It didn't seem like much of a dilemma to me. If it appears that it was a clear case of cheating, then the only response to the student is that they shouldn't ha

It didn't seem like much of a dilemma to me. If it appears that it was a clear case of cheating, then the only response to the student is that they shouldn't have to be told not to cheat. Where's their inner moral compass? How severe should the penalty be? I give an instant oral quiz, and if it looks like they could have solved the problem anyway, I let them off with a warning.