4 ms·
I'd say it's very hard to find any violent revolutions that improved a society. It's pretty much a long line of tragedies. I count throwing out a foreign oppre
by BurningFrog 7y ago
I'd say it's very hard to find any violent revolutions that improved a society. It's pretty much a long line of tragedies.
I count throwing out a foreign oppressor, like the American revolution or the Czech "velvet revolution" as a separate category. Those can be good.
- TomMarius 7y agoThe central point of the Velvet revolution was that it was non violent; also it was not about foreign oppresor primarily, we were oppresing ourselves very well without much help needed.
- BurningFrog 7y agoMy impression is that once it was clear the Soviet Union would not rescue the regime, it had lost it's power base, and was doomed.
- TomMarius 7y agoYes, but that was the last resort, after the regime's own army and secret police got overwhelmed.
- ciceryadam 7y agoBy the time the Velvet Revolution started, Poland was already after it's semi-free election, Hungary dismantled the heavily protected border with Austria, and the Berlin wall fell. But still, part of the local communist army had a contingency plan, 2 MiG-29 jets going supersonic, as low as they could, above the 300000+ protesters in Letna park. Thank god they didn't go through with it. Sources in Czech: https://www.seznamzpravy.cz/clanek/stacil-by-prelet-stihacky-nad-letnou-a-byli-by-mrtvi-vzpomina-na-listopad-prominentni-estebak-82837 https://www.seznamzpravy.cz/clanek/stacil-by-prelet-stihacky... https://www.parlamentnilisty.cz/zpravy/Havel-vzpominal-Stacily-dve-stihacky-A-revoluce-by-byla-krvava-218079 https://www.parlamentnilisty.cz/zpravy/Havel-vzpominal-Staci...
- HaloZero 7y agoVietnam gained independence from France, might not be much better but I would say colonialism in general follows this. Or would that fall under "violent revolutions that throwing out a foreign oppressor".
- BurningFrog 7y agoYeah, I don't count sending the French home as the kind of revolution I talk about. If the decades of war and communism that followed were an improvement can be debated, but it's a quite separate issue.
- shlom22 7y agoPretty sure Mau handing out eviction notices to all those landlords helped China, did it not
- marcosdumay 7y agoThere were plenty of violent revolutions that stopped early enough to make gains. (At around the French one, England had a few.) But any revolution that lasts enough to make into the popular definition of the word will cost more than it gains.
- pdonis 7y ago> At around the French one, England had a few. The USA had one too.
- marcosdumay 7y agoI don't think independence wars are on the same category. They are much more likely to be beneficial, and having a well defined enemy, much less likely to grow unbounded.
- BurningFrog 7y agoIt's also an enemy that can go home when they lose. Afterwards you don't have to choose between coexisting with them, or killing them.
- vkou 7y ago> I'd say it's very hard to find any violent revolutions that improved a society. The reign of terror in France may not have improved France, but it did scare the European aristocracy, and ended up indirectly giving a lot of political and economic rights to the general population. Aristocrats very quickly realized that they did not want a repeat of that performance in their home countries. The Soviet Union, especially under Lenin and Stalin was no picnic, but it scared the West shitless, thus forcing it to concede rights, benefits, and legislature to labour movements, to prevent full-scale communism. Social democracy, as an institution, can credit much of its existence to the communist revolution. People with power over you never give anything up, unless they are scared. Violent revolutions tend to make neighboring oligarchs quite scared.
- GordonS 7y agoYou are right about the US being scared shirtless about communism, though I'm not convinced labour rights etc were as a direct result. Also look at all the damage the US did to other societies in the name of preventing "red danger" - the repercussions of which are still being felt in some countries.
- bdauvergne 7y agoThe burden of proof is on you, most institution of French social democracy where created in the thirty years following the soviet revolution; without knowing I think it's the same in the rest of western Europe.
- jbay808 7y agoIt's worth casting a critical eye on the American Revolution, too. https://www.gwern.net/Mistakes#the-american-revolution https://www.gwern.net/Mistakes#the-american-revolution
- vharuck 7y ago>I count throwing out a foreign oppressor, like the American revolution The revolutionaries were British citizens, just like the soldiers they faced. Sure, England shipped in more soldiers, but neither side was more foreign than the other.
- BurningFrog 7y agoCall it a war of independence, if you prefer. I think the important part is that the overthrown regime was based outside the (new) country, and was no longer a factor in the internal politics.
- mnm1 7y agoCommunist Romania. Things improved immensely. And that was definitely not a foreign oppressor. I'm sure there are others, but yeah generally it's rare.
- BurningFrog 7y agoThat's a decent counterexample. Though maybe people didn't revolt before, since ultimately the Soviets would roll in the tanks if they ever toppled Ceaușescu.
- mnm1 7y agoYeah, hard to say. The USSR was still alive for two more years but probably too busy by the end of '89 to care much about such foreign affairs as it was likely crumbling from the inside. But it's hard to know. I think what's more likely is that Ceaușescu would have kept going long after Soviet collapse if he hadn't been killed, probably into a multi generational cult of personality dictatorial communist state. Basically another North Korea. I'm so glad they killed that monstrous piece of shit. Best Christmas present for Romanians ever. If NK or China ever follows suit, I imagine a similar outcome. Some people are better off dead.
- BurningFrog 7y agoYeah, I'm somewhat familiar with the utter madness and evil of that regime... Thanks for making me a little less sure of my universal revolution theory :)