9 ms·
>This is locking down for the sake of locking down, not an evidence-first safety driven approach. That is something I cannot support. I hope however you do sup
by Barrin92 7y ago
>This is locking down for the sake of locking down, not an evidence-first safety driven approach. That is something I cannot support.
I hope however you do support respecting the law even in cases where you disagree with a decision.
- icelancer 7y agoThis country was founded on the opposite of that; there's a lot of people who live here who identify with that spirit. There's also a litany of unjust laws in the past that were enforced regularly that we look very much down on today. Whether that happens in the future with COVID-19 regulations, who knows, but blind respect of the law is not really something Americans are known for.
- teachrdan 7y ago> There's also a litany of unjust laws in the past that were enforced regularly that we look very much down on today. Are you seriously comparing Alameda County's shelter in place ordinance to slavery?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoWhy would you assume that's the reference? Many unjust laws have existed in American history other than legalized slavery.
- teachrdan 7y ago> unjust laws in the past that were enforced regularly that we look very much down on today What else would they be referring to, besides perhaps the internment of Japanese Americans, Jim Crow, or other laws that have absurdly little in common with the shelter in place ordinance that's keeping Tesla's factory temporarily closed?
- yadaeno 7y agoThe prohibition or the classification of marijuana as a schedule 1 narcotic.
- astronautjones 7y agopeak hn
- cecja 7y agojust wait we will get a hitler reference :D
- cma 7y ago> For as in absolute governments the King is law, > so in free countries the law ought to be king; > and there ought to be no other. > >-Thomas Paine
- enumjorge 7y agoI agree that blind respect of the law is not inline with American culture, but petulant disrespect of the law should not be encouraged either. The way Musk has been conducting himself lately strikes me less as someone who is pushing back against irrational dogma, and more like someone who's throwing a tantrum because he's unhappy that a pandemic is hindering his ability to run his business.
- icelancer 7y agoI wouldn't disagree with that. I'm enjoying it all the same.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 7y agoDid you read more the the tweets? his recent Joe Rogan interview shows the contrary.
- pengaru 7y ago> his recent Joe Rogan interview shows the contrary I listened to the interview and found Elon ridiculously dismissive of the risks and when he started arguing Shanghai's gigafactory not having any employees die of COVID-19 was proof of the shutdown being unnecessary, it became hard to continue listening at all. How many of those workers got infected and went on the increase community spread to non-employees? Why are we only considering employee deaths? It's as willfully ignorant as people saying things like "I don't wear a mask because I don't have any symptoms."
- rcMgD2BwE72F 7y agoYou can also consider the effects of reopening factories (like Tesla's Shanghai) on the spread of C19 and view the manufacturers' sanitary policies as successful (in avoiding a rapid 2nd wave). I guess Musk talks about deaths (over thousands of employees) because it's the most reliable indicator, one that does not depend on, say, testing policies.
- ntsplnkv2 7y agoBlind respect of the law is looked down upon - but there are proper channels to change the law as defined in our constitution and proper protest. Read the federalist papers and the actual writings of our forefathers. You will be quite surprised. The constitution was framed to prevent the people from being stupid and killing the nation just as much as it was to prevent a monarchy.
- Karunamon 7y agoAbsolutely not. Garbage laws deserve no respect. Society routinely violates speed limits, copyrights, and so forth, to the benefit of all.
- FireBeyond 7y agoTell us about the widespread societal benefits of violating speed limits.
- duskwuff 7y agoAll I can think of now is: > drunk driving may kill a lot of people, but it also helps a lot of people get to work on time, so, it;s impossible to say if its bad or not, -- https://twitter.com/dril/status/464802196060917762 https://twitter.com/dril/status/464802196060917762
- lonelappde 7y agoLess wasted time and lower pollution.
- duskwuff 7y agoFuel efficiency of most cars drops precipitiously at higher speeds. You're generating more pollution by speeding, not less.
- CamperBob2 7y agoMaybe in 1974. My car does about the same at 80 MPH as it does at 65 MPH, as counterintuitive as that seems.
- dpoochieni 7y agoIt helps keep people from driving too complacently and unattentively.
- sjwright 7y agoWhile it is fallacy of herd mentality, the safest speed nonetheless tends to be the speed of the other vehicles around you. Speed deltas are the real danger—not failure to adhere to a specific, oft-arbitrary number.
- mrfusion 7y agoJust curious what you would tell Rosa Parks?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- geofft 7y agoI think what I'd tell her, honestly, is that it really sucks that our legal system has no way to challenge bad laws in court without getting arrested for them first, and we should fix that. It shouldn't have required her getting arrested to have a court case of the form "If she does this, she's clearly going to get arrested, let's have a judge review that law." And it really sucks that it wasn't her case that decided that the Montgomery bus discrimination laws were unconstitutional, it was the cases of Claudette Colvin and four others (Browder v. Gayle), and really at most one ought to be enough. (And, in turn, if a judge reviews the lockdown order and finds that in fact it is a legitimate exercise of government power, then we're in a very different situation from the one she was in.)
- greglindahl 7y agoI don't think there's any argument about standing regarding Tesla suing Alameda county without reopening first.
- paulgb 7y agoRosa Parks and a billionaire defying an order to put production on hold because the county feels it isn't safe for his workers to return to work makes for a hell of a comparison.
- SantalBlush 7y agoI don't think it was meant to be a comparison between the two, I think it was meant to be a counterexample to the notion that we should always follow the law.
- 7y ago
- downerending 7y agoNot OP, but I think Musk should definitely respect the law. I also think he should leave the state if they're jerking him around--he'll get far better treatment elsewhere.
- pmorici 7y agoTesla's whole legal case revolves around the argument that the county is not respecting the law. This isn't really about respecting the law it is about a disagreement between the county and Tesla about what the law is.
- Barrin92 7y ago>disagreement between the county and Tesla about what the law is and that's perfectly fine, however, those disagreements happen in a court. I don't think disagreeing with a county order gives you the right to simply ignore it. If Tesla thinks this is wrong they can sue, which they did, and that should be it.
- pmorici 7y agoThere is a state level order and a county level order the state level order says to open the county says stay closed. They can't do both. They consulted a lawyer, chose to follow the higher authority, and asked a court to confirm they are in the right. What they are doing is entirely reasonable.
- AlexandrB 7y agoThis is straight-up false. The state-level order delegates final decision-making authority to counties. Stop spreading misinformation. > California Governor Gavin Newsom said Thursday that state-level guidance allowing manufacturing to resume some production didn’t supersede county-level restrictions. The company had unsucessfully tried to argue that Tesla’s production should be considered critical infrastructure.[1] [1] https://www.theverge.com/2020/5/9/21253127/elon-musk-lawsuit-alameda-coronavirus-tesla-fremont-lockdown https://www.theverge.com/2020/5/9/21253127/elon-musk-lawsuit...
- pmorici 7y agoYou might be the one who is spreading false info. I clicked your link and its reference to Newsom's statement is a linked CNBC article. In that article there is no such quote from the governor only a reference to the county's website claiming that their order takes precedent over the state which is the whole dispute here. In other words that Vox article falsely attributes a quote to Newsom which he didn't say or at least their source doesn't support their claim.
- fasteddie31003 7y agoRemember when the government told people NOT to wear masks. I proudly and strongly went against the government then.
- cecja 7y agooh god dude I helped saving lives now I want to be allowed to kill them. xD
- ripberge 7y agoCalifornia at the state, county and city levels routinely flouts federal laws that they vehemently oppose. I think many of those decisions make sense and act as a catalyst for change. I also think Tesla's stance makes sense and is a catalyst for change.
- manigandham 7y agoThere is no law being broken here, it's local county orders with (currently debated) legal authority by a single official.
- rhizome 7y ago"It's not illegal" is a shitty ethical basis.
- manigandham 7y agoMany other companies and factories are open, workers are not required to show up, and if they do they're following guidelines developed from the factory presence in China with thousands of unharmed employees. This is on top of most of the state being effectively open for weeks already. What is the ethical quandary here?
- rhizome 7y agoLet's start with, "respecting public policy."
- manigandham 7y agoWhat if public policy - or single official's order in this case - is wrong and they disagree with good reason?
- rhizome 7y ago"Is wrong." OK, and just by force of personality Elon establishes that? Since when is Elon an epidemiologist? Sounds like about as much as he's a underwater rescue expert and ventilator manufacturer. Take a step back, he's a troll juicing his stock price 80% of the time. Read elsewhere where he has a $700B bonus hanging in the balance here, and so how is that not the simplest explanation? There's your "good reason." I believe the people who say it's still unsafe. If you don't and want or need the work, I think they're hiring in Fremont, or will be soon.
- dpoochieni 7y agoWhat law?