6 ms·
>This whole industry is yet another example of “fake markets” that were created by just massively subsidizing something with VC cash. How do you reconcile this
by s1artibartfast 7y ago
>This whole industry is yet another example of “fake markets” that were created by just massively subsidizing something with VC cash.
How do you reconcile this narrative with the fact that Grubhub turned a net profit every available year until 2019 per their SEC filings. [1] All told, they only took about 85 million between founding in 2004 and IPO in 2014, and they were already net profitable when they took the last 50.[2]
[1] https://investors.grubhub.com/investors/sec-filings/default.aspx https://investors.grubhub.com/investors/sec-filings/default....
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grubhub#Grubhub_history https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grubhub#Grubhub_history
- aripickar 7y agoMost people railing against "fake markets" haven't considered the fact. Grubhub has long been profitable, same with Seamless. People still think that their uber rides are being subsidized on every ride, but uber now makes profit on every ride (at least in the us, not sure about abroad). For some reason, theres this streak on HN of people that think that VC's are just complete idiots, and are completely just pissing away money.
- Skunkleton 7y agoI personally don't have the data to support or refute the "fake market" claim. I would point out however that it is not enough to be cash-flow positive for individual transactions. Sure Uber now makes money on every ride, is the business as a whole poised to make money? Will that be stable in light of likely regulations? Like I said, I don't know. I don't think the questions can be dismissed just by assuming that VCs know what they are doing. Edit: I went and looked at GrubHubs 2019 Q4 results [1]. They operated at a $30M loss. Most of the expenses were "operations" related. I'm not sure if that includes engineering, but I guess it doesn't. [1] https://investors.grubhub.com/investors/press-releases/press-release-details/2020/Grubhub-Reports-Fourth-Quarter-And-Full-Year-2019-Results/default.aspx https://investors.grubhub.com/investors/press-releases/press...
- s1artibartfast 7y agoThat is why I said until 2019 in the parent thread. I suspect losses in 2019 were related to increased competition from UBER EATs, Ect. Net income for prior years were: 2019: -18M 2018: +78M 2017: +99M 2016: +49M 2015: +38M 2014: +24M 2013: +7M 2012: +8M 2011: +15M
- john_moscow 7y ago>For some reason, theres this streak on HN of people that think that VC's are just complete idiots, and are completely just pissing away money. They are not. But they are banking on the general public to buy shares without scrutinizing the business sustainability and be left holding the bag.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- adventured 7y agoWhich bags were the public left holding? There have been a lot of very easy wins for investors picking up VC-backed companies in the public market. If all you did is just spray around some diversification at prominent tech IPOs, you've done extraordinarily well over time. Since IPO: Shopify? $28 to $754 ServiceNow? $25 to $361 Alibaba? $93 to $199 Splunk? $36 to $149 DocuSign? $39 to $119 Teladoc? $28 to $188 Atlassian? $27 to $175 MongoDB? $30 to $194 Square? $12 to $73 Twilio? $26 to $187 Workday? $48 to $153 Veeva? $44 to $195 Zoom? $62 to $167 Facebook? $38 to $205 Palo Alto Networks? $53 to $215 Okta? $23 to $177 Wix? $17 to $166 Wayfair? $32 to $183 The Trade Desk? $27 to $292 Coupa? $29 to $205 RingCentral? $18 to $283 Zendesk? $15 to $73 Zscaler? $33 to $75 PayPal? $34 to $143 CyberArk? $30 to $96 Proofpoint? $13 to $115 Qualys? $13 to $101 Smartsheet? $19 to $52 JD.com? $20 to $47 Anaplan? $24 to $40 Zillow? $26 to $46 Roku? $26 to $117 Or more recently: CrowdStrike? $58 to $76 Cloudflare? $18 to $27 Fastly? $24 to $36 Maybe they're holding one of the older bags. Fortinet? $8 to $137 Tesla? $20 to $790 Salesforce? $4 to $169 Baidu? $8 to $95 Netflix? $1 to $438 Google? $50 to $1,349 Oh the horror.
- code4tee 7y agoThe whole “Uber makes a profit on the ride” stat is broadly just creative accounting that counts the revenue and ignores most of the costs including the huge back office operation to build and support the app, marketing, admin, etc etc. Yes it’s good that they charge the customer more than they pay the driver, but that doesn’t translate into a “profitable transaction” from a business standpoint. If it takes $X millions in engineering costs to build and maintain an app required for that ride to have occurred then one needs to prorate that cost across each ride as a cost and so on. There are lots of examples of these creative “our transactions are profitable” claims like WeWork’s much ridiculed “Community Adjusted EBITDA” metric. The fancier your metrics need to be to show you are “profitable” the bigger the red flag should be that all is not well in Oz.
- SkyMarshal 7y ago> For some reason, theres this streak on HN of people that think that VC's are just complete idiots, and are completely just pissing away money. Well sometimes they are, sometimes they aren't. Softbank Vision Fund justifies at least questioning some VC strategies.
- pbourke 7y ago> For some reason, theres this streak on HN of people that think that VC's are just complete idiots, and are completely just pissing away money. Some of us think they're hypebeasts in search of a greater fool.
- draw_down 7y agoRemember that revenue is a fact, profit is an opinion!
- chadlavi 7y agoGrubhub's profits come directly out of local restaurateurs' pockets. It's easy to be profitable when you get to set your fees and have platform lock-in.
- s1artibartfast 7y agoThat is not a unsustainable "fake market", it is being a transactional middleman, as seen in almost every market.
- landryraccoon 7y agoI don’t see what the drawback is for Grubhub. You just made a case that investing in Grubhub is going to pay solid returns.
- projectileboy 7y agoExcept that local restaurants are already operating on razor thin margins. And when the only surviving restaurants are Perkins and Applebee’s, the delivery services lose a lot of their value proposition.
- RandallBrown 7y agoSeamless has been around for over 20 years and is very popular in NYC. Why would restaurants keep using it if it wasn't advantageous for them?
- onemoresoop 7y agoThey have no choice. People used to have a stack of menus form local deliveries. Nowadays the convenience made ordering food through apps the thing to do. The thin margins that restaurants operate on gets sweeped under grubhub’s and the landlords rugs. This will kill most small food business which rely on deliveries.
- Swizec 7y ago> It's easy to be profitable when you get to set your fees and have platform lock-in. That's exactly the VC playbook isn't it? Subsidize the market until you achieve lock-in, then stop the subsidies. Now the market has nowhere else to go but to pay almost whatever you want. A restaurant can't afford to not be on GrubHub. A diner doesn't even consider non-grubhub options due to habit.
- wtvanhest 7y agoThe OP is calling this a 'fake market'. That is inaccurate in that of course a certain number of people will pay for food to be delivered. Pizza delivery has been a thing for a long time. Grubhub has taken a profitable share of the market which makes sense. Some people believe that new entrants are using private funding to subsidize the price of delivery to gain market share. By doing so, they are expanding the market beyond what the economics of the market support. Those new entrants would argue that they are doing so because once they lock in customers and restaurants, they can raise their prices or lower their costs and turn a profit. Where this all ends up is an interesting thought exercise , but it certainly isn't an easy question to answer.
- s1artibartfast 7y agoI totally agree with your assessment. Given that, it really makes me wonder how UBER and their ilk skirt predatory pricing laws. UBER is running a loss, tanking the profit of grubhub, and now considering buying it out.
- unreal37 7y agoThe pizza delivery operation is typically part of the pizza chain, and not outsourced to a third party that takes a hefty fee from the restaurant and the customer. Easier to pay a kid $7.50 per hour to drive around than to pay $12 per order to a third-party.
- hiram112 7y ago> not outsourced to a third party that takes a hefty fee from the restaurant and the customer. I delivered pizza for years before and during college. Looking back, I sometimes think the drivers were the ones who were subsidizing the big chains. This was very early 2000s. I was paid about $6/hour and $0.70 per delivery plus tips which averaged $2 per delivery @ 3 deliveries per hour, 90% tax free as credit cards weren't used much then. I would walk home with $14 / hour, after taxes, which seemed like a great deal back then when the only other option for an introverted average looking guy who wasn't gonna make it as a waiter / bartender would have been $12/hour working awful data entry jobs or $8/hour doing retail. It helped that gas was $1/gallon then, though within the next 8 years it would rise to almost $5/gallon. But in those few years, I put on tons of miles of the worst kind of stop-and-go driving. I had a relatively decent 5 year old Honda, but after 4 years of delivering pies, it needed replacing. So essentially, I thought I was making $14/hour in a pretty cool job (driving around, listening to CDs, eating free pizza), but I'm guessing it was more like $10/hour after accounting for the wear and tear on my car. I'd imagine most Uber, Lyft, Grub Hub, etc. drivers are all gonna see similar costs of doing business when they tally up their profits & losses over the lifetime of their car.
- freshhawk 7y agoHave you seen the bills restaurants are getting from Grubhub and the numbers on the restaurant side? The shadow restaurants opening up to serve these markets that massively lower the quality of the food in shared terrible kitchens (most not zoned for that and with little to no safety equipment) but using the restaurant name anyway? It's the whole thing end-to-end that is unsustainable.
- uptown 7y agoHere’s one: https://twitter.com/susie_c/status/1255971900599046144 https://twitter.com/susie_c/status/1255971900599046144 $1042 becomes $346.
- drewrv 7y ago> The shadow restaurants opening up to serve these markets that massively lower the quality of the food in shared terrible kitchens (most not zoned for that and with little to no safety equipment) but using the restaurant name anyway? Or as a recruiter recently pitched it to me, Travis Kalanicks next billion dollar opportunity! https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.businessinsider.com/cloud-kitchens-travis-kalanick-san-francisco-location-address-pictures-2019-11%3Famp https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.businessinsider.com/cloud-k...
- projectileboy 7y agoThere is one complicating factor, however, which is that Grubhub and similar delivery services were making things very difficult for restaurants, which is already a difficult business. It’s not obvious that in the long run the big food delivery players wouldn’t have simply been the parasite that killed the host. Now, we’ll probably never know, since restaurants will be mostly doomed for at least the next year, taking any value-add businesses along with them.
- Non24Throw 7y agoI think GrubHub’s partnership and tie-in with Yelp makes this a very apples-to-oranges comparison. Food delivery apps operate with or without the restaurant’s approval and aren’t able to reach into the restaurant’s pocket the way Yelp and GrubHub can (and boy do they). Also this is anecdotal, but I’m way more likely to place a pickup order through GrubHub than any of the other apps (if they even offer that). I think it might have to do with the Yelp integration, and me associating that experience with in-person dining... so maybe I’m just naturally in a “find a place to physically go to” mode when browsing Yelp? The takeout side of this business would obviously have no issues being profitable.
- x3blah 7y ago"How do you reconcile this narrative with the fact that Grubhub turned a net profit every available year until 2019 per their SEC filings." Easy. Take away the VC funding and see if anyone wants to try or can manage to start a similar company. In most cases, these companies are just middlemen. Many folks do not see middlemen as "legitimate" businesses, even though the middlemen make money. Hosts and parasites can each thrive. However only one can survive on its own. Ideally hosts would prefer to live free of parasites. It should be expected that some consumers or producers will want to cut out the middlemen. We cannot reasonably expect everyone to appreciate those middlemen for the success they may have in taking a cut (and collecting data on consumer behaviour).