4 ms·
>> Anyway technically the physical jobs can be done remotely if latency isn't a concern We all talk about robots, but I have yet to see ANY robot remotely capa
by sandworm101 7y ago
>> Anyway technically the physical jobs can be done remotely if latency isn't a concern
We all talk about robots, but I have yet to see ANY robot remotely capable of the simplest jobs. At my work, an exaust fan failed overnight. Replacing it is a simple task: a few screws and some basic wiring. Latency isn't the issue. There are no robots with the dexterity to even consider such a job. I'd be amazed if one exists that is capable of navigating the ladders and corners needed to get to the fan. (Flying isn't an option. We are near an airport.)
- andrey_utkin 7y agoWhat you describe is not a "simplest job", definitely not for a robot, but also for an unskilled labour. I see the way to handle this sort of situation is to embrace "whole node replacement" tactic. I suppose this is already happening in some cases. "Repair robots" is one possible way to accomplish that, but it's not the only way, and in most cases not the cheapest available way. For example, if a fan has failed in your work laptop, you don't call the technician to fix it in place, you request a replacement laptop and post your failed laptop to your IT support facility.
- nradov 7y agoNode replacement isn't generally a practical option with large machinery or commercial facilities. And even where it could be possible, robots won't be up to the job for many decades. Show me a robot that can extract a badly rusted bolt.
- sandworm101 7y agoShow me a robot that can FIND a rusty bolt. The act of cleaning, of scrubbing away the dust and dirt from a work area, is beyond AI at the moment. If that rusty bolt has been painted over it might as well not exist.
- neutronicus 7y agoShit, and what if it's so badly rusted that you have to drill it out and then use a tap to clear the remaining crud from the threads...
- mrunkel 7y agoThe robot doesn’t need to see it if it has the plans in it’s head.
- NortySpock 7y agoDoes the planned schematic reflect the reality of the installation? Does the wiring diagram show how the cable bends under its own tension?
- pnutjam 7y agoYes, current infrastructure is not designed for automated maintenance, I'm dealing with that in the software world. It will take more time to retrofit the physical world, but it will happen. If things are remote, they get documented better then onsite people running around with their asses on fire.
- nkrisc 7y agoWoops the original installer didn't do it to plan.
- dzhiurgis 7y agoIf a whole plant/shop is ram by robots then you wouldn’t need a fan first place!