4 ms·
Another aspect of this is the cost of the physical solar cells have dropped low enough that other costs have become significant. This is pushing companies to i
by Retric 7y ago
Another aspect of this is the cost of the physical solar cells have dropped low enough that other costs have become significant. This is pushing companies to increase efficiency which opens the door for other applications.
A hypothetical cheap ~30% efficient solar panel could add something like 40 miles of range per day to a car in ideal conditions. That starts to look actually useful vs a simple gimmick.
- _-david-_ 7y ago>A hypothetical cheap ~30% efficient solar panel could add something like 40 miles of range per day to a car in ideal conditions. Does this take into consideration the increased weight of the solar panel and any additional equipment?
- andy_ppp 7y agoCould it not be built into the roof directly! This is a great idea as presumably people who don’t use their car a lot need not leave it charging permanently and if you run out of battery you can just wait (if it’s sunny enough).
- _-david-_ 7y agoI am not positive but I am guessing that solar panels as the roof would weight more than the regular car material? I am not really an expert on electricity but there could also be additional equipment involved as well (inverters, transformers, etc).
- Retric 7y agoThe light collecting portion of solar panels is extremely light weight. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B082FCZ4MD/ref=emc_b_5_t?th=1 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B082FCZ4MD/ref=emc_b_5_t?th=1 59.2 by 26.5 inches or ~1 square meter Weight: 6.2 lbs. If you looking at 12 square meters of space that’s 75 pounds though an integrated system would have plenty of options to save weight. Solar panels are DC as are batteries so you don’t need an inverter.
- cortesoft 7y agoWhy is that better than just putting the solar panel on the roof of your house and plugging the car in?
- Retric 7y agoYour car is presumably not always at home. So, a solar panels on the roof of your house don’t increase the range of your car. At highway speeds assuming regular charges that’s mostly irrelevant. But if you’re camping or run out of charge it could become so. Even relatively small solar arrays could keep a car from discharging at an airport parking lot etc. That could extend to running the climate controls when your shopping without concern for draining the battery. PS: That said, the roof also has many advantages such as allowing you to park in a garage without issue.
- hnick 7y agoI wonder how that would change the safety profile of the car (for driver and outsiders) and insurance costs. Panels are fairly cheap but you'd be adding a bit of value there.
- TheGrim-888 7y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, and I quite possible could be, but from a quick Google search, I'm seeing numbers of anywhere 200Wh/mile to 350Wh/mile for a Tesla. If we're generous and assume only 200Wh/mile, then 40 miles of range translates to an energy consumption of 8,000Wh. A 100 watt solar panel, producing the full 100 watts, would take 80 hours of perfect sunlight to produce enough power for an extra 40 miles of range. Assuming best case (unrealistic) conditions, if you get 8 hours of perfect sunlight in day, and your solar panels produce 100% of their rating for all 8 hours, it would take 1000 Watts worth of solar panels to produce that extra 40 miles of distance over 8 hours. It seems kind of unrealistic to fit 1000 Watts of solar on top of a car. And that's an absolute minimum, under best case conditions. If you had, say, maybe a more realistic 300 watts worth of panels on top, and they got 4 hours of full sunglight, you'd be producing an extra ((300W * 4h) / 200Wh/mile) = 6 miles. And that's still assuming best case condition for power consumption per mile. [Edit] - And like the other commenter stated, those few extra miles get cut down when you consider the weight of hundreds of watts of solar panels added onto the vehicle.
- rootusrootus 7y agoHere's a recent analysis: https://teslatap.com/articles/solar-vehicle-roof-analysis/ https://teslatap.com/articles/solar-vehicle-roof-analysis/ To me it looks like it will never be a meaningful solution, due simply to physics.
- Retric 7y agoThat has several really bad assumptions by assuming all solar roofs need to fit on an existing Tesla‘a roof. > The usable clear area of a Model S glass roof is 42” x 45” A Model S is actually 195.9” by 77.3 (ex. mirrors). Assuming a reasonable shaped solar car using 75% of that surface is covered in panels that’s 12x the area. But you also gain from panels covering the sides of the vehicle. Further “Because the vehicle roof is flat, it collects less light than if it was positioned at the optimum angle to the sun.“ as I said your not limited by the roof. “Lastly, we lose at least 10% more due to the safety glass,” we don’t need glass and that’s already part of panel efficiency numbers. “and the inverter/charging is only 81% efficient.” Solar panels and batteries are both DC so you don’t need an inverter, the charge discharge efficiency of lithium ion can be over 90%. San Francisco 5.34kWh/m * .3 efficiency * 7.33 square meters = 11.7kW/day /.3kW per mile = 35 to 39.14 miles in San Francisco depending on how much your charging the battery with plenty of areas getting more sunlight. Using the highest efficiency panels currently produced that goes up significantly, but cheap 30% efficient panels seems like a more reasonable mid term prediction. PS: Example of a flexible 1m panel zero glass required at under 300$/m: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B082FCZ4MD/ref=emc_b_5_t?th=1 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B082FCZ4MD/ref=emc_b_5_t?th=1