3 ms·
I'm not sure why this is getting downvoted. Even prominent Bitcoin promoter Fred Wilson admitted that Bitcoin wasn't viable as a currency: https://avc.com/2017/
by wpietri 7y ago
I'm not sure why this is getting downvoted. Even prominent Bitcoin promoter Fred Wilson admitted that Bitcoin wasn't viable as a currency: https://avc.com/2017/08/store-of-value-vs-payment-system/ https://avc.com/2017/08/store-of-value-vs-payment-system/
A couple years back, an NYT writer tried living on Bitcoin: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/16/nyregion/new-york-today-living-on-bitcoin.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/16/nyregion/new-york-today-l...
It didn't work. It doesn't function as a currency. Whatever the intention, it's a speculative, high-volatility commodity with no use value traded in an unregulated market.
- jameslevy 7y agoWould you say the same thing about gold? Genuinely curious, since obviously Bitcoin is frequently compared to gold as a store of value instead of a unit of exchange. The most persuasive defense of Bitcoin as a store of value is that the world needs precisely one digital store of value, and game theory may dictate that it will end up being Bitcoin. But yes, Bitcoin is obviously ridiculously volatile. I tell friends that there is money to be made, but you need to have a very strong stomach for it.
- chii 7y ago> the world needs precisely one digital store of value that's an assumption, not a fact. The existence of an object doesn't automatically prove that the world needs that object's existence. May be the world _never_ needs such a method, given existing mechanisms already fullfill such a need (e.g., a bank account/credit card).
- wpietri 7y agoWould I say what? That it's a "speculative, high-volatility commodity with no use value traded in an unregulated market"? No. Gold has use value and is generally traded in regulated markets. If something is volatile and great for speculation, it's a bad store of value. So I don't think Bitcoin qualifies as that either.
- SilasX 7y agoI’m not sure why you’re confused about it being downvoted. 1) Whether or not it meets the (or someone’s preferred) definition of currency is wholly incidental to the answerer’s explanation, so even if correct, this is not the place to make the point. 2) Bizarre non-sequitur that equates finiteness of currency with zero sum utility which is a real stretch and easy to find counterexamples for (eg chore tokens). For the cherry on top, it links Medium as a main source. Is that a good enough justification to downvote?
- three_seagrass 7y agoThis is splitting hairs. Sure, everything can be used as a currency. Gold, bitcoins, fiat cash, snackpack puddings at lunch, seashells, etc. Then there are qualities that make something a good currency, by modern standards. As others have pointed out with links to examples, being deflationary, irreversible, volatile, and having low coverage with unpredictable fees are traits that make Bitcoin not a very good currency. Yes you can hand wave about future promises to be a great currency or chore tokens, but that does not reflect the utility of Bitcoin right now as a good currency.
- SilasX 7y agoI wasn't addressing whether bitcoin is or isn't a good currency. I was explaining why I downnvoted a comment that argued to that effect. Are you saying that every comment whose conclusion happens to right should be upvoted (or at least not downvoted)? If so, that would be a mistake. If you present bad reasons to believe correct conclusion X, you are hurting the discussion just as much as if you argued for not-X. And the reasons given in that comment (fixed quantity implies zero-sum utility over such transactions) are bad reasons to believe bitcoin is not a currency. Furthermore, there's still the fact that the commenter was latching onto a minor, tangential point and blowing it up to be the focus of the discussion. That's also an anti-pattern. If you want to argue that bitcoin makes for a bad currency, great! I would just encourage you to bring it up in a place where it's actually relevant to the article or comment it replies to, and do so with reasons that pass simple sanity checks.
- 7y ago
- vokep 7y agoWhenever I see things like this, it reminds me of articles about VR being dead and how its obviously not actually useful or interesting. It has always had potential to be a currency, but it requires a context of use in order to actually function as a currency. That context is still being established, and until it is, any basic evaluation of "is bitcoin a currency" will result in a "no".
- wpietri 7y agoAfter a dozen years of "real soon now", there's no particular reason to think the context is still being established.