6 ms·
>> "Benefits not available to low-income workers" A more accurate statement would be "Benefits not available to low-income jobs" There are plenty of jobs that
by sandworm101 7y ago
>> "Benefits not available to low-income workers"
A more accurate statement would be "Benefits not available to low-income jobs"
There are plenty of jobs that simply cannot be done remotely. The more physical the job, the less it can be done remotely. A meat packer at a meat packing plant cannot work from home. A construction worker cannot build houses from a desk. (I'd add nursing, but a large amount of those jobs is paperwork that often can be done remotely.) And there are some very highly-paid jobs that cannot be done from home. Pilots cannot pilot from home (of the few that still have jobs). Surgeons cannot cut. Mechanics cannot turn their wrenches from afar.
And all the IT people. Some of them can login remotely to diagnose network and service problems, but someone always has to have hands on hardware. There is yet to be a robot that can replace a failed cooling fan on a law firm's NAS device. Some, many, of these people are in fact making trips to other peoples' homes to service the equipment that allows them to work at home.
- lmilcin 7y agoI would also say that even for people that can work remotely, low income may mean worse environment for work at home. Even with three kids I was able to quickly repurpose one of the rooms for home office and get everything needed to work comfortably from home. As my wife does not need to work we have less problem with kids staying at home. This is currently mostly discussion how to provide healthy environment for them to grow. I know colleagues at work who are not as fortunate and have to share same space with kids with no breather and it is putting a very visible strain on them.
- vladvasiliu 7y ago> I would also say that even for people that can work remotely, low income may mean worse environment for work at home. Even with three kids I was able to quickly repurpose one of the rooms for home office and get everything needed to work comfortably from home. I would think that working from home all the time as a matter of course (as opposed to being forced to, like during a pandemic) would allow lower income people to live further from the expensive cities and, arguably, in much better conditions. I know that if I could WFH full time I could move to the suburbs (or even to a smaller city) and live in a house bigger and cheaper than my current flat.
- thayne 7y agoThat is a good point. There is a big difference between being forced to work from home, and choosing to work from home. In my case, I've actually been wanting to work from home for a while, and was already preparing for it in some ways, so being forced to work from home was not a hardship at all, but if you aren't prepared for it, I imagine it would be a lot harder.
- lmilcin 7y agoIt is different when you plan for it and when you are forced to do it. I actually always wanted to work from home full time and have already worked for 2 years on a contract working fully from home (showing up at the office once per two or three months). If I knew I would not be at a significant disadvantage searching for WFH contracts vs being available in a major city center I would gladly move outside city. I have three kids and I need to take into account that once I move outside city it might not be possible to move back.
- Nasrudith 7y agoEven more accurate is "most low income jobs" call centers aren't exactly high income. Anyway technically the physical jobs can be done remotely if latency isn't a concern but if it is sufficient to remote work the question usually becomes "Why not do the last 10% and fully automate it?"
- peterwoerner 7y agoBecause typically the last 10% incurs 90% of the costs.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 7y agoThe way I've heard it is 90% of the job can be done in 10 hours, the next 9% in 100, the next 0.9% in 1000, the last 0.1% in 10,000 hours I'd hazard a guess that hours is replaceable with millions of dollars for a rough gauge.
- mokus 7y agoProviding remote control options is probably the first step to automating the last 10%, too. Once the control and feedback channels are completely digital, it’s just a matter of time until the decision-making is too, at least for jobs where wrong decisions are not too costly.
- sandworm101 7y ago>> Anyway technically the physical jobs can be done remotely if latency isn't a concern We all talk about robots, but I have yet to see ANY robot remotely capable of the simplest jobs. At my work, an exaust fan failed overnight. Replacing it is a simple task: a few screws and some basic wiring. Latency isn't the issue. There are no robots with the dexterity to even consider such a job. I'd be amazed if one exists that is capable of navigating the ladders and corners needed to get to the fan. (Flying isn't an option. We are near an airport.)
- andrey_utkin 7y agoWhat you describe is not a "simplest job", definitely not for a robot, but also for an unskilled labour. I see the way to handle this sort of situation is to embrace "whole node replacement" tactic. I suppose this is already happening in some cases. "Repair robots" is one possible way to accomplish that, but it's not the only way, and in most cases not the cheapest available way. For example, if a fan has failed in your work laptop, you don't call the technician to fix it in place, you request a replacement laptop and post your failed laptop to your IT support facility.
- xattt 7y agoI’ll chime in from the perspective of nursing. Desk nurses are the minority and are often the “holy grail” of the profession for people looking for better work-life balance. Acute care employs the majority of RNs with less acute facilities (long-term care, community care) more likely to employ LPNs and unregulated care providers. Half-jokingly, I’d love to join a start-up developing a remote work nurse-robot.
- madamelic 7y ago> I’d love to join a start-up developing a remote work nurse-robot. Even ignoring the WFH bit, a remotely-controlled 'nursebot' could be the best case. Not only would it prevent communicating disease, but it would reduce stress on nurse's bodies, more precise medication administration (by reducing error + augmenting knowledge). Although, isn't human contact considered an important part of recovery? I guess the nursebots would be better in some cases than others.
- steve76 7y agoI would say it's the reverse. A lot of that can be done remotely. There's just momentum, really big momentum, working against automation. Education: Jobs exist to give people who aren't geneticists or neurologists something to do. Diplomacy: Jobs are a past concession for people giving up private wealth for public development. Defense: No coincidence a lot of jobs work the same as weapon systems. Regardless of nations, a lot of stateless actors today are really dangerous. Unproven risk: Things can spiral out of control and it takes time for something new, like using genetics or beams to butcher cattle, to become palatable and accepted by the public. Amortization: What do we do with perfectly working, if inefficient, process and infrastructure if everything is free, there's no demand, and without maintenance bad things leak out of it? There are plenty of solutions that take out the physicality. I wouldn't bet against it: What you do is you work on a larger scale. Instead of unbolting a muffler, just shred the entire thing. Cars are a public utility with a free tier. Take the same principle to unmanned private jets. Take out the entire urban center with a rail system. Catheterization, preventative medicine, therapeutic imaging, genetics applied to chemotherapy, blood thinners. I would also bet most people will be surprised at the amount of busy work. Kill yourself pumping a barrel of oil, only to drive to the coffee shop to complain about pumping that barrel of oil.
- nradov 7y agoAnyone who does classified work (including software developers) can't do it at home.
- djsumdog 7y agoDid Snowden work fully remote as an NSA contractor with classified data?
- rkeene2 7y agoNo. If he did work at home (which is what I'm assuming you mean by "fully remote") on classified material it was not part of his job, and thus if he billed the US Government for that time it would be timecard fraud. If you have knowledge of this, you should report it to DCAA ( https://www.dcaa.mil/ https://www.dcaa.mil/ ).
- kthxbye123 7y agoThis is the most powerful snitch energy I've ever seen.
- rkeene2 7y agoIt was clearly a joke response to a joke question. Reporting Edward Snowden for timecard fraud, while technically it could be a valid infraction, misses the scope of the crimes he is already known to have committed. Also, the penalty would be on the company that has the agreement with the US Government and not Edward Snowden himself (which could include being barred with doing business with the US Government for 1 year).
- windthrown 7y agoMy recollection is that Snowden worked in remote/satellite facilities such as the Operations Center in Hawaii (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kunia_Regional_SIGINT_Operations_Center https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kunia_Regional_SIGINT_Operatio...), but not from his house.
- vinniejames 7y ago"Pilots cannot pilot from home" ... Google 'drones' "Surgeons can't cut" ... oh but they can, https://www.therobotreport.com/remote-surgery-via-robots-advances-china-5g-tests/ https://www.therobotreport.com/remote-surgery-via-robots-adv... Builders can't build... but they can click "Print" https://www.businessinsider.com/3d-homes-that-take-24-hours-and-less-than-4000-to-print-2018-9?op=1 https://www.businessinsider.com/3d-homes-that-take-24-hours-...
- WalterBright 7y ago> "Pilots cannot pilot from home" ... Google 'drones' Most of pilot training consists of dealing with emergencies. Pilots tend to be highly motivated to be safe because they hit the ground first. There's a saying among pilots that saving themselves saves the passengers. I wouldn't get on an airplane with a remote pilot. BTW, in WW2, bringing the chief of maintenance along for the check ride after an overhaul ensured a quality job was done.
- vinniejames 7y agoWould you buy a package shipped on a plane with a remote pilot? Not all flights carry passengers
- WalterBright 7y agoThat would depend on if you're willing to accept the risk of a malicious hacker taking 50+ over. That would be a "nope" from me.
- vinniejames 7y agoHow many times has that happened to military drones? I'd be more worried about an armed stealth jet than a cargo plane full of rubber dog $ out of Hong Kong
- JamesBarney 7y agoJobs that are easy to do remotely, are also easy to offshore unless they are sophisticated and require intensive communication to get right. There are many low income jobs that can be done remotely. And they are, I very rarely talk to a customer rep from the U.S. or buy something that was woven or built here.