16 ms·
Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance
- Element_ 7y agoEmployers asking to install this junk on personal devices seems like an over reach. Maybe some bored software developer could create the "uBlock of employee trackers". A program that would feed fake data into these trackers to make them unreliable for employers.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoBYOD must not require spyware, period. Companies that do it are too cheap to provide corporate equipment and too insecure to trust their own employees observable output. An open video stream to employees workstation could be reasonable if there is suspicion of fraud, like outsourcing their work to untrusted 3rd parties. It's not too unlike having an employee in the office. Though even in office employees have some expectations of privacy, like not exposing their home life or bathroom routines. Of course a company device would still need to be provided.
- itronitron 7y agojust watch this video when you think you're being surveiled >> https://youtu.be/7YvAYIJSSZY https://youtu.be/7YvAYIJSSZY
- normalnorm 7y agoLet me make a wild guess: your paycheck ultimately depends on collecting other people's private data.
- itronitron 7y agono, I just think it is worth remembering a time when it was understood even in pop culture to be freaked out by people watching you
- cosmodisk 7y agoIt's being done by the same clowns who can't live without time clock cards, all sorts of monitoring,and tracking.These are the people who have no clue how to manage people,how to measure their work and act upon results.These are the same crappy companies who would rather ask their staff to email endless Excel spreadsheets to each other instead of investing some money in database or some crm system. In a nutshell,these are the bottom feeders of this world.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoFundamentally it's just an outdated style of doing business. The same people who tell you not to do personal web browsing at work will not respond to an email that arrives in the evening until they clock in the next morning. Whereas sure, I don't spend an eight hour solid block of time working each day, but I'll respond to a help ticket at 11pm because someone had a quick need and my computer is handy. My employer is still getting my eight hours, possibly more, just diffused through the whole day.
- poulsbohemian 7y ago>My employer is still getting my eight hours, possibly more, just diffused through the whole day. Even that sticks in my craw... we need to make this 8 hour bar die. Some days I'm just not productive. Other days I might be heads-down on a problem for 15+ hours straight. So long as I'm accountable to my work and it is producing the results we've mutually agreed upon, this hour nonsense (for workers not billing by the hour, which is its own separate discussion) needs to go away.
- Gibbon1 7y agoMy favorite is trying to figure out a bug and nothing I can think of provides any clue. So I do some other work for a bit and go home. And the next morning sit down down and fix the problem in 2 minutes. Obviously _something_ got done between last night and this morning. But how would you bill for THAT. Or an old example from a mentor. Get in the shower, start thinking about what you're going to work on today. Realize you've been in the shower for half an hour. How you going to bill for that? I've come to the idea that you pay an engineer for his attention to your problems. Engineers I dislike working with are ones that don't. Their other interests have crowded out what they are being paid to mind. And some of those guys definitely do spend 8 hours in the chair going through the motions. They do work but there is a disunity to the whole thing.
- bpatel576 7y agoI think this is a situation where employees need to leave the company. We vote with our choices. If we don't deem this to be appropriate, we must respond in kind. It's not simple and not everyone has the choice, but for those that can, should.
- javajosh 7y agoOr regulate. Consider that your same argument was applies to e.g. the 40-hour workweek, and workplace safety standards in the US. We quite rightly decided not to leave such things to the market because in practice the labor market is FAR from perfect.
- loa_in_ 7y agoRegulation is the opposite of exercising freedom you already have
- js8 7y agoI downvoted you, because I think this is not true in general. Regulation can actually increase the freedom. It is a concept in philosophy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance And it's also not true in particular, you might happen to be in a group which benefits from given regulation. Hopefully, in a democratic society, the group that is negatively affected (if any) is as small as possible.
- subhobroto 7y ago.. and I downvoted you, because it absolutely true by definition. Regulation, by definition, decreases freedom. That's the whole point of regulation - to threaten with violence, acts that people have agreed are not a good idea. If software engineers were regulated under IEEE, the freedoms of software engineers would decrease not increase. I quote from the article you linked: "In order to maintain a tolerant society, the society must be intolerant of intolerance." Regulation, by definition, is intolerance. For example - the minimum wage regulation. You have now removed the freedom of an untrained, unemployed person to sell their labor at a lower floor which was their only way to gain employment when there's a trained but unemployed person willing to also work for minimum wage!
- lamby 7y agoAnother concrete example against our "tech will solve everything" tendencies.
- iask 7y agoIt’s old-fashion management. If you don’t understand your employees workload and don’t trust them then either you resign or fire the employees. Simple as that. I don’t see how this makes any employee productive. This adds more stress imo. An employee gives you 8 of their 12 hour day. Now, you tell me if that works only for you - the management. They’re people just like you. They have a life just like you. They have responsibilities similar to you. They might have a family similar to you. There’s no fucking way they can manage all this, giving you a focused 8 hour. They might need a few mins to pay a bill, lookup a medication, place a personal Online order. And many other activities that come with “living”, being alive. I am certain most managers that implement this are antisocial fucks. It’s poor management. Uneducated decision making. Now, it does has its place. For example in highly secured environments or when dealing with highly sensitive documents. But for a small or regular office, no! HR/Payroll companies such as ADP and Insperity need to start setting ground rules. I know that they’re in favor of the employer, however, it would make good on them.
- bluntfang 7y agoTBH these managers probably don't have work life balance, spend 12-16 hours a day on work, probably less than 4 are productive, and believe their subordinates and ingrates if they don't share the same "devotion" that they do, regardless of ability to complete the assigned job/task.
- mc32 7y agoAnd they probably pore over metrics more than anything else and prepare reporting based on a bunch of old queries and automated reports package it and send it off. They might also have chats with subordinates about those metrics and at the end think “what a good boy/girl am I!”
- gilrain 7y agoMaybe. We don't know what they're doing at their desks or away from the office, because they don't get surveiled like the plebs. Any manager who feels the need to peek over the shoulders of their workers should submit to the same.
- vanilla-almond 7y agoIf you want an example of what workplace surveillance software can monitor and capture, watch the following video. It's simply horrible that employees have to put up with this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xA_fJh4lzqQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xA_fJh4lzqQ
- sidlls 7y agoDoes Interguard have a license from NBC to use characters from “The Office” in their marketing and other materials? It would be pretty funny if they got dinged for this and had some revenue extracted for profiting off someone else’s work because they weren’t productive enough to generate their own content.
- tsukurimashou 7y agospeaking out of my ass but from experience, it's probably just an intern that was told to put fake data in there that happened to be fan of 'The office', I can tell you with 99% of certainty they don't have the rights
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- _curious_ 7y agoNo one has to put up with anything, everyone gets to decide, and they even get to review that decision on a daily basis! Don't like what a job is asking you do to? Don't like a policy? Don't like spyware? Peace out.
- RankingMember 7y agoEasy to say, less easy to do in real life where job opportunities and life situations don't always lend themselves to such a simple outlook.
- _curious_ 7y ago
- sumanthvepa 7y agoI own a small business, and all of us, my employees and me work from home. We've been doing this from well before the COVID-19 epidemic. My team is mostly programmers with a one marketing person. This sort of intrusive monitoring is utter garbage. My team would quit if I used it and in any case, I don't want to know what they are upto by the minute. I don't even encourage realtime slack unless we've mutually agreed to a specific time. Email, slack and the zoom calls (and lunches when COVID-19 was not a thing) are more than enough (Indeed too much.) What idiot managment even thinks this a good idea?
- blaser-waffle 7y agoNothing about your business sounds like it reflects the rest of the white-collar working world.
- sumanthvepa 7y agoNot sure what part of the white-collar working world you are in. But my work experience at every one of the companies I worked at prior to starting on my own, were not dissimilar. All of these companies were in the Fortune 500 when I was in their employ, and none as I can recall had surveillence of this nature. They were intense work environments, I grant that, and deadline pressure in tech and Wall street, is strong, but nobody surveilled me in this manner. Cameras in the corridor yes. Strictly controlled access to critical code repositories and databases -- yes. Keystroke monitoring and keeping webcams on -- no. Indeed, at IBM Research, one of the places I worked at, a stroll through the building at around 3pm would probably the quietest thing you ever did. I'd see pople aimlessly playing at table tennis, and the dicussion after the game over tea would turn to the research problem they were working on. Ideas would flow, some would peel away to scribble on a whiteboard. Others would just take a print out of a paper and sit in the lawn reading it. And yes some would be in their rooms typing away... These were some of the most productive computer scientists in the world, many of them now work at Google and other places you'd be familar with. (They did suck at table tennis though :-) Many pure tech startups are not that different, although the pressure levels are much, much higher. You cannot determine a technical person's productivity by the time they spend at the keyboard. It's in the kind and quiality of the software they release, that entirely eliminates the need for whole classes of time-card workers. If you need surveillance in this situation, you've got the wrong person -- folks like this self-selct themselves to work in these places. They are intrinsically motivated by the problem that interests them. No amount surveillence software will improve their output, if they are not interested in the problem -- they'll just quit.
- mylons 7y agoThe lack of ethics in the companies, and people that work at them, that create this software is sad and borderline demoralizing.
- pixxel 7y agoLack of ethics for sure. Sadly the tech industry is filled with people lacking ethics, which allows privacy breaching companies like Facebook, Google etc. to thrive.
- greendave 7y ago> And with few legal barriers, employers who turn to this software during the pandemic may choose to keep using it even after work-from-home orders are lifted, he said. Unsurprising - why give up power once you've accumulated it. Regulation is the only way to reverse that. The companies building these tools are a special breed.
- runawaybottle 7y agoYour last sentence is an interesting point. Like, man, I really don’t want to be apart of that if I can avoid it.
- runawaybottle 7y agoThere’s no way decent companies are doing this. Any company that does this probably also has skeleton budgets with underpaid staff. I just can’t fathom it.
- capdeck 7y agoI don't think decency has anything to do with it. Profits are king that everyone bows to. I can see a management meeting where inevitably someone throws the idea of webcam surveillance into the rink. After all it is simple to understand, it "makes sense", (micro)managers will really enjoy it. So it will pass with flying colors. And as they say, the rest is history. Good workers will eventually leave. Some will adapt. Software and hacks will appear that can trick key presses and mouse clicks. Eveyone will become 9 to 5 no matter what. I see some examples brought up where developers are not putting up with it - that is correct. For developers, typing <> productivity, so that will not stick. But there are other occupations around - admin work, marketing, data entry, HR, etc... Productivity in those occupations will dip, some people will leave, but in larger scope work will continue. Companies will compensate by hiring more people, it won't be visible on a balance sheet as "survelliance tax" because no one is tracking. And the world will go on. Worse off than before, unfortunately.
- trhaynes 7y agoBasecamp is a decent company and is actively blocking this effort: https://m.signalvnoise.com/employee-surveillance-software-is-not-welcome-to-integrate-with-basecamp/ https://m.signalvnoise.com/employee-surveillance-software-is...
- thrower123 7y agoMy mother-in-law is trying to teach driver's ed over Zoom. It's a horrible clusterfuck, because they are trying to force everyone to keep their webcam on at all times as a means of tracking attendance. The first session was 75% her shrieking at kids because their internet connections were dropping out or Zoom was glitching and the video feeds froze. Not to mention that Zoom can only show a 5x5 grid at a time, and some of the classes had 27 or 30-something kids in it. It's not easy for normies to deal with video-conferencing... Take your normal enterprise conference call bingo card, and put it on turbo.
- OldHand2018 7y agoYesterday, one of my kids was in group class on Zoom. The instructor kept yelling about the kids being quiet. So my wife reached over and muted the microphone. The instructor unmuted it and proceeded to continue yelling about being quiet.
- downerending 7y agoThat's great (and would make a good YouTube video).
- jordache 7y agoi'm a manager of individual contributors. If I'm not aware of this being used at my company, is it likely a good indication that it's not? Are there examples of this surveillance only being conusmed at higher levels in the management structure
- underdeserver 7y agoBut my lord, is that legal?
- sevenf0ur 7y agoWould you be okay with tracking software if it was installed on a work provided computer?
- matheusmoreira 7y agoWhy would mandatory malware ever be okay under any circumstance?
- mikeg8 7y agoTracking software is not malware. I totally oppose the use of tracking software, but they are not the same.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoThe only difference is a clause in the contract saying the employee agrees to use the software.
- mikeg8 7y agoDefinition of malware: software that is specifically designed to disrupt, damage, or gain unauthorized access to a computer system. You could argue that tracking software is "disruptive" but more so to the user, not the system itself. you're conflating your dislike for both tracking software and malware as the same. Again, I'm not defending tracking software, just disagreeing with your false equivalency.
- mlillie 7y agoIsn't spyware just a subset of malware? This is definitely spyware
- redblacktree 7y agoAbsolutely not. If I'm not trusted to do the job, that isn't the kind of relationship I want with my employer.
- 7y ago
- option 7y agoIf a company can have most, if not all, of its software engineering workforce WFH, why would they hire in US or Europe for those/similar roles?
- taborj 7y agoTiming, for one thing. For example, we have two sites in India; one of them works on Eastern time, the other on Indian time. The one that works Eastern time is a lot easier to deal with, as they are active when the rest of the US-based company is active. However, that means the Indian-based team is working nights, which makes it harder to retain good engineers. The team that works on Indian time has good engineers, but with little overlap to the US-based management structure (and US-based engineers), there are sometimes significant delays in getting everyone on the same page. That's one example, but there are others, such as cultural (i.e. expectations for US-based management may not be the same as non-US-based engineers) and "optics" (US-based customers like it better when US-based companies use US-based employees)
- OldHand2018 7y agoWhen an employee steals all your intellectual property, would you rather sue: 1) An American citizen in an American court 2) An Indian citizen in an Indian court
- Tade0 7y ago"If you're idle for a few minutes, if you go to the bathroom or whatever, a pop-up will come up and it'll say, 'You have 60 seconds to start working again or we're going to pause your time,' " the woman said. Solution to that using appliances available in every home: Dangle the mouse from you desk and put a fan next to it so that it hits the mouse from time to time. But also quit your job - managers who use such tactics are usually very trigger-happy when it comes to firing people, so you're just delaying the inevitable.
- moolcool 7y agoOr get a USB mouse jiggler! https://www.amazon.ca/Cru-Dataport-Wiebetech-30200-0100-0011-Jiggler/dp/B000O3S0PK https://www.amazon.ca/Cru-Dataport-Wiebetech-30200-0100-0011...
- lozaning 7y agoJust buy a digispark for $4 and reflash it to be a rubber ducky.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoIt's probably not difficult to work around these checks but nobody should be suffering this indignity in the first place. People can't even go to the bathroom without getting called out by managers over lost productivity. How dehumanizing.
- Tade0 7y agoAnd it's not even effective. There's a quote from one of the more known Total Quality Management evangelists, which stuck with me(paraphrased): "Don't engage in games with your employees, because you can't win." He elaborates further explaining that any scheme or incentive system created for a specific behavioral outcome is bound to be exploited or otherwise worked around.
- rconti 7y ago
- 0x262d 7y agocan I figure out if my company is doing this? will Interguard show up in Task Manager somehow?
- xf1cf 7y agoAs a prelude to what i'll type below I hate these things. They are not useful and I believe they are detrimental to employee productivity through the "panopticon" idea of management. There's no need in my eyes for regulating this or getting in quarrel over workers rights. You, the employee, sign a contract with the employer to perform some work for some compensation. If the employer wishes to run this type of strategy on their own hardware I do not see a problem with this. You can, and should, find a job that respects you as a worker. What we are seeing here is the MBA-style spreadsheet management turned into software. This "panopticon" management increases turnover rate and decreases productivity. I have personally seen it. I worked IT in a company that had this software (I was a low level sysadmin and had no control). People would spend an inordinate amount of time finding ways to hide their activity instead of just quickly doing what they had to do and moving on. The solution isn't to complain, or call for regulation, but rather just leave your job. If the software isn't being installed on your computer then the company is completely okay to do this, no matter how damaging it is to their bottom line through subsequent lost activity.
- downerending 7y agoThere's a lot to say for this. One management proposes something as ridiculous as this, there's really know way to restore the relationship. If I have to live on beans and rice instead, I will.
- bergstromm466 7y agoIt doesn’t lead to it, the capabilities to do so were already there, it’s just being activated more.
- und3rth3iP 7y agoIf you need to rely on this sort of technology to feel confident your team is being productive and meeting their goals, you're not doing a very good job managing your team and/or you're simply not a great manager. Full stop.
- GuiA 7y ago"Are they generally active on programs and websites that I would consider productive like Excel, PowerPoint, Word, email, as opposed to YouTube or Facebook?" The CEO talking about his product in terms of first person value judgements tells you all you need to know about the degrees of sliminess involved.
- matheusmoreira 7y ago> "If you're idle for a few minutes, if you go to the bathroom or whatever, a pop-up will come up and it'll say, 'You have 60 seconds to start working again or we're going to pause your time,' " the woman said. This is the exact type of sociopathic behavior that creates unions.
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoThere's too many techbros and 'rockstars' that think they're 10x better than anyone else. Surprise - they're more average than others tell them. But I've seen it again and again, IT people don't seem to gravitate towards unions.
- wintermutestwin 7y agoQuestion: Is it legal for a company to provide you with a laptop that you use at home and then monitor video/audio from it? What happens if I am using it in a space with my family present? Is it legal for my employer to spy on them? What if my two year old runs naked through the room? Can they monitor during "non-working hours?" What if I have to be on 5am video conferences and am answering emails at 12am?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SamuelAdams 7y agoWhy don't you just shut the laptop off unless you are actively working, ie 8-5?
- edw519 7y agoactivity != accomplishment We always knew that's bad bosses never understood this. It's just sad to see that now there's a market for it.
- r0m4n0 7y agoI think a lot of this comes back to laziness and/or lack of critical thought toward measuring efficiency of completing work. It’s perfectly normal to want to determine who is most efficient and who is not. Those who are working harder than others should be rewarded and the inverse for those that need to improve. I think the big question is how do you measure output? The wrong way is measuring how often your mouse is moving or tracking how much time you spend on Facebook. Ultimately management should have some way of measuring job efficiency, in a way that is difficult to influence in any other way. Surveillance software is going to give you terrible metrics probably unrelated to output (amongst tons of other bad side effects)
- wickerman 7y agoI think it's time to start naming and shaming these companies. This doesn't increase productivity. It's disgusting. You don't own people's lives for 8 hours a day; you pay them to help you achieve goals for the company. It baffles me how the US has trouble not understanding that paying for someone's time does not make them your slave.
- samizdis 7y agoIt's not just the US. We've had episodes of this sort of thing in the UK, albeit with clumsier tech, for years. Here's a tale from 2016 [1] about motion sensors under journalists' desks (management later did a reverse ferret, aka volte-face [Edited to add the aka]): [1] https://www.theguardian.com/media/2016/jan/11/daily-telegraph-to-withdraw-devices-monitoring-time-at-desk-after-criticism https://www.theguardian.com/media/2016/jan/11/daily-telegrap... BTW - "Reverse ferret" is a British media thing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_ferret https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_ferret
- aSplash0fDerp 7y agoI had to laugh a little about your second paragraph. I grew up in the deep south and have actually seen caucasion slaves (they had no freedom or agency in their life), and being a military brat, their reality was almost too funny to bear. If someone was raised in slavery, they have no concept of 1st world perks. If you were to name/shame them, how would you brand the companies? (ie. Would you accuse them of bringing communist values to America or using 3rd world surveillance protocols in the 1st world)
- nunya8149 7y agoMS Teams has a "green check" next to your name if you've touched your keyboard or mouse in the last five minutes and automatically sets your status to "away" if you haven't done so. I've had people at work use this to try and figure out if I'm working or not. It is a violating feeling, but also very similar to the "is your butt in the chair" way of management when not working from home, and I can see why managers like the feature. For any of those suffering under this problem, have a look at caffeine[1], it simulates a keystroke on your laptop every 59 seconds. 1: https://www.zhornsoftware.co.uk/caffeine/ https://www.zhornsoftware.co.uk/caffeine/
- technofiend 7y agoWorking for a highly regulated company at least company owned desktop monitoring is BAU. I assume anything I do with company equipment is monitored at all times. And if I forget they remind me every time I log in. When I discovered the company needed to protect their data by pushing on a policy that let them wipe my personal device remotely I respected that and bought a personal device dedicated to the task of reading email and running their apps. But not everyone has that luxury. I'm fortunate to be able to buy an iPad and dedicate it to blackberry and the company app store. It's an interesting conundrum because am I really obligated to install this to every personal device or just the one I'm using for work-related tasks? I think a reasonable person would assume the latter. And am I under obligation to use a personal device compatible with their spyware? What if it only works under IOS and I'm an Android user? What if tsheets only works on Windows and I'm a MacOS guy, or heck I just run a remote desktop viewer from a raspberry pi? Lol.
- driverdan 7y agoWhy would you install anything from an employer on a personal device? If they want you to install their spyware they should buy the hardware.
- lonelappde 7y agoOr they can decline to let you connect to the corp net when you are out of office.
- technofiend 7y agoWhich isn't really an option now that we have mandatory work from home. I'm not going to quit my job because they don't wish to supply me with a laptop.
- sleepychu 7y agoRight, but now the situation is give and take. You want me to do work on my personal device? Maybe I'm willing to bring that to the table. You want me to install your spyware on it... not so much.
- edw519 7y agoSounds like a business opportunity. How hard would it be to get your phone to transmit gps coordinates you choose, not where you actually are? How hard would it be to override what tattleware sends your boss with what you want it to send?
- djhaskin987 7y agoMS Teams has a "green check" next to your name if you've touched your keyboard or mouse in the last five minutes and automatically sets your status to "away" if you haven't done so. I've had people at work use this to try and figure out if I'm working or not. It is a violating feeling, but also very similar to the "is your butt in the chair" way of management when not working from home, and I can see why managers like the feature. For any of those suffering under this problem, have a look at caffeine[1], it simulates a keystroke on your laptop every 59 seconds. 1: https://www.zhornsoftware.co.uk/caffeine/ https://www.zhornsoftware.co.uk/caffeine/
- brianjlogan 7y agoI prefer Mouse Move. Windows Store so it seems to get around the corporate blockers. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/move-mouse/9nq4ql59xlbf?activetab=pivot:overviewtab https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/move-mouse/9nq4ql59xlbf?ac...
- SauciestGNU 7y agoYou can also script automated keystrokes and mouse movements in python easily using pyautogui, and make something that defeats activity detection surveillance like you're describing in 5 or 10 lines of code. It also has the advantage of not being easily recognized as an automated input program like caffeine.
- raztogt21 7y agoEarlier in my career looking for my first remote job, I got an offer for 20$-30$ per hour. This is 2.5x the average salary where I live, and almost 2x of what I was making at the time. "Are you okay with installing surveillance software installed on your computer to track everything you do?" Laughed at their faces. I will take ANY job (roof repairing, garbage man, security guard) before doing that.
- HumblyTossed 7y ago> After two weeks of working from her Brooklyn apartment, a 25-year-old e-commerce worker received a staffwide email from her company: Employees were to install software called Hubstaff immediately on their personal computers so it could track their mouse movements and keyboard strokes,and record the webpages they visited. I'm 100 percent positive that I would tell this company to get stuffed if they suggested I put that crap on my personal computer/phone. This is managerial paranoia. These are probably managers that worked their way up by stepping on people and bumping others into oncoming buses along the way.
- bo1024 7y agoI completely agree, but it's a privilege to be able to risk your job for such a principle. I hope we can push to level the power imbalance between companies and employees so that privilege is available to more people.
- HumblyTossed 7y ago> ... but it's a privilege to be able to risk your job for such a principle. I absolutely agree that it is.
- folkhack 7y agoIt's an extension of the "butts in chairs" management style that's all over in America. When the managers are unable to actually measure output due to incompetence + lacking the ability to do the same job as their subordinates this is one of the few levers they get to pull. It's a management style of fear and dissonance where the workers are constantly being judged not based on merit, but on useless metrics and butt kissing... In contrast - I've worked for managers that could care less about "butts in chairs" and are much more concerned with output/quality... this means they have to be actually productive/knowledgeable in my field which typically is an exception - especially for larger corps. I personally find my mental state is so much better and my output is magnitudes greater when working with this management style! The other thing that's great about output based managers is that the bad-to-mediocre talent/work ethic folks get weeded out ASAP because it's apparent who can't cut it vs. higher output workers. "Butts in chairs" workers are good at gaming the optics + politics regardless if it's surveillance software or someone complaining about being in the office for X hours a day/week. All-in-all I agree with your statement.
- dbattaglia 7y ago> But in the office, it is much easier to figure out if someone is doing a job well. I found this odd. The only measure of doing a job well is the output, isn’t it? How is this easier in an office? Plenty of people can spend all day cranking away in Excel or an IDE, with no Facebook or YouTube in sight, producing complete garbage.
- uses 7y agoVox Reset covered worker surveillance software in their most recent two episodes: https://www.vox.com/reset https://www.vox.com/reset "The future of work pt 1 & 2" One nice thing about being in a union is that if my upper management ever got a twinkle in their eye about this kind of thing (they wouldn't, because they're cool), I'm 100% sure I could flat out tell them no, AND keep my job. If I wasn't in a union, I'd like to think I'm personally in a position where I could still tell them no and deal with the consequences. But I know a lot of people won't be in that position.
- fmakunbound 7y agoI feel like if you're involved with the development of tools like Time Doctor, you should go fuck yourself. edit: Also deploying such tools.
- jb775 7y agoWork surveillance leads to employees who feel disrespected. Employees who feel disrespected don't go that extra mile when it really counts. A better approach would be to trust the employees (hand-picked by the company), and set measurable performance expectations.
- _curious_ 7y agoThat's a dramatic exaggeration...companies you describe exist everywhere and it's up to the individuals to change if they don't like it.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 7y agoVictim blaming like this breeds radicalization. Need I say more?
- _curious_ 7y agoDepends, could you elaborate on what you did say because I don't follow. Thanks!
- Avicebron 7y agoPeople who are facing destitution with no other options frequently become radicals. Especially when there is a clear reason, abuse from powerful, untouchable organizations.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 7y agoAs avicebron said, when a person has had enough of being stomped on they will snap. Most won't drive a truck through a crowd of people, or blow up buildings, but a few will weld themselves into bulldozers* and level buildings, or shoot up schools, or rob banks, or drive through crowds of people. The action doesn't really matter. Destroy every gun in existence? We'll see more knifings and vehicular homicides. Unless everyone is locked into a cage like a rat in a straight jacket people will find ways to maliciously hurt themselves and others when they've been pushed too far. Many self deluded and extremely privileged people decline responsibility for these extreme behaviors, yet, in reality, we are all culpable in the actions of the worst of us. It is everyone's responsibility to arrest the decline of someone nearing the breaking point. Once a person is closeto snapping they are no longer capable of rational thought, let alone digging themselves out of a hole that they are not fully responsible for digging. If we are to dismiss responsibility for these people that have been pushed too far then we only create a habitat for more of these desperate and sad souls to develop in. * https://youtu.be/qlZh9-NQEyI https://youtu.be/qlZh9-NQEyI
- _curious_ 7y agoCounterthought: anyone who would knowingly and willingly install spyware on their personal computer deserves to lose their privacy.
- HumblyTossed 7y agoNo they don't. They have two choices; quit or be fired. Personally, I would quit, but I've got that type of personality. Others can't just up and quit so they comply.
- _curious_ 7y ago"Others can't just up and quit so they comply." Who are these others? Are you suggesting they do not have the ability to decide if they want to continue working?
- HumblyTossed 7y agoI'm sorry, but do I really have to answer these questions? How is it people still don't understand there's a huge segment of the working population who just can't up and quit a job?
- _curious_ 7y agoPoint to a single person who cannot quit their job right now?
- salawat 7y agoPoint to an example of a company that's taking a bailout that can't just bootstrap themselves to go without a bailout right now. I'll wait. Same thing. The capability to make the decision may be present, but an unwillingness to acknowledge that there are practical limits to the capability to execute on that decision without jeopardizing the decider's capability to fulfill higher priority commitments (family/self safety, food, transport, shelter, medical care) demonstrates a malicious willingness to indulge in the discount of the interests of others when it is to the convenience of oneself. Just to head it off; no, morally speaking, it is your problem when you know they have no other options. You are just as much a contributor to their state of affairs through employment of abusive labor practices as they are. You drag down everyone by going above and beyond to lower the bar of acceptable business practices. If that doesn't concern you the least bit, then I'm not sure continued conversation will be fruitful in any way.
- _curious_ 7y agoIt's up to individuals as employees to decide if they want to subject themselves to this (agreed repulsive) treatment...what's with all these comments and sentiment in this thread acting like they have a gun to their head? JUST QUIT already if uncomfortable with whatever a given job entails should that include perceived invasive measures ie - surveillance.
- boo_boo 7y agoYou're out of touch with the reality for a large chunk of workers if you believe it's simple or even advisable for them to "just quit". We should be making the case for better conditions across the board, and this means not leaving it up to those in shitty situations to figure it out for themselves.
- _curious_ 7y agoWho said it was simple? But advisable, sure if you or anyone is not uncomfortable with what they are being subject to/asked to do as part of a job, YES, I would advise them to quit if deemed necessary. Would you advise them to stay and subject themselves to they type of treatment they did not agree with?
- boo_boo 7y agoWould you advise them to leave and risk not being able to put food on the table if they can't find another position? If there's little to no opportunity for lateral movement in their job market right now?
- _curious_ 7y agoI would advise them to do what they felt was in their net best interest. Either way, they are making a conscious choice - a choice to stay and continue subjecting themselves to such treatment or a choice to leave and assume the risk. Again, would you advise them to stay and subject themselves to they type of treatment they did not agree with?
- _curious_ 7y agoEveryone has a choice: yes or no. Consequences may vary, but then again, no-one is owed anything legally, morally, or otherwise so to act as though every individual does not have or exercise their own self-agency is disingenuous.
- bo1024 7y agoI strongly disagree. There are certain human rights that it is immoral and illegal to contract away. The common example is that selling yourself into slavery is illegal even though people have self-agency. Over time we have decided on others so for example it is illegal to take a job that disallows bathroom breaks or violates certain safety standards. It's also not legal as far as I know to take jobs with certain consequences for quitting, like "we break into your house and kill your family". Although, "we will ensure your family starves" may be an unwritten one. Also, it is disingenuous at least to say every has their own "self-agency", but "Consequences may vary." I would agree it's a sliding scale because people's chioces imply different levels of consequences for losing one's job (for example if you bought an expensive mortgage versus not). But morally, and legally as well, we certainly owe people the ability to make actually free choices without metaphorical guns to their heads.
- _curious_ 7y agoThanks for strongly (and respectfully) disagreeing out loud instead of being one who just downvotes without the courage to provide an alternate view/retort!
- stronglikedan 7y ago> just downvotes without the courage to provide an alternate view/retort It's not about courage. It's usually that someone else has already provided the same alternate view/retort, so there's no sense in starting a new comment branch.
- _curious_ 7y agoyou show great courage stronglikedan!
- SeanFerree 7y agoGreat article!!
- Chris2048 7y agoAre the employees using their personal computers/phones for work stuff?
- munificent 7y agoUsing this software is a tacit admission that the manager is unable to measure the output of their own employees, nor are they able to determine what an appropriate level of productivity is. You don't need cameras to track where the dough goes if you already know how much flour you bought, how many pizzas you sold, and how much flour it should take to make a pie. This reflects a fundamental inability of the manager to do their job.
- UweSchmidt 7y agoDoubts about the efficiency of such ideas, calling managers incompetent and general handwringing will not work. The data, the tech is here. The only thing that will prevent your most horrific workplace dystopia is regulation.
- sjperez 7y agoIs anyone aware of any actual research on this issue? If so, what does it say? Do remote workers actually work less? Do intrusive monitoring apps improve productivity or decrease productivity? I've always had the sense that people who work remote are perfectly capable of being productive without monitoring. In some ways, depending on your personal situation, being at home can be less distracting than being at the office. On any given day, I would bet that most people in an office only put in 3-4 hours of good work (or less). Much of the rest of the time is spent being distracted by office gossip, meetings, coffee breaks, etc. Why should we expect people working from home to put in 8 solid hours of good focused work when we don't demand the same of people in the office? It would be nice to see some actual data on this problem. I have an instinct that this is a major overreaction by managers and that it will ultimately drive productivity and retention down. However, I'm open to being proved wrong if this is an issue that has been studied in a rigorous fashion.
- eli-bryan 7y agoThere's a researcher, Ethan Bernstein, who has looked into this quite a bit and has some great stories about the ways close monitoring can (sometimes) go sideways. He did a fascinating history of it here: https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Publication%20Files/BernsteinE-MakingTransparencyTransparent-AMA2017HBS_1ffde6a8-90b5-4dcb-8014-c2eea12b78bf.pdf https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Publication%20Files/BernsteinE-M... A representative anecdote re: a factory workfloor: "First the [embedded researchers] were quietly shown ‘‘better ways’’ of accomplishing tasks by their peers — a ‘‘ton of little tricks’’ that ‘‘kept production going’’ or enabled ‘‘faster, easier, and / or safer production.’’ Then they were told, ‘‘Whenever the [customers / managers / leaders] come around, don’t do that, because they’ll get mad.’’ Instead, when under observation, embeds were trained in the art of appearing to perform the task the way it was ‘‘meant’’ to be done according to the codified process rules posted for each task. Because many of these performances were not as productive as the ‘‘little tricks,’’ I observed line performance actually dropping when lines were actively supervised." From "The Transparency Paradox": https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0001839212453028 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/000183921245302... I've also interviewed a few engineers about this recently and there are plenty of horror stories. My favorite 2 quotes (from the same person) about screenshot monitoring freelancers: "It almost uniformly led to worse work..." and "... but my boss loved it." https://medium.com/@elibryan/employee-performance-tracking-doesnt-have-to-be-toxic-b8538aa39376?source=friends_link&sk=aceafa8cd097a280568e95f37868508b https://medium.com/@elibryan/employee-performance-tracking-d...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- justchilly 7y agoCounterpoint: Is it really fair to say this is "more surveillance"? Requiring employees to be on site where there is a manager present is a form of intrusive surveillance. Wouldn't this kind of monitoring simply be an effort to retain existing dynamics.
- FpUser 7y agoI wish the employees of that fucked up company would band together and tell the management to sod off. If everyone done that the company could do nothing short of committing business suicide. Unfortunately this is extremely unlikely to happen.
- amaajemyfren 7y agoMy question would be ... does it work? Say there are people who are not being tracked using these tools ... does the act of tracking them make them more productive? 𝗔𝗻 𝗶𝗹𝗹𝘂𝘀𝘁𝗿𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻 There is the old joke paper given to the British Medical Journal (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC300808/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC300808/). The "problem" it tries to figure out is do parachutes work? There is anecdotal evidence that they work - bit there have been cases where people have fallen from great height without a parachute and not died and there are cases where someone has jumped from low altitude with a parachute and died. What they then do is suggest a proper double blind analysis to confirm that a parachute actually works. But it is a joke so they do not go far. The point they make applies here also. On the part of the boss it does feel like you are in control and I am sure HR would love it because they now have time sheets that they can use to process payroll etc. But for the end user ... does it actually increase productivity? Actually ... does it actually matter whether it does or not? Maybe their goal is to make the bosses happy. My suspicion though is that it may actually be reducing productivity as they mess up morale. But that has not been tested either. (Not sure if it can be tested).
- caseymarquis 7y agoIt sure would be fun to write software which pretends to be working and boosts people's 'productivity scores'. Some days I think I missed out by not taking a job I could have gotten a computer to automate, and spending all my time doing interesting coding projects.
- dan_can_code 7y agoThis is a surefire way of making everyone employed at these businesses miserable. No one likes someone looking over their shoulder, especially for the entire working week. These companies are going to lose interest from their talent most likely. I feel for anyone working in these circumstances. I expect it will be extremely demotivating also.