45 ms·
> As an end user why do I care about "openness"? If I pay a premium for my platform, why would I want second rate cross platform software? Falsehoods HNers bel
by hombre_fatal 7y ago
> As an end user why do I care about "openness"? If I pay a premium for my platform, why would I want second rate cross platform software?
Falsehoods HNers believe about how people buy/use software. Didn't stop Slack/Discord from become ubiquitous.
"But native tho" just becomes a circlejerk. Talking about what users care about, most people don't know what native means nor if a given app is it. They don't know if Zoom is using more memory or CPU than it "should".
- scarface74 7y agoLet's not forget that MS Teams has more paying users than Slack.... How many people know that Slack is battery draining monstrosity? The only people that pay for Slack are companies. The definition of Enterprise Software is where the user is not the customer.
- zankly 7y agoMS Teams has more paying users than Slack because for every CIO in America there is probably a Microsoft employee who goes to strip clubs with him.
- what-the-grump 7y agoHmm this one is tough Office 365 has more paying users on teams. I doubt anyone is paying for teams, also they are not direct competitors. We use both, likely to get phones with teams in the future as well.
- scarface74 7y agoWhether it is fair or not that Teams comes with Office is irrelevant. This is Slack's competition. They have to convince companies that it is worth paying extra for their product. In the famous words of Jobs about Dropbox -- chat isn't a product, it's a feature.
- what-the-grump 7y agoWhat I am saying is, we dont pay more or less for teams, its a SfB replacement.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ascorbic 7y agoMS Teams is an Electron app too. This very post is about React Native for Windows and Mac, which are being developed by MS because they're used for the front-ends of much of the rest of Office 365. Microsoft clearly thinks that it's worth rewriting large parts of their crown jewels using cross-platform frameworks.
- gvjddbnvdrbv 7y agoI remember when Spotify 'upgraded' from a native to a js application on MacOS. It bricked my wife's computer. She never installed Spotify again. This is someone who doesn't usually care about software. She did care about that annoyance.
- ascorbic 7y agoIt works fine for hundreds of millions of other users
- ulisesrmzroche 7y agoYeah, it sounds like a real fake anecdote. JS app did not brick the computer.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jasonlotito 7y agoIf Spotify bricked her computer, it was an issue with computer, not Spotify. It just so happened that you installed Spotify before the computer was bricked. If Spotify did that, you’d have heard stories of other Macs just completely dying out there if this was an actual issue.
- pjmlp 7y agoI use Slack and other Electron based applications because my job requires it, imposed by our IT or customers, not because I freely have chosen to use them or have the liberty to look for alternatives. Other than VSCode for Rust and TypeScript, my own personal computer is as much Electron free as possible. So don't mistake market share for freedom of choice.
- nindalf 7y agoVSCode is a great example. We’ve already established that the average joe out there doesn’t care about whether an app is implemented in electron or not. But VSCode’s success at the expense of every other editor out there indicates that even developers don’t care that much. The important thing is features - which VSCode has, and the speed at which those features are developed and deployed on all platforms - where VSCode is nearly peerless. If developers cared about performance and resource consumption above all else, no one would be using VSCode right now (you included). They’d be using vim, emacs or perhaps Sublime. But that isn’t the case. So why does HN keep flogging the “electron is bad” meme?
- pjmlp 7y agoThe day Microsoft releases Rust support for Visual Studio, VSCode gets kicked out of my PC. Also, I wonder how much the Electron love overlapps with VSCode, after all many of those developers were pushing for Atom before VSCode was born.
- baxuz 7y agoNot much, at least here. I was a Sublime Text user for years. I tried Atom but it was an ugly, janky mess. I switched to VScode quickly after its release because the features it provided over Sublime Text were worth it, and the performance was good enough, even though not on par with ST.
- pjmlp 7y agoAnd me thinking that it was probably about those $80.
- thirdsun 7y agoIndeed. I had this argument with some of our non-tech staff countless of times. They absolutely prefer Slack, Basecamp & Co. as separate app. Doesn't matter if it's just an electron container - to them a browser tab/window is a subpar experience compared to an icon in the dock and its own exclusive window. Hardware requirements and the fact that each app needlessly runs itws own browser obviously aren't a concern to them.