5 ms·
Much of the lockdown effect was not imposed by top-down fiat
- qubex 7y agoThis is an excellent analysis. For me the key quote is “One of the trends that’s jumped out is that lockdown orders have tended to ratify public behaviour as much as prescribe or circumscribe it”. The author argues quite convincingly (with transportation data) that the decision to lockdown is, as he writes, ‘crowdsourced’ and coming from a groundswell of micro-decisions made on the individual level, and that consequentially the debate on lifting lockdown orders is rather moot: people will likely continue to be very prudent after the orders are lifted just as they were very prudent before they were officially promulgated.
- IIAOPSW 7y ago>people will likely continue to be very prudent after the orders are lifted just as they were very prudent before they were officially promulgated. The debate is not moot because an imprudent minority can ruin it for the rest of us. Based on the models I've seen, the % of people disobeying the lockdown (even an informal lockdown) has a highly non-linear affect on the effectiveness.
- djsumdog 7y agoBut what is the end game? This is in the environment and it can't possibly be eradicated at this point; except maybe in New Zealand. In Sweden and the UK, it's most likely just going to go through the population until they're a reasonable immunity. That will set other countries who have eradicated the virus in an interesting state, with little natural immunity, they may not be able to open their borders again for a very long time. People are already spreading this through basic supply and grocery store runs. People are getting it from family they live with. It's going to spread no matter what, through the people who still hang out once or twice a week with their best friends. I think it's silly to plague shame people at this point. We are looking at each other in constant fear for something no one can control; based off information from experiments only a subset of the population can replicate, reported to us by media and governments who have repeatedly lied to us. There is no way we will realistically see a vaccine in 18 months. That's big pharma insanity. Should we simply stay locked down forever? or until one of these drugs/compounds works? Humans are not cogs in a machine you can simply stop, or a device you can put in standby or low power state. We're human beings.
- loopz 7y agoWe stopped uncontrolled contagion. Next steps are mitigation in order to keep contagion low enough. We don't know how immunity works for this novel virus, so research, massive testing and improved tracing. Borders can open up when countries cooperate. Prove better medicine to reduce ICU time. Work while embracing the remaining uncertainties.
- collyw 7y agoNo one ever offers a long term plan. I have posted some comments similar to your on facebook. People will nitpick details but no one says how long we should remain in lockdown. We were told we needed lockdown to flatten the curve. We have managed that (I am in Spain). Now it's all about new normal and completely screwing the economy with little evidence about the effectiveness of the measures.
- Gibbon1 7y ago> This is in the environment and it can't possibly be eradicated at this point This pure defeatism.
- TylerE 7y agoThe problem with this is that much of the relief for both businesses and employees is tied to the order. If they could be open, they no longer qualify for aid if they choose not to be.
- votepaunchy 7y agoThe Unemployment Insurance bonus runs through July. Many businesses are looking to this to preserve wages while reducing payroll. And I have not heard of this program being capped and running out of funding as has happened with PPP. “California workers who see their hours cut as little as 10% due to the coronavirus outbreak are eligible to receive the entire $600-a-week federal subsidy offered in the $2-trillion federal rescue package, state officials and employment experts say.” https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2020-04-27/coronavirus-relief-law-workers-reduced-hours https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2020-04-27/coronaviru...
- orwin 7y agoThe conclusion might be right (and the analysis may be excellent), but the arguments seems to be based on carefully chosen data and ignoring other graphs. I'm a bit distrustful i have to admit, especially when an article is music to my ear and confirm my beliefs with public data.
- aiscapehumanity 7y agoThat's false if the amount of traffic I saw the other day in my reopening in my local area of my state is anything to go by. As prude as people got was a seemingly 1/3ish with some type of mask, social distancing was dropped.
- sifar 7y agoThey are crowdsourced if only in the sense because that is how the crowd has been trained to think. The peoples reaction to isolate, stay indoors was not spontaneous and though prudent, certainly not individual. There was a lot of group think involved. If there is one thing that this pandemic has taught me, it is this - the extent of the thought/behavior control machinery spans the globe, and is effective. Edit: This is an example of abuse of data and hence arriving at an incorrect position which can then drive policies. The author plots the transportation data and the graph decline clearly shows people choosing to not travel. What it doesn't show is the propaganda broadcast preceding those times which "informed" the people and consequently altered their behavior. If you do, you'll see a sharp increase just before the transportation decline.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThere are things I would like to see come out of this. I have a compromised immune system and I saw a lot of benefits for me. My life mostly carried on as usual. A few things I typically attend were cancelled, but I already work from home and don't get out much. I hope the pandemic leads to certain hygiene things being take more seriously and improved, like public bathrooms. I hope it continues to be easier for me to avoid certain things post pandemic without it raising an eyebrow. But if people were better about not doing awful things like blowing their nose in crowded public spaces, I don't think we really need a lock down, honestly. I have a serious medical condition and I habitually avoid large crowds and certain other things, but most people don't really know how much my life choices are driven by my medical situation. I look sort of "normal" in some sense. I sure as hell don't run around wearing a mask and gloves when I go out.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoThe only practical remedy for this in the US is free antibody testing for asymptomatics and free infection testing for those with symptoms. Ideology will prevent this from happening even though the same actors never bat an eyelash over blowing trillions on pointless wars.
- nostromo 7y ago> Ideology will prevent this from happening Congress already passed a bipartisan bill to provide free testing.
- foogazi 7y agoProof that they can’t fix logistical problems with the stroke of a pen The same US government appears to have given up on testing now
- votepaunchy 7y agoThe US continues to scale up testing (and are doing more than any other country). The problem is that we don’t manufacture most goods domestically so have limited supply of swabs and such. https://covidtracking.com/data/us-daily https://covidtracking.com/data/us-daily
- ryan_lane 7y agoA hate site is making it to the front page now?
- arpa 7y agoI could not infer it from the article. Why is this a hate site?
- shijie 7y agoI would imagine Quillette, being a conservative-leaning publication, routinely disagrees with this person’s socio-political beliefs, so ad hominem must necessarily be used.
- ryan_lane 7y agoIt's not just conservative leaning. It's an alt-right publication.
- djsumdog 7y agoIt is hardly an alt-right publication. I got started on Quillette from the podcast Wrongspeak. They don't do regular episodes anymore, but they tackled a lot of really hard questions. I don't agree with everything on Quillette, but their arguments are at least well thought out. There's a lot I don't agree with in this one (the author justifying Ferguson's non-deterministic models as even remotely acceptable is absolutely not-even-wrong from a data sciences perspective; not to mention we don't have the original code; not to mention the code had race conditions). I'd suggest reading a few of their articles first. I don't see how you can see them as alt-right. They're a bit right of center, but they're pretty much centrists.
- ryan_lane 7y agoThe point of alt-right is to act as a bridge between extremist views and modern conservative views. Most alt-right sites have a mix of reasonable articles, conspiracy theories, and somewhat extreme articles. The comment sections of these sites often lead to more extreme information, with the sites actively allowing it, and often encouraging it. The YouTube recommendation loop is a good example of how this works. Sending traffic to any alt-right site helps recruit people to extremism.
- geofft 7y agoThat's a very interesting graph, but I think it's not a complete story. Here's another graph: https://www.endcoronavirus.org/countries https://www.endcoronavirus.org/countries In particular, compare Sweden and the US with other countries (Norway, perhaps, or South Korea). Given the lack of correlation between government lockdown policy and public transit ridership, there's a couple of conclusions you could draw. One, as the author does, is that government lockdown policy doesn't effect behavior. Another, based on the second graph, is that none of the four cities the author shows had a meaningful government-mandated lockdown - that yes, as the author says, people didn't change behavior on their own, but that we can't conclude that government has no leverage here because none of those cities tried very hard. (As an NYC resident I can tell you that the government is sitting quite firmly in the unfortunate valley between leaving people alone and actually having an effect: there's a lot of people out of work and enough stories of nonsensical policing like throwing people in a crowded jail for not social distancing, but there are a lot of people, including our mayor himself, who are out and about in public that it isn't obviously helping with R₀.) Another possible one is that public transit ridership is a limited subset of behavior and changes for its own reasons (it's hard to maintain social distance and avoid touching metallic surfaces on a subway train) that don't necessarily track whether people are staying home or whether they're going around by means other than public transit. While I do agree with the author that the model of the government having a magic lever is simplistic, I also don't think it follows that the government has no leverage. There are a number of policies well within the powers of government, from unemployment eligibility to literally giving out food, that I'd think have a much more effective influence on whether people stay home than whether they're told to stay home. (I suspect the author will agree with me that it's better to use government levers other than "we'll send armed men after you if you don't," if you have any.) The lockdown protests from people who want to return to work (to be distinguished from the protests from people who want others to return to working for them) are from people who need to work to survive and don't have remote work options - there are other things the government could do to meet the underlying demands besides saying, okay, you can go to work. In general, it's not that they want to leave their house, it's that they have to. And while I do agree with the author that it's the people and not the government who make or break the lockdown (see also Hong Kong, where the citizenry realized that their government wasn't taking the problem seriously, for a particularly good example), I don't really think that ends the debate at all. I think the author is pretty wrong about whether it's safe to send kids back to school, for instance!
- himinlomax 7y agoIn my case, the government mandate was necessary because my employer was dragging its feet to generalize work from home, even though everything was in place to allow it and we're the kind of business (online) that's pretty much ideal for it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mistermann 7y agoCan you explain how these are "alt right" opinions? I wonder if it's that style of thinking behind the [flagged] status as well. If an idea is wrong, please challenge it with superior ideas, if you have any, not slurs and memory holing. What is happening to people's minds?
- sifar 7y ago"I am told by reliable sources within my own family that some of these parents are even pressuring their neighbours to do likewise, and are shaming dissenters on social media as bad parents. It’s lockdown by mob. To some extent, I find this attitude of populist hyper-vigilance to be exasperating, because sending your young kids to school is now generally safe (and, selfishly, because I think my own seven-year-old could benefit from getting back to a structured education environment). But we got into this mess by letting our guard down, and so it’s not surprising that many ordinary people want to err on the other side of the equation for a month or three. Whatever your views, though, if you’re all in a fuss about lockdown policy, please remember that the real lockdown was never imposed by government. It turns out that it was inside each and every one of us all along." This is a real slight of hand thinking. People were primed for lockdown, even shamed, and then the claim that it was never imposed by the government.