agoI hope they will work together with Code for Germany to multiply the impact: https://www.codefor.de/en/ https://www.codefor.de/en/
- TulliusCicero 7y agoInteresting. How much will they pay them, though?
- lustigmacher 7y agoThe document doesn’t say how much. I guess, it’s just an umbrella document. More detailed regulations will be eventually adopted. That said, my estimate would be 500€ max per month.
- em-bee 7y agothat would not work. 500€ is not enough to pay rent in most places. it would have to something that covers your current living expenses, no matter how high they are, because unless you are young and single with a lot of flexibility, you are not going to be able to put a hold on all those expenses. therefore the two reasonable options are: the government continues to pay your current salary, or it pays what you'd get if they'd hire you. the latter would disadvantage high earners, but that is somewhat reasonable. anything less would unlikely get any people interested.
- panpanna 7y agoJust please don't create your own distro this time. I'm sure Canonical would happily hier some devs from Munich to make this look local.
- bmn__ 7y agoLimux is not its own distro, just a Debian/Ubuntu with additional branding and a few pieces of bundled software in an apt repo.
- sokoloff 7y agoI think the “Public money => public code” is a stronger (and arguably more interesting) piece of content in the article.
- fsflover 7y agoDirect link to the petition: https://publiccode.eu https://publiccode.eu
- acd 7y agoGovernments should develop and run opensource systems. That way different governments can collaborate to build better systems through open innovation. Not wasting tax payers money on closed source. I bet tax and pension systems have the same basic requirements cross countries with some local specifics.
- mikekchar 7y agoWhile I completely agree with you, there is a compelling argument for governments spending tax payer money on goods from local companies rather than competing with them. Of course, I don't think I would class MS as a "local company" for Munich ;-). I'm just saying that there are lots of reasonable points of view on this topic.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoIn the UK we outsource to the cheapest provider. More bang for the buck but it doesn't seem very holistic and appears to encourage corruption.
- em-bee 7y agohow is hiring local developers as employees any different from outsourcing to a local company? if the city is developing software then it is surely something that doesn't already exist, and when they do they are also not selling it, so i see no competition there. if the goal is to create jobs, then that also happens either way. i don't see the problem.
- toshk 7y agoI'm working on some projects for the city of Amsterdam, by default all we develop is open source. But whether this is a legal issue is actually an open debate, in some specific cases companies could potentially sue Amsterdam for sharing solutions with other governments and thereby "competing" with the market. How a judge would rule is not clear. But this is something they are aware of and it's a risk. It seems to also be connected to the way the project is shared. As far as I know they are looking into changing the law on the national level so this stops being a problem. Also strangely enough, I've been told, as soon as the project gets funded by the EU, this law is not applicable anymore. Open source means published on github, not many projects are actually properly documented.
- xvilka 7y agoAfter one lie they have zero trust. Most likely just trying to negotiate lower prices for Microsoft licenses.
- dgellow 7y agoYep, the same story every year, and always for the same result.
- flohofwoe 7y agoMaybe the difference to last time is that the Greens are now the strongest party? I guess they are not as easily "lobby-able" by Microsoft as the others.
- cpach 7y agoI seem to recall hearing the City of Munich considering FOSS for the past 15-20 years or so :)
- nelaboras 7y agoNo, they were implementing it at scale for 10+ years. There was an issue with lots of incompatible legacy software so they were still using windows as well but >50% of desks were Linux only. Then in a very short timespan (1) a new conservative city government came in, (2) Microsoft announced a big local office and (3) the new government killed the open source project without warning and anlunced they'd switch everything to windows 10. This transition back to windows is now still ongoing and as contracts are signed will not really be feasible to stop. The now new-new Green+social democratic government makes noe a pledge to take open source seriously for all future needs (and I suppose switch back to a Linux asap).
- dntbnmpls 7y agoMunich made headlines for deciding to switch to linux in 2003 and decided to go back to windows in 2018. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LiMux https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LiMux I still don't understand why major nations don't create or help create national OSes for their own countries/industries. You would think an OS is national security issue at the very least. A municipality isn't going to cut it. It's going to require a major national effort to stave off a monopoly like microsoft.
- m4r35n357 7y agoBean counters prefer to pay others to "make those problems seem to go away".
- MaxBarraclough 7y agoWasn't so long since their last U-turn, switching from Linux to Windows 10 around 2018. https://www.zdnet.com/article/linux-champion-munich-will-switch-to-windows-10-in-50m-rollout/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/linux-champion-munich-will-swi... , https://www.techrepublic.com/article/end-of-an-open-source-era-linux-pioneer-munich-confirms-switch-to-windows-10/ https://www.techrepublic.com/article/end-of-an-open-source-e...
- kleiba 7y agoYes, as discussed in the article.
- redleggedfrog 7y agoI suspect this time they will be able to make it stick, even if a new government comes into power in following years. The options, particular for desktop linux, have gotten better since the last time they tried it.
- gryzzly 7y agoIn case of government spend it is hard for me to comprehend why almost no place in the world has fully open source gov technology. Governments everywhere spend these insane amounts on really bad software :/
- Zhyl 7y agoThe sad reality is that there just isn't enough awareness or understanding of technology within Government to make it onto the agenda. The exceptions of this are little pockets of like-minded individuals such as GDS [1] who have done some exemplary work on open sourcing tech. The downside is that much of the 'trunk' of IT (workstations, Business Software, internal systems) are still contracted out to monolithic, old-school contractors who have no incentive to innovate by non-technical procurement teams. This leads to a culture of proprietary software where the established/expensive solutions are seen as the most trustworthy and there isn't any cost to vendor lock-in or non-interoperability of systems until the next tranche of officials have taken over and all of those issues can be written off as 'legacy' and as a sunk cost. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_Digital_Service https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_Digital_Service
- vharuck 7y agoAs a state government worker, this jives with my experience. The ultimate beneficiaries of any budget savings or improved processes are citizens who have no idea, let alone input, about what we're doing behind the scenes. It's very hard to convince public employees to work with those people in mind. You're right, the people buying the software are even harder to convince. With no good measures of effect, they rely on what's easiest for them. So Microsoft and PDFs everywhere. Our software licenses are paid through a grant from the federal government. If we replace them with open source software, we don't get to keep the difference. So now I have licensed software like SAS and ArcGIS gathering dust on my machine while I use R and Python. And sharing software we develop is even harder. I've pushed to release code for my statistical reports. When I said researchers and other states could benefit by reusing parts, my supervisors only saw it as a liability with no benefit to us. I might try to slip it in as part of the technical notes.
- 7y ago
- jsnider3 7y agoBeautiful.
- imchillyb 7y ago...Until they're voted out and replaced with those who are against 'hacker software'. This is the same ol' carousel we've been going round and round on now for more than 2 decades. Some people 'get' free and open software, the other people run our world.
- ARandomerDude 7y ago> wherever possible This reminds me of a quote by the character Humphrey Appleby on "Yes, Minister" ("The Office"-like sitcom about government): "Almost anything can be attacked as a loss of amenity. And almost anything can be defended as not a significant loss of amenity."