7 ms·
I live in an area with a large number of AirBnBs, specifically a beach town near Los Angeles. Me and a few friends were hoping to see a significant drop in home
by ashtonkem 7y ago
I live in an area with a large number of AirBnBs, specifically a beach town near Los Angeles. Me and a few friends were hoping to see a significant drop in home prices due to AirBnB landlords being forced the liquidate under financial duress.
Obviously we didn’t think this would undo decades of disastrous housing policy, but the hope is that some units would cross into striking range for those of us with good jobs. Alas, the price barely moved in my area, much to my surprise and frustration.
- graton 7y agoI wouldn't expect that in 7-8 weeks that prices would be impacted appreciably. But maybe in 6-18 months. If you have a decent amount of people who over-extended themselves, they default on their mortgages, houses get foreclosed, and the banks resell them. Then prices might start coming done. But that process takes a long time.
- supernovae 7y agoThe data on how much a property can generate is pretty open data. Most banks are willing to work with owners on re-fi, short term deferments and such and it's not rocket science to convert to full-time rental in lieu of STR. So investors will snap up anything of value and inventory that wasn't profible will just go back to market.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoKeep watching. I'm doing the same in several markets waiting for the most distressed to start moving. Even if it doesn't happen, the cost is low versus the reward of a deal. I'm even reaching out directly to AirBnB hosts to offer my info when they're ready to do a transaction.
- realdlee 7y agohave you gotten many positive replies? curious about the response rate...
- toomuchtodo 7y agoHaven’t made a lot of calls, but have had enough folks say yes it’s worth my time to continue outreach based on data mining. I have a fairly mature financing operation from collateral I’ve grown over a decade and cash on hand, so I can move quick (48hr closing). I also make it worth the seller’s time with a shared equity model. I lock in my gain, they get a share of any upside in the future. Less “We buy houses!” and more “you need a business partner with deeper pockets”.
- d883kd8 7y agoI'd suggest making lowball offers yourself, people may be delusionally hanging on to what prices were a few months ago.
- api 7y agoCareful. It could go a lot lower. Millions and millions of boomers will be unloading homes too over the next few years. RE has been in a bull market since around 2000. That bull run may be ending. It's even possible that the true bubble ended in 2008-2010 and what we have seen since then is a large bear rally a.k.a. "double top." RE is a very slow market where things that could happen in days or months in stocks take years.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoRE in certain metro regions offering high incomes and multiple employers and popular vacation areas has been in a bull run market. Large swaths of the US has stagnated, and I predict the popular areas will continue to stay popular.
- api 7y agoI don't expect those popular areas to get cheap, but I'm speaking of the historic RE bull run that began in 2000 that saw the rate of increase vastly outstripping core inflation and wages. That was clearly a bubble, and RE is still ridiculously high as a multiple of median wages in many "hot" markets. LA, SF, Seattle, etc. are almost totally unaffordable to anyone below 1-2 standard deviations above the median income, which is crazy. SF Bay is by far the craziest at least among major cities, though I suspect there may be crazier small "boutique" markets around. Bubbles are basically naturally occurring Ponzi schemes. They are not driven by fundamentals.
- epistasis 7y agoA lot of that run is from systematic under building, especially where markets are hottest. Construction starts will be hit super hard again. Even the boomers exiting may not be enough to meet demand now. There are systemic issues with regulatory capture in real estate, those who benefit from limited supply (landowners) have blocked land from being used more efficiently, dramatically driving up its prices.
- gruez 7y ago>Me and a few friends were hoping to see a significant drop in home prices due to AirBnB landlords being forced the liquidate under financial duress. >Alas, the price barely moved in my area, much to my surprise and frustration. I suspect it's because foreclosure take a few months to do, and are probably suspended right now due to the lockdown, so those distressed houses haven't translated into supply yet.
- ashtonkem 7y agoThat’s a great point, but I was mentally assuming that more AirBnB hosts would liquidate before that since they don’t actually live in their properties.
- vmception 7y agoThe only reason real estate works as an investment vehicle for people is because it's a slow market. The inefficient pricing and the slowly updating pricing allows for the HIGHEST amount of leverage to work for people. In any other market, unsophisticated investors would have been margin called overnight. Instead they get to sit for years on slowly moving prices, and use those years to continue boosting their collateral as if nothing happened. So you can't expect a significant drop in home prices just yet. But definitely pay attention to foreclosure auctions. The court houses are not even processing these yet until the economy turns back on in the local municipality. You're too early, but wait for it. For now we are all trying to quantify just how leveraged people were. Many people don't think there were that many AirBnB speculators to affect the housing market. So every article to the contrary just helps form the picture. For the 2008 great financial crisis, it only took 7% of mortgage holders defaulting to cause the market convulsions (as in there really weren't that many "bad" borrowers, people overwhelmingly played by the expected rules to the best of their ability). Expect that the % necessary to cause distress to banks to be bit a higher these days, due to some marginal reforms, but also watch to see how many are going to default because that could also be a much higher percent its interesting because so many more people already won't be able to pay their mortgages because the unemployment already happened first.
- api 7y agoMakes me wonder if companies flipping homes and other fast high tech financial types getting into RE will actually lower prices in the long run. Part of the thing keeping prices high is that people see RE as a no brainer safe asset where they can just dump money. A faster market would end that perception.
- jrockway 7y agoThere are a lot of people that see real estate as a no brainer safe asset, but some of that is intrinsic in what real estate is. You can go inside your house and it keeps the rain out, which is nice. I am more interested to see what happens to commercial real estate. I have a feeling that hotels are kind of unhappy about their real estate holdings right now. The question is whether they can get rid of it (and if someone can turn a hotel into apartments successfully, which sounds like a challenge to me). Ultimately, I think the status quo will prevail and nothing will change. The cost of change is too high.
- arminiusreturns 7y agoHave hope, because the real estate market for many reasons is very laggy in it's indicators. It could take multiple months for the effects of all this to hit it.
- Spooky23 7y agoRight now people are just not paying bills. I'd guess that your dreams are unlikely -- banks and others will unload to different equity funds, who can use free Federal $$$ to buy up this stuff. The second and third waves of the economic crisis will be worse, and I'm sure we'll see all sorts of cronyism pushing this stuff. We haven't seen anything yet.
- rdtwo 7y agoYeah I agree odds of consumers and regular people having access to the liquidation market are low. The favorite parties will scoop everything up with low interest loans
- MattGaiser 7y ago> Alas, the price barely moved in my area You are early. Banks aren't becoming aggressive quite yet.
- v77 7y agoI'm a Canadian starting to look for a California retirement property and I'm hoping the same. This is the problem with most desireable real estate markets: there's always people on the sidelines waiting to come in.
- louiswilbrink 7y agoJust want to offer perspective from the investor side: I own just one Airbnb in a hot market (downtown, hip neighborhood) and even though bookings were cancelled in April, they’re building back up for May and summer months. It was scary for sure for a span of several weeks, but there were always other contingencies before liquidating (like converting it to a long term rental). Even if I went along with the panic, it would take probably three months to go through with any transaction that would throw a desirable property onto the market. The demand is still so strong that the low price would likely chum the waters and competitive bidding would drive the price up. I think these Airbnb liquidation sale headlines are being sensational and end up wasting buyers time.
- jcomis 7y agoYeah I have a feeling many of those people will be cancelling.
- ghaff 7y agoI take anecdotes about people booking travel plans with something of a grain of salt. For the right price, I might book something for the fall if the price were right AND it was fully cancelable. (Probably not if it involved paying up front though as there are too many things that could go wrong at this point.)
- paganel 7y agoAnd to add a new perspective, over here in Europe we've also started thinking in terms of "if the second wave catches me in a different country while vacationing will I be able to come back in my home country more or less easily?" The answer to that question has been a definite "no" for lots of people during this latest and recent first wave (which has now started retreating a little) and I suspect lots of people will think twice before vacationing in a different country (even if that second country it's also in the Schengen area).
- ghaff 7y ago
- ptero 7y agoIt is probably too early for the price drops. No one knows how much of a crisis this will end up being, so any price moves are likely to be slow. Most owners can sit out a season of no rents, and a few who cannot may get some mortgage relief or bailout to help them swim for a while. Not idea on how seasonal LA real estate market is, but if things are looking dim in late summer / fall you might find some bargains then. My 2c.
- scruple 7y agoSame in south OC, too. Prices have plateaued but they've not really gone down. I am seeing an increase in supply over the last week, however, so it may be starting soon.
- squnch 7y agoKeep hoping. Homeownership rates are very high in Republican country and the government will do almost anything to prop up home prices. Of course if they can find a policy that hurts the coastal homeowners while protecting the yeehaw homeowners they will but expect lots of money printing.
- wdr1 7y agoInteresting. I also live in a beach town near Los Angeles (Santa Monica), but I'm seeing prices hold as steady as ever, if not slightly up. That said, inventory here has been extremely tight for a while.