12 ms·
New surge of bad programmers is a more apt title, or "We gave game clients absolute control and you wont believe what happened next!!1". Pretty much all the gam
by rasz 7y ago
New surge of bad programmers is a more apt title, or "We gave game clients absolute control and you wont believe what happened next!!1". Pretty much all the games listed have ZERO server side validation. As I commented under previous Valorant anti cheat backdoor story:
'what is actually crazy are modern game servers lacking even the most basic server side assertion logic(1) letting players FLY around the map, teleport, summon items, kill other players on the server at the press of a button, etc. Seen in all massive FPS games, for example Apex Legends, PUBG, Escape from Tarkov.'
- alpaca128 7y agoAnd Crysis 2. I wanted to get into the multiplayer of that game but it was hopeless. Every single server was filled with either cheaters or players that were so damn good they could almost match the cheaters.
- dijit 7y ago> New surge of bad programmers is a more apt title, or "We gave game clients absolute control and you wont believe what happened next!!1". Pretty much all the games listed have ZERO server side validation. I feel like I should share an inside opinion, but you will not like it. So please take it as an opinion and don't crucify me. The Industry itself is mired in complexity, year on year we have to build bigger games, better and more complex games and we have diminishing amounts of budget (both in time and money) to do so. Failing to make something truly great will cause the next iteration to have even less budget and then you're dead. When it comes to gameservers, which is actually something I understand very well[0] there are additional budgetary constraints. The cost of a player, playing the game is an eternal one. If you keep playing we only get the upfront game sale from you, so there's an incentive to keep the costs as low as possible. NDA prohibits me from saying an exact number, but lets assume (and it's mostly true) that if you play a game for 3 months then we've lost money on you from server time alone, and we well optimise our servers. The more you put in for verification and detection, the more cost there is. This is why when we originally talked about releasing the game we were intending to forego a PC release entirely, as consoles are barely affected by this, and when they are it's quite easy to detect comparatively. [0]: you can see me talking about it here: https://youtu.be/d29tHMRJIU8?t=2060 https://youtu.be/d29tHMRJIU8?t=2060
- jstummbillig 7y ago> year on year we have to build bigger games, better and more complex games and we have diminishing amounts of budget (both in time and money) to do so Why is that? Online Gaming as a market is growing, how are budgets shrinking?
- dijit 7y agoThe cost of making games outpaces the revenues generated by games, especially if you're not EA, Rockstar or Activision. That is why there are monetisation options and special editions and, disgustingly: loot boxes. Notably EA (which, gamers hate) is known inside the gaming industry as being quite competent and not as constrained on the time or financial budget, so they can throw more resources at things. But the ongoing cost of a server instance is still eternal and will eat your profits away in the future, so they focus on being p2p. Rockstar has budget too, but they also don't have online games in their DNA yet, their development teams seem to still think of single player games. (based on a few conversations with their devs).
- pjc50 7y agoThere are a lot more of them, so each individual game has a smaller slice of the pie. Unless it becomes a massive hit like Fortnite. It's going to be like startups where most lose money.
- uxcolumbo 7y agoWhy do you have to host the games and carry the cost? Wouldn't it be cheaper for you to provide some great server software, but people would have to host it themselves, like it was done years and years ago with games like Day of Defeat, Half life etc. Or maybe I'm missing something - it's been a while since I played those type of games.
- superkuh 7y ago>Or maybe I'm missing something - it's been a while since I played those type of games. The primary reason companies do not follow the tried and true method of game design is that they can't extract money in the form of microtransactions or server rent if they provide the full game (including server).
- eska 7y agoI understood why code was run server side around the year 2000, but even then cheating destroyed certain genres of games. Still game designers would not adjust their game design to make cheating less disruptive for other players. The "P2P" games mentioned in the article are also not really P2P. Instead, one player gets to host the game, and a lot of logic runs on each client, as if it were an offline game session with trusted peers.. In a real P2P architecture players would cross validate each other. And it's hilarous how game developers have shared conferences, but still haven't created an anti cheating association to share technology and banned player information for heuristics. Glad to see that Valve is offering its service to others at least.
- pjmlp 7y agoAnd naturally, "memory corruption is not an issue in games!". Well, it is when you plug them into the network.
- jrockway 7y agoI can forgive some of these things because they are basically implementing a distributed system where events have to be finalized in 1/240th of a second and where communication latency changes the outcome of the game. Some hacks are necessary, and players have to deal with the consequences. I never enjoy dying to a weapon that was never even fired, but that is the reality of Internet latency. The travel time of the projectile in the game is less than the travel time of the packet that says "the weapon was fired". So the game client gets that and before it can draw anything, gets another message that says "btw you died". Then you're dead to a weapon that was never even fired from your view. That sort of thing would never work for storing data to a database, but it works out okay in a fast-paced game. (I know this is not what you're talking about, but what you're talking about stems from needing to reduce latency, and this is meant to be a story about how that can be annoying even when people aren't synthesizing "hey I'm cheating!" packets.) Having said that, I feel like the game industry decides that because some hacks are necessary, they're all necessary. Hearthstone is a card game and relies on the client for critical checks, and people hack the client to successfully cheat. It happened recently with a certain card that copies itself and costs 0. Obviously a strong combination. There is a limit to the number of cards you can play per turn, however, and so you couldn't really go infinite with this. The card takes a certain amount of time to play, and your turn is a fixed amount of time, and that bounds the blast radius of a combo like this. What people did, though, was just hack the client to skip animations. The server happily accepted this. That sort of hack is a real problem; the server should know how many cards you are allowed to play and just say "nope, not possible". The fact that that's missing is just a hack; why write the code if it's not needed? One day it is needed, though, and people get mad and stop playing your game. It is a tough balance, and as someone who favors correctness and least surprise... I'm glad I don't work in the game industry. I would die. But people seem to be making money selling games, so perhaps my opinion is simply wrong.
- stunt 7y agoIt's more about company strategy than available talents. There are some sacrifices associated with gameplay and online experience but most of the cutting corners are about budget.
- DavidVoid 7y agoOverwatch allows none of that and seems to have some pretty well-designed netcode. Clients only send their controller inputs and the server has full authority of what actually happens. Blizzard's GDC talk about it is really good if you want an explanation of how to make a game feel responsive and fair without giving clients authority over everything [1]. Ofc this does not eliminate aimbot or wallhacks, but it gets rid of pretty much all other forms of cheating. [1] https://youtu.be/W3aieHjyNvw?t=1341 https://youtu.be/W3aieHjyNvw?t=1341 (Netcode talk starts at 22:22)
- chupasaurus 7y agoIt does eliminate most of wallhack opportunities, unlike CS:GO/PUBG/CoD:Warzone/Valorant.
- throwaway2048 7y agoCS:GO does not belong in that category
- chupasaurus 7y agoEach one from that list could be removed by a certain criteria. By server-client architecture and netcode CS:GO is worse than the others by a few miles, yeah.
- throwaway2048 7y agoIts really not, it has full server side simulation/verification, PUBG has none and is completely client side for instance. The only viable hacks in CS:GO are aimbots and extremely limited wall hacking (basically you can see a few "feet" around corners, the server does not send you any other data). This compares to PUBG where you can press a button and headshot the entire map at once, while flying through the air and spawning guns.