2 ms·
Honestly this kind of drivel needs to be kicked out of hn. Start-ups create value and what companies do with these start-ups once they have been acquired is the
by tomjen3 16y ago
Honestly this kind of drivel needs to be kicked out of hn. Start-ups create value and what companies do with these start-ups once they have been acquired is their own problem. Big companies a constantly screwing up left and right, but that is not our fault.
Yes we lust for new things, which is why the author can afford a computer to write his article on; yes we lust for profit, that is why joining a start-up and taking up the huge risk is something one is willing to do; yes we make old businesses obsolete, but that just frees people to join other companies which are capable of creating stuff, not sucking up resources.
The only thing start-ups forces people to do is to think and adapt. And if they aren't willing to do so, they have nobody but them-self to complain about.
And no start-up can create a bubble, those bubbles come from the insane recklessness of the FEDs dollar printing and the resulting super low interest rates because there is too few productive places to invest ones money.
We need more start-ups, not fewer; We need more economic activity, not less and we need more people with ability, not clones who will never amount to anything.
- johnrob 16y agoI think we over estimate the impact startups have on job creation. The recent home runs (google, facebook, zynga, groupon) have created astonishingly large value with relatively few employees - a few thousand on average. Startups are good at creating wealth, but not necessarily jobs (we still have record level unemployment in silicon valley). Our country needs to put millions of people to work; the 20k jobs created by startups are not going to solve that problem. Theoretically, the unemployed workers can adapt to the "new economy" and re-establish themselves. Empirically, however, that's not happening. Startups are more likely to aid the jobless via welfare (from tax revenue) than by actually employing people.
- gsmaverick 16y agoNew startups don't just create jobs for the people they themselves hire. Google & Facebook in particular have created far more jobs than those on their payrolls.
- tomjen3 16y agoIt is possible for a writer now to make a good living selling his self-published ebooks on Amazon's kindle platform, to maintain a living writing blogposts for an audience larger than many smaller magazines ever had, etc. But that is beside the point: job creation isn't the goal of any business nor is it the responsibility of any business to hire a certain amount of people, and the country as such doesn't need to put a large number of people to work - people are responsible for their own life and if they are not willing to do that (and you may very well be right about that I don't know), that is their own problem.
- PetoVera_Matt 16y agoI disagree, Tom. You see, I believe entrepreneurs are heroes, and as such they need to lead and guide people who are unwilling to lead themselves for the greater benefit of all.
- tomjen3 16y agoNobody can change others, and there are plenty of guides online about personal development if that is what one is interested in.
- ChuckMcM 16y agoI was thinking of the parallel "article": The guy who wrote the "article" and I use it in quotes because it means different things to different people, actual journalists spend time and effort crafting a story and thinking about the various sides, where as this sort of "article" is spit out partially considered with an expected lifetime of minutes, never to provide another insight later on ... More experienced folks seem to grasp that business creation is good. They also understand that businesses start and then evolve in response to market forces. And lets not forget that businesses are the expression of the people who it employs.
- PetoVera_Matt 16y agoHi Tom, I think most people (me included) would agree with your last sentence) Question for you though: which do you think creates more wealth for the most people: Short-term greed or long term greed?
- tomjen3 16y agoI don't think there is a difference really: short term greed which has little negative effect on the future is merely good long term greed (since a dollar today is better than a dollar tomorrow) whereas eating the seed for the next harvest isn't really greed, but insanity. I am not advocating a blind greed simply to get as much as possible damn the consequences but a rational greed based on the understanding that it is better to have than it is to not have.
- PetoVera_Matt 16y agoI would reconsider some of the assumptions in your first statement. How or what would you define as "rational greed"? If you have an example that would be best since we wouldn't have to discuss in hypotheticals :)