15 ms·
Redfin: Vacation real-estate ‘toast’ as Airbnb owners rush to offload homes
- tony_cannistra 7y agoThe human v. algorithm power dynamic here is pretty uneven. The prospect of getting an instant offer from these companies is probably a net-positive for folks who are facing serious financial hardship (e.g. from lost rental income that was paying their mortgage), but the same system that enables it also really encourages unethical algorithmic low-balling. Will a Redfin/Zillow data scientist use new coronavirus cases / county in their pricing model? Should they?
- Analemma_ 7y agoPeople who rent out Airbnbs which aren’t their primary residence, especially if they took out a bunch of debt for it, are squeezing the housing supply and driving up costs, so I’m not gonna shed too many tears if they get screwed by the algorithm. Let them eat a huge loss as a warning to others so they’re wary to try it again.
- joncrane 7y agoThe CEO's comments seemed to indicate that the pricing was only to "build in some margin" for unexpected events, as opposed to "squeezing as much juice out as possible." Having said that, publicly traded companies exist to maximize profit and if extra-lowballing property owners in the hardest hit areas maximizes profit, what should stop them?
- lotsofpulp 7y ago> Will a Redfin/Zillow data scientist use new coronavirus cases / county in their pricing model? Should they? Same answer as “should I pay more for my airline/hotel/car rental than the lowest they are willing to sell for”. I know my customers are taking into account the new demand curves, I don’t see why I wouldn’t, not others wouldn’t...unless they want to be on the wrong side of a mispriced transaction.
- peder 7y agoThere are already people and companies lowballing offers, with Redfin and other algorithmic players joining the game, it actually increases prices and improves the liquidity of home ownership.
- _curious_ 7y agoWhat is "unethical algorithmic low-balling." ?
- jrockway 7y agoI'm not a Redfin/Zillow data scientist but I'll buy your beach home for $1.
- jiveturkey 7y agoeh? You can't just throw that out there so carelessly. What is unethical about it?
- ashtonkem 7y agoI live in an area with a large number of AirBnBs, specifically a beach town near Los Angeles. Me and a few friends were hoping to see a significant drop in home prices due to AirBnB landlords being forced the liquidate under financial duress. Obviously we didn’t think this would undo decades of disastrous housing policy, but the hope is that some units would cross into striking range for those of us with good jobs. Alas, the price barely moved in my area, much to my surprise and frustration.
- graton 7y agoI wouldn't expect that in 7-8 weeks that prices would be impacted appreciably. But maybe in 6-18 months. If you have a decent amount of people who over-extended themselves, they default on their mortgages, houses get foreclosed, and the banks resell them. Then prices might start coming done. But that process takes a long time.
- supernovae 7y agoThe data on how much a property can generate is pretty open data. Most banks are willing to work with owners on re-fi, short term deferments and such and it's not rocket science to convert to full-time rental in lieu of STR. So investors will snap up anything of value and inventory that wasn't profible will just go back to market.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoKeep watching. I'm doing the same in several markets waiting for the most distressed to start moving. Even if it doesn't happen, the cost is low versus the reward of a deal. I'm even reaching out directly to AirBnB hosts to offer my info when they're ready to do a transaction.
- realdlee 7y agohave you gotten many positive replies? curious about the response rate...
- 7y ago
- Pfhreak 7y agoWhat is iBuying? It's not really explained in the article. I'm guessing it's where redfin acts as the agent and facilitates the sales online, but I'm not sure.
- empath75 7y agoRedfin buys and flips houses themselves.
- JKCalhoun 7y agoInteresting, competing with their own customers.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tomjakubowski 7y agoNot too different from what Amazon does: use their own customers' data to crush them in competition.
- product50 7y agoThis is exactly similar to what all retailers do.
- kube-system 7y agoZillow also does this.
- empath75 7y agoGiven that my company is sort of waving in the direction of allowing permanent full time remote, buying a beach house at a discount sounds pretty appealing.
- billpg 7y agoIf you'll excuse me, I'll be purchasing some tiny violins.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoThe article buries the lede: > Employers that were really stuck on whether to let people work from home have gotten completely unstuck. And if you can work for Goldman Sachs, but not in New York, if you can work for Amazon, but not in Seattle, well, why would you pay the premium? Vacation rentals impact prices, but are a mere slice of the total market. If tastes and preferences shift away from expensive cities due to remote-work friendly policies, that will have a profound shift on not only housing, but automobiles, gas, etc. People certainly enjoy living in cities, but how many people live in cities exclusively for the physically proximate job access they provide? Time will tell.
- untog 7y agoI'm really curious to see how this actually pans out. As someone who enjoys remote work it's tempting to look at the situation today and say "finally! The fever has broken! Employers will realise how great remote work is!", but in reality a lot of the current remote working situations are a complete shitshow. I think we on HN feel it less because we're already a very tech-literate crowd, so remote video conferencing and collaborative editing (e.g. GitHub) is nothing new to us. But we're not normal in that regard. I wonder if we'll see a sharp swing to the reverse once this pandemic is controlled (however that actually ends up looking). This experience might actually poison people's opinions of remote work in the longer term, not boost them. I hope to be wrong.
- mrits 7y agoI've been number crunching the last few weeks for my next startup. I can't compete with big tech companies in salary but I can give the ability for them to relocate to where ever they really want to live. I've been really surprised how many conversations I've had with people interested in giving up huge salaries for the freedom to live where they want.
- untog 7y agoThat isn't a new phenomenon though, surely? The idea of leaving SF etc. and working somewhere remote for a better life balance has been a discussion for some time now.
- ateamtexas 7y agohttps://ateam-texas.com/ultimate-guide-to-building-an-mvp-minimum-viable-product/ https://ateam-texas.com/ultimate-guide-to-building-an-mvp-mi...
- ateamtexas 7y agohttps://ateam-texas.com/6-benefits-of-serverless-app-development/ https://ateam-texas.com/6-benefits-of-serverless-app-develop...
- _curious_ 7y agoAs someone in a STR coastal hotspot, I generally agree with the sentiment here that it's too early for the average observer to ascertain a market correction...for vacation/STR areas, it's the rental market change that will precede the housing. (for example, many properties tyically churning $5-$20k/mo during peak season via STR are now renting M2M @75%ish off - and this is good for local communities IMO). Online enablers like Redfin have perch from which to observe the market like no-other, hence the reason they can buy and sell in house with competitive technological advantage. That said, I didn't see any data from the article to suggest what the CEO is purporting "home-buying demand is almost back to pre-pandemic levels." - so going to call BS on that full stop; he has every reason to say this esp. without a "reporter" who will challenge the statement or followup...read between the lines. Also, these players restarting their own in-house buying programs are simply able to tweak their algorithms to low-ball and who can blame them? Does not indicate a healthy/positive market ahead either...just that they are going be hunting for deals via automated offers...again who can blame them? (Just don't interpret that move as meaning much of anything at this time). TLDR; this is a marketing piece - give me evidence to support a claim or GTFO.
- jiveturkey 7y ago> "home-buying demand is almost back to pre-pandemic levels." yeah that's clearly fraudulent marketing. > Online enablers like Redfin have perch from which to observe the market like no-other eh? Not at all. What data do they have that any MLS subscriber doesn't have?
- biztos 7y ago> What data do they have that any MLS subscriber doesn't have? Wouldn’t they have some insight into what people want to buy?
- squnch 7y agoI believe it on home buying that there is a blip... March and April went down so much that the buyers who can’t delay any more are buying now. So three months of 66% reduced demand are combining for a month of normal demand.
- jcomis 7y agoIn my city (Denver) where a lot of the Airbnb usage is event based (sports, conventions, concerts) I've noticed a rash of fully furnished rentals come on the market at just under market rates. These are clearly all former AirBnbs. People are definitely having cashflow issues and I'm guessing many got their units through a ton of leverage and are now in a very bad spot.
- ganstyles 7y agoCompletely anecdotally, we were staying in an Airbnb for a week before shifting to a longer term rental. This was right when things were shutting down. Our Airbnb host told us that all their renters were cancelling for all their properties. They offered for us to stay essentially as long as we wanted for something like 50% of our rate. We unfortunately couldn't take advantage of that because of the aforementioned prior plans, but it was an interesting data point and would have saved a bunch.
- latchkey 7y agoI just looked around Berkeley craigslist yesterday. Tons of places available, month to month, that are mostly fully furnished and at high rents. A lot were nice cottage additions to houses. The rents are not dropping, yet, but it is clear that these were all AirBnB's.
- k3oni 7y agoI'm really not expecting to see a significant drop in home prices at least until close to the end of the year. While some vacation rentals owners might have listed their properties for sale they are doing it pricing those close to the current market value based on other properties for sale in their respective area. We're looking for a vacation home and i'm monitoring the prices in a few areas pretty close, but i don't think we'll do anything until the start of 2021. Remember you need surplus to drive price down. Also keep in mind that the foreclosure process is currently on hold, once this opens again we'll be able to get a closer look at the impact all the closures had/have on the RE market.
- jdhn 7y agoAgreed. There may be short term movements, but like you said, we’ll see the full effect once the courts reopen and things start moving again.
- xoxoy 7y agoI’m seeing 50 homes under $1M in San Francisco listed in last 30 days. That’s much more in that price range than I recall seeing in a very long time
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoIn places like SF you might see more sales because people are afraid to rent these homes. They may never get any rent and it would be very hard to evict a tenant because of local laws and policy.
- k3oni 7y agoAlso to keep in mind that RE markets are regional. SF/NYC for example are out of bounds when it comes to this. Question is what is the actual value for each property, they might be under 1M but it might just be that that's their actual value, just more ppl trying to sell now.
- squnch 7y agoSingle family homes? Or condos?
- code4tee 7y agoMany real estate investments are highly leveraged—-you need people renting your property to pay back the loan you used to buy the property. If a family owns a vacation property outright and they’re going to miss out on some extra income then things are annoying but not terrible. Those that bought in a leveraged scenario (and worse did so on multiple properties) are heading into a really bad situation and thus it’s understandable they’ll want to offload the property ASAP.
- rb808 7y agoI'd think with new lower mortgage rates vacation real estate will rise in value. Sure, some people get squeezed in the short term, but in a year or two this will probably be all over and people will be desperate for their vacation. Plus baby boomers are still retiring and more people are escaping big cities.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoAs someone looking for such a home, I definitely haven’t seen the market soften nearly close to what the doomsayers are predicting. Speaking with some owners, I think many of them are instead turning it into a long term rental for a year or more.
- chrstphrhrt 7y agoHoarding shelter should be outlawed anyway. Or hotel licenses should be required with massive fines for evasion. Get a real job "hosts" (a disturbing doublespeak term for parasite). The original evolution of couch surfing that Airbnb started with was still cool and I like to be able to let my apartment when out of town. It's the rent seeking behaviour that distorts the housing market.
- chrstphrhrt 7y agoNice downvotes, found the sycophant Airbnb managers who just fired everyone :)
- biztos 7y agoI’m not downvoting, but you do realize that subletting while out of town is both rent-seeking and distorting the hotel market, right?
- chrstphrhrt 7y agoIf it's your primary residence that you live in for e.g. 80% of the year and you swap with other primary residences or actually stay in normal hotels when travelling, I can't see any distortion there. Not trying to apologize for hosts or hotels in particular, I just feel like primary residence swapping is pretty harmless. Also, if hotel licenses are required, how is adding more hotels distorting the hotel market other than adding a tiny amount of fair and regulated competition?
- supernovae 7y agoHow are they hoarding? Why call them parasites? More people still rent out houses for long term (as investments) than STR and really, with no data to back up your claims and attacking people for creating something others demand seems... misguided. A lot of STR's are homes that have always been second homes or homes that would never have full occupancy in cities they occupy. They're homes that bring skiers to mountains, friends and family to beach, loved ones to touristy areas. They create lots of revenue, jobs and the impact in their local economies is huge - from property managers to cleaning services to Lowes/Homedepot/Ikea spend to tax revenue (VRBO does collect occupancy tax where required) to working with cities for legal operations. I'd say STR owners are just people who invested and make money through other means of hard work (and risk - such as now). The "disturbing" people are the ones like yourself who can't fathom there are millions of people who work in the STR travel industry either directly or indirectly and you seem to hate them. Most STR owners still hold their day jobs and just want to share their house (and the burden).
- tinyhouse 7y agoVacation rentals still have demand. Many people would rather spend the lockdown in a nice house in nature somewhere than in their urban place. The problem is that at least in the US many states issues a ban on non-essential rentals, so they are illegal currently in many places. Once that's lifted many of these places would be fully booked. The rental places in urban areas that rely on tourists visiting cities are a different story.
- ghaff 7y agoI can easily see a scenario where, say, extended rentals on beach houses on Cape Cod are especially popular this summer given: - A lot of the usual urban concerts etc. will probably be canceled and even casual eating/drinking/walking/shopping will be more awkward. - International travel will be mostly a no-go. - Flying in general will be more awkward - Even a driving vacation won't be as low friction as usual So maybe better to rent a house somewhere nice and hang out with the family.
- apocalyptic0n3 7y agoAnecdotal, but I've been monitoring homes on Zillow for a while now hoping to find my first purchase. There's usually 2-3 dozen news ones within 5 miles of my current location that were listed in the last 14 days. I checked this morning and there are 200+, and that was after filtering out new constructions, apartments, and condos which I normally I don't do. I was a little shocked at how many there were. No change in prices, though. I'm assuming this is a bunch of owners wanting to sell before the market falls and their home is worth less.
- uptown 7y agoPartially, yes. But real estate is also typically very seasonal for many regions. Spring is traditionally the peak selling season, so you'll see an increase in homes hitting the market this time of year.
- thehappypm 7y agoIn my region (Northeast US), nobody even thinks of selling until May, and summer is when the vast majority of homes hit the market.
- supernovae 7y agoIt is moving season...
- subsubzero 7y agoI don't know about vacation towns but given expensive urban cites I expect to see large drops in prices. Given covid-19 and its mindset it no longer makes sense to live in densely crowded expensive metro areas anymore. With large tech companies finally waking up to the fact that remote work actually works expect to see a huge exodus of people from these expensive regions. With all the restaurants and museums closed and really no outside space they don't have much to offer except high taxes and crowds. Also if a engineer can get roughly the same pay but work where they can buy a house instead of have 3 roommates in a 5k a month apt. which would they choose?
- smileysteve 7y agoFrom my experience, UberEats and Instacart are two pandemic essentials that most city dwellers aren't ready for in a rural environment.
- ghaff 7y ago>pandemic essentials Not really. Yes, if someone isn't in a dense urban environment, they're going to need to cook a lot of their meals. But, unless you're in a really rural location, there are supermarkets and at least some restaurants. In a lot of cases you can pickup orders at the door even if you can't get delivery. A lot of people seem to think you're either in Manhattan or in the wilds of Idaho somewhere. There are plenty of places that are in orbit of a major city that aren't actually all that congested.
- smileysteve 7y agoI've spent much of my stay at home where the nearest grocery store that had order ahead was 27 miles away and had a 5 day order ahead time (which was more or less expected). Yes, a handful of restaurants have pickup orders but there are ~4 within a ~5 mile range, and they have the best food without going that 27 miles. It's my perception (in part from the long order ahead times) that grocery and food delivery have gone up in areas that offer them and that modern urbanists that regularly cook at home (or even go to the grocery store only once a week) are a minority.
- TomMckenny 7y ago>...the bifurcation of the American dream. It used to be that working-class folks could reasonably aspire to buy a house. ...So unemployment is going to be bad for one part of America... Housing as institutional investment and institutional land speculation is a condensed example of why stocks can rise during an economic catastrophe, why housing will become yet more unaffordable and what drives increasing inequality between wage earners and asset owners. Redfin's stock has been part of the record breaking rally during the pandemic because the drop in housing prices that would have kept them somewhat in sync with a drop in income will instead be at least partially absorbed by Redfin and other speculators and so make housing even more unaffordable. As we know, the model is to offer a desperate seller a low price then keep the unit empty until a new higher price is met. So a unit stays empty longer than necessary, prices are kept high by a seller that can afford to do so (ie Redfin) and profit is made from widespread economic hardship. In particular the housing crisis is not due to bifurcation between wage earners, it's a simple perpetual shift upward in housing prices that affects everyone who works for a living. Portraying it as bifurcation obfuscates the cause of the problem by creating a conflict between wage earners with different incomes while portraying the speculator's actions a inevitable, natural and harmless. But housing is not expensive because some people earn what they are worth, it is expensive because housing is used as investment.
- joshstrange 7y ago> Redfin's stock has been part of the record breaking rally during the pandemic and is doing well because of widespread economic hardship. Their stock has been rising due to the Fed buying up a ton of assets like these. Their stock price does not reflect "reality".
- prepperpotts 7y agoalthough i'm a home owner as of fairly recently, this feels like a bit of a necessary correction. people owning multiple homes drives up prices for everyone else.
- jedberg 7y agoIt's too early for prices to reflect economic realities yet, especially since foreclosures are on hold and car auctions are on hold too. Car prices and house prices haven't moved yet. House prices usually lag a bit behind because people have to miss a few payments and get over the emotional hurdles of losing their house before they start selling. But it will come, unless we see a V shaped recovery, which is still possible with the money the Fed is printing.
- rednerrus 7y agodeeperpockets about to be shallowerpockets...
- jojo2000 7y ago> Despite the coronavirus outbreak causing a downturn in home sales and listing activity through March and April, Redfin managed to beat expectations with its first quarter earnings as the company posted a net loss of $60 million. A year ago, Redfin had reported a larger net loss of $67 million, for comparison. That's a weird way of "beating expectations"
- purplezooey 7y agoThe article appears to have been pulled. In any case it seems unlikely that vacation rentals are "toast". The drivers of their expansion, mainly our lack of ability to build anything in sufficient quantities nearly everywhere, aren't going away.