3 ms·
A lot of that run is from systematic under building, especially where markets are hottest. Construction starts will be hit super hard again. Even the boomers ex
by epistasis 7y ago
A lot of that run is from systematic under building, especially where markets are hottest. Construction starts will be hit super hard again. Even the boomers exiting may not be enough to meet demand now.
There are systemic issues with regulatory capture in real estate, those who benefit from limited supply (landowners) have blocked land from being used more efficiently, dramatically driving up its prices.
- amluto 7y agoI’m not convinced by your assertion that land owners are to blame. Land is land, and you can’t just make more. Replace “land” with “dwelling unit” and I might agree with you.
- epistasis 7y agoThe regulatory capture happens from landowners restricting both the number of dwelling units that are allowed under zoning, and by landowners using political planning process to stop even those dwelling units that fit the zoning. Massive chunks of our cities are restricted to a single or two dwelling unit per parcel, which creates a huge bubble in land prices. So in summary, landowners use law to inflate land values by restricting the number of dwelling units that are allowed. (And ironically, by unfairly capping the population density, they force overcrowding of people into existing units, which is what studies are finding to be the true factor the geographic distribution of COVID19 cases in places like NYC, rather than density... but I digress)
- api 7y agoI've come to the view that local zoning should be abolished. We should have standardized zoning at at least the state level patterned after Japan. Local zoning is nothing more than a property owners' cartel that restricts supply to extract rent. Critics will see this as un-democratic when in reality it's much more democratic. Most local zoning is controlled by tiny opaque cabals of land owners who use all kinds of tactics to prevent participation by anyone beyond other sympathetic land owners with a vested interest in raising prices. These cartels have sat around while an entire generation has been ruined by their practices. It's time to take their little fiefdoms away.
- epistasis 7y agoThree books that dive into the problems of our "local control" system, including how it can be anti-democratic: Neighborhood Defenders by Katherine Einstein et al Segregation By Design by Jessica Trounstine (recently won a planning book of the year award) And though it's not about loca control, as much, The Color of Law by Richard Rothstein is an essential for looking at the federal policies that forced segregation in housing.
- ashtonkem 7y agoI think we should keep the industrial vs. residential zoning, there is a baby in that bath water. But I largely agree, zoning laws to enforce density norms appear to do much more harm than they prevent.
- epistasis 7y agoI agree, but I don't think that any of the "end zoning" people mean to end industrial/residential zoning; at least I've never seen that aspect of it criticized. But it's also such a tiny proportion of zoning, that if it were kept and the rest of the bad zoning policies were removed, that "end zoning" would probably be a good way to describe that result.
- stass 7y ago> Most local zoning is controlled by tiny opaque cabals of land owners who use all kinds of tactics to prevent participation by anyone beyond other sympathetic land owners with a vested interest in raising prices What tactics do they use and why would that not apply at the state level? We already saw huge influence of big interest groups at the state level for many decades now, e.g. with the most recent passage of the rent control legislation in CA (benefiting developers). State-level legislation results in a much more damage than any local legislation could. On a different topic, I'm surprised people keep bringing up the notion that restrictive zoning benefits landowners. If anything, upzoning always increases land prices as it allows more economic value to be extracted from it (think how big the cash flow would be from a 20 unit apartment building developed on a 10000 sq ft lot compared do a duplex even assuming that per-unit rent goes down). I know plenty of landowners and landlords, and none of them favor restrictive zoning. The only people supporting low-density zoning are homeowners living in these neighborhoods as they extract value from the neighborhood character and scenery and could not care less what they real estate is worth (until they are selling). These are not the people you whose voice in the matter of town governance you'd want to take away. That would be a textbook definition of tyranny of majority.