4 ms·
I am the proud recipient of many Apple rejection notices from the App Store (I have been releasing iOS apps since 2012). I have not had an app pulled, but I hav
by ChrisMarshallNY 7y ago
I am the proud recipient of many Apple rejection notices from the App Store (I have been releasing iOS apps since 2012). I have not had an app pulled, but I have had many rejections to submitted apps (the latest were received yesterday).
In all of the notices, Apple is usually quite explicit in what the problem is, including attaching screengrabs, and they will respond, if I ask them for further clarification.
- victorvation 7y agoI've seen cases where Apple will actually decompile/debug your app and point you the exact feature / method / line that they find unacceptable. Despite all of my other complaints about iOS ecosystem, they _do_ keep their App Store walled garden fairly well tended.
- hutzlibu 7y agoOut of curiosity, where those big name apps, or small ones? I assume that level of service is reserved or more important apps?
- victorvation 7y agoNot a tiny app by any means, but we were definitely small enough that we were surprised at the level of depth in their analysis.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoSmall ones. Most are free. Over the years, I've had over twenty apps in the store, but most are retired. I'm down to seven: https://littlegreenviper.com/AppDocs/ https://littlegreenviper.com/AppDocs/
- ashtonkem 7y agoI had Apple point out that I hadn’t yet added a TOS for a trivia app I was making; they’re very thorough.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoAlmost every rejection has been a matter of "process," like ToS, privacy policy, plist entries, etc. In a couple of cases, they actually found crashes that I missed in my testing.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoI should also mention another common rejection reason, so it's "out there." Trademark use. I have had apps rejected because I used a trademark (usually Apple's) in my app name or description. For example, I had submitted an app called "Bluetooth 8-Ball for tvOS". I was told that "tvOS" was not allowable. I had to use "TV". This kind of thing has happened a few times. I casually use Apple trademarked terminology a lot, but I can't be as sanguine about it when I submit apps. Full Disclosure: They also had a problem with the app being a "demonstrator" app. They don't want us releasing apps that they don't think we're "serious" about. They had a point, and I ended up withdrawing the app.
- filleduchaos 7y agoThis is why I'm often amused when people gripe about the $99/year membership fee for the Apple Developer Program.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoI consider it a "token" amount, calculated to be just enough to keep people that aren't actually serious about releasing apps out. They sure aren't looking at developer account fees to hold their bottom line up. It's low enough that I can easily keep two organizational accounts going.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoAs someone who gripes about it: I think $99/year is a perfectly reasonable fee in order to submit to the App Store. I just don't think it should be the only way to run my own code on my own phone (without jumping through the rediculous hoop of reinstalling an app every single week).
- sushid 7y agoYou just answered yourself. It's not a the only way to run your own code on your own phone. AFAIK that restriction is to prevent jailbreakers from easily sideloading paid apps as "their" apps on their phones.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoBut it effectively is! There is no way for me to make anything useful for myself if I have to connect my phone to a computer and reinstall the app every seven days. If I forget, the app suddenly won't open. If I go on vacation without a computer, the app won't open. The seven day thing is useful for testing, and nothing more. If the goal is to prevent piracy, well, as with other forms of DRM I as a paying customer don't appreciate being treated like a thief. Dedicated pirates can and do just buy stolen enterprise certs on the black market anyway.
- 7y ago
- sb8244 7y agoSomeone from Apple got on the phone with me to explain a rejection. I was disappointed with the outcome but very surprised at how they were willing to talk about it and explain why.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoI was able to get a couple of apps approved, but I have perfected my forelock-pulling and wheedling skills. I always deal with them very respectfully and deferentially. Basically, I support Apple’s “walled garden.” It’s a pain to deal with, but it makes their App Store a lot more valuable. There is a lot of loud, vocal, opposition to it, but the vast majority of regular (as in non-geek) people like it just fine.
- sb8244 7y agoI agree. While I wasn't happy with the outcome, I do respect it and would not do anything to actively work around it. Just pulled the feature and moved on with the app. The fact that they took the time to explain and justify the rejection made all of the difference. I have been on the receiving end with Google and it's much more difficult to deal with.
- jonnycomputer 7y agoWhich pretty much blows up the idea that Google's vagueness is about security.