5 ms·
For this reason, I've been trying out Flutter or even considering to go back to native apps. This says so much about the sad state of modern software developme
by scarface74 7y ago
For this reason, I've been trying out Flutter or even considering to go back to native apps.
This says so much about the sad state of modern software development...
When native development is a last resort.
- macinjosh 7y agoWhy does it have to be sad? To me it is good news! Especially if it is open source. The more software we can write that isn’t specific to a platform the more free and useful software can become. It wrestles back control from google, apple, microsoft et. al and makes their closed platforms less relevant.
- scarface74 7y ago"Useful" as long as you don't care about battery life, memory usage, taking advantage of features of the host platform, or the native UI. As an end user why do I care about "openness"? If I pay a premium for my platform, why would I want second rate cross platform software?
- pikelet 7y agoAs an end user you might not get that software at all if no one is motivated to build it.
- dhosek 7y agoBut junk software is still junk and not worth the trouble.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoAre we to presume you think that using native SDKs saves your junk software from being junk? I'm not sure how else to interpret your comment in this thread.
- dhosek 7y agoHaving software that doesn't act like native software makes it junk. I've deleted a lot of software that was created with cross-platform SDKs that just didn't behave the way every other program on my computer did. I don't have time for that. It's a lot more likely that something created with a native SDK will behave like a native app than something slapped together with the cross-platform SDK du jour.
- hombre_fatal 7y ago> As an end user why do I care about "openness"? If I pay a premium for my platform, why would I want second rate cross platform software? Falsehoods HNers believe about how people buy/use software. Didn't stop Slack/Discord from become ubiquitous. "But native tho" just becomes a circlejerk. Talking about what users care about, most people don't know what native means nor if a given app is it. They don't know if Zoom is using more memory or CPU than it "should".
- scarface74 7y agoLet's not forget that MS Teams has more paying users than Slack.... How many people know that Slack is battery draining monstrosity? The only people that pay for Slack are companies. The definition of Enterprise Software is where the user is not the customer.
- zankly 7y agoMS Teams has more paying users than Slack because for every CIO in America there is probably a Microsoft employee who goes to strip clubs with him.
- what-the-grump 7y agoHmm this one is tough Office 365 has more paying users on teams. I doubt anyone is paying for teams, also they are not direct competitors. We use both, likely to get phones with teams in the future as well.
- scarface74 7y agoWhether it is fair or not that Teams comes with Office is irrelevant. This is Slack's competition. They have to convince companies that it is worth paying extra for their product. In the famous words of Jobs about Dropbox -- chat isn't a product, it's a feature.
- what-the-grump 7y ago
- badsectoracula 7y ago> If I pay a premium for my platform, why would I want second rate cross platform software? Are you paying for your software or getting whatever you can find for free? If you are paying, is the software's leanness something you value - that is, will you buy some software because it is leaner over some other software that is heavier? Would that be even if the heavier software has more features? What sort of software have you bought? I'm asking seriously, not trolling - i've bought Total Commander myself exactly because it was lean (check: windows calculator vs one of the most feature packed file managers[0]) but i do not think there are many that value things like that. [0] https://i.imgur.com/LYzN3Cj.png https://i.imgur.com/LYzN3Cj.png
- rado 7y agoJust bought the wonderful native git client Fork, even though it works for free and the Electron GitHub Desktop is also free.
- scarface74 7y agoAs far as desktop software, the only software I pay for are subscriptions to Office 365 and JetBrains R#. I don’t really use my personal computer for too much of anything besides Office and a Plex server - I paid for a Plex Pass solely to support the developer. On mobile, I’ll pay to remove ads and I won’t use any software or games where I can’t remove ads. With the economy in the crapper, I’m starting to voluntarily pay more to support my favorite content producers.
- jasonlotito 7y agoThis is funny because you just listed a bunch of cross platform software.
- scarface74 7y agoThe argument is not about cross platform software. It’s about native client software. Office is not written using one of the cross platform frameworks and is usually only around 3-9 months behind when it comes to taking advantage of new features as Apple releases them. Plex is server software. The UI is a web page. R# itself is a plug-in only for Visual Studio for Windows. Yes Rider is cross platform, but I don’t have a need for it. The only other software I mentioned are games. No one expects a native experience from games.
- Barrin92 7y ago> If I pay a premium for my platform this is something that you might value but I think it's fair to say it is already a minority position. phones and the web have become the primary platform for software delivery, and people do not treat their desktop if they even have one as some sort of premium platform, it's a terminal for the internet. at this point, people are probably more familiar with the look and feel of web applications than they are with native applications and value similarity across platforms over features of individual platforms. The operating system and the hardware are increasingly becoming irrelevant and a detail compared to the web on top.
- scarface74 7y agoFollow the money. People pay for what they value. Who is paying money for desktop software besides games, Office 365, and the Adobe Creative Suite? Who values desktop software enough to pay for it? I know in the Mac market at least, the few indy developers making money are not writing apps using cross platform SDKs.
- pjmlp 7y agoLots of business running Windows on their labs and using desktop software for various use cases, like data analysis. Plenty of money to be made desktop solutions to life sciences, manufacturing, factory automation, aren't plugging their air gaped dashboards to the web. Anyone doing music composition, graphics, animation, infotainment systems. In Europe there are enough Win32, WPF, UWP, Qt related jobs and consulting projects with hourly rates to do a comfortable living. As for B2C, it is always going to be an uphill battle regardless of the application type, there are only so many application types that one is willing to pay for outside established brands, and SaaS is a much better way to avoid piracy and get everyone to pay.
- scarface74 7y agoWe are speaking specifically about B2C where the users are the customers. But either way, you kind of made my point. Consumers aren't paying for applications built on cross platform frameworks outside of games.
- jfkebwjsbx 7y agoFalse dichotomy. Native applications can be cross-platform.
- diss 7y agoI don't think so, if RN or similar is a viable option then it makes far more sense than juggling large Java and Swift implementations of the same app.
- scarface74 7y agoOr the alternative is not to have run bloated cross platform apps and run native apps.... Why would you think React Native would be less bloated than native apps?
- diss 7y agoI don't think it would be less bloated, it's impossible for a layer on top of native to be less bloated. That's not to say it couldn't be efficient, and efficiency in development time is the key factor. It can be a nightmare to manage apps across different platforms, frameworks and languages. RN could be massively improved, but the concept is a godsend.
- scarface74 7y agoWhy would I as end user care about developer efficiency?
- diss 7y agoAside from update frequency you wouldn't, users can't tell the difference if it's done well. Are we not talking about "the state of software development"?
- scarface74 7y agoMicrosoft and Adobe update their apps quite frequently -- for Mac, Windows, iOS, and Android. I gladly pay $100 a year for O365. What are some well done cross platform apps that don't unnecessarily drain battery life? I can think of one - VSCode.
- sayhello 7y agoWhy does it have to be sad? When software becomes easier to develop, it enables everyone to benefit. More developers, more applications of software. At the same time, performance has a tangential relationship with computer code being interpreted or compiled to native. After all, Java is compiled to byte code and powers plenty of high traffic servers efficiently. Many AAA games use ActionScript, Python, Lua, etc for their UIs and scripting for mods. While it's true that there is no substitute for code compiled to native when high performance is called for, I think it's justified for native development to be last resort. This is coming from someone who codes primarily in C++, where high performance is important. I wish I didn't have to.
- scarface74 7y agoAfter all, Java is compiled to byte code and powers plenty of high traffic servers efficiently. How well has Java done on the client in the last two decades? Many AAA games use ActionScript, Python, Lua, etc for their UIs and scripting for mods. What's the actual performance sensitive parts written in?
- ascorbic 7y agoI don't think anyone is suggesting writing game engines or the core of graphics processors or video renderers in React Native. It's for the frontend. The pattern of using React Native for the frontend and native moduels for the backend is a pattern being used by many companies. The difficult stuff can be written as a native cross platform library, while the front end can use React Native. This is what MS is doing with Office.
- jfkebwjsbx 7y agoJava, JavaScript, .NET, forks of Lua, forks of Python, and others are JIT compiled. So I am not sure what you are saying. Everyone that is able to is compiling their stuff to try to regain some efficiency. The reason is that people wants to do more complex things with their software nowadays, and hardware can't keep up with the trend. There is also battery life, smartphones, tablets... Those are the reasons we are seeing a resurgence of native development.
- friedman23 7y agoGood abstractions are the reason why we have so much cool technology.
- krzat 7y agoWriting the same thing multiple times is also sad. On desktops, it was understood long time ago.
- scarface74 7y agoSad for who? Yes and a long time ago Sun came out with Swing. How did that work out? Even before that MS came out with P-Code and the abomination that was Word 6 for the Mac.
- krzat 7y agoSad for developers. What I had in mind regarding desktop were big tools like Blender, Photoshop, Blender, IntelliJ IDEs, which existed long before Electron. I think it clearly shows that complex UI apps require cross platform UI, or will remain single platform (Xcode, Visual Studio).
- scarface74 7y agoLet me tell you a story... I was at a crossroads in 2008. I had been developing mostly in C for a decade and decided to pivot to being your standard “Enterprise Dev”. I had a choice between moving my career to C# or Java. I chose C# partly because of the bad stench of the cross platform Java IDEs at the time. Give me VS or Xcode any day over a Java based IDE. Photoshop definitely isn’t using a non native runtime. I doubt that Blender is either.
- iaml 7y agoHave you heard about our lord and savior, vs code? People are choosing it over full blown vs. Also, I haven’t seen many happy xcode devs.
- ratww 7y agoVS Code is winning because it's multiplatform and has great support for lots of languages. I'd say it's the best choice for 95% of programmers. But for writing C# apps in a Windows computer, the old VS was already miles ahead back in 2010. It is a really good product. It had RAD tools, testing, deployment, source control, database migrations, all wrapped in a very snappy and convenient GUI that I still don't think VS Code replaces properly. As much as I love the command line and unix philosophy, there was something about such a complete IDE that made me very productive. All IMO of course. However I strongly believe that VS Code will get better and better with time and be able to fully replace old VS even for this use case in the future.