5 ms·
I think it's dangerous and toxic in general for billionaires to threaten economic retribution when the government doesn't enact their preferred policies. I cont
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
I think it's dangerous and toxic in general for billionaires to threaten economic retribution when the government doesn't enact their preferred policies. I continue to think that here, even though I generally like this particular billionaire and agree with the policy position he's fighting for.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoYou do what must be done. If the government provided more support to businesses due to COVID shutdown, this wouldn’t have been necessary. This is a Federal government failure manifestation. Elon is trying to save his business he’s worked two decades on. I can’t fault him. Airlines and Ford (pinnacles of responsible business operations /s) getting bailed out by the Fed through junk bond liquidity operations? Why not Tesla too?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoIt's even worse for billionaires to threaten economic retribution because the government didn't give them enough money.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI agree with Elon (from his latest interview with Joe Rogan) that billionaires get a lot of shit (which is why he’s going minimalist nomad supposedly, to deflect criticism by eliminating anything ostentatious in his life). Almost all of them deserve it, but Musk, Gates, and Buffett don’t (all for various yet obvious reasons). They are in a different class. Arguably, we still want those billionaires to succeed, but we also want taxes paid and workers protected across the board. I don’t think that’s unreasonable, but complex problems and their solutions are hard to discuss at scale because of entrenched interests, sound bites, the twenty four hour news cycle, and people acting in bad faith.
- andrepd 7y ago> we still want those billionaires to succeed, but we also want taxes paid and workers protected across the board We want taxes paid and workers protected, so we want tax-evading and union-busting billionaires to succeed.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jdross 7y agoNo, we want better lives for ourselves and the people around us and coming after us. Taxes and worker welfare are two tools we can deploy towards that goal. A company is a voluntary organizational tool, and when run as well as Tesla is, an extremely effective one at accomplishing a goal.
- threatofrain 7y agoThat's the federal government? Or is it all "The Government".
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThe United States Federal government by way of the CARES stimulus act, funded using Federal Reserve lending operations. States don’t control the currency, nor have the budgets to backstop large cap firms in economic distress.
- Foober223 7y agoIs it dangerous and toxic when the state government threatens/acts to confiscate more of your earnings?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoIt's the county government he's mad at here, but yes, that's also bad. Alameda County should let him run the factory unless they have some reason to believe they're in more danger than the rest of the state.
- alpha_squared 7y ago> Is it dangerous and toxic when the state government threatens/acts to confiscate more of your earnings? If you're talking about taxes, that's an awfully entitled phrasing.
- stale2002 7y agoAnd it is equally "entitled" to think that the government owns those businesses, and something is being taken away from the government, when those businesses decide to voluntarily move somewhere else.
- fzeroracer 7y agoFor one, this isn't the state government. This is a local government choosing to enact things of its own volition. If you believe in small government, then obviously this is the ideal scenario for delegation of authority is it not? And second, the people voted in said local government. So isn't it going against the spirit of America (and Democracy in general) to threaten elected officials for doing what the people elected them to do?
- Foober223 7y agoThe "threat" is to not play in their sandbox after they change the rules. People can of course vote to take more of your earnings. But it's fair to leave when the rules change, it's a broken contract.
- mft_ 7y agoLook, he's clearly having a hissy fit, which isn't the best look for any CEO. But you saying "billionaire" here is pejorative and unnecessary. How about "...for CEOs to threaten moving their economic operations to places where governments are more hospitable". Still dangerous and toxic?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoThe problem I see here really is that he has a lot of money. If billionaires get their way by threatening dire consequences, it creates the perception that rules and regulations are for sale to sufficiently high bidders, or even worse that billionaires can create company towns which must pass whatever regulations they want. If the CEO of some 100 person company tweets out "screw you guys I'm moving to Texas", I think that's fine. Even if the state makes changes in response, nobody's going to think that his money alone was the deciding factor.
- mft_ 7y agoThe reason his threat is credible is because he runs a large business which brings jobs and prosperity to the states that it operates in. In this case, him being rich is irrelevant, as he’s not threatening to use his personal wealth.