5 ms·
The pain needs to propagate up the debt ladder now that it has overflowed the first layer of rent payers. When landlords aren't getting their incoming payments,
by mindslight 7y ago
The pain needs to propagate up the debt ladder now that it has overflowed the first layer of rent payers. When landlords aren't getting their incoming payments, there should be growing political will to do this - freezing mortgage payments, interest, and a large part of real estate taxes.
It's either now, or a future crisis when the black hole of debt has grown even larger.
- nradov 7y agoIt's impossible to freeze real estate taxes. Local governments don't have reserves and would quickly become insolvent.
- mindslight 7y agoLayer 3: frozen interest and payments on municipal bonds.
- nradov 7y agoMunicipal bonds are a minor issue. Employees (and retirees) still have to be paid. Asphalt to repair potholes isn't free. Your proposal in totally unreasonable.
- mindslight 7y agoI haven't fleshed out all the details, because I'm describing the fundamental problem. The economy is a distributed system, precisely because nobody can know all the details. I'm sure the cities themselves are perfectly capable of figuring out how to salvage their situation, when they actually feel the squeeze. By bluntly rejecting my analysis, you're effectively arguing that cities shouldn't have to feel any of the squeeze, by making the pain remain on others instead. You're right about defined benefit pensions. They also are in the class of economic rent payments, and so should also be drastically reduced during the pullback.
- jeffbee 7y agoWhy freeze taxes? You're proposing that land owners are allowed to capture all of the upside of a booming economy, and then should be protected in falling economies? Why? They are demonstrably to better-off among us. If a jurisdiction had the ability to forego that revenue, I'm sure they can find a better place to cut it (like suspending sales taxes on food, or payroll taxes).
- mindslight 7y agoBecause that's the debt chain. Real estate taxes are a recurring payment levied by a city on a fictitious asset valuation, the same as a mortgage. And I did say a "large part", chiefly the part that goes to paying municipal bonds (the next link in the debt chain). I understand we all want to see landlords reap the full rewards of their bad decisions, but the article is correct that this will just allow the administrators of the next higher level to mop up, with nothing fundamentally changing. When the eviction freeze is over, tenants will be right back on the debt treadmill, with an even more distant and less empathetic landlord.
- jeffbee 7y agoHonestly could not parse your argument. We should suspend taxes because we do not intend to pay bond holders?
- mindslight 7y agoTaxes and bonds, along with landlords, are steps in the long path of economic rent payments that start with tenants paying rent. Many tenants are not paying rent. Therefore, rather than trying to turn the screws harder on the tenants (as resuming evictions would do), or making some unlucky middlemen go bankrupt today (just to be replaced with increasingly centralized middlemen as the article points out), we should examine and aim to pause the entire chain of economic rent payments that starts with the tenants.