11 ms·
> New surge of bad programmers is a more apt title, or "We gave game clients absolute control and you wont believe what happened next!!1". Pretty much all the g
by dijit 7y ago
> New surge of bad programmers is a more apt title, or "We gave game clients absolute control and you wont believe what happened next!!1". Pretty much all the games listed have ZERO server side validation.
I feel like I should share an inside opinion, but you will not like it. So please take it as an opinion and don't crucify me.
The Industry itself is mired in complexity, year on year we have to build bigger games, better and more complex games and we have diminishing amounts of budget (both in time and money) to do so. Failing to make something truly great will cause the next iteration to have even less budget and then you're dead.
When it comes to gameservers, which is actually something I understand very well[0] there are additional budgetary constraints. The cost of a player, playing the game is an eternal one. If you keep playing we only get the upfront game sale from you, so there's an incentive to keep the costs as low as possible.
NDA prohibits me from saying an exact number, but lets assume (and it's mostly true) that if you play a game for 3 months then we've lost money on you from server time alone, and we well optimise our servers. The more you put in for verification and detection, the more cost there is.
This is why when we originally talked about releasing the game we were intending to forego a PC release entirely, as consoles are barely affected by this, and when they are it's quite easy to detect comparatively.
[0]: you can see me talking about it here: https://youtu.be/d29tHMRJIU8?t=2060 https://youtu.be/d29tHMRJIU8?t=2060
- jstummbillig 7y ago> year on year we have to build bigger games, better and more complex games and we have diminishing amounts of budget (both in time and money) to do so Why is that? Online Gaming as a market is growing, how are budgets shrinking?
- dijit 7y agoThe cost of making games outpaces the revenues generated by games, especially if you're not EA, Rockstar or Activision. That is why there are monetisation options and special editions and, disgustingly: loot boxes. Notably EA (which, gamers hate) is known inside the gaming industry as being quite competent and not as constrained on the time or financial budget, so they can throw more resources at things. But the ongoing cost of a server instance is still eternal and will eat your profits away in the future, so they focus on being p2p. Rockstar has budget too, but they also don't have online games in their DNA yet, their development teams seem to still think of single player games. (based on a few conversations with their devs).
- pjc50 7y agoThere are a lot more of them, so each individual game has a smaller slice of the pie. Unless it becomes a massive hit like Fortnite. It's going to be like startups where most lose money.
- uxcolumbo 7y agoWhy do you have to host the games and carry the cost? Wouldn't it be cheaper for you to provide some great server software, but people would have to host it themselves, like it was done years and years ago with games like Day of Defeat, Half life etc. Or maybe I'm missing something - it's been a while since I played those type of games.
- superkuh 7y ago>Or maybe I'm missing something - it's been a while since I played those type of games. The primary reason companies do not follow the tried and true method of game design is that they can't extract money in the form of microtransactions or server rent if they provide the full game (including server).
- uxcolumbo 7y agoBut if you have a cheat fest server, players will leave and not buy any hats and other accessories. Also, as part of the server software it could include the marketplace, which would sit on the game developers servers, so all transactions would go via the game developer and maybe they could give some commission to the person hosting the game.
- berti 7y ago> players will leave and not buy any hats and other accessories. They might go buy another game though... A healthy community built around a self-hosted server tends to hold people for long periods of time.
- dijit 7y agoI guess that very much depends on the game, but the game I make would be very uninteresting if you hosted your own server, it doesn't lend itself to that 'pick up and go' style of play like counterstrike does. It's more like Destiny, World of Warcraft or Diablo in that there are RPG elements, a grind for loot and the possibility to meet other players.
- NullPrefix 7y ago>if you play a game for 3 months then we've lost money on you How inconsiderate from the gamers, maybe they should just buy the games and not play them.
- dijit 7y agoThat's not what I'm saying or implying, obviously this is something the company takes into account when producing the game. I'm lucky to work for a company (that, yes, is still a company so wants to make profit): is more interested in continuing to make games than seeking great profits. So for us, making a game that doesn't make money back isn't a bad thing, unless we make a game that doesn't make it's costs back and then we're risking the ability to continue making games. (cough Ghost Recon Breakpoint cough) The truth of it is, most people don't play 3 months straight with no breaks, most people will play for a month, complete a campaign and then the player numbers will dwindle rapidly to the 20%~ mark. But we put in monetisation strategies (skins, so forth) to carry the continued cost of the server instances forward. Hardcore players might buy some and that is enough to make them cost neutral or cost positive.
- zwaps 7y agoBack in the day one could host one's own games and servers. What happened with that?
- dijit 7y agoI answered that here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23124383 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23124383
- SiempreViernes 7y agoWrong link? The comment you linked doesn't really address the disappearance of self hosting servers. My guess is it was a combination of cost-savings related to the extra polish needed for making a distributable server, but mainly as an anti-piracy measure.
- vvG94KbDUtRa 7y agoI have to doubt this is a primary factor. If it were then developers would make more single players games, but everyone wants to make online games with microtransactions
- dijit 7y agoI'm trying to find a nice way of responding to this because it's rather loaded. > I have to doubt this is a primary factor Time and money are indeed a factor, micro transactions typically are used to continue "live services" of a game, and don't get counted towards recouping development costs. (at least in Ubisoft). > if it were then developers would make more single player games We can, and do, but sometimes to create the game you want other players involved. Imagine a NPC only For Honour or Rainbow Six: Siege.. that would be very boring. > but everyone wants to make online games Because there can be more interesting games than just "go here, kill boss, go here, loot thing", you can have genuinely unique experiences on every play through with online and networked games. > with microtransactions To cover the cost of the servers and staff required to update/fix the game, usually. This is a complex one because people are so polarised by micro transactions. I (and incidentally, my studio) are convinced that they _MUST_ be optional, they can offer no advantage in game. We used to have the policy that you must be able to earn that cosmetic with a realistic amount of in-game time (which is contradictory for us because more in-game time = less money, and obviously we "lost" the revenue of a player not buying it, but that goes without saying). Given that we release buggy mess games, you might argue that we would need less micro transactions if we just did a good job in the first place, but obviously we try our best to make decent games. I think it's dangerously arrogant to assume that 60 developers working on engine and game server code are all less intelligent than you are- and there definitely isn't malice, most game developers are gamers themselves otherwise the complexity, stress and time spent would definitely not be worth it. So I'm not sure why people are so outwardly hostile to game developers, the alternative is that we spend longer and charge more for games, but people don't like that either, so at some point the market has to make up it's mind about whether it can accept rushed products that have improvements year on year, no or marginal improvements year on year (ala Fifa, Call of Duty) or pay more. There is no magic here, unless we bring back slavery.
- tsco77 7y agoThis may have been true in the past, but the Tf2 hat model (dunno if tf2 was first to the cosmetic market, but it was my first memorable experience with it) proves that you can continue to extract value from customers after initial purchase. How much does it cost to run a server compared to a $3.00 hat? (which if you're valve you develop a secondary market to trade those items and take a cut after creating demand by restricting the number of earbuds available).
- chupasaurus 7y agoValve didn't run game servers at the time.
- tsco77 7y agoEven better for them.
- na85 7y agoIsn't that solved by letting players run their own dedicated servers, like in the hood old days? Seems like the games industry has created or at least exacerbated this problem by making everything free to play (easy to make a new account if you get banned) and by removing dedicated servers (cost problem as you mentioned)
- meheleventyone 7y agoNot really because part of the push to running servers for the game is to provide consistency in game experience, lowering the barrier of entry to less technical players (thus widening the playerbase) and to support features that would be much harder or impossible to implement if you let anyone run a server. There are trade offs in that decision for sure but there are also trade offs in going the other way.
- cwhiz 7y agoGame companies invented this “problem” so they could extract more money from gamers. Go back 10-12 years ago and most PC games had server software and the community hosted most of the matches. The community handled the cheaters. Game companies took this away so that they could sell season passes, hats, shirts, and other cosmetic garbage. This is a problem your industry created. So please spare us all the woe is me charade.
- mjburgess 7y agoPossibly. Or perhaps that delivering on AAA games now requires blockbuster-level financing whilst not having blockbuster-sized audiences. The cost of making games has ballooned, which provides a context for the monetizing behaviour of publishers.
- dijit 7y agoI did warn you that you wouldn't like it. But go back 10-12 years; lets see what's available; 2008: Battlefield: bad company. - no self-host option GTA IV. - no self host option Fallout 3 - no self host option. Left for Dead 2 - downloadable server option, no official servers -- I think your interpretation is very uncharitable. The cost of making games has increased in a near exponential rate, regardless of if there's servers or not. On a more personal note: I don't understand why everyone wants to eat the fancy cake but hate the baker for telling you what it took to make it.
- iforgotpassword 7y agoI agree it never made much sense for games like wow, but I preferred games where you could host yourself and tweak a thousand knobs and add mods and whatnot and integrate it into a website thanks to rcon. I'm not really gaming anymore for more than a decade but I'd be surprised if there aren't still games around that ship with server software. Just not the triple As anymore.
- hoorayimhelping 7y ago>On a more personal note: I don't understand why everyone wants to eat the fancy cake but hate the baker for telling you what it took to make it. Because nobody asked for the fucking fancy cake! Why do people in the industry not get this simple fact? We were all very happy with the cookies we had before. Which is why we kept coming back to the bakery and telling all our friends how awesome the bakery is. Then the baker says, "hey, those cookies suck, what you really want is the fancy cake! No more cookies, only cake" and despite the customers screaming at the baker, pleading with him to bring back the cookies, he just won't and is surprised that customers are frustrated that they can't get what they want. We eat the fancy cake now because it's the only thing available. But we want the cookies we had before.
- lucb1e 7y agoNote that one needs a Google account to watch the video. You probably don't notice if you're logged in all the time so I figured I'd mention this barrier exists.
- dijit 7y agoAh, I'm sorry, it's due to the fact that there is gameplay on the video and the game is rated 18. :(
- nwallin 7y agoYour post does nothing to explain why server side cheat detection is in such a poor state. "Don't trust user input" is a fundamental maxim in this industry. When you log into your bank's website, does it do action validation on the client side or the server side? Every few weeks there's some security bug that boils down to the server trusting the client when they shouldn't. And hackernews comments correctly boil that down to the devs were lazy and/or incompetent. Games are no different. Sure, your industry has its own quirks and limitations. But trusting unverifiable user input... That's in the ten commandments, man.
- dijit 7y agoIf I wasn't clear I apologise. Let me try to explain what I mean as simply as I can so that I can be sure I'm communicating what I want to say: Games are complex and ever more complex and costly each year. Verifying user input is expensive on the CPU of the remote side. Servers are expensive, people have indicated they want to run one: one of our servers costs more than my monthly salary every month. Double if it's in the cloud. So verification of the server side is not done for all things, some ray casting here and there for bullets, some bounds checks, but nothing like a defined absolute "you can _only_ do X,Y,Z" because that would be very very very expensive on CPU, because there's millions and billions of things you can do based on your current situation. And we have to trust that the actions you're sending that change your situation are true. So we start tracking movements every frame, updating your state on the server and then suddenly there's incoming damage. We can see that you got hit, but on your screen you were in cover? who decides? So now we have this exponential increase in "where people are" on the server, what is possible for them to do. Instead of just doing the raycasting on the bullet trajectory. (which is expensive, but not like "take 30s" expensive. Synchronising state amongst all clients 240 times per second is very difficult, in fact, I assume you know computer science so you tell me how easy distributed systems are without trust of anything. It's pretty difficult to have quorum here. Now do it for as many players as possible (say, 1.000), and you have 2 engineers for a year. Btw at the same time you need to make deployable health skills in-game, oh and support level design and also write AI for the NPCs (Civilian and 5 factions of combat). Making games is complex, obscenely so, and everything that's done is a hack on a hack on a hack. Frankly I'm surprised they work. To give context: we are roughly 10% of the engineering force that makes the browser dialog pop-ups on google.com. But we have code that is at least three orders of magnitude more complex and we had 2 years to make it.
- imtringued 7y agoMinecraft started out as a single player game and then notch bolted in some basic block syncing and player position syncing. Everything else ran on the client, including the mobs. You could set the difficulty to peaceful to get rid of mobs in multiplayer. Step by step they converted everything to run on the server before the beta phase ended. What you are talking about is just pure laziness and incompetence.
- dijit 7y agoI'm very glad that Minecraft was successful. I can't speak to my competence, maybe I am grossly incompetent and those I work with are too. I can say that I was well regarded in my profession before joining the gaming industry and I feel like the work I'm doing is significantly more complex than I was doing before, but that might be because I am lazy and incompetent. That said, I'm pretty sure you know that Minecraft and AAA games are largely dissimilar.
- imtringued 7y agoIt's an example of making the worst decisions possible for a multiplayer game (i.e. by not implementing any multiplayer at all) and fixing them anyway. I'm not sure what you mean by "more complex" because there aren't many games that even reach a tiny bit of the depth of modern minecraft with a modpack like Skyfactory 3. Do your games involve building nuclear reactors out of 60k individual blocks that each have a tile entity (game object) allocated for it? Did I mention that this is just one power generator and doesn't even involve intricate item transport networks carrying hundreds of thousands of item stacks (each of that is a game object) to your manufacturing machines (another game object with completely arbitrary rules)? The machine wasn't cheap. It cost millions of iron ingots and those had to be processed from ore and that had to be mined automatically and the machines that mine the ore were tile entities too. These aren't things that could even possibly run on a game client. Just think about the nightmare of synchronizing such a huge amount of data from the client to the server. You'd need 100mbit upload or more.
- lxdesk 7y agoWhile I know the technical reasons(I've been in the industry and worked on exactly these kinds of games), I also have a certain other thought on it after getting time and distance from the trenches, which is that, on some basic first-principles level, the industry is trying too hard to market appealing falsehoods. And online multiplayer constitutes one of the biggest falsehoods of all, since it has to pull some magic to synchronize an apparently similar, real-time experience across many computers, which leaves integral parts of the experience compromised. What's tested in competition, ordinarily, is your belief in your skills and likewise those of your opponent. When we play these games(and I still do play some of them), what's tested is more like a mixture of what you believe, what your opponents want to believe, and what the game code says you should believe. The less authority you impose to regulate this belief - at any level, not just in the specific code for in-game results, but in terms of overall moderation, matchmaking, and QoS - the more flimsy the result is. What results from poor regulation is that player communities will behave dishonestly. Players left to their own devices are excellent at innovating new ways of gatekeeping, not just with cheating but with mutual agreements on playstyle and how to rank talent. The industry isn't too concerned about this because, in the end, they have to make a product. I don't think it's the way to make sustainable products, though.