3 ms·
Something that really sunk in for me while arguing with people on HN is that the entire Nuclear power industry is ~60 years old and provides around ~10% of huma
by roenxi 7y ago
Something that really sunk in for me while arguing with people on HN is that the entire Nuclear power industry is ~60 years old and provides around ~10% of humanity's electricity [0]. Even after the effective moratorium from 1985.
It seems very unlikely that we've really run up against the limits of what physics can do for us. That is an enormous change and it isn't even a lifetime ago. One more development like that would trivially justify investment values in the trillions of dollars range. Let alone all the other stuff that is likely to happen along the way.
Theoretical limits are all very well, but I strongly suspect the rational amount to spend on it is "everything we can". If I really wanted to start a fight I'll argue that diverting all welfare spending to scientific research would probably result in a greater net good over two generations.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Nuclear_power_history.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Nuclear_power_history.svg.
- why_this12 7y ago"If I really wanted to start I [sic] fight I'll argue that diverting all welfare spending to scientific research would probably result in a greater net good over two generations." Bizarre comment is in the plus, critical comments are downvoted. Never criticize CERN or Microsoft on HN.
- roenxi 7y agoThanks, I fixed that typo.
- buzzkillington 7y agoYou are talking about engineering there, not science. Science is using duct tape to explore the properties of graphene. Engineering is building a plant that can produce 500km2 of graphene a day.
- tsimionescu 7y ago> If I really wanted to start a fight I'll argue that diverting all welfare spending to scientific research would probably result in a greater net good over two generations. Why welfare spending? Why not corporate subsidies? Or just forcefully seize the entire assets of some number of non-scientists, chosen at random? Cutting out welfare as a whole seems to be the single spending cut most likely to kill the largest number of people.
- marcosdumay 7y ago> Cutting out welfare as a whole seems to be the single spending cut most likely to kill the largest number of people. Yes. I think the GP's point was that even on the worst case it would still pay off. Personally, I doubt it. Increasing social risks would move things the other way around and decrease the speed of science advances, even with high investment.
- bergstromm466 7y agoYes, this is the grandiose technocratic elite who believe they can save the world. A bit exaggerated, but I find these kinds of comments scary, misguided and naive, as well as very revealing of the underlying ideologies and oversimplified & mechanistic views of society.
- kd5bjo 7y ago> I strongly suspect the rational amount to spend on it is "everything we can". By saying “everything,” you’re dodging the question of what sacrifices we should make to speed up basic science research. How do you draw the line between what we can and can’t afford? Should we require everyone to pursue a Master’s degree? A PhD? Do we shut down university humanities departments? Do we halt all production that doesn’t directly support the basic sciences? Do we reduce food production to only that which is needed to support the scientific staff? Some or all of these suggestions are probably beyond your idea of what’s acceptable. If so, you agree that there is some price that is too great to pay. The interesting question isn’t whether there’s a limit, it’s what it is.